Microsoft Antitrust Paper Essay, Research Paper
Viewed together, three main facts indicate that Microsoft enjoys monopoly power. First, Microsoft’s share of the market for Intel-compatible Personal Computer (PC) operating systems is extremely large and stable. Second, Microsoft’s dominant market share is protected by a high barrier to entry. Third, and largely as a result of that barrier, Microsoft’s customers lack a commercially viable alternative to Windows, the operating system of all PC’s.
Microsoft enjoys so much power in the market for Intel-compatible PC operating systems that if it wished to exercise this power solely in terms of price, it could charge a price for Windows substantially above that which could be charged in a competitive market. Moreover, it could do so for a significant period of time without losing an unacceptable amount of business to competitors. In other words, Microsoft enjoys monopoly power in the relevant market.
Microsoft possesses a dominant, persistent, and increasing share of the world-wide market for Intel-compatible PC operating systems. Every year for the last decade, Microsoft’s share of the market for Intel-compatible PC operating systems has stood above ninety percent. For the last couple of years the figure has been at least ninety-five percent, and analysts project that the share will climb even higher over the next few years. Even if Apple’s Mac OS were included in the relevant market, Microsoft’s share would still stand well above eighty percent.
Microsoft’s dominant market share is protected by the same barrier that helps define the market for Intel-compatible PC operating systems. As explained above, the applications barrier would prevent an aspiring entrant into the relevant market from drawing a significant number of customers away from a dominant
- 1 -
incumbent even if the incumbent priced its products substantially above competitive levels for a significant period of time. Because Microsoft’s market share is so dominant, the barrier has a similar effect within the market: It prevents Intel-compatible PC operating systems other than Windows from attracting significant consumer demand, and it would continue to do so even if Microsoft held its prices substantially above the competitive level.
Microsoft’s actual pricing behavior is consistent with the proposition that the firm enjoys monopoly power in the market for Intel-compatible PC operating systems. The company’s decision not to consider the prices of other vendors’ Intel-compatible PC operating systems when setting the price of Windows 98, for example, is probative of monopoly power. One would expect a firm in a competitive market to pay much closer attention to the prices charged by other firms in the market. Another indication of monopoly power is the fact that Microsoft raised the price that it charged Original Equipment Manufacturer’s (OEM’s) for Windows 95, with trivial exceptions, to the same level as the price it charged for Windows 98 just prior to releasing the newer product. In a competitive market, one would expect the price of an older operating system to stay the same or decrease upon the release of a newer, more attractive version. Microsoft, however, was only concerned with inducing OEMs to ship Windows 98 in favor of the older version. It is unlikely that Microsoft would have imposed this price increase if it were genuinely concerned that OEMs might shift their business to another vendor of operating systems or hasten the development of viable alternatives to Windows.
Finally, it is indicative of monopoly power that Microsoft felt that it had substantial discretion in setting the price of its Windows 98 upgrade product (the operating system product it
- 2 -
sells to existing users of Windows 95). A Microsoft study from November 1997 reveals that the company could have charged $49 for an upgrade to Windows 98 — there is no reason to believe that the $49 price would have been unprofitable — but the study identifies $89 as the revenue-maximizing price. Microsoft thus opted for the higher price.
Microsoft’s first response to the threat posed by Netscape Navigator was an effort to persuade Netscape to structure its business such that the company would not distribute platform-level browsing software for Windows. Netscape’s assent would have ensured that, for the foreseeable future, Microsoft would produce the only platform-level browsing software distributed to run on Windows, Internet Explorer. This would have eliminated the prospect that non-Microsoft browsing software could weaken the applications barrier to entry. Executives at Microsoft received confirmation in early May 1995 that Netscape was developing a version of Navigator to run on Windows 95, which was due to be released in a couple of months. Microsoft’s senior executives understood that if they could prevent this version of Navigator from presenting alternatives, the technologies branded as Navigator would cease to present an alternative platform to developers. Even if non-Windows versions of Navigator exposed Internet-related Application Programming Interfaces (APIs), applications written to those APIs would not run on the platform Microsoft executives expected to enjoy the largest installed base, i.e., Windows 95. So, as long as the version of Navigator written for Windows 95 relied on Microsoft’s Internet-related APIs instead of exposing its own, developing for Navigator would not mean developing cross-platform. Developers of network-centric applications thus would not be drawn to Navigator’s APIs in
- 3 -
substantial numbers. Therefore, with the encouragement and support of Gates, a group of Microsoft executives commenced a campaign in the summer of 1995 to convince Netscape to halt its development of platform-level browsing technologies for Windows 95.
Most harmful of all is the message that Microsoft’s actions have conveyed to every enterprise with the potential to innovate in the computer industry. Through its conduct toward Netscape, IBM, Compaq, Intel, and others, Microsoft has demonstrated that it will use its prodigious market power and immense profits to harm any firm that insists on pursuing initiatives that could intensify competition against one of Microsoft’s core products. Microsoft’s past success in hurting such companies and stifling innovation deters investment in technologies and businesses that exhibit the potential to threaten Microsoft. The ultimate result is that some innovations that would truly benefit consumers never occur for the sole reason that they do not coincide with Microsoft’s self-interest.
