Educational System? – A Debate Essay Essay, Research Paper
Should Public Universities Implement
a No-Grade No-Degree Educational System?
Jeff Pruitt
This debate takes place between two university students who are roommates- JD, who’s a sophomore and Josh, a senior. While eating breakfast before class they read a story in the local paper about falling test scores among American college students. They begin to discuss what the problem might be, and agree that some changes need to be made at the university level. JD says he has an idea that would work, a no-grade, no-degree system. He explains that under this system students wouldn’t be given grades in any of their classes nor would they receive a degree after the completion of their required classes. Josh has never heard of anything like this and is very skeptical that it would be beneficial. He begins the debate by asking JD why this system would be more effective than the one currently in place.
JD: Public universities need to adopt a no-grade, no-degree system because it’s the only way to make people focus on learning. Too many people go to a university just because they need a degree to get a good job. They choose a field such as engineering because of the money and they’re stuck doing something they don’t like or aren’t very good at. Once they get their degree they realize they don’t know very much about their field because all they ever did was focus on getting the grade. By eliminating grades, people would have to focus on the real reason to be at a university – to learn. By learning I don’t mean remembering it for 2 days, I mean really knowing how to do something, like it’s second nature.
Josh: I understand, but most people need some incentive to study, and a good grade provides the reward for hard work. Without some kind of benchmark to tell how well you were doing in the class I believe people would take advantage of the system. They would either not show up or not do any of the work because they wouldn’t be held accountable. They could just cruise through, partying every night or whatever they felt like doing. There would be no way of making sure students were learning anything. Look at how many people don’t go to class now and they need the grade to graduate.
JD: I believe those people would be weeded out. If someone pays their money and never goes to class, or does any of the work, they will realize that they are just wasting their time and money. They could be doing whatever else they want to be doing without spending the money for classes that they’re not getting anything out of. These people would, in essence, flunk themselves out. When they were ready to come back, they would then come back for the right reason, which is to learn. Besides, the current system today only encourages memorization. Since most people feel the pressure of making good grades, they must study relentlessly before the test to try and memorize everything they can the night before. Not having grades allows people to learn at an appropriate pace and not cram six chapters of information into a four-hour study session.
Josh: Many people use memorization as an important learning tool. I mean you must memorize some things, and studying things over and over can be a helpful way of lodging things into your long-term memory. Not all classes are based on memorization anyway. Many classes use presentations, speeches, etc to help students learn. There is also a competition problem within the no-grades, no-diploma system. Without grades there is no way of separating students within the same field. Employers wouldn’t know whom to hire without being able to compare GPA’s. They would have no idea who actually put in the time and effort to learn the material. This could be very detrimental to their business if they hired someone who knew absolutely nothing.
JD: There would be a way for employers to know what kind of employee they were getting. Every student would take a final exam which covers everything they should’ve learned in their field, a four-year cumulative final. There wouldn’t be any passing or failing the exam, you would just receive a score that showed how much you learned during the time in your major. It would be similar to the GRE exam that most departments require for entrance into graduate school. There’s no failing a GRE it just shows how ready you are for the material to be presented in graduate school. Similarly, this final exam would show employers how prepared you were for a certain job. This system would eliminate people who slip through the cracks without learning much, by copying off their friends or cheating, while maintaining high GPA’s. The effort and ability of each student would be accurately assessed by this test.
Josh: Your entire education based upon one test hardly seems fair. Some people just aren’t good test takers and freeze up. These people may be well qualified for any position but would be left out under this system. The quality of education the students receive might also fall. There would be no communication from the students to let the instructor know how well they were learning the material. Likewise, the teacher wouldn’t know how effective he was without testing the students on what they should’ve learned. Every class would have a large lecture hall atmosphere in which the teachers don’t care and the students don’t understand.
JD: I believe this system would create more communication between students and teachers. Without grades, students would hold their teachers responsible for teaching in a competent manner. Under the current system, students don’t care how well the teacher presents the material as long as they’re making a good grade.
Josh: Well I just believe that without some incentives and rewards, such as grades and degrees, people won’t see the reason to attend a university implementing this system. Those students who do will take advantage of not being held responsible for grades, and we will have a smaller number of educated people than we presently do. I know that a system like that would be tough for me to handle. I’m not sure if I could get motivated to do anything. Well anyway I’ll talk to you later, time to go get an “A” on my math test.
