Paper
The Four Arts of Freedom
In Wayne C. Booth?s essay ?What?s Supposed to Be Going on Here?? he directly challenges what we consider to be a liberal education and proposes a solution based on revamping the ?three r?s?. This long-winded look at the mental ignorance of people today offers several interesting insights, as well as Booth?s critique of his own proposed solution. Although he admits to having a flawed solution, he does not believe any of the flaws would overthrow his general argument.
Booth begins by stating that what we term as ?liberal education? is actually quite the opposite. He implies that while we are being educated to eradicate ignorance, we are in fact becoming more ignorant because we are being taught to use the information we are given ?for social climbing? (55). Booth also states that without knowledge ?we may embrace political programs and schools of art and world views with as much passion as if we knew what we were doing, but our seeming choices are really what other people have imposed upon us? (55). It seems that educated or not, Booth would consider the average person to be ignorant.
How can this ignorance be stopped? Booth suggests a revamping of the ?three r?s? (reading, ?riting and ?rithmetic). He has proposed another list of r?s, which he considers three of the four on his new list to be ?available, in some degree, to every student who is willing to seek them out? (56). The first r is the art of recovery of meanings. In defining this first r, Booth states that it is ?the art of recovering what other people mean and not what we?d like them to mean?(59). While this sounds fairly easy, it is very much the opposite. Booth believes so many of us have fallen into the habit of assuming we listen with an open mind to other people?s thoughts and ideas, when in fact we essentially sort the ideas into categories we have already formed in our minds and more often than not use that to invalidate the information we are trying to learn.
Zutshi 2
The second r is rejection. Rejection, Booth believes, is something that can be worked on mainly by uneducated minds. We need to be able to discern which ideas can go together and which ones do not. The best example Booth gives of this is:
The uneducated mind will accept slogans like ?students are the most exploited class in America today,? even though it also knows that migrant workers and black workers have been immeasurably more exploited and have a right to be insulted by the comparison with affluent middle-class students (62).
Although he targets the uneducated mind, Booth does make a point of saying that all of us, educated or not, will have conflicting ideas such as that. However, someone who is educated would be able to notice the conflict in such a statement and work through that.
The third r is renewal/renovation. Renewal mainly ties in with rejection. Renewal would come up when the educated man would sit down and rethink his opposing ideas and come up with a new ?renovated? idea that would not be conflicting. Renewal also comes up in discussing the media?s role in our education. Rather than just sitting back and absorbing all of the information that is thrown at us on the radio, on the television, and in printed materials, Booth tells us to take a closer look. Education should allow us to ?see our contradictions clearly and, more importantly? (64) should ?teach the methods of bringing contradictions to the surface, of working out genuine harmonies, and of presenting the results persuasively to our fellow man? (64).
The final r is revolution. Booth is suggesting an intellectual revolution. Using recovery, rejection and renewal as key factors in education, and intellectual revolution could begin. However, even as clearly defined as Booth has made this solution, there are a few complications he himself has noted. The first would be spending ?too much time trying to get all my ideas clear before I act? (64), which could result in him never acting. The other side of that argument would be to act too rashly. The idea could be half developed but for fear of never acting, could be rushed out to the public and end up doing more harm than good.
Zutshi 3
Another possible complication would be how can we tell and educator from an ?indoctrinator disguised as [an] educator?? (64). No matter what precautions were taken, it would be easy to assume that there would still be some people out there trying to impose their opinions, or those of others, on the student (to the point where the student would come to believe that it was their own opinion). Although Booth?s plan sounds different than most things being taught now, it would still be very difficult to realize if one was in fact being misled.
While there were other complications with Booth?s solution, he does not believe that any of these would effect or invalidate his initial plan. He believes that within his ?four arts of freedom? (64) solution lays the path to true freedom- whether it is spiritual, mental or physical. His suggestions, he believes, would truly make our ?liberal education? liberal.
Booth, Wayne C. ?What?s Supposed to Be Going on Here?? Making Choices Eds. Michael Cooley
Katherine Powell. Boston: Houghton Mifflin, 1997: 55-65.
Другие работы по теме:
Martial Arts In China Essay Research Paper
ME10.20.96. BTHSCBL – 1 Martial Arts To follow is my report on martial arts in Asia. This a very interesting subject, and a very good report. It will describe martial arts and some types of martial arts. It will
Liberal Arts Essay Research Paper An Education
Liberal Arts Essay, Research Paper An Education in Liberal Arts Liberal arts is a universal education that provides a strong foundation of knowledge in many subjects. Liberal arts can observe the capabilities as well as the limitations of each field of study. This allows students to find connections between different fields of study, to explore them, and to discover new theories and/or inventions.
