THE WOMAN IN WHITE: THE CREATION OF A NEW REALISM?
I had now arrived at that partcular point of my walk
where four roads met – the road to Hampstead, along
which I had returned, the road to Fichley, the road
to West End, and the road back to London. I had me-
chanically turned in this latter direction, and was
strolling along the lonely high-road – idly wonder-
ing, I remember, what the Cumberland young ladies
would look like – when, in one moment, every drop of
blood in my body was brought to a stop by the touch
of a hand laid lightly on my shoulder behind me.
I turned on the instant with my fingers tighten-
ing round the handle of my stick.
There, in the middle of the broad, bright high-
road – there, as if it had that moment sprung out of
the earth or dropped from Heaven – stood the figure
of a solitary Woman, dressed from head to foot in
white garments….. (p.47)
An analysis of the above passage will illustrate why The Woman in White and
novels of a similar nature have been labelled `sensational’ and denied any
significant status as realism. Most obviously, the extract shows the main
characteristic of sensationalism: the sudden shock or surprise – every drop
of Walter Hartright’s blood `brought to a stop’ on encountering the figure on
the highway: he grips his stick nervously in anticipation of the unknown. The
aspect of mystery and the ghostly, too, can be seen – the Woman is described
as being `out of the earth’, otherworldly, her white garments, too, evoking a
ghostly overtone. The text, here, highlights yet subtler aspects of
sensationalism which I wish to discuss. Walter comes to a point where there
is a network of roads, where `four roads met’. The number of directions in
which he can travel mirrors the multi-faceted and intricate plot of Wilkie
Collins’ novel. This importance of plot has become – rightly or wrongly – a
trade mark of `sensational’ fiction. A further aspect of this genre is
fatalism, the predestined, the notion perhaps that is not mere chance that
Anne Catherick appears on Hartright’s `lonely high-road’ and not on the other
four.
The `characteristics’ of the sensation novel which I have touched
upon superficially above have, critically speaking, prevented it being
bestowed with any notion of `realism’. Though I do not desire necessarily to
challenge the notion of sensationalism in the novel but I do wish to question
the apparent `lack of realism’ in The Woman In White. I hope therefore to
illustrate the sensation paradox – that Collins’ novel is bound in realism as
well as being `sensational’. I would like to suggest also that the result is the
creation of a new, higher realism, different to that of writers such as Eliot
and Trollope.
I believe it would be appropriate, initially, to define the traditional
connotation of the term `realism’. The common view is that the main function
of realism in fiction is mimetic; that to be realistic is to attempt to convey
an accurate imitation of life as it is: we are supposed to be left with the
impression that these realistic characters have lived and breathed. I first
want to demonstrate the degree to which The Woman in White defies this
traditional code of Victorian fictional realism.
When reading Collins’ novel we cannot fail to be struck by the
intricacy of the plot. This is what grips us so, what makes us read on, what
forced Anthony Trollope to stay up all night to finish the book. It is the
design and plot that is uppermost in our minds; we are not necessarily
concerned about the feelings of Marian Halcombe or Walter Hartright.
Undoubtedly in The Woman In White, character is subordinated to plot. The
former is dictated by the latter. It is Anne Catherick’s initial confrontation
with Hatright on the road to Limmeridge House that sets the whole chain of
events in motion. In fact it could be traced back to Hatright’s association
with Pesca; it is the Italian – returning a favour to Hartright for saving him
from drowning – who secures his position as Drawing Master employed by
Frederick Fairlie. The first narrator observes:
If I had not dived for Professor Pesca when he lay
under water on his shingle bed, I should…never
have been connected with the story which these pages
will relate. (p.37)
Contemporary critics tended to link – wrongly I believe – novels of incident
such as The Woman In White to sensationalism and novels of character to
realism. I will illustrate later how I feel this judgement is flawed but I am
merely pointing out here that the supremacy of plot breached the realistic
faith.
As an adjunct to this, it must be admitted that depth of character
(with the possible exception of Count Fosco) and plausibility of motive is
wanting to a certain extent within The Woman In White. Frederick Fairlie is
just a hyperchondriac; Marian Halcombe’s characteristics are seen to be
those of strength and bravery; Laura is weak-willed and sensitive while
Hartright is a combination of the latter two. It would be a mistake to say
that the figures which populate the novel are colourless – they are not – but
they do lack the complexity of, say, a Dorothea Brooke. In addition,
traditional realism demands that the actions of a character and motives
behind them be plausible, be `believable’. Plausibility does seem lacking in
sections of the novel. Walter Hartright’s sudden move to Honduras is a prime
example of this. He becomes timid, frail and effete, deciding to go to `another
country to try a change of scene and occupation’. He is merely said to be
making `excavations among the ruined cities of Central America’. There is no
real description about the thought process behind such a decision.
