Essay, Research Paper
Bernard Shaw?s famous play Saint Joan recalls the legend of a young girl who leads her nation to an improbable victory against the English. Joan of Arc has since become a role model for girls and women everywhere as a woman who conquered seemingly indomitable odds in a world of men. But one must wonder: Would the legend of Saint Joan have the magnificence that it does had Joan not been burned when she was? Is the grandeur of the story of Joan of Arc found in her life or in her death?
The first step to learning the answer is by understanding the French and English opinions of Joan. When Joan defeats the English at Orleans, she earns the respect of her French peers as a competent general and an extraordinary person. She is not viewed as someone special or revered; she is simply a good, brave soldier. Then their opinions of her begin to change ? she is no longer seen as the unstoppable, driving force of the French military. The second time around, they expect her to meet defeat at the hands of the English, with or without God?s support. The French even begin to question her religious motivation: “When you first came you respected [the authority of The Church], and would not have dared to speak as you are now speaking. You came clothed with the virtue of humility; and because God blessed your enterprises accordingly, you have stained yourself with the sin of pride" (105-6) exclaims the Archbishop. The Church is the authoritative voice throughout France, as well as throughout England, and Joan?s dissension causes the French nobility to lose faith in her and in her abilities. "The voice of God on earth is the voice of the Church Militant; and all the voices that come to you are the echoes of your own wilfulness " (110). Even after her victories against the English and her crowning of the Charles as King of France, Charles distrusts the authenticity of Joan?s voices. "Why dont the voices come to me?" he asks. "I am king, not you" (106). The faith he had in Joan when he gave her complete control of his military and resources is depleted; the way that he speaks to her now is bitter and contains a hint of annoyance with her. Even Dunois, her friend and fellow general, feels that her assistance from heaven has run out; only the better tactician, the better army, and a little bit of luck can decide the outcome of her battles now. With the new lack of support among the French towards Joan, her popularity among the nobility is spiraling quickly downwards.
The English see Joan as an enemy of England, the feudal system, and The Catholic Church, as she is considered to either be a witch or a heretic. Cauchon has different worries about her existence than Warwick does; he is more concerned about the religious aspects of her being, while Warwick worries more about the temporal aspects. Cauchon sees the girl as an enemy of The Church for multiple reasons. Firstly, he believes that Satan inspires Joan to commit her heresy rather than God or saints; this diabolical influence threatens the well being of Joan?s soul. Secondly, Cauchon sees Joan?s attempts at Nationalism as anti-Catholic and anti-Christian because it splits up Christ?s kingdom. Thirdly, he feels that she creates a bad influence on other men and women, which could bring dire consequences in the future, because it spreads the idea of Protestantism. Cauchon asks, "What will the world be like when The Church?s accumulated wisdom and knowledge and experience, its councils of learned, venerable pious men, are thrust into the kennel by every ignorant laborer or dairymaid whom the devil can puff up with the monstrous self-conceit of being directly inspired from heaven?" (95). Warwick views Joan of Arc in a different light. While Warwick also regards Joan?s nationalism negatively, he does so for two secular reasons. First, obviously, England is losing land with every defeat to Joan. Secondly, as a lord himself, he has no wish to become a servant to the king; he prefers the power he already holds. As Warwick exclaims, "It is a cunning device to supersede the aristocracy, and make the king sole and absolute autocrat. Instead of the king being merely the first among his peers, he bocomes their master" (97). As an enemy of the nation, Jane is obviously disliked amongst the English.
With this lack of popularity around both England and France, it appears that Joan?s execution came with her last chance at leaving on a high note. Four years after her death in 1431, Charles took his army into Paris, the capital of his empire. Though the war is considered to have ended with the capture of Bordeaux in 1453, the war essentially ends with the taking of Paris. Had Joan lived, she most likely would have lost control of the army because of Charles?s lack of faith in her and would have lost even more of the king?s trust and respect because of her recent defeat in battle. These things would have effectively ending the war for her just a short time later, and her fifteen minutes of fame would be over, along with her place in history. With her death, however, she retained the magic and mystique that surrounded her life, thereby making her a legend and a saint. Warwick?s claims in the epilogue are completely founded: "when they make you a saint, you will owe your halo to me, just as this lucky monarch owes his crown to you" (154).
