Paper
The Quarrel About Historical Explanation
The discussion of the philosophical question of historical explanation
is in reality a disagreement concerning the nature of the philosophic method.
There are primarily two sides taken in this argument, those who agree
with Carl Hempel and those that do not.
According to Hempel a historical event is only sufficiently explained
when it logically fits a set of confirmed pre-existing conditions along with
some universal laws.
Certainly all things cannot easily be assigned to rules and laws.
Political coups, assassinations and revolutions are too complex for such a rigid
explanation. And who is to say what perquisites there are for situations.
Certainly there is no one who can predict every instance of a given event, there
are just too many variables.
Hempel then notes that Historians are seldom able to stick to his
procedure and at best can only make an explanation sketch. Hempel seems to be
saying then, that the majority of explanations surrounding historical events are
inadequate and incomplete.
There are three main divisions of anti-Hempelians. There are those that
agree with Hempel to the point that there are rules and general laws that can be
followed, but a historian’s explanation is adequate if all he can provide is a
sketch. The second group states that the general laws are not necessary and as
long as the explanation provides an understandable narrative, it is complete.
The final group believes that only one condition is necessary, and if more
information is needed, one only needs to elaborate on that one condition.
The Hempelians and the anti-Hempelians both have common ground. They
are both engaged in the philosophy of history, but this is where the agreement
stops for even the groups starting points are different.
Hempelians give their explanations to answer the question of why
something happened. Their objective is to replace curiosity with understanding.
For this to happen both the laws and general rules given must logically agree.
In other words you must be able to deduce the answer after given the laws and
rules.
It would not be enough for a Hempelian to hear that conditions led up to
an event. He must know himself that these conditions are causes, and he’ll know
this only if the conditions are widely known or confirmed causes of said event.
These conditions must not only be confirmed but true or the explanation would
merely be an exercise in futility.
An anti-Hempelian’s problem with all of this is summarized in that
historians do not use such methods to do their explaining, even if they did an
explanation may not result, and finally historians are doing a very fine job
without Hempel’s help.
Anti-Hempelians have three principles in their objections. 1. A
philosopher should stick to the facts that he knows and not assign laws and
rules that he’s not sure of the existence of. 2. A philosopher cannot be
creative and come up with his own theories because he has to stick to the simple
matter of filling in the blanks. 3. Each person that asks for an explanation
wants to know something different. Each has their own knowledge and interest
and it takes different complete answers to satisfy them.
In the end, the Hempelian method is too big of a task. The number of
explanations surrounding certain events are too many for the method to be simple
and useful. Furthermore, this type of classification and identification is more
the work of a scientist, not a philosopher. And what is to happen when there
don’t seem to be rules and laws predicting an event, is a Hempelian to then make
them up? It would seem then, that the Hempelians are in danger of losing sight
of their objective.
Другие работы по теме:
Historical Notes In The Handmaid
’s Tale Essay, Research Paper Historical Notes on The Handmaid?s Tale? The Handmaid?s Tale by Margaret Atwood is an intriguing look into a darker one of infinite possibilities that our future as a country offers. The
Historical Fiction Essay Research Paper Textbooks can
Historical Fiction Essay, Research Paper Textbooks can often prove to offer only a limited amount of information. Space and time constraints place the author(s) of these textbooks in a sticky situation. They must get the general concept through without taking up to much space. However, this can sometimes push out relevant material that van help to support the general concept.
God Essay Research Paper God is allgood
God Essay, Research Paper ?God is all-good, God is all-powerful, and yet evil exists.? (Mackie, 90) The stated are three premises that are true. Truth lies in the explanation for why evil exists. The origin of sin is the explanation for the evil and suffering that people and nature bring on mankind. Once cannot doubt the existence of God based on principles that He has permitted to exist in mankind.
Writing A Poem Essay Research Paper Writing
Writing A Poem Essay, Research Paper Writing a Poem It is beyond reason; there is no motive, no explanation Why it is, I do not know because there is cause, no clarification.
Strange Explanations Essay Research Paper Sleeping disorders
Strange Explanations Essay, Research Paper Sleeping disorders occur to millions of people around the world. People say that they are medical problems, and some people would just say it was stress. Then there is the explanation that some people choose to follow that is the explanation that aliens had abducted these people.
Dream Deffered Essay Research Paper Dream DeferredHe
Dream Deffered Essay, Research Paper ?Dream Deferred? ?He knew as he stood there that he could never tell why he killed. It was not that he did not really want to tell, but the telling of it would have involved an explanation of his
God Essay Research Paper To say that
God Essay, Research Paper To say that God does exist, is to say that we can prove God exists by describing some proof we have of this statement, or at least a being with what we think some of the attributes of a God would be. Since we cannot prove beyond reasonable doubt that God exists we have to infer certain things about how we came to be.
Elmer Kelton Essay Research Paper In Elmer
Elmer Kelton Essay, Research Paper In Elmer Keltons “Politically Correct or Historically Correct” he mentions about the way people see and describe historical events. Some people can describe
THoughts On Pocahontas Essay Research Paper After
THoughts On Pocahontas Essay, Research Paper After watching the disney movie, Pocahontas, many people have found a large amount of historical inaccuracies in both the setting, and the characters portrayed. An example is: the topographic features of Virginia aren?t at all like the waterfalls and mountains shown in the movie.
Brown Vs The Board Of Education Essay
, Research Paper If I were to base my decision on the presentation of the opposite sides of the case, I would have to rule against Brown. Her argument lacked sufficient support and explanation. Furthermore, her proposed solution was very eluding for it would not solve the problem of segregation and racism.
