P.Shyam Sundar11G Essay, Research Paper
The Treaty of Versailles – Source Based Questions
a) Many historians have viewed the Treaty of Versailles in varied contexts. Some historians support the German claim that the treaty was extremely harsh towards them while others seem to acknowledge the fact that the Treaty was anything but damaging to the Germans, as the Second World War seems to prove. But the most important aspect to focus on in the answering of this question is the concept of nationalism.
Source C is a quotation found in a secondary source in the form of an extract from a speech made by a German MP in 1919. The claim of “inflicting the deepest wounds on us Germans” seems to be supported by Source B. Sources D and E, however, do not share the same viewpoint as the German MP in Source C. The peace treaty that marks the end of any Great War is almost always dictated by the victors; the Treaty of Versailles was no different. Georges Clemenceau of France, Llyod George of Britain and Woodrow Wilson of the USA were the three major players. Clemenceau wanted a harsh Treaty that would cripple Germany both economically and militarily so that she would never be a threat to France again, this aim of his is clearly represented in Clause 160 of Source B. But 100,000 men and 6 battle ships was a mere trifle compared to the extensive armies and rapidly developing technology that the super powers of those days possessed. Germany was left with nothing to defend herself with in case of invasion. Furthermore, the blame for starting the war and all the consequences thereof were fixed on Germany (Article 231). This in many senses was extremely unfair, as all the powers had played a role in the start of the First World War. Woodrow Wilson’s 14 points were totally overshadowed by Clemenceau who succeeded in imposing his aims on the Treaty. Therefore I believe that Source B does adequately support the claim made in Source C.
However, Sources D and E take a completely opposite viewpoint in comparison to Source B. The writers, imminent historians, argue that the Treaty in actual fact did nothing to diminish German power in any way. As the author of Source E notes: “The Treaty of Versailles was not excessively harsh on Germany, either territorially or economically.” Humiliation is always a major part of defeat and defeat was not something that the Germans hoped to conceive in World War 1. They believed that they had to win and dictate terms. The Treaty of Versailles that resulted from their defeat also brought immense humiliation and that strong sense of nationalistic pride. After all, the Treaty was being signed in the very hall that had witnessed the defeat of France in 1871 at the hands of Prussia. This actual defeat that the Treaty of Versailles imposed upon them angered the Germans more than the actual terms of the Treaty. The historian in Source C aptly concludes: “However, the German people were expecting victory and not defeat. It was the acknowledgement of defeat as much as the treaty terms themselves, which they found so hard to accept.”
b) The views expressed in Sources C, D and E are very much different. One must take into account several different factors that combine to produce this discrepancy. Firstly, the authors of Sources D and E are historians and possess something that the German MP in Source C doesn’t and that is hindsight. They have had the opportunity to study the First World War and the Treaty of Versailles in retrospect and have examined the effects on Germany. They have studied the revival of the German economy and the Second World War. Therefore they are in a better position to judge whether or not the Treaty of Versailles was a crippling blow to Germany. The politician in Source C on the other hand is talking on the spur of the moment. The Treaty of Versailles might have been close to completion and the Treaty terms might have seemed a devastating conclusion. The very vision of impending collapse brought on by the treaty might have caused him to lash out in the way that he does.
One other factor that might also play a part in the variation found in the views expressed is bias. After all both of the historians are not German and are said to be British historians and would therefore, however modern their ideas and thoughts might be, be slightly biased towards the British side while dealing with the Treaty of Versailles. Furthermore, the time period in which JAS Grenville’s book was published (1994) is quite distant from the era of the First World War and also from date of publication of Ruth Henig’s book. Therefore his writings might have been influenced by the countless more opinions and analyses, some of which might be biased towards one side or the other.
c) The Treaty of Versailles was the conclusion to the “war to end all wars”, but did the Treaty of Versailles actually serve as a peace treaty or did it only succeed in causing more cracks in the already fissured continent of Europe? The sources all serve as ample supports to the statement that the “foundations for a stable peace had not been laid in 1920.”
