, Research Paper
Should you obey an unjust law?
According to the theory of Jean-Jacques Rousseau, 18th century French political philosopher, ?in a democratic society the state represents the general will of the citizens, and that in obeying its laws each citizen is pursuing his own real interests.? Thus, in an ideal state, laws express the general will. An individual who disagrees with a law must be failing to look at things from the moral standpoint.
Rousseau is talking about an ideal state where laws express people?s general will, a will that aims at the common good. But the question is: are we living in an ideal state and do all the laws of our land express the common will of the people and should we obey all the laws even if they are unjust? The answer to this question can be different for different people, but in my opinion it is ?NO?. I think the state in which we are living in is not an ideal state described by Rousseau. There are times when the laws are unjust and it is reasonable to disobey them and protest against them to get them change if there is a higher moral or purpose behind it. I would agree with St.Augustine, ?an unjust law is no law at all.? As we know during the sixties large number of people recognized that obeying the law was sometimes harmful because sometimes the law itself was wrong. Therefore, we had a civil rights movement, an anti-war movement and several other smaller movements in which people purposely disobeyed the law. But the question is how and when to disobey the law; how does one determine whether a law is just or unjust?
If we look back in history we find perfect examples to get an answer to our question; the example of Henry Thoreau, Mohandas Gandhi and Martin Luther King. They all were governed by the sense of justice. For them there are times when it is necessary to break the law for a higher purpose. To give a brief description of what is an unjust law, I would quote from Martin Luther King?s ?Letters from Birmingham jail?. He writes, ?a just law is a man made code that squares with the moral law or the law of God. An unjust law is a code that is out of harmony with the moral law. To put it in the terms of St. Thomas Aquinas: an unjust law is a human law that is not rooted in eternal law and natural law. Any law that uplifts human personality is just. Any law that degrades human personality is unjust.?
There is no doubt that laws are made for a reason and the laws of a society reflect the values of that society because of tradition, necessity, and expectation. But occasionally there will be a law, which is unjust and wrong though not for everyone but say, for a group of people. If the law contradicts with their high morals or religion, in my opinion it is right for them to protest against it in a reasonable way. So now the question is what is that reasonable way and how to protest against an unjust law? First those people have to ask themselves if there is a higher purpose, which make them to disobey it. They should look beyond the intent of the law and immediate results to see what the final result will be. It is not right to disobey an unjust law for just personal convenience. People should look at the alternatives, weigh them against what their personal beliefs may be, and then make a judgment based on their individual moral values.
Here I would like to give an example of one of the laws of Pakistan, where I spent most of my life. Though it is very embarrassing for me but it is a fact that government in Pakistan is and has been very corrupt. Besides few people who are very rich, majority of the public is very poor and their average annual income is lower than $1000 a year. Government has imposed high taxes on people, which actually is a burden on middle class and poor people. There are no means to enforce tax laws so rich people usually get away with them easily. Instead of using the tax money for public welfare bureaucrats are wasting that money on their personal luxuries. To make matters worse, government has imposed a new law of additional sales tax recently to meet the deadline of (International Monetary Fund) IMF?s debt payment. Majority of the money that was given by IMF was used by the government officials to fill up their own pockets. Now they have burdened the common people of Pakistan for paying the debt. The public is protesting against the new sales tax and the businesses in the country are shut down. Majority of the rich and influential community have bribed their way out of this mess and the middle class and the poor community is now fighting to keep their hard earned money from the government?s hand. Because of these unjust laws the corruption is getting worse day by day. People have no choice other then commit robberies and use unjust means to survive to make their both ends meet.
Therefore, in this situation, I think it is right to protest against that type of unjust law. But there should be a way to do it. Thoreau, Gandhi and King all point out clearly that they are not saying, “do whatever you want to do if you get away with it.” Instead they recognized the value of the law and deeply respected it. They never ever advocated breaking laws on the sly for personal convenience; they attacked unjust laws at their own risk in order to improve society. I think in the case of Pakistan too, people should follow the path of these three eloquent men who were apostles of non-violence. They can protest against the government through non-violent direct action. In order to do it, they should use the power of media by writing about it in newspapers. They can follow a complete strike for a day by not showing up for work, but a long-term strike will not be favorable for them because people are already very poor. People can also perform marches in front of the parliament house but the key to remember is that all this should be done without any violence.
In the end I would just say that protesting against the unjust law is not a departure from democracy; it is absolutely essential to it. It is a corrective to the sluggishness of ?the proper channels?, a way of breaking through passages blocked by tradition and prejudice. It is disruptive and troublesome, but it is a necessary disruption, a healthy troublesomeness.
