Microsoft Antitrust Case Essay, Research Paper
Microsoft Antitrust Case
Since 1998, the Microsoft Corporation has been struggling with an antitrust case against the United States Justice Department. They are being charged with violating aspects of the Sherman Act. This act prohibits companies from using their size and power as a monopoly to expand their positions and take hold of new markets. It is not illegal for a company to be a monopoly, but it is illegal for the company to use their size as an advantage over other companies (Lohr article 1). I believe that the Microsoft Corporation is in violation of the Sherman Act and the United States government should take actions against the company to monitor their business transactions and prevent this from happening again. There are many examples of how the Microsoft Corporation used their size as an advantage over other companies to gain advantages in the software and computer market.
Compaq is one of the largest computer producers in the country. They are the largest customers of the Microsoft Corporation. They buy most of their software from them to load on their computers for sale. Compaq considered loading the Netscape Navigator program as default instead of the Microsoft Internet Explorer. Netscape is Microsoft’s main competition in the internet browser market. When Microsoft found out about this decision, they threatened to stop selling the Windows program to Compaq (Lohr and Markoff). Windows is the most popular program on the market, and it controls at least eighty-five percent of the computers. If Compaq were not able to sell their computers with the Windows program, their sales would plummet. Their product would not be as attractive to consumers without the program because of its popularity. This is an example of Microsoft using their power as a monopoly to control other companies. According to the Sherman Act, a company cannot use their size as an advantage over other companies when it comes to promoting their product in a new market. Compaq new that if they sold their computers without the Windows program, their company would suffer, so they decided to use Microsoft’s Internet Explorer instead (Lohr and Markoff).
Microsoft supplies many computer companies with the programs that are needed to run their products. They also design programs for the Apple computer company, because their computers need a type of software different from other computer companies. Microsoft designs a word processing program specifically for Apple (Brinkley article 1). They threatened to stop making this program for Apple if they did not use their Internet Explorer program as the default on their products. Microsoft also threatened to stop selling the Office programs to them if they did not use their internet browser on their computers. Microsoft Office is equivalent to the Windows program in the business software market. This program has about ninety percent of the sales for office software (Brinkley article 1). If the Apple corporation could not offer the Microsoft Office program on their computers, their sales would suffer. This situation is similar to the Compaq situation because Microsoft is using their power as a monopoly to control the internet browser market. Companies are not allowed to use their size and power to promote their products in new markets. This is exactly what the Microsoft Corporation is doing in each of these situations. They are in violation of the Sherman Act, and there should be actions taken against them to prevent this from happening again (Brinkley article 1). Apple was forced to make Microsoft’s internet browser the default on their machines out of fear of losing the programs that they obviously needed to sell their products. Companies should be able to make decisions about their products without having to worry about other companies intimidating them with threats.
A controversy has arisen over Microsoft’s Windows 98 program. Its release was delayed because the Microsoft Corporation wanted to include the Internet Explorer program as a feature. This delay has been a topic of discussion in the court case. The U.S. Justice Department says that Internet Explorer and Windows 98 are two separate programs and that Microsoft bundled them together to gain an advantage over their main competitor, Netscape. Microsoft says that the Internet Explorer program is only a feature of Windows 98, and that the two are not separate programs (Lohr article 2). By the two programs being put together, consumers are now not required to buy a separate internet browser. In January of 1997, an email exchange between two Microsoft executives suggests that the browser and the operating system were two separate programs, and the company did not consider them one product. The email talked about how they should use Windows to promote their product because it was the only thing that Netscape did not have (Lohr article 2). It is illegal for a company to force a second product on a customer by tying it in with another market leading product (Lohr article 3). Microsoft is using their stronghold on the software market to impose their internet browser on its customers. By doing this, they are eliminating any competition in the internet browser market. About eighty-five percent of computers are run by Windows, and by bulking it with an internet browser, they are eliminating any need for another internet browser (Lohr article 2). If they eliminate any competition in the software market, they may also prohibit any advances in new technology. There are always new advances in software and computer technology, and Microsoft may be eliminating that possibility if they continue with their current practices.