- 4 -
Bibliography
New York Times:
"How Microsoft Sought Friends In Washington." 7 November 1999: A33
"Microsoft’s Horizon." 7 November 1999: A33A
"A Breakup Of Microsoft? Possibly, but Investors Shrug It Off." 9 November 1999: C1-C16
"Prosecutors Seeking To Break The Grip Of Windows System." 10 November 1999: A1-C30
"Microsoft Faces A Class Action On ‘Monopoly.’" 22 November 1999: A1-A16
USA Today:
"Conservative judge at helm of Microsoft talks." 22 November 1999: B1-B2
"Microsoft findings spur lawsuit findings." 23 November 1999: B2
The Wall Street Journal:
"Microsoft Hopes for GOP Savior, but States Are Problem." 9 November 1999: A28
Financial Times:
"Experts say Microsoft case will drag on." 9 November 1999: 11
- 5 -
Другие работы по теме:
Microsoft A Monopoly Essay Research Paper Microsoft
Microsoft A Monopoly Essay, Research Paper Microsoft a Monopoly? The potential breakup of the Microsoft Corporation is presently one of the most consuming issues in our society. The government has declared Microsoft a monopoly, and could possibly be broken up into three pieces. This has come as a shock to most everyone, because ?Microsoft Windows? is usually the first thing that pops up on almost everyone?s computer when you first turn it on.
Microsoft X Essay Research Paper Microsoft XBoxThe
Microsoft X Essay, Research Paper Microsoft X-Box The Microsoft Corporation has changed the way we look at computers, but can they change anything else? Of course they can. Microsoft has expanded into the gaming world outside of the PC. They are now in competition with Nintendo, Sega, and other major gaming corporations.
Microsoft Essay Research Paper Microsoft has had
Microsoft Essay, Research Paper Microsoft has had a couple of though months since July last year, when Judge Thomas Jackson ordered the company to break up in two. However, since the beginning of this year things have just looked better for Microsoft.
The Microsoft Antitrust Case Essay Research Paper
The Microsoft Antitrust Case The case against Microsoft was brought buy the U.S. Department of Justice, as well as several state Attorneys General. Microsoft is accused of using and maintaining monopoly power to gain an unfair advantage in the market. The case has been under observation for a long time, but the Justice department is having trouble coming up with substantial evidence against Microsoft.
Canadians And Americans Essay Research Paper Canadians
Canadians And Americans Essay, Research Paper Canadians and Americans There is much that has distinguished the Canadian experience as different from thatwhich has, and continues to, define the American experience. At first glance, superficiallyCanada and the United States share many aspects in common, for as one comedian oncestated “Canadians are just unarmed Americans with health care”, and for the most part,this is the common belief, as viewed by other nations in this world.
Microsoft Essay Research Paper By running the
Microsoft Essay, Research Paper By running the Internet Microsoft could set up any programs that they wanted to. Also the software buyer would have to sue it because his system (computer) would only be
Oh Really Essay Research Paper Oh Reallyyou
Oh Really? Essay, Research Paper Oh Really, you think i am a lark, the dogs they run and bark, but when i say to them, shut up shut up shut up, you say to be nice to them,
Greeks Essay Research Paper Our culture is
Greeks Essay, Research Paper Our culture is ruled by social norms. In America it is expected that we abide by these unwritten laws. Whether viewed by a small group of people or society as a whole, breaking such guidelines could have devastating effects. I choose to do my experiment with the least intimate group of people; total strangers.
My Trip Essay Research Paper The role
My Trip Essay, Research Paper The role of the visit to Pemberley by Elizabeth and the Gardiners would most closely resemble a modern visit to a museum or a tourist attraction.
Another Computer Essay Essay Research Paper The
Another Computer Essay Essay, Research Paper The Computer Underground. The beginning of the electronic communication revolution that started with the public use of telephones to the emergence
Neuromancer Essay Research Paper The case against
Neuromancer Essay, Research Paper The case against Microsoft is based not just on bad economics, but on a fundamental misunderstanding of government’s decision-making role when it comes to market operations. This misunderstanding has led to an attack on one of the US?s most successful firms.
Antitrust Act Essay Research Paper Antitrust Acts
Antitrust Act Essay, Research Paper Anti-trust Acts in the Information Age As many people have noticed, recently there has been a huge focus in the media on Bill Gates, and his huge Microsoft Corporation. This past Friday, May 22, 1998, a federal judge combined two lawsuits and set a trial date for September 8, 1998.
Database Design Essay Research Paper Before you
Database Design Essay, Research Paper Before you use Microsoft Access to actually build the tables, forms, and other objects that will make up your database, it is important to take time to design your database. A good database design is the keystone to creating a database that foes what you want it to do effectively, accurately, and efficiently.