Другие работы по теме:
Martin Luther King Essay Research Paper Letter
Martin Luther King Essay, Research Paper ?Letter from Birmingham Jail? Martin Luther King Jr. writes the Clergymen that have written him a letter disputing his actions in Birmingham. King is disturbed and offended by the Clergymen disagreeing with his purpose in Birmingham. King say he normally does not respond to criticism because it would waste to much precious time, but since these were men of good will he wanted to give his answers to their statements.
Mlk Jr Letter From Birmingham Jail Essay
, Research Paper Martin Luther King Jr. Letter From Birmingham Jail Martin Luther King Jr.’s “Letter from Birmingham Jail,” was very persuasive to a wide variety of audiences. Not only did he directly address the writers of the newspaper article, but included fellow African Americans with their struggle to gain acceptance.
Just Laws Essay Research Paper The definition
Just Laws Essay, Research Paper The definition of a law as just or unjust can only come from the people whom are governed by the law in question. Although everyone should be free to decide whether or not a law is just, the only opinions that should matter are from those of the nation ruled by the law.
Socrates To Conform Or Not
– A Struggle Essay, Research Paper To Conform or Not? Socrates- A Struggle When one is pondering the question, what do the laws mean by stating that Socrates needed to be obedient because of all that the laws have done for him, you can find the meaning in the text of the Crito. The law states, that if they were not there, Socrates would not have been born.
Untitled Essay Research Paper The Republic written
Untitled Essay, Research Paper The Republic written by Plato examines many things. It mainly is about the Good life. Plato seems to believe that the perfect life is led only under perfect conditions which is
Statutory Rape Essay Research Paper In the
Statutory Rape Essay, Research Paper In the face of unjust laws, I believe that civil disobedience is mandatory. I have a scenario to defend my argument. I introduce to you Stan Lippy. Stan is a 19 year old student at Louisiana State University and he loves his girlfriend. Unfortunately, she is a 17 year old high school student with over-protective parents.
Kings Fight For Justice Essay Research Paper
King s Fight for Justice Justice is like a breath of air: each person is entitled to it, and is born with the right to take it. Definitions can sometimes lack the true meaning of a term. For example, justice has a different meaning to each person. The Webster Dictionary defines justice as: Conformity to truth and reality in expressing opinions and in conduct; fair representation of facts respecting merit or demerit; honesty; fidelity; impartiality; as, the justice of a description or of a judgment; historical justice. (806) However, perhaps it is not the definition of the word, but the way the term in used and interpreted which gives the term it s true definition.
Thoreau And King Jr Essay Research Paper
There are times throughout the history of the United States when its citizens have felt the need to revolt against the government. There were such cases during the time of Dr. Martin Luther King Jr. and Henry David Thoreau, when there was unfair discrimination against the Afro-American community and Americans refusing to pay poll taxes to support the Mexican War.
Henry David Thoreau Vs Martin Essay Research
Paper Henry David Thoreau vs. Martin Luther King There are times throughout the history of the United States when its citizens have felt the need to revolt against the government. The two essays, Civil Disobedience, by Henry David Thoreau, and Letter From a Birmingham Jail, by Martin Luther King, Jr., effectively illustrate the authors opinions of justice.
Ella Enchanted Essay Research Paper A young
Ella Enchanted Essay, Research Paper A young girl named Ella received a spell at birth from the fairy Lucinda. Lucinda gives the gift of always being obedient. The spell causes Ella to obey commands of others. Ella was happy with her life otherwise. Ella and her mother would do everything together, until her mother became sick and died.
Socrates On Democracy Essay Research Paper In
Socrates On Democracy Essay, Research Paper In Plato?s Euthyphro, Crito and the Apology, we learn of Socrates? highly critical view of the democracy. Socrates believed that democracy was a flawed
Civil Rights And Disobedience Essay Research Paper
By acting civil but disobedient you are able to protest things you don?t think are fair, non-violently. Henry David Thoreau is one of the most important literary figures of the nineteenth century. Thoreau?s essay ?Civil
Are We Ever Morally Justified In Disobeying
Laws We Consider To Be Immoral? Essay, Research Paper Are we ever morally justified in disobeying laws we consider to be immoral? The answer to this question depends very much on our understanding and opinion on the status of the law. On this issue it is likely that everyone falls into one of two broad categories.
Henry Davis ThorueaCompare Essay Research Paper Henry
Henry Davis Thoruea/Compare Essay, Research Paper Henry David Thoreau was an American writer who is remembered for his attacks on the social institutions he considered immoral and for his faith in the religious significance of nature. The essay Civil Disobedience is his most famous social protest. Thoreau believed that each person must be free to act according to his own idea of right and wrong, without government interference.
Justice
& Fairness Essay, Research Paper Justice & Fairness When a person commits a crime, many people call for him to be brought to justice. To many people, it means punishment. If a person commits murder, some say he should be brought to justice by having to serve a long prison sentence or even face the death penalty.