Microsoft is accused of making an illegal offer to their main competition in the internet browser market, Netscape. Their offer was an attempt to divide the internet browser market. Microsoft offered Netscape information that would help them design a program that would run as smoothly as possible with the Windows program. In return for the information, Microsoft would invest in Netscape and take fifteen to twenty percent (Lohr and Markoff). Microsoft would also receive a spot on Netscape’s board of directors and licensing privileges to licensing their new technology. All hardware and software must run smoothly with Windows because of its popularity in the market. The information that Microsoft supposedly offered Netscape would have been very useful to their software design. Netscape declined the offer from Microsoft. Microsoft denies claims that their objective was to stop Netscape from competing with them in the internet browser market (Lohr and Markoff). The justice department has a sworn testimony from Chris Jones, a Microsoft manager, admitting that Microsoft’s intentions were to persuade Netscape from competing. Microsoft claims that Jones’s testimony explains how they wanted to become partners with Netscape. They say that they wanted to divide the applications and design of the programs between the two companies, so the two could work together in the industry (Lohr and Markoff). If it is concluded that Microsoft’s offer was illegal, they are in violation of the Sherman Act. These are each examples of how Microsoft used their power as a monopoly to expand their position. A neutral forty-eight page paper was written to describe some of the allegations against Microsoft as well as some information in their defense (Lohr article 3).
Chris Hall, an independent software developer, wrote the paper. He explains how there are holes in the allegations against Microsoft. He says that the government witnesses who say Windows and Internet Explorer are two separate programs have little merit (Lohr article 4). Hall also talks about the low price of the Windows program. He says that the low price does not reflect that of a monopoly abusing its power. The cost of the program only accounts for about five percent of the total cost of the computer. Microsoft says the low price of Windows is due to competitive threats of competition (Lohr article 4). They say that any other computer software company could come out with a program that competes with Windows. An executive from Compaq is testifying in Microsoft’s defense to state the possibility of another program to arise to compete with Windows (Lohr article 4). Although these examples of defense are valid, the examples against Microsoft far outweigh them.
The trial is still pending. If Microsoft is found guilty of violating the Sherman Act, it will be very difficult to decide what actions to take against the company. The justice department is soliciting ideas from outside sources for suggestions on a remedy to the situation. They have been asking antitrust experts on their opinions of the case. Timothy F. Bresnahan, an economics professor from Stanford University, has taken a leave from his job to help the Justice Department devise a proposal for a remedy (Brinkley article 2). Government witness, William H. Harris’s remedy proposal suggests breaking the Microsoft Corporation into separate companies. His proposal also calls for government regulation on the industry (Brinkley article 3). There are many possible remedies that can be taken to handle the case, and it may take a long time for the judicial system to come to an agreement.
Microsoft has made many poor business decisions and abused their status as a monopoly. They clearly used unfair business practices that prohibited other companies from expanding and competing. There are far more valid examples of Microsoft’s unjust business practices exemplifying their abuse of power. The judicial system should take actions against Microsoft by monitoring their business practices closely to prevent them from abusing their power.
Brinkley, Joel. “Microsoft Defends Tactics In 1997 Talks With Apple.” New York
Times 5 Nov. 1998: C2.
Brinkley, Joel. “U.S. and State Officials Weigh Microsoft Remedies.” New York Times
16 Nov. 1999: C1.
Brinkley, Joel. “Intuit’s Chief Urges Division of Microsoft.” New York Times 5 Jan.
1999: C2.
Lohr, Steve. “Gates. On Capitol Hill, Presents Case for an Unfettered Microsoft.” New
York Times 4 March 1998: A1.
Lohr, Steve. “Browser Memos Pose Challenge To Microsoft.” New York Times 5 Nov.
1998: C1.
Lohr, Steve. “Filing Offers a Way to find Microsoft Violated the Law.” New York
Times 2 Feb 2000: C8.
Lohr, Steve. “Business; Playing ‘The Price is Right’ With Windows.” New York Times
3 Jan. 1999: Sec. 3 pg. 4.
Lohr, Steve and Markoff, John. “Microsoft’s World: A Special Report.” New York
Times 8 Oct. 1998: A1.
Другие работы по теме:
Microsoft A Monopoly Essay Research Paper Microsoft
Microsoft A Monopoly Essay, Research Paper Microsoft a Monopoly? The potential breakup of the Microsoft Corporation is presently one of the most consuming issues in our society. The government has declared Microsoft a monopoly, and could possibly be broken up into three pieces. This has come as a shock to most everyone, because ?Microsoft Windows? is usually the first thing that pops up on almost everyone?s computer when you first turn it on.
Microsoft X Essay Research Paper Microsoft XBoxThe
Microsoft X Essay, Research Paper Microsoft X-Box The Microsoft Corporation has changed the way we look at computers, but can they change anything else? Of course they can. Microsoft has expanded into the gaming world outside of the PC. They are now in competition with Nintendo, Sega, and other major gaming corporations.
Microsoft Essay Research Paper Microsoft has had
Microsoft Essay, Research Paper Microsoft has had a couple of though months since July last year, when Judge Thomas Jackson ordered the company to break up in two. However, since the beginning of this year things have just looked better for Microsoft.
