, Research Paper
Baracker, Gabe
2-16-98
Phil 102
GTF: Tim Rohrer
essay exam #2
1. You are at a party and you see your best friend?s girl/boyfriend making
out rather intensely with someone (someone other than your friend). After a
while they get up, walking right by you without noticing you, they disappear
into a room together. Do you have a duty to tell your friend what you saw?
Do you consider the consequences of telling your friend before you decide
whether to tell them about what you saw? Does it matter what kind of person
you would be if you told/didn?t tell them?
Discuss this situation with respect to three of the theorists we have
studied-one who focuses on duty, another who focuses on the consequences,
and a third who thinks it is important to consider what kind of human being
we are/want to be. What question(s) do you think to be most important to
ask? Give reasons for your answer. (You may supply details and vary the
situation as necessary to bring out particular philosophical theories.)
To Tell Or Not To Tell?
That, Is The Question.
Quite a predicament, isn?t it? I really do not believe that there is a right
or wrong answer for this type of situation. Either way you are going to get
burned. It is just that by whom you will be burned, that is in question. I think
that everyone has probably been in a situation somewhat like this, right? I
sure know that I have. Actually, I think that I have probably been in all four
positions, that of boyfriend being cheated on, on-looking best friend of
boyfriend, cheating boyfriend, and of the boy making out with the girlfriend
of the boyfriend who happens to be the on-looking friend?s best friend.
Therefore, I must have firsthand and pretty excellent knowledge to clearly
assess and resolve the situation at hand, right? Wrong. It is quite a bit more
complicated than that. What will your best friend think of you after telling
him the horrible news? Will he not like you anymore? Should you just mind
your own business and not tell him at all? It can be dealt with by any number
of means. The innumerable amount of choices or avenues to be taken, make
the final decision hard to determine. Immanuel Kant would argue that we
must tell our friend the truth because it is our moral duty, while Bernard
Williams would have us consider how we would view ourselves before or
after we spilled the beans. Still another, John M. Taurek, would have us
consider the consequences to the parties involved if the truth was known.
Theorists and philosophers such as these have argued for centuries about
what would be the appropriate choice given situations like this.
Immanuel Kant would have me tell my friend about his girlfriend
fooling around behind his back. He believed that any action (my telling him
the truth) must come from a sense of duty and that duty is a moral necessity.
Categorical imperatives are moral requirements which are unquestionable in
terms of commanding what a person must do. The categorical imperative is
thought to be the rational action. Kant believes there is a connection between
what is moral and what is rational. This is because he believes that a moral
action must be based on good reasoning. For instance, it is the morally
correct thing to do to tell the truth because there are negative repercussions
that result from lying. Furthermore, Kant believes that a categorical
imperative must apply in all situations and for all people; to be universal or
have a universal moral law. He thinks that it is the rational thing to have
consistency in morals. So in the end I tell my friend what I saw. I do this
because it is my duty to do the right thing and to tell the truth.
?There are many people we are not in a position to help at all? (Doing
and Being, 51). This is how I feel in answering this question. There is not
one brilliant answer to this situation. John M. Taurek offers this solution to
the problem of the cheating girlfriend. He focuses on whether or not the
number of people affected counts as something to consider when presented
with a dilemma. He also states in the life-saving drug example that ?I will
save my friend.? and it is not morally wrong to do that. Taurek objects to the
utilitarian thought that treats people as objects. He instead considers his
friendship and personal feelings when assessing a situation because he does
not believe that people have ?objective value?. This leads me to believe that
he would tell his friend about his unfaithful girlfriend because he respects his
friends feelings and does not want to see him hurt any further.
It is also important to consider what kind of person I would be and
what kind of morals I would want to hold as my own if I did or did not tell
my friend of his cheating girlfriend. Bernard Williams bases his belief in
moral integrity. Take for example the case of George the biochemist. If he
takes the job in the chemical weapons factory, he is violating his own morals.
If he turns the job down then he is putting his family deeper and deeper in
debt. He thinks that it is important that a person feel harmony between the
action he is doing and the result of it. When I choose to tell or not to tell my
best friend about his cheating girlfriend, I am making a choice as to what kind
of person that I am morally. The choice that I make will inevitably say what
kind of person I am, whether I care about friends and family or whether I
choose to sit back and see them suffer.