Dance Essay Research Paper The reasons I
Dance Essay, Research Paper The reasons I want to attend Oklahoma Summer Arts Institute are the fact of dancing for two weeks straight. The chance to be able to express myself in my
Eco 2 Essay Research Paper SURVEYOR NEEDEDSurveyor
Eco 2 Essay, Research Paper SURVEYOR NEEDED Surveyor Job Description The Canadian Government is looking for a surveyor. This could be your lucky day. If you are totally identical to what is bellow then we want you. So don’t miss out on this great opportunity. Fill out your Resume today.
Awakening Essay Research Paper When Edna swam
Awakening Essay, Research Paper When Edna swam out into the ocean at the end of The Awakening, I think it was because she realized her situation. She was madly in love with Robert and she was married. Her husband, Leonce, was much too proper and business-like to please her childish spirit. However, in the end, she understood she could not be with Robert.
Poem Freedom Essay Research Paper FreedomI dig
Poem: Freedom Essay, Research Paper Freedom. I dig my feet into the sand. Stare at the stars above me burning bright. I close my eyes and hear the ocean, I taste the salt upon my lips.
The American Dream Essay Research Paper Americans
The American Dream Essay, Research Paper Americans have always had a universal dream ranging from marriage to freedom, and of course, money. Some Americans pursue them more diligently than others, while the others just sit and dream.
Where Would I Be Without Freedom Essay
, Research Paper I walk upon the earth and marvel at the ability to let the grass cushion my wandering feet. What if my feet could not wander? What if I were a slave to this rich soil, then where would
Freedom Essay Research Paper As with any
Freedom Essay, Research Paper As with any government, there is the necessity of an economy, or else the government would fail because economy is one of the basic necessities of a government. With a democracy like we have in a country of our size, managing this economy becomes a big problem. One important factor is; In a country based on freedom, how much are we willing to give up to keep the economy stable? None? A little bit? All of it? The answer is not as simple as any of those.
Capitalism And Communism Essay Research Paper Capitalism
Capitalism And Communism Essay, Research Paper Capitalism and Communism are two totally different economic systems. Capitalism is a much better economic system than Communism. Capitalism is an economic system characterized by freedom of the market and is the economic system where you do not have freedom because the government will make most of your decisions for you.
Freedom Essay Research Paper English 9
Freedom Essay, Research Paper English 9 – 2January 11 , 1999 What Freedom Means to Me When I think of freedom I think of courage. In order for us to receivefreedom our country has gone through a great deal of courageous fighting towin the battles that most of us take for granted. If our forefathers hadn’tfought we might live in a world where there was a ruler, and we would not beallowed to make up our own minds.
Teenagers Have Too Much Freedom Essay Research
Paper ??Young people today have too much freedom.?? Do you agree ? Nowadays, many teenagers are spoilt, they are doing things which are unsuitable for their age. You may ask , ??Why ??? I am sorry to say that the kids have too much freedom, they
Freedom Essay Research Paper Free to me
Freedom Essay, Research Paper Free to me means that you have no restrictions, no laws, and no boundaries controlling you. You can do basically what you want, when you want. If people were to follow my idea of freedom though, the world would be a chaotic place to live.
Freedom Essay Research Paper What Freedom Means
Freedom Essay, Research Paper What Freedom Means to Me Free*dom (noun) First appeared before 12th Century 1 : the quality or state of being free: as a : the absence of necessity, or constraint in choice or action
Handmaid 2 Essay Research Paper freedom mean
Handmaid 2 Essay, Research Paper freedom mean to you? The meaning of freedom is different for each individual. For some it may be the freedom offered to immigrants fleeing torment of their home countries to seek refuge in other countries. To a sixteen-year-old boy, freedom has only one true definition, driver s license.
Freedom Essay Research Paper How can one
Freedom Essay, Research Paper How can one measure the meaning of freedom without understanding the torment of confinement. The dark, unfathomable reaches of a dank pit, the deep, unknown regions of a large tree, even the confines of school, all can be the breach of freedom.
Images Of Freedom And Confinement In
“Boys And Girls” Essay, Research Paper Many of the images and events in “Boys and Girls” have to do with freedom or the lack of it. The narrator defines freedom in a number of situations. In this story, the male world represents freedom while the female world represents confinement. In the narrator’s perspective, her mother was confined to the kitchen of their house and “never came out unless it was to hang out the wash or dig potatoes.” On the contrary, the narrator’s father was not confined to a specific place and worked outside killing and skinning foxes.