The Microsoft Antitrust Case Essay Research Paper
The Microsoft Antitrust Case The case against Microsoft was brought buy the U.S. Department of Justice, as well as several state Attorneys General. Microsoft is accused of using and maintaining monopoly power to gain an unfair advantage in the market. The case has been under observation for a long time, but the Justice department is having trouble coming up with substantial evidence against Microsoft.
Microsoft Essay Research Paper In the early
Microsoft Essay, Research Paper In the early 80s the world so the initial boom of the computer era. The first personal computers were sold and the main players of the business were sorted
Microsoft Report Essay Research Paper Park Place
Microsoft Report Essay, Research Paper Park Place, Boardwalk, Next Stop Microsoft? In the 1920’s and 30’s, Standard Oil became one of the most controlling companies America had ever seen. Under the watchful eye of John Rockefeller, Standard Oil methodically phased out any and all competition. Back then, the government realized what was happening and put into effect the anti-trust law.
Loophole Or A Conspiracy Essay Research Paper
Loophole Or A Conspiracy? Virus, Hmmm I am sure that you have heard this word before. I am not talking about the living virus like an influenza virus. I am talking about the computer virus. According to the New York Times, Microsoft, Compaq, and Hewlett Packards computers are at a great risk. I wonder why we the consumer, are in this position? I cannot come up with one straight answer.
Microsoft Essay Research Paper By running the
Microsoft Essay, Research Paper By running the Internet Microsoft could set up any programs that they wanted to. Also the software buyer would have to sue it because his system (computer) would only be
The Computer Age Essay Research Paper Ben
The Computer Age Essay, Research Paper Ben Purdue 8/24/01 It is my prediction that the biggest issue we will face in the coming century not only as a nation but also as a planet is finding a blind between security of protected information and freedom of information. I say this because as a computer security consultant I understand the need for security of important information, however I as a programmer I understand such issues as the battle for open source code and freedom of information as a hole.
Spread Of Computers Essay Research Paper Let
Spread Of Computers Essay, Research Paper Let’s face it, in today’s world we are using computers more and more. The growth of accessibility to the Internet has given us a brand new definition to
MicrisoftA Modern Monopoly Essay Research Paper Many
Micrisoft-A Modern Monopoly Essay, Research Paper Many have asked the question of whether Microsoft has turned into a monopoly of the high technology and software industry. This question is an easy one to answer, yes it is. Over the years, Microsoft has used its wealth and influence over the software industry to pull away from the competition by threatening competitors of withdrawing contracts and software deals.
Comparing Operating Systems Essay Research Paper Comparing
Comparing Operating Systems Essay, Research Paper Comparing Microsoft Operating Systems : 95/98/NT This report is centered on the similarities and differences of the three major operating systems provided by Microsoft during the previous decade. There were and will always be changes and upgrades some of the information may not be current, as these systems have had certain upgrade modules that may not covered.
Neuromancer Essay Research Paper The case against
Neuromancer Essay, Research Paper The case against Microsoft is based not just on bad economics, but on a fundamental misunderstanding of government’s decision-making role when it comes to market operations. This misunderstanding has led to an attack on one of the US?s most successful firms.
Antitrust Act Essay Research Paper Antitrust Acts
Antitrust Act Essay, Research Paper Anti-trust Acts in the Information Age As many people have noticed, recently there has been a huge focus in the media on Bill Gates, and his huge Microsoft Corporation. This past Friday, May 22, 1998, a federal judge combined two lawsuits and set a trial date for September 8, 1998.
Database Design Essay Research Paper Before you
Database Design Essay, Research Paper Before you use Microsoft Access to actually build the tables, forms, and other objects that will make up your database, it is important to take time to design your database. A good database design is the keystone to creating a database that foes what you want it to do effectively, accurately, and efficiently.
Microsoft Essay Research Paper
- Legal_Issues – Microsoft and mediation negotiations - Microsoft and mediation negotiations By: Steve Since its antitrust trial began in 1998, the software giant
William Wordsworth Essay Research Paper Wordsworths Way
William Wordsworth Essay, Research Paper Wordsworth?s Way of Explaining His Past ?William Wordsworth, English poet, one of the post accomplished and influential of England?s romantic poets, whose theories and style created a new tradition in poetry ? ( Microsoft Encarta 1). Wordsworth began writing poetry when he was still in school, but it wasn?t until 1793 that any of his poems were published. ?Wordsworth?s political and intellectual sympathies underwent a transformation after 1800.
Keats Essay Research Paper John Keats John
Keats Essay, Research Paper John Keats John Keats is one of the finest poets ever to write inEnglish. By the time of his death at the age of 25, he hadaccomplished more than all but the finest writers haveachieved in a full lifetime.”Endymion”, the poem was thefirst major work he undertook.(Microsoft) Keats was born to a family of humble means, the eldestof four children.
