Set You Free? Essay, Research Paper
Does the Truth Always Set You Free?
On the Waterfront is a classic, award-winning and controversial film. It received eight academy-awards in 1954, including best-picture and director. The director, Eliza Kazan, in collaboration with Budd Schulberg wrote the film’s screenplay. Based on actual dockside events in Hoboken, New Jersey, On the Waterfront is a story of a dock worker who tried to overthrow a corrupt union.
Marlon Brando superbly portrays the character of Terry Malloy. He is a young ex-prize fighter, now a dock worker given easy jobs because his brother is the right-hand man of the corrupt union boss Johnny Friendly. After Terry unwittingly allows himself to be used in setting up a man’s death, he starts to question the basic assumptions if his life. This includes his loyalty to his brother and Johnny, who after all ordered him to take a dive in his big fight at Madison Square Garden.
The film’s controversy exists in the fact that Terry decides to testify against Johnny Friendly. His testimony attempts to show how it is fundamentally right to break group silence in a tough situation, even if a person appears to “rat” on his friends. To be at peace with oneself, Kazan seems to say, one must tell the truth, despite the fact that one will face ostracism, and, as in the film, probably be murdered. Kazan makes the hardships of testifying painfully clear. Thus, Brando’s character is a hero. However, a dark agenda exists behind the film’s plot.
On the Waterfront was made in 1954, two years after Kazan willingly testified before the House Un-American Activities Committee. In 1952, Kazan named the names of eight friends and colleges allegedly affiliated with the communist party. Kazan was an active member of the communist party in the 1930s, until he went through a violent break with the party prior to the hearings. He said that communism could override a person’s intellect and beliefs. He also stated that Hollywood and Broadway heavily financed the party. Recounting his decision to testify, Kazan said, “Communists were in a lot of organizations–unseen, unrecognized, unbeknownst to anybody. I thought if I don’t talk, nobody will know about it.”
On the Waterfront is Kazan’s justification for his decision to testify. In the film, when a union boss shouts, “You ratted on us Terry,” Brando shouts back: “Maybe from where your standing, but I’m standing over here now. I was rattin’ on myself all those years. I didn’t even know it.” That reflects Kazan’s belief that communism was an evil that temporality seduced him and it was necessary to oppose it. Since Kazan believed that communism was an evil threat to the American way of life, he tried to portray his decision to testify as a heroic act of valor. He wanted to show the public that a person who testifies is brave, not a coward.
Throughout the film there are a number of references to the code of silence, “D n’ D”, or “Deaf and Dumb.” This means that no matter how wretched the circumstances are, a person never rats. The union thugs make a joke about the boy pushed off a building because he threatened to talk to the crime commission, thus breaking the sacred code of D n’ D: “A canary. Maybe he could sing but he couldn’t fly.”
Kazan has one character, in particular, stress the importance of speaking out in life. Father Barry believes that the truth will always set a person free. He says,
There’s one thing we’ve got in this country and that’s ways of fightin’ back. Gettin’
facts to the public. Testifying for what you know is right and what you know is wrong.
What’s rattin’ to them is telling the truth for you. Can’t you see that? Can’t
you see that?
This quotation is an example of Kazan crying out to the public for forgiveness. Later in the film, Kazan tries even harder to gain acceptance, as there is an obvious parallel between his own testimony and Terry Malloy’s.
In the courtroom scene, Terry Malloy turns “stoolie” and betrays Friendly throughout his testimony. He tells the court that, on the night authorities discovered the body, someone pushed Joey Doyle from the roof. He states that he was the last person to see him alive, “except for the two thugs that murdered him.” Terry testifies that, after the murder, he went immediately to the Friendly Bar, where he expressed his feelings about the murder to Mr. Friendly. Terry is a hero because he made it possible for honest men to work at the docks, with job security and peace of mind. However, Terry’s struggle is just beginning. Friendly sums up Terry’s supposed fate with one sentence, “You’ve just dug your own grave.”
After the trial, Terry’s friends refuse to talk to him and he does not receive work. Neighborhood friend Tommy kills Terry’s pet pigeons on the rooftop. Tommy tosses the dead bird at Terry and shouts, “A pigeon for a pigeon.” People deride him and ostracize him as a “canary.” In interviews, Kazan discusses his identification with the Brando character.