Другие работы по теме:
Do Public Figures Have The Right To
Privacy? Essay, Research Paper This is a very well documented debate, especially after the tragic death of the Princess of Wales. I feel that there is no right and wrong answer. People and the press have to look at individual circumstances and decide whether it is relevant to a high enough degree to pry into other people’s lives
Was There A Link Between Women
’s Suffrage And Education In The Early 20Th Century Essay, Research Paper Was There A Link Between Women s Education and Their Right To Vote? During the woman’s rights movement one of the major concerns people had
Образование в англоязычных странах
University education The are 44 universities (not counting the Open university*) in Britain. Although the Government is responsible for providing about 80 per cent of universities’ income it does not control their or teaching nor does it have direct dealing with the universities. The grants are distributed by the University Grants Committee, a body appointed by the Secretary of State for Education and Science.
Elementary School Teaching Essay Research Paper Elementary
Elementary School Teaching Essay, Research Paper Elementary School Teacher Elementary school teachers teach pupils at levels kindergarten through sixth grade or, in some cases, through eighth grade a wide range of academic, social, emotional, and motor skills. They plan and present programs of instruction using methods and materials to meet the needs of the students.
Schools Comparison Between Canada And Taiwan Schools
Essay, Research Paper Schools: Comparison Between Canada and Taiwan Schools School is the best place for people to be educated. Everyone has to go through this stage in order to be knowledgeable, so they can be useful in
University and Further Education
The principal post-school institutions of higher education are 47 universities (including the Open University), of which 36 are in England, 8 in Scotland, 2 in Northern Ireland and 1 in Wales.
Getting Rid Of Letter Grades Essay Research
Paper Getting Rid of the Letter Grades As our country moves into the twenty-first century, it must closely evaluate its current system of doing things. However, an evaluation of today’s students would not be positive. This is because students fear failure and fear getting bad grades. A simple solution to this problem would be to eliminate grades altogether and to reinstate the power of learning to gain knowledge and character, not to get a letter grade.
The Ideal Education Essay Research Paper A
The Ideal Education Essay, Research Paper A university is an institution that educates a student to better prepare them to work in the field that they choose. The best curriculum varies for each student, but it is necessary that the students have some experience in the working environment before they set out on their own.
The American Dream Is Based On Success
, Happiness, And Money Essay, Research Paper The American Dream Is Based on Success, Happiness, and Money I believe that the American Dream today is based on success, happiness, and
Public Essay Research Paper According to the
Public Essay, Research Paper According to the Oxford English Dictionary, ?Public? means of, belonging to, or pertaining to the people as a whole. A public place or thing becomes available to all people who must share and support these places or things through taxes or other charges. All people may visit national parks or monuments which they support through taxes and fees.
THINKING AS A HOBBY Essay Research Paper
Thinking as a Hobby In his essay “Thinking as a Hobby,” William Golding classifies thinkers into three categories. Analyzing everyone he meets is a very interesting hobby for Golding. When classifying these people, he puts them into “grades” according to their thinking style. Grade-three thinkers are very common, and Grade-two thinkers are less plentiful, but not as rare as Grade-one thinkers, who are most extraordinary.
Public Vs Private University Essay Research Paper
Searching for the right college or university can be a long and painful process. There are undoubtedly hundreds if not thousands of colleges to review. In deciding on a college, you may take in a count the city, the state, and the status of the college or university. But the crucial decision in determining a college or university is if you want to attend a college or a university.
Public Vs Private Essay Research Paper In
Public Vs Private Essay, Research Paper In the world today many parents ponder the thought whether private schools are better than public schools. They decide what would be better for their children. When they do this they ponder many different things like what would be academically better for my son or daughter or which would be safest and some people even would send their son or daughter to a school just for athletics.
Transfer Essay Research Paper Procedures for Transferring
Transfer Essay, Research Paper Procedures for Transferring to a University in the United States There are several steps that a prospective international student should follow in order to transfer to study at a university in the United States. These steps that are outlined below will normally take about one year to complete, particularly if application is also being made for scholarship support.