The end of the epilogue affirms these facts to an even greater extent. After all the different characters apologize to Joan for what they had done and praise her for their respective reasons, Joan explains that, as a saint, she can rise from the dead. In this situation, rising from the dead is no different from never having actually died, and thus, will have the same results. The thought apparently frightens the others; they are all, excluding the soldier, able to give reasons as to why she is better off dead, often contrary to what they have just finished apologizing for. Cauchon, after explaining that he was fair and just during the trial, rationalizes that heretics are better off dead, and since humans cannot tell the difference between heretics and saints, she is better off deceased. Dunois simply explains that the world is not good enough for her. Warwick, after apologizing to Joan as "the burning was purely political" (154), now exclaims that even though he is sorry, it had to be done for those same political reasons. The Archbishop, after praising Joan for helping The Church come to its senses, still refuses to bless her but hopes to be blessed by her when he is dead. Like the Archbishop, the inquisitor, after praising Joan for helping the law come to its sense, believes that the trial and upholding the verdict is still important. The chaplain, happy with his humble life, still fears Joan and her power. The gentleman insists that her sainthood could be removed with her resurrection; the executioner says that, because it is his job, it must take place for his family?s sake. Even Charles, after explaining that she has made him independent, says that he should do what Dunois does. Ironically, the only one left is the English soldier from hell whose only comforting remarks are that they will all end up in hell with him. Even those closest to Joan can?t handle the thought of her coming back; all the praise that they have bestowed upon her, including her sainthood hundreds of years later, are reconsidered at the prospect of her return.
The plight of Saint Joan is like that of many celebrities of the modern era, but it can be best compared to a man who died almost two thousand years ago. Her story is much like that of Jesus Christ. Had the Romans not executed Jesus, it is hard to say how his story may have turned out. Much like Joan, Jesus brought forth miracle after miracle, but the higher powers at the time found him to be a heretic and political troublemaker. Had Jesus not been executed, Christianity would not be the world power that it has become, and the legacy of Jesus, like that of Joan?s, would have been diminished greatly. It is likely that the Romans or more powerful Sephardic Jews of the time would have brought him down before the eyes of the public. In fact, had he not "died for his people?s sins," there would probably have hardly been a record of him at all, past that of a great religious figure of the time. And a world without the legend of Jesus Christ would be completely different than one with it ? past, present, and future. The same can be said of Saint Joan; though not nearly as significant as Jesus, there still may have been many different changes in gender equality in the world.
It is hard to say what would have happened to Joan had she lived, as there is no way to tell for sure. When all of the facts are put together, however, they bring about the point that Joan of Arc was nearing her downfall within the political infrastructure of France. She was losing her leverage on King Charles; she was not his only solution any longer. As a stronger, more independent king, he had the option of taking over himself or even negotiating a peace treaty. Therefore, Saint Joan?s death is the only thing that kept her in the limelight for so long. During these recent years, Joan has played an important part as a role model and example for feminism and equal rights speakers everywhere. She has inspired them and leaders of the past to pursue equality as one of the most influential women in the history of the world. As a member of the lists "100 Women Who Shaped World History" and "The 100 Most Influential Women of All Time: A Ranking Past and Present," we can only wonder as to how the world would be today had Joan not been burned at the stake and had not become the legend that she has.
Другие работы по теме:
Valentine's Day
History of Valentine’s Day has always been the day dedicated to lovers. There are many stories as to how Valentine’s day started. Here are a few of them.
History Of Valentine
’s Day Essay, Research Paper Valentine?s Day at Its Best The whole holiday of Valentine?s Day is steeped in the concept of love and what greater love is there than Christ?s love laying down His life for those He loved. Like so many other holidays, the celebration of this holiday is derived from pagan origin, yet can have great significance and inspiration for the Christian.
The Maid Of Lorraine Essay Research Paper
The Maid of Lorraine Courage, strength, spirit, and determination are just a few of the ways to describe one of the greatest heroes to ever live. Joan of Arc worked to reunite France at an age when most people would be at the end of their high school careers. She led an army to battle at an age when most people, today, are hanging out with friends and looking forward to college.
Identity And Margaret Atwood
’s Lady Oracle Essay, Research Paper The relationships we have with different people throughout our lives are strong influences on us all. Our relationships with one another can define who we are, as well as the quality of the lives we lead. Strenuous relationships cause stress and unhappiness, while close, loving relationships are a source of support and comfort.