Pyschological realism appears, on a superficial inspection, to be neglected.
32b
Другие работы по теме:
Moby Dick Essay Essay Research Paper Moby
Moby Dick Essay Essay, Research Paper Moby Dick Essay Throughout time, people have associated their problems with with something bad that happened to them. That thing became the center of their problems by causing a lot of suffering to that person. In Moby Dick, Melville has many interpretations of what the white whale symbolizes.
Dorris Lessing Essay Research Paper Dear Ms
Dorris Lessing Essay, Research Paper Dear Ms. Doris Lessing, I just finished reading the short story you wrote, The Woman on the Roof and I must say that I was rather confused about its meaning. Perhaps I was not looking deep enough into the story, but all I got out of it was that there was a woman tanning on the roof being harassed by disrespectful men.
Richard Iii Essay Research Paper Richard was
Richard Iii Essay, Research Paper Richard was a bad guy. This was one of his speeches: Was ever woman in this humor wooed? Was ever woman in this humor won? I?ll have her, but I will not keep her long.
The Bluest Eyes Essay Research Paper 2
The Bluest Eyes Essay, Research Paper “The Bluest Eyes” Toni Morrison was an African American woman that had gone through almost forty years of suppression. In an excerpt from her novel The Bluest Eyes, she tells the story of a young girl named Claudia who receives a white baby doll every Christmas. Claudia does not like the doll so she decided to tear it apart like every other “white baby doll” that she has received.
Ozymandias C Despair Essay Research Paper Ozymandias
Ozymandias C. Despair Essay, Research Paper Ozymandias C. Despair changed from the feeling that the greatness statue would inspire despair in others through fear but it did the opposite, the passers by feel despair for the statue in it wrecked stat, it is situational irony.
Xofds Essay Research Paper She was born
Xofds Essay, Research Paper She was born Marguerite, but her brother, Bailey, nicknamed her Maya (”mine”). As little children, they were sent to live with their grandmother in Stamps, Arkansas. Their early world revolved around this remarkable woman and the store she ran for the black community. White people were more than strangers – they were from another planet.
Midsummer Nights Dream
—sort Paper On Women Essay, Research Paper ?A Midsummer Night?s Dream?: I think something very interesting in this play is the way in which woman were seen in Elizabethan England during Shakespeare?s day. The play gives numerous examples of the way woman are treated as second class citizens; for instance, the laws concerning marriage and the position of men in society.
Queen Elizabeth Essay Research Paper Queen Elizabeth
Queen Elizabeth Essay, Research Paper Queen Elizabeth sacrificed many elements of her life for her country. She sacrificed her love, her dreams, and her most prized possession. She sacrificed her hair, which, during the Elizabethan Age was a woman’s most prized possession. Queen Elizabeth made the decision to forgo her beauty and all else in order to display her love for England.
Lucy Stone Essay Research Paper Equality for
Lucy Stone Essay, Research Paper Equality for Woman Lucy Stone was one of the most important workers for suffrage and other women’s rights. Born in 1818 on a farm in Massachusetts, Lucy grew up with an overbearing father that ruled the house and her mother “by divine right.” She was disquieted by her mother’s lowly role in the family.
Calpurnia Essay Research Paper Calpurnia acts like
Calpurnia Essay, Research Paper Calpurnia acts like she?s the mother of Scout and Jem. Not only does she cook and clean for the Finch?s, she also disciplines, advises, and takes care of all Jem?s and Scout?s needs. Cal is an extremely well educated black woman who lives in two very opposite worlds. In one world she is the mother of two white children and she speaks like them.
The Klan Essay Research Paper The
The Klan Essay, Research Paper * The Klan name and symbol break through the paper curtain of the anti-White media and brings us to the attention of those who want to
Nath Essay Research Paper Nathaniel Hawthornes short
Nath Essay, Research Paper Nathaniel Hawthorne?s short stories ?The Birthmark? and Rappaccinni?s Daughter are both tragic tales of women being taken advantage of. In each account a young woman is skillfully led to her downfall by a loved one she trusts. In each case Hawthorne includes an inconceivable innocence about the woman.
