A Lost Lady Essay, Research Paper
In Willa Cather’s A Lost Lady, we meet Marian Forrester through the eyes of a young boy who idolizes her as a maternal and romantic figure. The title is deceptively simple. The main focus of the narrative is Mrs. Forrester, so one would immediately assume that the title is referring to her. However, by delving deeply into the text, it becomes apparent that the title actually highlights the three central themes of the novel: Mrs. Forrester’s deterioration, the loss of Niel’s high regard for her, and the loss of the pioneering era [GOOD-SHE "DETERIORATES" IN A WAY, BUT SHE ALSO GETS OUT OF SWEETWATER AND REGAINS SOME SEMBLANCE OF HER FORMER LIFE. SHE CAN LIVE WITH A DIMINISHED THING. NIEL WANTS HER TO IMMOLATE HERSELF ON THE CAPTAIN'S FUNERAL PYRE.]. The deterioration of Mrs. Forrester is the most obvious interpretation of the title.
Because he idolizes her, there is no middle ground in Niel’s perception and Mrs. Forrester is presented as being exceedingly good when living up to his expectations [EXACTLY-"HIS PERCEPTIONS"] or exceedingly bad when she does not. For example, when Niel breaks his arm, he is only concerned with the beauty and smell of Mrs. Forrester, not with his own pain:
What soft fingers Mrs. Forrester had, and what a lovely lady she was. Inside the lace ruffle of her dress he saw her white throat rising and falling so quickly. (p.13) [NOTE THE INCIPIENT SEXUAL 0BSERVATION OF HER THROAT]
Later, when he finds Mrs. Forrester in a compromising position, his image [GOOD CHOICE OF WORDS-"HIS IMAGE"]of her is ruined:
In his hand he still carried the prickly bunch of wild roses. He threw them over the wire fence into a mud-hole the cattle had trampled under the bank of the creek . . . “Lilies that fester,” he muttered, “lilies that fester smell far worse than weeds.”(p.47)
Through careful reading of the text we get a more accurate picture of Marian Forrester’s true character when she relates how she met her husband. Having fallen off a cliff and broken both legs, she was carried by Captain Forrester back to camp. Her legs began to heal while waiting for a doctor to arrive and had to be rebroken and set correctly. Marian Forrester is a survivor. Cather has intertwined the theme of violence and falling with male/female interaction. Niel’s fall and resulting broken arm are juxtaposed with Mrs. Forrester’s fall and rescue by Captain Forrester. [EXCELLENT!! YOU HAVE THE OBSERVATION, NOW START WORKING ON MORE DEVELOPED INTERPRETATION-THIS IS EXACTLY WHAT I WANT TO SEE IN THE RESPONSES!! YOU DO NOT HAVE A POLISHED READING YET, BUT YOU HAVE SOME CLOSE READING TO MAKE A CREATIVE CONNECTION. LOOK SIRECTLY AT HOW THESE THINGS ARE PRESENTED AND DEVELOP FROM THERE]
I believe [AVOID "I BELIEVE," "I THINK," "IN MY OPINION"-MAKE THE ASSERTION AND THEN DEMONSTRATE IT; A READING SHOULD STEM FROM CLOSE, REASONABLE ANALYSIS, NOT BELIEF, SO LET YOUR WORD CHOICE REFELCT THAT] that the book’s title refers more to Neil’s perception of Mrs. Forrester as being somehow lost rather than a reflection of the actual situation [YES-GOOD UNDERSTANDING OF THE NOVEL], since Mrs. Forrester proves herself unexpectedly resourceful in many ways. She is able to deal with reality far better than Niel. Over the course of the story, her husband loses his fortune, becomes an invalid, and eventually dies. She is able to deal with all these things with resourcefulness, but Niel initially views her resourcefulness as disloyalty to her husband and a way of life he has romanticized. Diametrically, Niel is most affected by the Captain’s words:
