A Civil Role Model
The word civil carries a lot of weight. The usage needs to be carefully considered when it’s entered into a sentence or a phrase. Civil means a wide variation of things. It can be defined as a way to be observant of the forms required for good breeding. It can also be a means to the needs and affairs of the general public. However, the latter of the two definitions can also be stretched to include a definition of the private rights and the remedies sought by action or suit. The point is that the word civil has a greater meaning that has been embraced by our American legal culture. It is the premise that law is there to serve the people and the lawyers are nothing more than mere guardians of law.
These are thoughts that were considered during the class viewing of A Civil Action. In the proceedings of the case, there were many concerns that were brought up about our legal culture. For example, was the quest for money so great that it clouds the goals of the case? If the testimonies were that technical, was it fair for the Judge to cut the trial at the point he did, with the questions he wrote? This does not even include the degrees of separation that exist from the true story. Is what was depicted by speakers and the movie and accurate representation of the case? However, the most important question is whether or not the actions of the head counsel were done for the public good or in for the lust for money.
The movie itself does raise a lot of questions. One of the more intriguing, is if the drive of Jan Schlichtmann is money or duty? The movie’s viewpoint is clear. Travolta’s character begins with a very lucrative malpractice law firm. He continues to provide the court and his opponents with those little tricks that enable him to bring home the money. However, is it always possible to maintain such a level of superficiality? In the beginning of the movie, Schlichtmann tells Anne Anderson that the money from the deep pockets of the companies will be the apology that they are looking for. He gives no concern to their feelings and continues to proceed with the trail trying to get the large lump sum of money. It was when he told her that money would be all the forgiveness she would need a great injustice was done not only to Anne Anderson, but to the legal culture. It was at this moment Schlichtmann was no longer a guardian of law. To begin with, a civil action is action for the public good. Fiscal compensation for those who suffered is not a public good. However, if you can ensure that such violations never occur again that is a public good. That would be a civil action to help the general public and ensure their rights in law and in providing a healthly environment.
In addition, Jan should have taken the opportunity in the meetings with Anne Anderson to explain to her how money would have been the apology she was looking for. To begin with, an explanation of what type of an apology she was going to get was in order. It should have been made clear, by Jan, that there was going to be no verbal communication of an apology from W.R. Grace and Beatrice. If there was an apology both companies would be openly admitting that they were at fault and inviting thousands of other suits. Also, it was Jan’s duty as a lawyer to convey to his clients that an apology in the form of money is sufficient and efficient. Companies don’t want to lose money and therefore it serves as an apology and a punishment. If Anne Anderson was searching for someone to take the blame and clean up the mess, it was also the responsibility of her counsel to explain that Courts usually order someone to clean up whether its them or the Courts. In the end, companies definitely are not big fans of negative publicity either. The families should have been made aware that seeking money from the companies was the only way to make them realize what they did was wrong and to ensure such an act never happens again. In the long run, the movie portrayed the profession of lawyers as greedy and self-serving people.
It is this portrayal that seems to have the largest effect on American legal culture. Is this how the world views the law profession? Is this how the guardians of the law that protect my rights do their job? If the fuel for justice the dollar bill or is it the satisfaction that a public good has been accomplished?
At the end of the movie, Jan has lost his partners, his car, his house, his staff, his office and his practice. He has also lost the case. He was unable to provide for the large cash settlement he and his ego thought he would have undoubtedly received. However, Jan will not give up. He discovers small little details in the case and passes it on to the EPA with a very nicely written letter explaining the importance of justice and this case for the people of Woburn. At first glance, the letter seems to be a very nicely written apology not only for his failure to the families, but to the law profession for his unneeded greed. After a second glance, the letter could have simply served as his ticket to ensure that this case would be followed up and his name cleared and ego re-inflated. If you follow the initial motives for him to pick up the case you can see similar motives in him wanting to be justified by closing the case. In the end, it wasn’t about the money or the justice it was about the ego. It was about proving that he was right. Jan Schlichtmann wanted to prove that he was the victor in the end.
American legal culture has suffered many blows, but this portrayal of a lawyer is quite disheartening. Jan seems to be selfish, and egotistical. There is no sincere apologies made to the families for the failure of the system on their behalf. The movie itself is a fairly accurate description of the case, but in the case are the actions of Jan, the role model, the law profession should be putting forth? Were the actions of Jan providing the world with the reassurance that the system is working for them and that they can seek justice in the system. Does the role model in this movie increase the trust of the public in their guardians? Where are the role models in American legal culture?
Другие работы по теме:
Civil Liberties Essay Research Paper Civil LibertiesThe
Civil Liberties Essay, Research Paper Civil Liberties The term civil liberties refers to the “freedoms that individuals enjoy and that governments cannot invade”. These rights include a persons freedom of speech and religion.