Mechanical Enginearing Essay Research Paper Mechanical Engineering
Mechanical Enginearing Essay, Research Paper Mechanical Engineering Mechanical engineering has two basic parts. The first, which is the base for mechanical engineering, is the field of engineering itself. The second part is the specialized branch which in this case is mechanical.
College Essay Research Paper My Desires for
College Essay, Research Paper My Desires for and Commitment to a college Education My Desires to go to college and to get a Degree began many years ago when I was in the fifth grade and my teacher kept telling me that I would need a college education if I wanted to be successful in this lifetime. I want to make a commitment to college because I want to succeed in the business world, have a successful job and I want to set a good example for me brothers and sisters
Cheating Essay Research Paper CheatingI believe that
Cheating Essay, Research Paper Cheating I believe that cheating is a terrible thing to do and will hurt you in the long run. When you cheat on a homework assignment, quiz, or test, you are only cheating yourself. You should be honorable enough to take a bad grade and admit that you don’t know everything.
Performances At Private Playhouses Essay Research Paper
Performances at private playhouses 36 may be taken to have approximated to those at universities, inns of court and royal residences, in aiming at the taste of more refined audiences than did the public playhouse—though too much stress should not be laid on the supposition. Noblemen, ambassadors and other great people went to the public playhouses; but, while it is on record that Elizabeth went to the Blackfriars, she is not known to have ever visited the Globe.
Education In England Essay Research Paper England
Education In England Essay, Research Paper England has one of the finest educational system in the world. All English children between ages 5-16 must attend school. About 90 percent of the students go to schools supported entirely or partly by public funds. The rest of the students attend private schools.
Parent
’s Taking Control Of Their Children’s Education Essay, Research Paper Never before in the United States have parents been so disgruntled about their children’s education. The main
Private Schools VS Public Schools Essay Research
Paper Private Schools VS. Public Schools Parents often wonder how to start off their children?s education. Depending on ones religion or beliefs a private or public school is a choose most parents face. Of course, each school offers it?s own pros and con?s the choice is simple. Public schools offer the best well rounding of a student.
Grade Inflation Essay Research Paper What is
Grade Inflation Essay, Research Paper What is the definition of grade inflation? The most obvious definition is that grade patterns change so that the overwhelming majority of students in a class, college, or university receive higher grades for the same quantity and quality of work done by students in the past.
Observation Report Essay Research Paper Christopher TippinsObservation
Observation Report Essay, Research Paper Christopher Tippins Observation Report Dr. Kibria April 26, 1999 During the month of March, I observed a special education classroom at East Elementary School. This was a third grade class containing only disabled students. Although this class was labeled a third grade class, the students were on different levels in certain subjects.
Образование в России 2
Education in Russia. The education system of Russia consists of two major levels: the pre-higher or school education and higher education. I will tell about both in bigger detail later on.
The Old Man And The See Essay
, Research Paper THE HISTORY OF INTERNET In the beginning of the 1970`s in USA was an older military network called ARPANET converted to Internetvork wish was a network between networks. Accept a few Universities
What Women Should Know Essay Research Paper
Karen Pratt Composition I 10:00 Analysis Essay September 22, 2000 What women need to know about Universities A woman should gain many things from a university education. Simply obtaining passing grades and graduating with a diploma are not the only benefits of college. Another benefit should be the development of confidence and self worth.
Computers Essay Research Paper computers are fun
Computers Essay, Research Paper computers are fun. they have a mouse a monitor and aol. this is gay cant you tell im bored and i need an essay before i get a bad grade. i love nic and steve and alex and randy and myself ta taoyuhljltkjglskdjlsakjfglakjdlkfjawldfjlakdjflakjdfljaldfjlaskfcomputers are fun. they have a mouse a monitor and aol. this is gay cant you tell im bored and i need an essay before i get a bad grade. i love nic and steve and alex and randy and myself ta taoyuhljltkjglskdjlsakjfglakjdlkfjawldfjlakdjflakjdfljaldfjlaskfcomputers are fun. they have a mouse a monitor and aol. this is gay cant you tell im bored and i need an essay before i get a bad grade. i love nic and steve and alex and randy and myself ta taoyuhljltkjglskdjlsakjfglakjdlkfjawldfjlakdjflakjdfljaldfjlaskfcomputers are fun. they have a mouse a monitor and aol. this is gay cant you tell im bored and i