Smile Essay Research Paper I never know
Smile Essay, Research Paper I never know the nature of which the casual smile hides Whether it be of unforsaken wickedness or lathered with goodnessDo we smile when we kill? I guess there are choices in interpretation:Optimistic or pessimistic, routes to which we can explore the apocrypha expressionsThis nature morphs with time spend together or at distanceThe fleshy gestures change and the explanation of which becomes a bothersome tribulationWith each day, with each thought, the meaning is refashioned So many vicissitudes, And so many lost devotions
Bible And The Word
“Inspire” Essay, Research Paper The Bible and the Word “Inspire” According to the Random House Dictionary, the word inspire means “to infuse an animating, quickening, or exalting influence into, or to communicate or suggest
Honesty Essay Research Paper Honesty is the
Honesty Essay, Research Paper Honesty is the telling of the truth. It is being there when you say you will be there. It is putting up with the bullshit, without questions, even when you believe it is wrong. The only thing you have in this life is your word, and without that, you have nothing. Everyday my honesty is questioned, without merit, without an explanation.
Ali Essay Research Paper Much of the
Ali Essay, Research Paper Much of the footage, particularly shots of Ali ingratiating himself with the natives and Foreman stepping off a plane accompanied by German shepherds, helps fill in the historical background of the fight. “Ali was loved by the Zaireans,” Gast says, “because they felt he was fighting for them.
Alexandre Dumas Essay Research Paper Alexandre Dumas
Alexandre Dumas Essay, Research Paper Alexandre Dumas was a major playwright who helped to revolutionize French drama and theater. He was one of the best historical novelists, publishing more than two hundred novels.
Poverty Essay Research Paper There are over
Poverty Essay, Research Paper There are over fifteen million people living in poverty today in the United States. The best explanation for this high number is, there is no best explanation. It is just how it is. There are two different theories to help identify the problem. But no theory has been proven correct.
Illiad Essay Research Paper The Illiad has
Illiad Essay, Research Paper The Illiad has by far endured the test of time due to the relation of ancient Greek themes to that of modern day. An abundance of themes from Homer?s era can clearly be observed in today?s society such as emotion, war, and honor. These themes are portrayed throughout the book in various passages, speeches, and dialogue.
Lincoln Essay Research Paper Abraham Lincoln based
Lincoln Essay, Research Paper Abraham Lincoln, based on facts in “The Assassination, Death of the President”, by Champ Clark, was one of America?s greatest President?s ever. Throughout this book, Lincoln?s life was told with great detail as well as the lives of all the other people that were explained. Also, the events that took place were presented by in depth information and impressing pictures.
The Lady Of The Lake By Sir
Walter Scott (1771 – 1832) Essay, Research Paper This absorbing tale, opening with an account of a stag hunt in the Highlands, is typical of Scott. He invented the historical
Titanic Essay Research Paper Hollywood director James
Titanic Essay, Research Paper Hollywood director James Cameron?s 1997 film, Titanic, is the most authentic historical drama of the sinking of the R.M.S. Titanic in 1912. Researching countless journals of the survivors and examining images of the actual ship, Cameron realistically recreated the doomed passenger ship?s voyage and destruction on a grand scale.
Faked Smile Essay Research Paper I sat
Faked Smile Essay, Research Paper I sat on the cliff facing the sea, Mixed emotions accompanied me, Did I say or do anything wrong, That broke the bond that could have last long.
Midsummernights Dream Essay Research Paper In act
Midsummernights Dream Essay, Research Paper In act two of this play, the reader learns of a quarrel between the king of the fairies, Oberon, and his queen, Titania. We later see the development of this quarrel into a dispute which the king is intent on resolving along with that of two passing mortals whose conversation we happen to overhear.
Argument From Design Essay Research Paper Hume
Argument From Design Essay, Research Paper Hume s criticism in regard to the Design Argument, although complex, can be summarized quite simply. It is first important to understand the main elements of the Design Argument. Hume s theory in opposition to that of the Design Argument contests the suggestion that the simple things in the universe must be compared with the greater to appreciate their complexity as a component of the system of the universe.
Recovered Roots Essay Research Paper RECOVERED ROOTSBuilding
Recovered Roots Essay, Research Paper RECOVERED ROOTS: Building National Identity In Yael Zerubavel?s Recovered Roots he identifies and outlines the components of ?national identity.? National identity is described as a group?s common historical highlights. This identity is established through ?collective memory? i.e. a group?s vision of their history based on historical records revised to fit ?social and political agendas.? The revision is not a rewritten history but rather a representation of history with selective emphasis on historical events.
Historical Speeches Essay Research Paper Historical SpeechesEvery
Historical Speeches Essay, Research Paper Historical Speeches Every political moment seeks a great orator to proclaim its hopes and dreams. Historical figures left speeches that inspire us, even in the future. Many of them have given numerous memorable speeches in an effort to change the minds of the world.
Art And Photography Essay Research Paper
- To what extent has photography been used as an instrument of social control? Use historical examples to illustrate this essay. Photography was once prized for its ability to objectively capture what sat in front of the lens. The content of a photo was to be believed without question. Because photos seemed to be able to portray objects exactly as the human eye seemed to, they were taken at face value.
Dinquent Essay Research Paper When things go
D|inquent Essay, Research Paper When things go wrong, When things don’t go the way you wanted, You know it’s the right time To call it quits. He or she wouldn’t know what you have in mind,
The Sociological Quest Essay Research Paper THE
The Sociological Quest Essay, Research Paper THE SOCIOLOGICAL QUEST – SUMMARY OF CHAPTERS 3 & 4. The term ’sociology’ is an amalgam of the Latin and Greek word meaning reasoning about the social’. Sociologists attempt to find the quest for sociological understanding through explanation and reasoning.