Ultimately, I believe that I do have an obligation to let my friend know
that his girlfriend was fooling around on him behind his back, but I do not
think that I would be able to tell him face to face. If I could let him know
what was up by some sort of indirect means, then it would be much better and
to my benefit because I would not be the one to upset him. My friend could
not be mad at me for breaking his heart and his girlfriend could not hold me
responsible for their impending fight and breakup.
333
Другие работы по теме:
On The Bench Essay Research Paper In
?On The Bench? Essay, Research Paper In his essay, ?On The Bench?, Robert Parker shows the trials and tribulations of trying to be both mentally and physically strong. He writes about how horrible it is being thin and weak, and having to hold on to his wife?s arm when it is windy out. I hope that this essay was intended to be humorous, because it did in fact make me laugh.
Moby Dick Essay Essay Research Paper Moby
Moby Dick Essay Essay, Research Paper Moby Dick Essay Throughout time, people have associated their problems with with something bad that happened to them. That thing became the center of their problems by causing a lot of suffering to that person. In Moby Dick, Melville has many interpretations of what the white whale symbolizes.
Reasons For Undertaking A Project On Land
Essay, Research Paper The reason that I decided to undertake this particular project was that I live on a farm and with doing so I had a rather broad spectrum of things I could do on the land, but nothing else interested me as
Romeo An Juliet Essay Research Paper hi
Romeo An Juliet Essay, Research Paper hi i need an essay about a character in romeo and juliet that demonsrtated maturity. in a well developed multi pagraph essay and say why you think the character’s maturity was greater than the other characters in the play.
The Death Penalty 11 Essay Research Paper
The Penalty of Death In this essay, H.L. Mencken has two arguments that stand out in the beginning of this essay. These arguments are against the penalty of death, although his essay is in a way, for it. The first one is, That hanging a man (or frying him or gassing him) is a dreadful business, degrading to those who have to do it and revolting to those who have to witness it . (Mencken 455).
April Morning Essay Essay Research Paper I
April Morning Essay Essay, Research Paper I think that some of the reasoning behind Moses Cooper letting Adam fight in the war was that Adam was no longer a small child like his brother
Oh Really Essay Research Paper Oh Reallyyou
Oh Really? Essay, Research Paper Oh Really, you think i am a lark, the dogs they run and bark, but when i say to them, shut up shut up shut up, you say to be nice to them,
ROTC Entrence Essay Essay Research Paper entrance
ROTC Entrence Essay Essay, Research Paper entrance essay For almost as long as I cn remember, I have been interested in th military. Influenced by such movies as “Patton”, and by my dad’s interest in military history, my
Seregas Essay Essay Research Paper The life
Seregas Essay Essay, Research Paper The life stories of many today s New Yorkers are amazingly similar and different at the same time. For those of us who can call New York our new home, the choice to move to this city has certainly been one of the most important decisions of our lives. Whether or not we came from fifty or five thousand miles away, the hopes for success and brighter future were the sources of our motivation.
Shane Essay Research Paper Sometimes I need
Shane Essay, Research Paper Sometimes, I need you more than I need air And sometimes I miss you more than I will forever, never forget the times that we have shaared. The are priceless
Poem Belong Essay Research Paper Where I
Poem: Belong Essay, Research Paper Where I belong I am weak, I am strong I will fit where I belong don’t know where it is for now but it will come, if I allow tomorrow, I start a brand new day
Comparitive Essay Essay Research Paper There are
Comparitive Essay Essay, Research Paper There are many stories of survival. When I think of survival I think of two things, The movie, Never Cry Wolf, and the story, When the Legends Die. These two are stories of men who survived in the wild after many obtacles. They were both very different but they were still the same.
Essay Writing Essay Research Paper email 7cdgqlinkqueensucaEssay
Essay Writing Essay, Research Paper email: 7cdg@qlink.queensu.caEssay Writing An essay is a literary composition. The purpose of a good formal essay is to try out an idea, thesis, or opinion, within the confines of a proper literary composition. To do this successfully one must know their topic, formulate a thesis, and finally write the essay.