The Good Earth Wang Lung As A
Rolemodel Essay, Research Paper The Good Earth: Wang Lung as a Role Model This is my definition of a role model: someone who does something that is admirable. One would be considered ignorant to think that a role model is perfect. In Pearl S. Buck?s The Good Earth, Wang Lung is set up to be a role model for his children.
Role Model Essay Research Paper Role ModelEveryone
Role Model Essay, Research Paper Role Model Everyone has a role model. Whether an athlete, an older sibling, a parent or relative, or just a special someone everyone wants to be “just like” that certain person. I am a role model to my younger siblings, my cousins, and I hope to be a role model to all of the Wild Life kids.
On The Bench Essay Research Paper In
?On The Bench? Essay, Research Paper In his essay, ?On The Bench?, Robert Parker shows the trials and tribulations of trying to be both mentally and physically strong. He writes about how horrible it is being thin and weak, and having to hold on to his wife?s arm when it is windy out. I hope that this essay was intended to be humorous, because it did in fact make me laugh.
Why American Troops Are Being Sent Overseas
Essay, Research Paper American troops are being sent overseas to maintain peace in a nation involved in a civil war. Whether the peace troops should or should not be sent overseas, they are being sent overseas.
Servqual Essay Research Paper PS1 What is
Servqual Essay, Research Paper PS.1 What is the ServQual model ? PS.2 What are the advantages and disadvantages of the model? PS.3 In what situation can it be used?
The Contractual Model Essay Research Paper The
The Contractual Model Essay, Research Paper The contractual model is the model in a professional client-relationship that shows the most trust within any of the professional-client relationships. For this model to work there must be a large amount of trust within the two parties since the choices are made collectively by each of them.
My Holy Heroine Essay Research Paper My
My Holy Heroine Essay, Research Paper My Holy Heroine When I think of a holy heroine, I think of my mother. What is a heroine? Everyone’s vision is somewhat different. To me, a heroine is someone who I can look up to as a role model. This is why I consider her to be my holiest heroine.
Reconstruction Era Essay Research Paper Reconstruction EraThe
Reconstruction Era Essay, Research Paper Reconstruction Era The Reconstruction period can be defined as the time after the Civil War when states were debating on what to do with a partially seceded nation. The Union, known as the North, wanted to come to agreements with the Confederacy, or the south, on how to successfully bring the states together again as one nation.
Does Rap Influenec Violents In Inner Cities
? Essay, Research Paper In my beliefs I truly believe that Rap, Hip-Hop, does reflect the violence in inner cities. I believe that mainly, because most rappers out there are originally from inner cities and rap about what they know, and what they see around them or experienced in life, like teen pregnancy, drugs, drive-bys, and murders.
Gun Control Essay Research Paper The following
Gun Control Essay, Research Paper The following is an excerpt from an ABC news broadcast on September 16, 1999: And so it has happened once again. After the massacre at Columbine High School and a day trading firm in Atlanta and the Jewish daycare center in Los Angeles, now someone has walked into a church in Fort Worth, Texas and started shooting.
Civil War Essay Research Paper Fatoorechi ShivaPer
Civil War Essay, Research Paper Fatoorechi, Shiva Per. 5 H. History 11-10-99 The Civil War leads to the Glorious Revolution The civil war lasted from 1642 to 1649. Directly after the civil war came the
Nixon Essay Research Paper NixonI Civil
Nixon Essay, Research Paper Nixon I. Civil Rights A. Some people, mostly blacks, did not get equal rights. B. Nixon believed fundamentaly in responsible civil rights policy on
Three Reasons Why I
’m Attending College Essay, Research Paper Three Reasons Why I’m Attending Frontier Community College There are many reasons for my decision to attend Frontier Community College. For example, I wanted to create a positive atmosphere for my family so I would become a better role model for my children. While in the mean time, preparing a solid foundation for my career, and furthering my education to improve my own self-esteem.
Model Society Essay Research Paper Model SocietyMy
Model Society Essay, Research Paper Model Society My model society would be a small society consisting of about one hundred to two hundred people. The people in this society would all believe in the same god, they would also all be the same race. Those are two large issues that cause major conflict among a society.
Three Easy Steps On How To Avoid
Being A Phony (Catcher In The Rye) Essay, Research Paper Everybody at one point in life has someone that he looks up to. Whether they want to ?Be like Mike? or want to be like their favorite actor, every child needs someone to be a role model. Unfortunately, many of today?s idols are people who are admired simply because they can run faster, jump higher, or shoot straighter than normal people.
Lucille Ball
– A Role Model To All Essay, Research Paper There are so many role models throughout the world that are looked up to. We usually admire these people for their good deeds and personalities. We dream to meet them and to know what they are really like behind the scenes, off the field, or away from the microphone. We wonder about their journey to fame and how they came so respected.