“A lot of that kind of thing happened to me after I testified at HUAC,” said Kazan.
I was snubbed. People I knew well would look at me but not talk. People looked
down on me. They couldn’t except the fact that correctly or incorrectly it was
something I did out of principle.”
After the release of On the Waterfront, Kazan was open about his hidden motives, noble and shameful, to make the film. The scene near the end of movie, when Terry shouts to Friendly, “You’re a cheap, lousy, dirty stinkin’ mug. And I’m glad what I’ve done to you,” disturbed some people. Critics interpreted this to mean that Kazan was not sorry for his severely damaging testimony. It appeared that he had no remorse for his actions. For other viewers, the buried agenda of On the Waterfront tarnishes the picture. The critic John Rosenbaum told Roger Ebert that he could “Never forgive Kazan for using the film to justify himself.”
In later years, Kazan did eventually have remorse for the people whose lives he ruined and the blemish his testimony left on the whole film industry. In his 1988 autobiography he says, “I have some regrets about the human cost of it. One guy I told on I really like a lot.” Twenty years later, unlike On the Waterfront’s victorious ending, in Kazan’s picture The Visitor, a man also testifies against former friends; however, that movie ends on a note of despair. Perhaps the words of a legendary character he helped to create, haunted Kazan. As Terry Malloy said, “Conscience. That stuff can drive you nuts.”
Bibliography
References
1. Dirks, Tim. On the Waterfront: Greatest Films.
www.filmsite
2. Cannon, Damian. On the Waterfront.
www.films.U-net/movies
3. www.articles
4. www.capitalismagazine
Другие работы по теме:
Waterfront Disputes Essay Research Paper The 1998
Waterfront Disputes Essay, Research Paper The 1998 Waterfront Dispute was described by John Howard (the Prime Minister) as a defining moment in Australia s industrial relations history . It represented a change in government strategy from the Labor Government s partisan stance to the Liberal Government s provocative stance.
On The Waterfront Essay Research Paper While
On The Waterfront Essay, Research Paper While watching the movie On the Waterfront directed by Elia Kazan, I was bombarded by many timeless topics about the human condition. The most striking of which was the struggle for power. Throughout the movie, the desire to be in control was the underlying motivation for the violence witnessed.
On The Waterfront Essay Research Paper When
On The Waterfront Essay, Research Paper When I went to see the movie ?On the Waterfront?, I thought that I was going to be bored because the movie was in black and white. But as I started to watch the movie it got more and more interesting. Then the next day I got to hear Dr. James Fisher lecture on this movie and he brought a whole new light of mind into my head.
Waterfront Essay Research Paper The Godfather and
Waterfront Essay, Research Paper The Godfather and On the Waterfront The Godfather and On the Waterfront are two movies that make an attempt to explain organized crime, urban life, working people, and the role of
As A Child Essay Research Paper As
As A Child Essay, Research Paper As a child, I was no exception. Three games that I especially enjoyed were Freeze Tag, Hide and Seek, and Truth or Dare. When I was little I used to play all three
Romeo Must Die Review Essay Research Paper
Fans of Jet Li know him for his excellent martial arts ability. He is making his third debut this year with his new movie Romeo Must Die. He made his first appearance as the bad guy in Lethal Weapon 4, and then starred in Black Mask. He is a seventh degree black belt and his fans hold him to it when they watch him on the big screen.
The Reality Of Freedom Essay Research Paper
In the book Fahrenheit 451, by Ray Bradbury, there are many thematic issues that revolves around a man named Guy Montag. The issues spread from truth and reality to the importance of the written word to a free society. Montag lives in a society that frowns upon the free thinker. He works as a fireman, who no longer put out fires they start them.
Employment Relations In Australia Essay Research Paper
Employment Relations Essay The 1998 Waterfront Dispute was described by John Howard as “a defining moment in Australia s industrial relations history.” Do you agree with this statement? Support your view by discussing the events and outcomes of this dispute. John Howard s comment on the 1998 Waterfront dispute between the Maritime Union of Australia and Patrick Stevedores was a hypocritical and ignorant description of one of Australia s worst industrial relations disputes.
Left Hand Of Darkness Essay Research Paper
Humanity is the condition, quality, or fact of being a human within a community. The definition of truth is things as they are, things as they have been, and things as they are to come. Truth cannot change because it does not reflect any personal perspective. The Left Hand of Darkness illustrates how humans relate towards themselves, friends, and enemies.