Deviance Essay Research Paper Theories of Deviant
Deviance Essay, Research Paper Theories of Deviant Behavior examines various theories and perspectives on conforming and deviant behavior which are products of Western scholarly thought: anomie, functionalism, social disorganization, social conflict, social control, psychoanalysis, status politics, differential association, labeling theory, etc.
Child Development Essay Research Paper In a
Child Development Essay, Research Paper In a typical four year old child, many social developments can be viewed. Four year old children are more independent of adults, but yet they seem to want attention from them, as well as peers. They begin to ask permission and they find that the like to have an adult nearby.
An Inspector Calls Has Been Described At
Different Times As A Sermon And A Lesson In Civics . How Far Can The Play Be Viewed Simply As A Vehicle For Priestley S Moral And Political Views? Essay, Research Paper
William Wordsworth Essay Research Paper Wordsworths Way
William Wordsworth Essay, Research Paper Wordsworth?s Way of Explaining His Past ?William Wordsworth, English poet, one of the post accomplished and influential of England?s romantic poets, whose theories and style created a new tradition in poetry ? ( Microsoft Encarta 1). Wordsworth began writing poetry when he was still in school, but it wasn?t until 1793 that any of his poems were published. ?Wordsworth?s political and intellectual sympathies underwent a transformation after 1800.
Keats Essay Research Paper John Keats John
Keats Essay, Research Paper John Keats John Keats is one of the finest poets ever to write inEnglish. By the time of his death at the age of 25, he hadaccomplished more than all but the finest writers haveachieved in a full lifetime.”Endymion”, the poem was thefirst major work he undertook.(Microsoft) Keats was born to a family of humble means, the eldestof four children.
Milky Way Essay Research Paper The Milky
Milky Way Essay, Research Paper The Milky Way is the place we call home, as well as about 100 billion other stars. It looks very much like other spiral galaxies when viewed from above. There are spiral arms and a nucleus. Viewed from the side, it is about 140,000 LY in width and the nucleus (core) is about 20,000 LY tall.
The Microsoft Antitrust Law Suit Essay Research
Paper Recently one of the biggest corporations in the United States, Microsoft had to face several ultimatums from the government. The case against Microsoft was brought by the U.S. Department of Justice, as well as several state Attorneys General. Microsoft is accused of using and maintaining monopoly power to gain an unfair advantage in software market.
Microsoft Antitrust Court Case Essay Research Paper
As this paper is written there is a landmark court case proceeding in Washington in front of a federal judge. This case involves the charging of the Microsoft Corporation for violating antitrust laws set up by the government to preserve market competition. A general overview of the accusations brought against Microsoft by the Justice Department was given by Hayes in the Scholastic Update article The U.S. versus Microsoft (1999).
Microsoft Essay Research Paper Microsoft the world
Microsoft Essay, Research Paper Microsoft, the world’s largest company by market value, is accused of acting monopolistic in the computer software industry. Microsoft provides for eighty percent of the computers used, operating system. The operating system is a basic program that loads or boots up your computer to make it perform.
Microsoft Monopoly Essay Research Paper By now
Microsoft Monopoly Essay, Research Paper By now everyone is familiar with the case U.S. vs. Microsoft. What is all this about? According to my two articles, Microsoft, the world’s leading software company, is being sued by the Justice Department joined by 19 states.
Microsoft Antitrust Editorial Essay Research Paper Microsoft
Microsoft Antitrust Editorial Essay, Research Paper Microsoft: The Big Bully Stealing Your Lunch Money A monopoly, by definition, is a business or group that engages in unfair and often unethical business practices to control an industry and eliminate all competition that might lessen their profits.
Microsoft Anti Trust Case Essay Research Paper
Microsoft Anti-Trust Case In 1890, Congress passed the Sherman Anti-Trust Act. Since then there has been very few companies that have violated this act. In 1911 it was used it to break J.D.
Microsoft Antitrust Case Essay Research Paper Microsoft
Microsoft Antitrust Case Essay, Research Paper Microsoft Antitrust Case Since 1998, the Microsoft Corporation has been struggling with an antitrust case against the United States Justice Department. They are being charged with violating aspects of the Sherman Act. This act prohibits companies from using their size and power as a monopoly to expand their positions and take hold of new markets.
Microsoft The Company Essay Research Paper Microsoft
Microsoft The Company Essay, Research Paper Microsoft: THE COMPANY The thought of forming a company which supplies its customers with software, was a great idea–especially coming from a college dropout. Bill Gates, along with high-school friend Paul Allen, formed a software company in 1975. From the beginning, Microsoft had a tremendous potential to become a very successful corporation.
Retail Trade Essay Research Paper Write a
Retail Trade Essay, Research Paper Write a structure-performance study of the retail trade industry Paper should include the ff structure 1 Introduction. In this section you give an overview of the industry, its size, growth over the past 10-20 yrs, its important to the economy and other significant factors. 1-2 pages
MS Power Point Essay Research Paper Reflection
MS Power Point Essay, Research Paper Reflection on MS Power Point The Microsoft Power Point presentation that we just completed was a fun project. I learned how to set up Power Point slides while infiltrating animation and sound.