SAINT PETER CLAVER Essay Research Paper Angel
SAINT PETER CLAVER Essay, Research Paper Angel Mendoza Saint Peter Claver St. Peter Claver was born at Verdu, Catalonia, Spain, in 1580. He descended from a very distinguished family . When
Art Analyisis Of JOAN OF ARC By
Jules Bastien Lepage Essay, Research Paper ?Joan of Arc,? was painted by the French realist artist Jules Bastien-Lepage in 1879. ?After the province of Lorraine was lost to Germany following
Schizophrenia Essay Research Paper Background and characteristicsJoan
Schizophrenia Essay, Research Paper Background and characteristics Joan Becker looks like a “normal” person. At times, she acts like a “normal” person and there are even times when she talks like a “normal” person. But, in getting to know Joan you realize she is far from “normal.” Joan suffers from schizophrenia.
Joan Of Ark Essay Research Paper There
Joan Of Ark Essay, Research Paper There are people in history that become an inspiration to people in later years. These people do only what they think and feel is the right thing to do. Many years later they are recognized for their achievements and honored for them. Joan of Arc is one particular woman who had a great impact on the history of France.
Joan Baez Essay Research Paper On
Joan Baez Essay, Research Paper On January 9, 1941, in Staten Island, New York, Joan Bridge and Albert Baez, gave birth to their middle daughter Joan Bridge Baez
Saint Joan By Bernard Shaw Essay Research
Paper The Importance of Scene One for the development of the play During the first scene of Saint Joan, George Bernard Shaw presents to us several themes that will be later discussed in the play. Themes as miracles, feudalism, nationalism and even military tactics are mentioned and introduced in this scene, and they will be further developed.
Saint Thomas Aquinas Writings Essay Research Paper
In “Summa Contra Gentiles”, by Saint Thomas Aquinas, one of the major proofs of the existence of God is the second proof. The second proof is based on the “everything has a cause” theory. He states that there are ordered lines of efficient causes, and nothing can be it’s own cause. Yet it is impossible for the line of efficient causes to extend into infinity.
God Essay Research Paper I think this
God Essay, Research Paper I think this is all valid because Saint Thomas Aquinas is saying that God has to exist sometime in life to make the Earth and nature and so forth. If their were to be a infinity then there would be no first or last causes to have happened. There would be no first or last causes to have happened.
Gilgamesh And King Arthur Essay Research Paper
The Epic of Gilgamesh has many similarities to The Legend of King Arthur. Although Gilgamesh and King Arthur have comparison they also have differences. The main difference is that one is an Epic and the other is a Legend. To compare and contrast The Epic of Gilgamesh and The Legend of King Arthor, one must first know what the words, “Epic” and “Legend” mean.
MtSaint Helens Essay Research Paper Mount Saint
Mt.Saint Helens Essay, Research Paper Mount Saint Helens Mount Saint Helens, A volcanic peak in the Cascade Range, Mount St. Helens is situated in southwestern Washington State. Dormant since 1857, it erupted on May
Saint Helens Essay Research Paper Tracie Knowlton7th
Saint Helens Essay, Research Paper Tracie Knowlton 7th period Many things can happen before, during, and after a volcanic eruption. A volcanic eruption is an extraordinary thing. You never know what is going to turn out as in the end.
David And Legend Essay Research Paper The
David And Legend Essay, Research Paper The legend of David and Goliath is a very familiar one to many people. It is an oral legend that has been told from one generation to the next. It has been mostly assumed to be a fictional story. The question is how do we know it is fiction. This is the problem historians have when using the tool of oral bards or legends.
St Augustine Confessions Essay Research Paper Saint
St. Augustine Confessions Essay, Research Paper Saint Augustine s Confessions Saint Augustine was believed to be the Christian Plato. He describes Plato with the adulation of an admirer and follower. He achieved most of his knowledge through the interpretations of the immensely popular neo-Platonists.
An Analysis Of Saint Joan Essay Research
Paper Saint Joan is considered to be one of George Bernard Shaw’s greatest works. The play deals with subject matter pertaining to events after the Death of Joan of Arc. In the play, Shaw avoids many problems identified by critics as prevalent in some of his other writing. Some have criticized Shaw, claiming that he tends to portray unrealistic archetypal characters, rather than well-rounded believable individuals.
Art History Museum Essay Research Paper As
Art History Museum Essay, Research Paper As a student of art history, going to a museum is the only way to fully experience a work of art. By only looking at a painting or sculpture in a
Saint Thomas Aquinas Essay Research Paper Saint
Saint Thomas Aquinas Essay, Research Paper Saint Thomas Aquinas Saint Thomas Aquinas was a philosopher, theologian, Doctor of the Catholic Church, and is the patron saint of Catholic Universities, colleges, and schools. He was born in Rocca Secca, Italy, in 1225 and was born into a wealthy family. He even was related to the kings of Aragon, Castile, and France.