Truth Or Lie Essay Research Paper January
Truth Or Lie? Essay, Research Paper January 31, 2000 Truth or Lie ….??? The truth should be told most of the time. I do not think however that lying should be put out of our mind because sometimes lying is the only option we have. Lying can be a good thing and a bad thing. Depending on the situation we should analyze it and find out if telling the truth would inflict more harm or lying would.
Truth Essay Research Paper Is there any
Truth Essay, Research Paper Is there any objective truth? Or must we finally accept that at bottom, in the end, philosophically speaking, there is no “real” or “objective” or “absolute” or “foundational” or “fact of the matter” or “right answer” truth about anything, that even our most confident convictions about what happened in the past or what the universe is made of or who we are or what is beautiful or who is wicked are just our convictions, just conventions, just ideology, just badges of power, just the rules of the language games we choose to play, just the product of our irrepressible disposition to deceive ourselves that we have discovered out there in some external, objective, timeless, mind-independent, world what we have actually invented ourselves, out of instinct, imagination and culture?
The Nature Of Truth Essay Research Paper
The nature of truth has been linked with the good and the beautiful as one of man’s supreme values. The pursuit of truth is indistinguishable in practice from the pursuit of knowledge, whether about the environment, nature, ethnical duties and ideas, or the relation to the divine.( Boodin 208-209 ) The complete understanding of the nature of truth is not humanely achievable.
Hot Lez Sex Essay Research Paper What
Hot Lez Sex Essay, Research Paper What is Truth and the best way to obtain it according to Ancient Scientists? In general, truth is anything that is correct of nature. The truth is in existence yet is not understood/known until it is uncovered. (Bruce Foltz WHGC lecture “What is truth?”)
Shangeid To China Essay Research Paper The
Shangeid To China Essay, Research Paper The book is about a boy named Neil who came down to Liverpool to stay with his grandparents . While Neil was there, he snuck out of the house and went to the waterfront.There he stopped to
Philosophy Truth Essay Research Paper Truth That
Philosophy: Truth Essay, Research Paper Truth! That is a word that philosophers have been arguing about for a good while! Truth is a state of mind free of error, a state of mind, which is an accurate reflection of things in existence, of the things about you. Truth is unchangeable; it is ageless and constant.
Summertime Essay Research Paper It was early
Summertime Essay, Research Paper It was early dawn on a Friday morning, as the sun rises from the distant blue ocean we wait for daylight to breakout. My friend and I sat down on spot on the beach, as I focus closely at the surface of the waterfront the sand is very white, much like the winter snowflakes. As I look along the different points along the shore, the waves and ripple’s of the salty water crash upon various sections of the beach.
A San Fransisco Carriage Ride Essay Research
Paper The warm summer breeze, combined with the crisp, refreshing smells of the waterfront, created a perfect day for sight-seeing in San Francisco. I parked my car along Thirty-second Street, in an area filled with various specialty shops, so I could easily find it at the end of the day. I gathered my camera and began my journey on foot.
Value Of Honesty Essay Research Paper April
Value Of Honesty Essay, Research Paper April 23, 1998 Eng 121 Sec47 Definition essay The Value of Honesty Honesty and simply being truthful seem, on the surface, to be one and the same concept. However, though they are closely related in definition and are in fact listed as synonyms, there are fundamental differences between the two.
Oedipus Rex Vs Hamlet Essay Research Paper
In the play Hamlet: Prince of Denmark, a young prince is in search of the truth behind his father s murder. At first, Hamlet sees the ghost of his deceased father and it tells him he was murdered by the now current king, Hamlet s Uncle Claudius. Hamlet has to think about how he will get revenge for his fathers death, but because his only knowledge came from a ghost that only Hamlet heard speak, he is hesitant to get his revenge quickly.
Hume Hobbes And Descartes Essay Research Paper
Hume, Hobbes, and Descartes Rene Descartes, Thomas Hobbes and David Hume are well known philosophers of the time. These three men were after the truth. The truth about life. The truth about how one exists. The truth about the world around them. They questioned, thought, and reasoned. This is what they did.
The Folly Of Logic The Freedom Of
Truth Essay, Research Paper Logic can very often restrain us from recognising the truth when it is presented to us. Allow me to begin by asking a question.