Enfluening OF Music Essay Research Paper This
Enfluening OF Music Essay, Research Paper This Essay is about how music can influence the emotions and effects of a person. I will be giving you precentages. I will also be giving you quotes of students
Poem She Sat Essay Research Paper She
Poem: She Sat Essay, Research Paper She sat… helpless in her room praying to whatever god there may be to let her call to him. could god ignore such a painful cry?
An Example Of Good Writing Zinsser
’s “Simplicity” Essay, Research Paper An Example Of Good Writing: Zinsser’s “Simplicity” Zinsser’s essay on Simplicity is an example of good writing for many
Comparison Essay Of Isadora And Art And
Isadora Essay, Research Paper Isadora Duncan It is always amazing to see how two different writers can use different techniques and writing styles to write about the same subject. Janet Flanner and John Dos Passo both
Miller Spring Essay Essay Research Paper Miller
Miller Spring Essay Essay, Research Paper Miller Springs Essay My science class and I went to Miller Springs to learn about sediments and nature a few days ago. The good and bad sides of the trip I will explain below.
Writing Techniques Essay Research Paper Writing TechniquesAfter
Writing Techniques Essay, Research Paper Writing Techniques After reading Katha Pollitt?s essay ?It Takes Two: A Modest Proposal for Holding Fathers Equally Accountable? and Patricia Mainardi?s essay ?The Politics of Housework?, several writing techniques become apparent in both essays.
Ode To Boys Essay Research Paper We
Ode To Boys Essay, Research Paper We like them But do they like us The ones we do never fuss They don’t stop in And we wonder why We stress, we bitch We sometimes cry
Persuasive Essay Essay Research Paper Persuasive Essay
Persuasive Essay Essay, Research Paper Persuasive Essay Driving is a tremendous responsibility. I believe our state should have rigorous driving tests to make the roads safe for others. However I think most teenagers aren’t ready to accept
The Process Of An Essay Essay Research
Paper Do you know how to write an essay? Writing an essay could be easy or hard. Some students cannot do it well and that is why they hate it. You can find the writing as something interesting and important for your own future. If you do not know how to write an essay, there are several steps that you can follow. There are three basic steps to write an essay; discovering a topic, supporting the thesis, and editing the essay.
Lincoln Application Essay Essay Research Paper Now
Lincoln Application Essay Essay, Research Paper Now is a time to make decision in life that will help me succeed in the future. The decision is to choose the right high school that will help me meet my goals and prepare me for college. A school that can train and give me all the tools I need to be an international business.
Dare Essay Essay Research Paper What DARE
Dare Essay Essay, Research Paper What D.A.R.E Means To Me Dare has prepared me to say no to drugs in eight different ways. If anyone asks me to do drugs I will know what to do, such as- just ignoring the person or just
Great Gatsby Essay Essay Research Paper The
Great Gatsby Essay Essay, Research Paper The Great Gatsby Essay In The Great Gatsby, there are three illicit relationships: Gatsby and Daisy, Nick and Jordan, and Tom and Myrtle. In some ways they are similar, and in some ways each is unique. In this essay, I will compare and examine each of the couples, and try to give some insight as to why none of the relationships worked out.
ProblemSolution Essay Essay Research Paper Have you
Problem-Solution Essay Essay, Research Paper Have you ever received a problem-solution essay where you cannot think of anything to write? Although many of the forty million students in America go through this at one time or another, don?t despair! There are several systematic ways to find a writing topic.
Gun Control Essay Research Paper Gun EssayShould
Gun Control Essay, Research Paper Gun Essay Should we really just keep adding gun control laws? Well, I don’t think so. I think that Senator Larry E. Craig said it best “the criminal that wasn’t stopped by 20,000 laws won’t stop at 20,001.“ My viewpoint is that we should have better law enforcemnt.
How To Writing A Research Essay Essay
, Research Paper How To Writing A Research Essay The toughest part of the essay, for me, was taking all the information I had gained and reduce it to a mere few pages essay. After all, quality is better