Let us start with source A. In this Source, an extract from the speech made by Woodrow Wilson to the US Congress outlining point four of his Fourteen Points, he makes it very clear that in order to achieve world peace the amount of armaments possessed by any country should be restricted to enough weaponry to protect domestic safety. This point is imposed upon Germany in the form of Clause 160 as is proved by Source B. However, the actual inclusion of this point was masterminded entirely by Clemenceau of France whose aim was not towards world peace but towards the military weakening of Germany while France kept her full army strength. This was the worse note that any peace conference could get off to. The reduction of the German Army and weaponry proved to be a major seething point for Hitler, whose major goal, once he established his control over Germany, was to secretly increase his arms in an attempt to hit back at the Treaty of Versailles.
Source B further presses home the humiliation suffered by the German people. The reduction of their once powerful army into mere nothingness by Clause 160, and the imposition of the entire blame for starting the war and the havoc caused by it on Germany, though clause 231, evoked strong nationalistic feelings that were used by Hitler to kindle his war. The hopes carried by Clemenceau that the Treaty of Versailles would ruin the Germans economically and militarily therefore ensuring that they would never be able to challenge France again was shattered by the eruption of the Second World War.
The German MP in Source C, even though he might have been mistaken about the Treaty of Versailles draining the lifeblood of the Germans, symbolizes the detestation of it that all the Germans carried within them. The ridiculous terms and the absurd conditions aroused the Germans’ nationalistic feelings. They felt a bitter hatred within their heart that the once powerful kingdom of the Kaiser had been reduced to shambles and forced to sign the Treaty in the very hall from which it had once emerged victorious in 1871. The peace that the Treaty of Versailles brought to the Germans was no peace at all but the psychological and physical need to get back at the people who forced it upon them.
British historians with the knowledge of hindsight have written both the extracts in sources D and E. They have had the opportunity to study the peace Treaty of Versailles and to judge whether it brought peace. They have gone thorough the Second World War and the way in which Hitler used the Treaty of Versailles to justify his position. They have witnessed the havoc and chaos caused by the Second World War and it’s aftermath. Therefore they are in a much better position to claim that the Treaty of Versailles did not set any foundation for future peace.
From the above sources it is a proven fact that the Treaty of Versailles can be criticized with the statement that “The conditions for a stable peace had not been laid in 1920.” The treaty neither weakened Germany nor did it reconcile Germany; it only succeeded in bringing about further conflict in Europe: the very scenario that it was meant to abolish.
Другие работы по теме:
World Court Essay Research Paper World CourtThe
World Court Essay, Research Paper World Court The World Court has developed as an arena where states can solve legal disagreements between each other. The development of international law gave need to such a venue and therefore the United Nations facilitated to this need by creating the World Court. The World Court hears grievances between states only; no outside parties may be represented within this justice system, such as individuals or corporations.
President Bush And The AntiBallistic Missile Treaty
Essay, Research Paper When the Cold War came to a finish in 1972, the Soviet Union and the United States of America knew some sort of action needed to be taken to evade a nuclear war in the future. The U.S. wanted an agreement with the Soviet Union for the limitation of ?strategic offensive arms?. From this dilemma, the Anti-Ballistic Missile (ABM) Treaty was produced, and signed, by both countries to put an end to their aggression towards each other and to limit anti-ballistic missile systems designed to defend against strategic ballistic missiles.
Revolutionary War 2 Essay Research Paper The
Revolutionary War 2 Essay, Research Paper The British lost and the Americans won the Revolutionary war. Though this is true there are arguments that the British lost the war more than the Americans won it. The Americans were under the control of the British and the Americans at first did not even have the intention of independence.
War Essay Research Paper The war between
War Essay, Research Paper The war between Japan and the United States did not have to happen. It could have been prevented by diplomacy in 1941. The United States was Japan?s principle supplier of scrap metal and oil. In 1940 Japan signed a treaty with the government of France for the establishment of airbases in French Indochina.
Nuclear Weapons Essay Research Paper Even though
Nuclear Weapons Essay, Research Paper Even though the United States and Russia have just concluded the most far-reaching nuclear arms reduction treaty in history, the danger that nuclear weapons will actually be used is growing rather than declining. George Bush and Boris Yeltsin’s START II accord does represent an important step in winding down the U.S.-Soviet nuclear arms race (Fromuth, 1993).