The Role Of Truth In Satyagraha -
– Gandhi Essay, Research Paper The Role of Truth in Satyagraha Gandhi developed a method of direct social action based upon principles of courage, nonviolence, and truth. This policy of nonviolent resistance and the search for this truth, is called satyagraha. Truth is soul or spirit; it is a major component in satyagraha.
Does The Truth Always Set You Free
? Essay, Research Paper On the Waterfront is a classic, award-winning and controversial film. It received eight academy-awards in 1954, including best-picture and director. The director, Eliza Kazan, in collaboration with Budd Schulberg wrote the film?s screenplay. Based on actual dockside events in Hoboken, New Jersey, On the Waterfront is a story of a dock worker who tried to overthrow a corrupt union.
The Allegory Of The
Cave Essay, Research Paper The Allegory of the Cave Plato gives rise to an interesting thought in The Allegory of the Cave . He suggest that people are to trusting in an unreliable society. Though he wrote this many years ago, it still applies today. It is ironic that people are willing to believe what the are told to be true, rather than search for the actual truth.
The Fight Theory And The American Legal
System Essay, Research Paper The aim of the legal profession is to seek out the truth and provide justice for those who were wronged. Lawyers represent clients who are on opposite sides of the case, and who most often have opposite views of the truth. In the legal system there exist two opposing views on the method of uncovering the truth.
Mythology Essay Research Paper What is mythology
Mythology Essay, Research Paper What is mythology? Mythology is like a fib that started many years ago in the olden days. It is still around due to people still continuing to use a myth as the truth. They seem to not know the difference between a myth and a legend. People these days are so naive it is ashame to know the rate of people that actually believe those myths.
Create Your Own Truth Essay Research Paper
Jenica Antonellis 11-20-00 IS101, Dr. Dean Walton Quiz #1 3.) The statement, “I create my own truth. What I believe to be true is true for me” is based on the illogical belief that all truth is subjective and that thinking something is true makes it true. There are many people who hold that view, and maybe some truths are subjective, but that doesn’t mean that people go around creating their own truths.
Lao Tzu
’S Response Essay, Research Paper I am Lao Tzu. In response to Mr. Martin’s observation: “The mind cannot find truth by itself, but it sure as hell can find falsehood. The idea of stumbling through life with my heart open and my bull*censored* detector turned off doesn’t appeal to me.”
Thank God For Believers Essay Research Paper
A single lie entangled my thoughts with confusion, Like rumors through a hallway, the lie continues to grow. Now spun is a web of wire. I dread the day of truth and innocence.
Blindness In Oedipus Rex Essay Research Paper
Blindness in “Oedipus the King” In Sophocles’ play, “Oedipus the King”, one of the main themes is blindness. The author uses physical blindness, as well as intellectual blindness to illustrate Oedipus’ status
Truth And Belief Essay Research Paper Truth
Truth And Belief Essay, Research Paper Truth and Belief James is a believer in the pragmatic theory of truth. He draws a relationship between the good and the true. The true is not an separate entity from good, but is one of the species of good.
The Quest For Truth Essay Research Paper
The Quest for the Truth To find truth, you must open yourself up to it. Forget all that you think you know, and embrace all that you don t. Honesty and Trust are the legs that truth stands on and without them the entire body collapses. In your search for spiritual truth, you need to first be honest with yourself, then others, for if you can t tell yourself the truth how could you possibly share it with others.
On The Waterfront Essay Research Paper Terry
On The Waterfront Essay, Research Paper Terry Malloy as a ?Hero???? When Terry Malloy was first introduced, he did not make any indications that he would strive for the respect that he gained throughout the story. His tough-guy behavior and compassionate attitude has made him what he is: a hero. He never revealed what he was truly made of or what he was capable of.
Jack London Essay Research Paper Sam JMrs
Jack London Essay, Research Paper Sam J. Mrs. Shields 10/02/98 Jack London Jack London fought his way up out of the factories and waterfront dives of West Oakland to become the highest paid, most popular novelist and short story writer of his day. He wrote passionately and prolifically about the great questions of life and death, the struggle to survive with dignity and integrity, and he wove these elemental ideas into stories of high adventure based on his own firsthand experiences at sea, or in Alaska, or in the fields and factories of California.