Legend Of Faust Essay Research Paper The
Legend Of Faust Essay, Research Paper The Legend of Faust In this paper I will be writing about the legend of Faust which gained recognition back in the 16th century by numerous authors.
Civil Disobedience Sometimes It
’s Necessary Essay, Research Paper Civil Disobedience: Sometimes It s Necessary And yet, as men s hearts know, I have done nothing wrong (Sophocles 4.66). Antigone, the main character from the ancient Greek play by Sophocles, faces a situation in which she must choose between what she believes morally right and a law or rule that she feels is wrong.
Saint Maybe Essay Research Paper Saint MaybeIn
Saint Maybe Essay, Research Paper Saint MaybeIn the novel Saint Maybe, by Anne Tyler, the church, led by Rev. Emmett, acts much like a psychologist, helping people get over their guilt. Ian, the main character of the story is involved in a horrible act and needs to find a way to forgive himself for it. With the help of Rev.
2 Paintings Modanno W Child And Angels
Essay, Research Paper The painting called Madonna and Child with Saint Francis and Dominic and Angels by Giulio Cesare Procaccini is one of many paintings labeled masterpiece. This painting contains brilliant brushwork and messages that are indirect.
The Real Arthur Essay Research Paper The
The Real Arthur Essay, Research Paper The Real King Arthur Arthur had been identified as the son of British king Uther Pendragon, who was the son of Constantine. Whatever else Arthur is, he is a composite figure of many different legends and beliefs. Some have even related his adventures to Greek mythology.
Saint Raphael The Archangel Essay Research Paper
Saint Raphael the Archangel The saint I?ve chosen for my confirmation is Saint Raphael the Archangel. Saint Raphael is also known as the Angel of Love and the Angel of Joy. A few things he is a patron of are the blind, love, lovers, travelers, young people, and guardian angels. His name means ? God has healed?, or ? Healer of God?.
Sgt York Life Legend And Legacy Essay
, Research Paper Sgt. York His Life, Legend, and Legacy Book Review Sgt. York: His Life, Legend, and Legacy, John Perry, Nashville, TN, Broadman and Holdman Publishers, 1997, 349 pgs, $16.99. In his thought-provoking book Sgt. York: His Life, Legend, and Legacy, John Perry details the life of Congressional Medal of Honor winner Alvin C.
The Faith Of Joan Of Arc Essay
, Research Paper Joan of Arc was an exceptional character. The pureness in her heart and the devotion she had to her faith drew me to learn more about her. In every way possible she was a saint. Her life provides inspiration to the rest of the world and teaches us to remain true to the voice of God within ourselves.
Joan Of Arc The Saint Essay Research
Paper Saint Joan was born on January 6, 1412, in the village of Domre my-la-Pucelle, on the Meuse River, in Eastern France on January 6, 1412, to Jacques and Isabelle d’Arc. Joan was the youngest of their suspected five children. While growing up among the fields and pastures of her village, she was addressed as Jeannette but when she entered into her mission, her name was changed to Jeanne, la Pucelle, or Joan, the Maid.
Joan Of Arc Essay Research Paper JOAN
Joan Of Arc Essay, Research Paper JOAN OF ARC A French saint and a heroine in the Hundred Years’ war was Joan of Arc. This farm girl helped save the French from English command and was often called the Maid Orleans and the Maid of France. Her inspiration led the French to many victories.
St Joan Of Arc Essay Research Paper
Saint Joan Of Arc The Maid Of France Saint Joan of Arc was born in Domremy in Lorraine, France, in 1412. Until the age of seventeen years, she lived the life of a simple shepherdess. At this time, she was commanded by Heavenly Voices to lead the French armies against the English forces which had invaded France.
Joan Of Arc 2 Essay Research Paper
Saint Joan of Arc Joan of Arc (Jeanne d Arc in French) was born on the year of 1412, in Domremy, France. Born into a family of four other brothers and sisters, Joan never learned to read
Trials Of Joan Of Arc Essay Research
Paper The Trial of Jeanne d?Arc Jeanne d?Arc, better known as Joan of Arc, was the Maid of Orleans. She was a great heroin of the Hundred Years War for the French and was the spirit of the army. She was only a teenager when she heard the voices of Saint Catherine, Saint Michael, and Saint Margaret. The voices told her to march with the French army to drive out the English and place Charles VII on the throne.