. . . a thing that is dreamed of in the way I mean, is already an accomplished fact. All our great West has been developed from such dreams; the homesteader’s and the prospector’s and the contractor’s. We dreamed the railroads across the mountains, just as I dreamed my place on the Sweet Water. (p.29) [THE CAPTAIN'S LOGIC HERE IS A BIT SUSPECT; ELSEWHERE IN THIS CONVERSATION, HE GIVES HIS "PHILOSOPHY": "WHAT YOU THINK OF AND PLAN FOR DAY BY DAY, IN SPITE OF YOURSELF, SO TO SPEAK-YOU WILL GET. . . . THAT IS, UNLESS YOU ARE ONE OF THE PEOPLE WHO GET NOTHING IN THIS WORLD." THE LOGIC IS SELF-CANCELING, SO HIS "PHILOSOPHY" AMOUNTS TO NOTHING. IN THE CONTEXT YOU ARE USING, CONSIDER HOW THE FIRST SENTENCE OF THE PHILOSOPHY IRONICALLY REFLECTS WHAT NIEL DOES TO HIMSELF]
Niel tries to hold on to the past, as if it were a mythological dream, while around him the world changes. This philosophy is reinterpreted sarcastically by Niel in Part II, Chapter 1. After meeting Ivy Peters on the train he thinks, “[The Ivy Peters] would drink up the mirage.” (p.90). He sees the draining of the marsh as a metaphor for the decline of the western spirit. [OF COURSE, YOUR "HE SEES' IS IMPORTANT, SINCE NIEL'S "SEEING" IS OFTEN SOMEWHAT BLIND-THERE IS SOMETHING HEROIS ABOUT THIS AGE, BUT IS IT AS HEROIC AS NIEL WOULD HAVE IT? OR THE NARRATOR, WHO IS NOT IDENTICAL WITH CATHER-SHE ORIGINALLY WROTE THIS IN THE FIRST PERSON WITH NIEL AS THE NARRATOR-THAT WAS TOO OBVIOUS, SO SHE SWITCHED TO THIRD-PERSON AND ENDED WITH A MUCH MORE SOPHISTICATED AND TRICKY NARRATIVE VOICE]
The ruin of the Forresters represents the end of regional America. People such as Ivy Peters take over and become successful, forming a national society of wealth. The old world is now forever “lost.” It can therefore be concluded that the title, A Lost Lady, is extremely universal and clever in that it envelops the three central themes of the novel.
Другие работы по теме:
Macbeth A Character Analysis Of Lady Macbeth
Essay, Research Paper A Character Analysis of Lady Macbeth What s done cannot be undone This is what Lady Macbeth said to her husband when he returned from murdering King Duncan. The statement is subtle and explains her way of thinking. Although Lady Macbeth is not completely evil-minded, she does play a big part as the antagonist in Shakespeare s Macbeth.
Revolutionary War 2 Essay Research Paper The
Revolutionary War 2 Essay, Research Paper The British lost and the Americans won the Revolutionary war. Though this is true there are arguments that the British lost the war more than the Americans won it. The Americans were under the control of the British and the Americans at first did not even have the intention of independence.
Macbeth Essay Research Paper What Transforms Both
Macbeth Essay, Research Paper What Transforms Both Macbeth and Lady Macbeth Into Tragic Figures Is The Fact That They Both Have Consciences. Discuss. At the end of Macbeth, Malcolm refers to Macbeth and Lady Macbeth as, ?a dead butcher and a fiend like queen.? Malcolm bases this judgement on the tyrannical rule and bloody murders that were a result of the Macbeths.
Macbeth 2 Essay Research Paper Mac Beth
Macbeth 2 Essay, Research Paper Mac Beth Shakespeare s time treasured classic play MacBeth has withstood the criticism of hundreds of years and has still remained popular and world-renown to this day. In this essay, I am going to characterize the three essential characters: Banquo, Lady MacBeth and MacBeth as portrayed through act II.