Bruce Lee Essay Research Paper Hello and
Bruce Lee Essay, Research Paper Hello and welcome to the annual martial arts convention of 1974. As accomplished martial artists, we have traveled worldwide here to learn from eachother for the advancement of martial arts as an art form and lifestyle. As an actor, martial artist, and father, Mr. Bruce Lee was to speak to us today on martial arts and the impact it had had on his life.
Being Trained In Martial Arts Essay Research
Paper Being Trained in Martial Arts: the spritual and physical aspects of martial arts. When a Asian guy, Bruce Lee, knocked down huge western guys whose bodies were almost twice bigger than his with only bare hands and fantastic speed and techniques in his world beating movies in early seventies, most people in the world, especially western people, were surprised and even shocked.
Martial Arts Essay Research Paper Martial ArtsWhen
Martial Arts Essay, Research Paper Martial Arts When you think of martial arts, what comes to mind? The slow, calm movements of ai-Chi Chuan or maybe the faster, hard movements of Karate or Tae Kwon Do. No
A Visit To The Norton Museum Essay
, Research Paper A Visit to the Norton Museum I saw a lot of amazing arts when I went to Norton Museum. The one that I was interested in was Nude on a Sofa. It had a different felling form the other arts. The art had a comfortable feeling when I look at it.
Are We Losing Our Freedom Essay Research
Paper ?Are We Losing Our Freedom? Many people today feel that living in America has more privileges than living anywhere else. But do we have enough freedom here in the United States? Many people can argue on their outlook on freedom. I personally feel that we are given many opportunities then other people in the world.
Visual Art Essay Research Paper VISUAL ARTS
Visual Art Essay, Research Paper VISUAL ARTS “The physical impossibility of death in the mind of someone living” By Damien Hirst (photo courtesy of the saatchi collection)
Allen Ginsberg Essay Research Paper What exactly
Allen Ginsberg Essay, Research Paper What exactly does it mean to be American? What are the boundaries of freedom and liberty? Do we have the freedom to speak from the heart? Allen Ginsberg believed so, and he did just that.
Jack Kerouac Essay Research Paper The novel
Jack Kerouac Essay, Research Paper The novel On The Road written by Jack Kerouac is a book that can be read as a quest taken by Sal Paradise who sets out to test the American Dream by trying to pin down its promise of unlimited freedom by following the example of Dean Morairty. In the book ? the road? becomes a symbol of freedom or escape for Sal and his friends.
The Giver Essay Research Paper The GiverSome
The Giver Essay, Research Paper The Giver Some say when you have the freedom to chose you really have no freedom at all. Many countries don t give their citizens the right to make their own decisions. In the
Rogers Essay Research Paper Drawing from our
Rogers Essay, Research Paper Drawing from our experiances with formal education , we have come to agree with Rogers to some degree, but also disagree with some of the points that he made concerning freedom in the classroom. There are many components of the theory that would be helpful to the learning process of the student.
What Freedom Of Speech Means To Me
Essay, Research Paper WHAT FREEDOM OF SPEECH MEANS TO ME The Bill of Rights states, “Congress shall make no law respecting an establishment of religion, or profiting the free exercise thereof; or abridging the freedom of speech, or of the press; or the right of the people peaceably to assemble, and to petition the Government for a redress of grievances.” This is quite possibly the amendment that makes the United States the democratic and orderly country it is.
Freedom VS Destiny Essay Research Paper People
Freedom VS Destiny Essay, Research Paper People like to believe that they have the freedom to choose what they want to do, however it is quite the opposite. Freedom has its limitations to what people are allowed to do, but predestination has no limits of any kind. Freedom is in fact used to cover up predestination, to keep people content in following absurd rules.
Freedom Essay Research Paper What Price Freedom
Freedom Essay, Research Paper What Price Freedom? What does it mean to be “American?” What makes it “American?” And how does it make us “American?” American stands for the freedom, the beliefs, as well as the people that come from this great nation. The beliefs of this great nation speak every language. These beliefs stretch from the furthest beaches of Africa to the city life of New York.
Art 2 Essay Research Paper Essay IndexCustom
Art 2 Essay, Research Paper Essay Index Custom Writing College Stuff Sumit an Essay Message Boards Links Link to Us E-mail Me Search Options | Click Here to search the Paper Store
Braveheart Essay Research Paper I have just
Braveheart Essay, Research Paper I have just recently watched the film 1995 film Braveheart directed by and starring Mel Gibson. The main thing that I noticed about the film was not the art or architecture, but the lack there of. In ancient Roman times, there was some kind of Roman architecture almost everywhere.