The Microsoft Antitrust Law Suit Essay Research
Paper Recently one of the biggest corporations in the United States, Microsoft had to face several ultimatums from the government. The case against Microsoft was brought by the U.S. Department of Justice, as well as several state Attorneys General. Microsoft is accused of using and maintaining monopoly power to gain an unfair advantage in software market.
Microsoft Antitrust Court Case Essay Research Paper
As this paper is written there is a landmark court case proceeding in Washington in front of a federal judge. This case involves the charging of the Microsoft Corporation for violating antitrust laws set up by the government to preserve market competition. A general overview of the accusations brought against Microsoft by the Justice Department was given by Hayes in the Scholastic Update article The U.S. versus Microsoft (1999).
Microsoft As A Monopoly Essay Research Paper
My position today is proving to you, Your Honor, that Microsoft has used monopolistic practices and market power to foster a non-competitive climate. According to Webster, a monopoly is the exclusive control of a commodity or service in a given market.
Microsoft Antitrust Paper Essay Research Paper Viewed
Microsoft Antitrust Paper Essay, Research Paper Viewed together, three main facts indicate that Microsoft enjoys monopoly power. First, Microsoft’s share of the market for Intel-compatible Personal Computer (PC) operating systems is extremely large and stable. Second, Microsoft’s dominant market share is protected by a high barrier to entry.
Microsoft Essay Research Paper Microsoft the world
Microsoft Essay, Research Paper Microsoft, the world’s largest company by market value, is accused of acting monopolistic in the computer software industry. Microsoft provides for eighty percent of the computers used, operating system. The operating system is a basic program that loads or boots up your computer to make it perform.
Microsoft Monopoly Essay Research Paper By now
Microsoft Monopoly Essay, Research Paper By now everyone is familiar with the case U.S. vs. Microsoft. What is all this about? According to my two articles, Microsoft, the world’s leading software company, is being sued by the Justice Department joined by 19 states.
Bill Gates Essay Research Paper Bill GatesThe
Bill Gates Essay, Research Paper Bill Gates The Chairman and Chief Software Architect of Microsoft William Gates III was born in October 28, 1955. He lived in Seattle with his father who is a Seattle attorney, his mother who was a chairwoman of United Way International, and his two sisters.
Microsoft Essay Research Paper Wednesday many government
Microsoft Essay, Research Paper Wednesday, many government sources confirmed that Justice Department lawyers have proposed splitting Microsoft Corp. as a remedy for the company’s allegedly anti-competitive behavior. The proposal was discussed over the weekend at a secret meeting of officials from the U.S. government and 19 states that have sued Microsoft.
Microsoft Antitrust Editorial Essay Research Paper Microsoft
Microsoft Antitrust Editorial Essay, Research Paper Microsoft: The Big Bully Stealing Your Lunch Money A monopoly, by definition, is a business or group that engages in unfair and often unethical business practices to control an industry and eliminate all competition that might lessen their profits.
Microsoft Anti Trust Case Essay Research Paper
Microsoft Anti-Trust Case In 1890, Congress passed the Sherman Anti-Trust Act. Since then there has been very few companies that have violated this act. In 1911 it was used it to break J.D.
Microsoft The Company Essay Research Paper Microsoft
Microsoft The Company Essay, Research Paper Microsoft: THE COMPANY The thought of forming a company which supplies its customers with software, was a great idea–especially coming from a college dropout. Bill Gates, along with high-school friend Paul Allen, formed a software company in 1975. From the beginning, Microsoft had a tremendous potential to become a very successful corporation.
Cold Fusion Essay Research Paper Allaire
Cold Fusion Essay, Research Paper Allaire’s ColdFusion studio and server package allows web developers to create database driven applications. ColdFusion is server side scripting that utilizes Microsoft ODBC drivers to access system databases. This allows ColdFusion to produce dynamic pages generated real time by the server.
MS Power Point Essay Research Paper Reflection
MS Power Point Essay, Research Paper Reflection on MS Power Point The Microsoft Power Point presentation that we just completed was a fun project. I learned how to set up Power Point slides while infiltrating animation and sound.
Grand Canyon Essay Research Paper Grand Canyon
Grand Canyon Essay, Research Paper Grand Canyon National Park Grand Canyon National Park was established in 1919. Located in northern Arizona, the park contains the world-famous Grand Canyon of the Colorado River and includes the river?s entire course from the southern end of Glen Canyon to the eastern boundary of Lake Mead (Microsoft Encarta Encyclopedia).