The Crucible Essay Research Paper What Willy
The Crucible Essay, Research Paper What Willy meant to Biff Did not like him that much. Ruined his life. Was his role model until he catches them in bed. What Willy meant to Happy
The Cavalry During The Civil War Essay
, Research Paper The Cavalry During The Civil War Essay submitted by God The Civil War played a crucial role in American history. Many different types of soldiers
Eisenhower Administration Essay Research Paper What role
Eisenhower Administration Essay, Research Paper What role did the Eisenhower administration play in Civil Rights? During the 1950 s race relations in the United States began to explode and the domestic tranquility caused years of injustice for African Americans. Eisenhower, the current president, entered office committed to Civil Rights in principle, and he pushed the issue in areas of federal authority.
Civil Diobedience Essay Research Paper While studying
Civil Diobedience Essay, Research Paper While studying Thoreau’s “Civil Disobedience” in my group, I learned that patience is necessary when working with people. Although when I came to this conclusion I was not aware of the comforts and advantages of working in a group. Some people like working in groups, then there are the independent type, these people enjoy working on their own.
Civil Disobeiance Essay Research Paper Civil
Civil Disobeiance Essay, Research Paper Civil Disobedience Civil disobedience is the refusal to obey civil laws. This refusal is in the form of nonviolence. People who use civil disobedience are usually protesting a
Antigone Civil Disobedience Essay Research Paper The
Antigone: Civil Disobedience Essay, Research Paper The short play, Antigone, was written in 441 B.C. by the Greek playwrightSophocles. It deals with some of the most basic problems that affect a society.One of them is Civil Disobedience. Civil Disobedience both a right andresponsibility of a person to fight an unjust law.
Thoreau Essay Research Paper Thoreau
Thoreau Essay, Research Paper Thoreau’s Civil Disobedience emphasizes the need to prioritize one’s conscience over the dictates of laws. It criticizes American social institutions and policies, mostly slavery and the Mexican American war.
Modern Atom Model Essay Research Paper The
Modern Atom Model Essay, Research Paper The evolution of the modern atom model took several years to evolved with contribution from different scientists. One of these scientists, the first to come up with a modern model of the atom is JJ Thomson. Thomson proposes that the structure of an atom is mainly a sphere.
Black Man Of Civil War Essay Research
Paper One of the things that were important at war was that the Blacks proving themselves was that of the Black Man acting as a soldier in the Civil War. During the Civil War the decision to use Blacks as soldiers in the
Old Man By The Sea Essay Research
Paper “The great DiMaggio is himself again!”(21), in Ernest Hemingway’s novel, The Old Man and the Sea, which takes place near Havana, Cuba in the Caribbean Sea, a very old, unlucky, fisherman sets out for the big catch. The great DiMaggio is seamed throughout the novel to symbolize the old man and his struggle to catch the big fish, yet also he poses as a role model for Santiago (the old man).
Social Role Essay Research Paper About Its
Social Role Essay, Research Paper About Its Social Role Waxing eloquent about stakeholder management and corporate social responsibility is in some circles the surest way to stifle a business conversation, if not a business career. Corporate philanthropy brings satisfaction to those who give and receive, the argument goes, but let us not get carried away by talk of give-aways.
Task Centered Model Essay Research Paper Task
Task Centered Model Essay, Research Paper Task Centered Model Task-Centered model is a time-limited, goal-oriented method designed to help individuals, groups, and families with problems
Transforming America With The Civil Rights Movement
Essay, Research Paper Transforming America with the Civil Rights Movement The civil rights movement transformed American society in to a color conscience society and started the anti-free speech political correct movement that we are seeing today. The civil rights movement gave African Americans the right to be treated as regular citizens but it was the urban riots of the mid-1960s and the voiced black rage that changed the tone of the civil rights movement.
Civil War Battles Essay Research Paper Civil
Civil War Battles Essay, Research Paper Civil War Battles- Bull Run, Shiloh and Vicksburg The American Civil War- 1861 to 1895. A terrible four years. Four years of victory, defeat and death. Though, without it where would the United States of America be? Pulled apart or reconstructed and as one?
Civil Vs Moral Essay Research Paper Civil
Civil Vs Moral Essay, Research Paper ?Civil Law vs. Moral law? In Sophocles? play ?Antigone?, Antigone?s life is taken from her because of her choice to follow the moral law by burying her brother and disobeying the civil law, which forbid this.
Role Models Essay Research Paper Role Models
Role Models Essay, Research Paper Role Models Who are the Role Model?s of Today? Who are the role models of today? It seems as though the culture of today has the tendency to mistake who a role model is rather then what a role model should be. How, then, is a role model defined? A role model is a person in our lives that give us inspiration, hope and keep our spirits up.