Seminoles Essay Research Paper SEMINOLESDuring the first
Seminoles Essay, Research Paper SEMINOLES During the first century, or rather (1789-1812), there were many confrontations between the Seminoles and Americans. From trading with them to having a war with them, living on the same land meant there were going to interactions.
The Nuclear Threat Essay Research Paper The
The Nuclear Threat Essay, Research Paper The United States, once a defender of world peace and an international police power, seems today to be loosening the grip that has in the past prevented so much violence through out the world. At a time when “renegade” nations are arming with nuclear weapons, the Senate has voted not to ratify the Comprehensive Nuclear Test Ban Treaty, a document that in the President’s words “is critical to protecting the American people from the dangers of nuclear war”.
The End Of The Cold War Essay
, Research Paper How and why did the Cold War end? The period of the Cold war was a very awkward time. Nobody really knew what was going to happen. Some were frightened and some didn t even pay attention to it. Communist and democratic relations in the late 1980s were not going too well. The United States and the world stood back and watched uprisings from both sides that eventually led to the fall of many communist governments.
Treaty Of Versailles More Trouble Than Good
Essay, Research Paper In a miserably failed attempt to stop the already ongoing violence during world war one, and prevent further conflict in the region, the Treaty of Versailles was proposed by ex-president Woodrow Wilson. Such treaty – not using the term according to its stipulated meaning – set cruel rules and pointers that would only produce more violence and terror.
The Kanagawa Treaty Essay Research Paper The
The Kanagawa Treaty Essay, Research Paper The Kanagawa Treaty In 1852 the United States appointed Commodore Mathew Perry to lead an expedition to Japan in efforts to open diplomatic and trade relations. Japan had been closed off from the rest of the world for over two hundred years. Only the Dutch and Chinese had limited contact with Japan.
Panama Canal Treaties Essay Research Paper I
Panama Canal Treaties Essay, Research Paper I here by hand my report copy rights to Cheat House!, Phillip Mayhew The Hay-Pauncefote Treaty The Hay-Pauncefote treaty was an agreement, in 1901, between Great Britain and the United States of America. This agreement provided construction and also regulation of a canal across the Isthmus of Panama.
Bosnia 2 Essay Research Paper BosniaThe war
Bosnia 2 Essay, Research Paper Bosnia The war in Bosnia-Herzegovina began in 1992. It has left at least a quarter of a million people dead or missing and made refugees of more than half the nation s population. A Treaty was signed on December 14, 1995 in Paris to formally end Bosnian War. It was signed by the presidents of Bosnia, Croatia, and Serbia as well as other international heads of state.
The Seminoles Essay Research Paper The Seminole
The Seminoles Essay, Research Paper The Seminole Indians are a tribe of Indians who now have territory and reservations in Florida and Oklahoma. They once belonged to the Muskogee tribe that lived along
Germany Essay Research Paper n 1914 a
Germany Essay, Research Paper n 1914 a world war broke out. A war that would crush millions of lives, destroy lifetimes of work and cause hate that lasted for
Land Mines Essay Research Paper Land mines
Land Mines Essay, Research Paper Land mines greatly contribute to the danger of international security because they are used as military weapons. Because land mines have caused great destruction there has been an effort from international and non-governmental organizations to ban mines and clear areas infected with them.
Native American Relations Essay Research Paper During
Native American Relations Essay, Research Paper During the numerous years of colonization, the relationship between the English settlers and the Native Americans of the area was usually the same. Native Americans would initially consider the settlers to be allies, then as time passed, they would be engaged in wars with them in a struggle for control of the land.
The Louisiana Purchase Essay Research Paper The
The Louisiana Purchase Essay, Research Paper The Louisiana Purchase was the purchase of the French province of Louisiana by the United States in 1803. The province stretched from the Mississippi River westward to the
Versailles Treaty Essay Research Paper Treaty of
Versailles Treaty Essay, Research Paper Treaty of Versailles The treaty of Versailles was a peace treaty signed at the end of World War I between Germany and the Allies. It was negotiated during the Paris Peace Conference held in Versailles beginning January 18, 1919. The allies represented were the United States, Great Britain, France, and Italy.