Interpretations Of Hills Like White Elephants
Essay, Research Paper Interpretations of Hills Like White Elephants The woman in the story realizes a lot about her husband in the story. He got her pregnant and they were deciding on having an abortion or not to have an abortion. Ernest Hemingway sort of hid this in his story. He does not say in his story that they are talking about an abortion and if the reader does not catch this the story does not make much sense.
Like A Winding Sheet By Anne Petry
Essay, Research Paper Pressure from the Women In "Like a Winding Sheet" Anne Petry chooses not to fully develop the female characters of the story but still used them as a
Love Essay Research Paper LOVEWhat is love
Love Essay, Research Paper LOVE What is love and how does it start? It may seem like a stupid question, but on second examination, it does not seem quite so stupid. After all, love is a feeling. How can we really describe what a feeling is or means? The meaning of any feeling can differ greatly between individuals, and the meaning of love is no different.
The Yellow Wallpaper Essay Research Paper Quiz
?The Yellow Wallpaper? Essay, Research Paper Quiz #1 Resubmission Exercise (The Yellow Wallpaper) “The Yellow Wallpaper” is a story of a woman and her struggle with her psychological problems, and her quest to regain her sanity. In “The Yellow Wallpaper”, the narrator instructed to refrain from any intellectual activity and to engage in total bed rest in order to cure her depression.
Woman In Society Essay Research Paper Women
Woman In Society Essay, Research Paper Women and their roll on society Women are important in our society. Every woman has her own job or duty in this modern society in which men are still the strongest gender . We can+t forget that
Poem Flowers Essay Research Paper Lynn had
Poem: Flowers Essay, Research Paper Lynn had never been serene like a glowing bright sky. Always to occupied, like a busy fly. Lynn met a powerful woman, who had some advice,
Ernest Hemingway Essay Essay Research Paper Final
Ernest Hemingway Essay Essay, Research Paper Final Draft Hemingway Essay A good writer s objective is to say as much as possible as briefly as possible. This enables the thinking about the implications of the word s presented. Ernest Hemingway explained this idea in his iceberg theory of writing fiction in an interview for Paris Review: If it is any use to know it, I always try to write on the principle of the iceberg.
Mr Essay Research Paper Aspects of the
Mr. Essay, Research Paper Aspects of the Perfect Female The ideal woman of today’s society would contain the following qualities: intelligence, honesty, a sense of humor, spontaneity, assertiveness,
Dawn Hand Soap Essay Research Paper Dawn
Dawn Hand Soap Essay, Research Paper Dawn Hand Soap Memo Purpose In this memo we will take an in depth look at the magazine advertisement used by Dawn dishwashing soap. With a specific focus on the ad’s purpose, description, their target audience, and the ad’s strategies.
The Yellow Wallpaper What The Hell Essay 2
The Yellow Wallpaper: What The Hell???? Essay, Research Paper The Yellow Wallpaper: What The Hell???? The Yellow Wallpaper does nothing but confuse me. It seems to be about
Woman And Equal Opportunities Essay Research Paper
Woman in the sixties have had many different roles than woman in the nineties. Life for woman has changed dramatically, to their advantage throughout the years. Today woman have gained many new rights and responsibilities, and now have equal opportunities as men.
Woman In Theater Essay Research Paper Woman
Woman In Theater Essay, Research Paper Woman In Theatre Woman in Greek theatre is something you just don t see. In fact woman were put in the same category as slaves. In this time of the gods, woman were forbid to play their own part in the famous thing we call Greek theatre. Taking the place of these women were testosterone driven men portraying the woman part with their own preconceived idea of how woman really are.
Color Of Water Essay Research Paper One
Color Of Water Essay, Research Paper One aspect of identity where feedback can be given almost instantaneously is race, as it involves a person’s skin color. Young children often ignore each others’ races unless they
Sex Anybody Essay Research Paper Sex Anybody
Sex, Anybody? Essay, Research Paper Sex, Anybody? By: Mel Antonio Man, Woman, Dog or Tree, On the menu of sexuality. What will it be, In this age of immorality? Today’s special: S& M, With Monica look-a-like On a big Harley bike. Or you can have toys, They’re not for little boys. They vibrate, They gyrate, They compensate.