Macbeth Essay Research Paper Lady MacBeth hated
Macbeth Essay, Research Paper Lady MacBeth hated Duncan when he came to the land. She hated the fact that he stood a chance of being king over her husband which ment she stood a chance of not being queen. Knowing this,
Great Expectations Essay Research Paper Growing Up
Great Expectations Essay, Research Paper Growing Up Most people hope for their kids to grow up into young gentlemen and ladies. In the book Great Expectation by Charles Dickens you can see this at work. Miss Havisham tries
Lady Macbeth Essay Research Paper Discuss whether
Lady Macbeth Essay, Research Paper Discuss whether or not you feel sympathy for Lady Macbeth There are certain aspects of Lady Macbeth s character that suggests she is good and therefore her downfall increases my sympathy for her by the end of act 5. But I would also argue that she entailed evil to fuel her sleeping ambition that would make her nemesis, her mental collapse, fully justified.
James Bartlett Essay Research Paper James Bartlett1240
James Bartlett Essay, Research Paper James Bartlett 1240 NW 175 terr Miami, Fl 33169 305 621 4377 Ms. Latcna My pouch was taken, at the Winn Dixie store. At that time I called First Union to tell them about it, I talked to a lady in the fraud division. She called the bank that I use and, I was told not to change the account.
Macbeth Essay Research Paper 1Early in Macbeth
Macbeth Essay, Research Paper 1)Early in Macbeth we see Lady Macbeth as the strong, rational, determined, ambitious, even ruthless woman ; on the other hand we see a more vacillating , fearful Macbeth. As the play progresses, we see both characters change. Discuss.
Poem I Think About You Essay Research
Paper Sometimes when I think about how things could have been I can’t help but think about that day The way you looked so different, so sad When I think about it I want to die
Lady Of Shalott Essay Research Paper FALLFor
Lady Of Shalott Essay, Research Paper FALL For me the fall is an exhilarating time of year. A time of change, an in-between period of muddled and varied weather. For others who view fall as a short time before a dreary winter, fall takes on a less colorful face. Alfred Lord Tennyson uses fall metaphorically throughout “The Lady of Shalott” to illustrate how the Lady of Shalott’s life (or lack thereof) progresses.
Macbeth Essay Research Paper Macbeth EssayFrom the
Macbeth Essay, Research Paper Macbeth Essay From the very beginning Macbeth has been a victim of the witches? prophecy and Lady Macbeth?s ambition. With no support he soon succumbed to the pressures of each.
Macbeth Reading Response Essay Research Paper Over
Macbeth Reading Response Essay, Research Paper Over the course of the play Macbeth and Lady Macbeth significantly change with respect to their characters and their personalities. Macbeth starts off as a brave soldier whom is devoted to his king, but is tainted from the witches’ prophecies, as Lady Macbeth appears as a kind wife but underneath lies a conniving, deceitful woman.
Wait Until Dark Essay Research Paper Wait
Wait Until Dark Essay, Research Paper Wait Until Dark Frederick Knott The play “Wait Until Dark” has a melodrama form about it, which opens in the first act with a confused plot. It is a normal size play with three act in it. The whole theme of the play is centered around a total of seven actors, each of which have pretty active parts.
My Fair Lady Essay Research Paper My
My Fair Lady Essay, Research Paper My Fair Lady is a musical comedy written by Bernard Shaw, which is set in England. The story is about Elisa, who spoke very bad English, with a cockney accent, but she wanted to learn how to speak better English, so she went to a phonetics? teacher, Higgins. Elisa was very poor, so she didn?t have the money to pay for the lessons.
Lady Bird Johnson Essay Research Paper LADY
Lady Bird Johnson Essay, Research Paper LADY BIRD JOHNSON Claudia Alta Taylor was born in a country mansion near Karnack, Texas, she was given the nickname “Lady Bird” when she was just a child; and by this name she is still known today. Her mother, Minnie Pattillo Taylor, died when Claudia (Lady Bird) was only five, so she was raised by her father, her aunt, and the family servants.
Poem Breaking Me Essay Research Paper Breaking
Poem: Breaking Me Essay, Research Paper Breaking Me Everyday, I see your face, I wish that you?d stayed Don?t even know what made you run away It?s just the way, that you play the game
Macbeth By Shakespeare Essay Research Paper Macbeth
Macbeth By Shakespeare Essay, Research Paper Macbeth by William Shakespeare In the play Macbeth by William Shakespeare, Lady Macbeth unconsciously uses Macbeth and others as a shield for guilt. When she wants something but doesn’t have the guts to perform the task herself, she calls upon anyone but herself to do it.