League Of Nations Essay Research Paper The
League Of Nations Essay, Research Paper The Versaille Treaty, an agreement for peaceful terms among the warring nations of World War I, was extinguished by the insatiable desires of all
Woodrow Wilson Essay Research Paper During his
Woodrow Wilson Essay, Research Paper During his term of presidency, Wilson introduced the Treaty of Versailles in order to assist in the “covenant” of the League of Nations. The Senate defeated this treaty after a long and tiring debate. Despite the strength of the opposition forces, both liberal and conservative, the treaty could still have been passed, had a few changes been made.
Effects Of The Treaty Of Versailles On
Germany Essay, Research Paper The Effects of the Treaty of Versailles on Germany World War I was one of the bloodiest and deadliest wars of all time. Many agreed that there were to be no more wars hence a treaty was signed. However, the contents of the treaty were not to Germany?s favour. The treaty of Versailles had a great role in Germany?s decision and desire to enter into war.
The War Of 1812 A Battle Essay
, Research Paper A.P. History Essay on the War of 1812 The War of 1812 also know as “The Second American War for Independance” (Bailey pg. 233) was fought between the meeger forces of the American government and the supreme power of Great Britain. The war ended in 1815 with the treaty of Gehnt, this treaty wasnt really a treaty but an armastice or surrender of arms.
The Kyoto Treaty Essay Research Paper Should
The Kyoto Treaty Essay, Research Paper Should the US ratify the Kyoto treaty? Implementation of the Kyoto Global Warming Treaty, which requires all industrial nations to reduce greenhouse gas emissions to below 1990 levels, is a critical first step in stopping global warming.
Ww1 Essay Research Paper The Causes and
Ww1 Essay, Research Paper The Causes and Effects of World War I? Omar Nova Home Room 306 World History/English 1 Mrs. Denicola/Mrs. Fisk April 11, 2000 Thesis Statement:
Arab Israeli Conflict Essay Research Paper The
Arab Israeli Conflict Essay, Research Paper The Arab-Israeli Conflict The Arab Israeli conflict has gone on for many years. There have been many wars, terrorist attacks and peace treaties between
Heading Towards Ww2 Essay Research Paper Heading
Heading Towards Ww2 Essay, Research Paper Heading Towards WWII World War II was a result of how World War I was resolved. The Treaty of Versailles, signed at the end of the Great War, was supposed to bring about change and
WWI Peace Settlement Essay Research Paper The
WWI Peace Settlement Essay, Research Paper The First World War started in 1914 and ended in 1918. Germany and her Allies, Austria – Hungary, Turkey and Bulgaria lost the war with the
End Of WW I Essay Research Paper
The End of World War I When World War I ended on November 11, 1918, peace talks went on for months due to the Allied leaders wanting to punish the enemy and ?dividing the spoils of war.? A formal agreement to end the war was made and called the Treaty of Versailles. The issue that took the most time were the territorial issues because the empires of Russia, Austria-Hungary, the Ottoman, and Germany had collapsed.
Hitler Essay Research Paper Mein Kampf
Hitler Essay, Research Paper Mein Kampf! Adolf Hitler would say. Adolf Hitler should be the Person Of the Century. Hitler has changed the world. He caused technology to evolve. Adolf was the
Golf Essay Research Paper Golf report in
Golf Essay, Research Paper Golf report in English Golf as we know it today was orginated in Scottland in 1421. It started off by players hitting a pebble around a natural course of sand dunes, rabbit runs and tracks using a club. Historians have came to believe that Kolven from Holland and Chole from Belgium influenced the game.
Three EmperorsS League Essay Research Paper 1
Three Emperors?S League Essay, Research Paper 1. Three Emperors?s League: In 1873 this league linked the monarchs of Austria-Hungary, Germany, and Russia in an alliance against racial movements.
Hitlers Germany Essay Research Paper One reason
Hitlers Germany Essay, Research Paper One reason the people of Germany accepted Hitler’s orders willingly and without question was beause it was what they wanted to hear. At the time the depression