Crazy Lady Essay Research Paper this book
Crazy Lady Essay, Research Paper this book is about a lady that has a son named ronald and has a mental problem. But their is a kid named vernon tha he deos stuff to that lady when he is with his friends. Until onne day he started to feel bad for tha lady and her son and he went and apologized, the crazy lady said that she knew vernons mother as they were talking and vernon became freinds with the crazy ladys mentally ill child named Ronald.
Macbeth Essay Research Paper The Downfall of
Macbeth Essay, Research Paper The Downfall of Macbeth Macbeth’s love for Lady Macbeth, in William Shakespeare’s tragedy Macbeth, caused Macbeth to feel the need to prove his manhood, which eventually lead to his downfall. Macbeth was not secure in his manhood, so he felt the need to prove himself to Lady Macbeth.
Lady Macbeth Essay Research Paper Lady MacbethThe
Lady Macbeth Essay, Research Paper Lady Macbeth The downfall of Macbeth was a great tragedy. He knew it was not right to kill the king, but he felt he had no other choice. He was trapped into doing wrong. Lady Macbeth gave him the evil ideas throughout the play. She was his driving force. Without her, Macbeth wouldn’t have done what he did.
Macbeth Witches Essay Research Paper Macbeth who
Macbeth Witches Essay, Research Paper Macbeth, who is hailed by the three witches as the ancestor of kings. Macbeth is an intelligent spiritual likeness of a villain-hero who feels his own guilt
Macbeth Essay Research Paper The Destruction of
Macbeth Essay, Research Paper The Destruction of Macbeth Three factors that are at work to destroy Macbeth are the flaws in his own character, the forces of evil of the Devil represented by the Tree Weird Sisters, and Lady
Joke Essay Research Paper Pretty funny You
Joke Essay, Research Paper Pretty funny!!!! You could die laughing…… A little old lady went into the Bank of Canada one day, carrying a bag of money. She insisted that she must speak with the president of the bank to open a savings account because, “It’s a lot of money!”
Macbeth Character Analysis Of Lady Macbeth Essay
, Research Paper MacBeth In The Tragedy of MacBeth, Lady MacBeth has strong id characteristics, and is not well balanced because her superego is severely out-weighed by her id. The id, superego, and ego are the
Macbeth Essay Research Paper Macbeth Lady Macbeth
Macbeth Essay, Research Paper Macbeth Lady Macbeth had one of the most important roles in the play I believe. Lady Macbeth is far worse than Macbeth. Although they both think of murdering King Duncan as soon as they hear the witches prophecies; Macbeth thinks more about what would happen if he did kill king Duncan, on the hand Lady Macbeth right away to evil spirits to get her the strength to kill King Duncan.
The Lost Generation Essay Research Paper THE
The Lost Generation Essay, Research Paper THE LOST GENERATION The lost generation has to be one of the saddest generation of people to have ever lived. They were destroyed not only physically, but also mentally and spiritually. The soldiers would have prefered to die because when they got back home from the war, they felt ?lost? and didn?t recognize anything.
Macbeath Essay Research Paper Anthony Sears12298Period 2Macbeth
Macbeath Essay, Research Paper Anthony Sears 12-2-98 Period 2 Macbeth Macbeth and Lady Macbeth are two megalomaniacs. Their actions in the first two acts are very childish and selfish. Their lust for power and control over runs their lives and becomes something to die for. Lady Macbeth is very persuasive, and Macbeth will almost follow her very word.
Lady Macbeth Essay Research Paper At the
Lady Macbeth Essay, Research Paper At the start of the play, Lady Macbeth seems to have a very strong character – almost stronger than Macbeth’s – but by the end she is reduced to being afraid of the dark. At the beginning she is Macbeth’s ‘dearest partner of greatness’, but at the end she is his ‘fiend-like queen’.
Macbeth Novel Essay Research Paper Compare and
Macbeth Novel Essay, Research Paper Compare and Contrast: Macbeth and Lady Macbeth Ambition, the world?s driving force to achieve their goals. Ambition is a characteristic of human nature,