Socraric Method Essay Research Paper The Socratic
Socraric Method Essay, Research Paper The Socratic Method of philosophy is basically a series of question leading to an answer. In order for this method to work though, two conditions must be met. The first one is that the interlocutor has to say what he believes. The second is that the answers must be kept short.
Socrates Essay Research Paper Socrates arguments that
Socrates Essay, Research Paper Socrates arguments that it would be wrong to escape from prison is as follows. In Critos, Socrates explains to his friend Crito that escaping from prison would go against many of the thins that he (Socrates) believes in; seeking virtue, seeking the truth, not repaying an evil with another evil, obeying the laws of the state and so on.
The Crito Essay Research Paper The dialogue
The Crito Essay, Research Paper The dialogue of The Crito, by Plato, recounts the last days of Socrates, immediately before his execution was going to take place in Athens. In the dialogue, Socrates friend, Crito, proposes that Socrates escape from prison. Socrates considers this proposal, trying to decide if escaping would be just and morally justified.
Moral Or Immoral Essay Research Paper In
Moral Or Immoral Essay, Research Paper In Martin Luther King Jr.’s essay, A Letter from Birmingham Jail he compares the issues of Moral acts verses Immoral acts. This essay was written in response to a letter some clergymen had written after a direct action march Dr. King had participated in. In their letter the clergymen had praised the local police officers and media for the nonviolent and calm manner in which the situation was handled.
The Milgram Experiment Essay Research Paper The
The Milgram Experiment Essay, Research Paper The Milgram Experiment The Milgram experiment is one of Psychology?s most controversial experiments. The study examines to what extend individuals obey an authority figure, and how far they will go, even if they believe their actions are harming another individual.
Civil Disobeiance Essay Research Paper Civil
Civil Disobeiance Essay, Research Paper Civil Disobedience Civil disobedience is the refusal to obey civil laws. This refusal is in the form of nonviolence. People who use civil disobedience are usually protesting a
Antigone Civil Disobedience Essay Research Paper The
Antigone: Civil Disobedience Essay, Research Paper The short play, Antigone, was written in 441 B.C. by the Greek playwrightSophocles. It deals with some of the most basic problems that affect a society.One of them is Civil Disobedience. Civil Disobedience both a right andresponsibility of a person to fight an unjust law.
Civil Disobedience Essay Research Paper Civil DisobedienceAn
Civil Disobedience Essay, Research Paper Civil Disobedience: An Essay Civil disobedience helps democracy because it provides a means to insure that which is just and that which is right will prevail. Democracy, founded on the principle of rule of the majority, cannot always insure that justice and rightness are maintained in the laws which guide it.
Civil Disobedience Essay Research Paper Henry David
Civil Disobedience Essay, Research Paper Henry David Thoreau was justified in writing Civil Disobedience. Civil Disobedience portrayed the problems of the newly formed government. Even though the United States was making great political progress, slavery was still legal in the southern states. This issue needed to be resolved and Thoreau took a step towards correcting the problem.
Thoreau Essay Research Paper Thoreau
Thoreau Essay, Research Paper Thoreau’s Civil Disobedience emphasizes the need to prioritize one’s conscience over the dictates of laws. It criticizes American social institutions and policies, mostly slavery and the Mexican American war.
And They Obey Essay Research Paper I
And They Obey Essay, Research Paper I chose the poem “And They Obey” by Carl Sandburg. The poem is addressing the human dualities that we have. Since thousands of years ago
Thoreau Essay From Walden Pond Essay Research
Paper Answer Thoreau’s question: “Unjust laws exist: shall we be content to obey them, or shall we endeavor to amend them and obey them until we have succeeded, or shall we transgress them at once?” Thoreau reminds us that the law has been created by the majority and to disobey would put him in the minority-a “wise minority.” Why should the wise minority have the right to disobey laws created by the majority? As we approach the end of the millennium, we must all ask ourselves, what lies in the future? Some people believe that the year 2000 will mark the beginning of world chaos.
Plato Essay Research Paper One of the
Plato Essay, Research Paper One of the most influential minds in western philosophy is that of Plato. Plato lived from 422-347 B.C, was born into an aristocratic family in the city of Athens. He was a student of Socrates and a teacher of Aristotle. Plato followed the basic ideas of Socrates, in which no laws are to be broken despite their relevance.
Antigone Essay Research Paper Antigone and The
Antigone Essay, Research Paper Antigone and The Mother Death surrounds us all. It is a common reminder of the life we have around us. Death is seen in people, nature, and animal’s everyday. It brings us sadness and pain. It is something that is not easily dealt with and sometimes may seem unjust. It helps us become better people by accepting death and learning from it.
The Unjust Life Is More Profitable Than
The Just Life Essay, Research Paper “The Unjust Life Is The Most Profitable Life” Plato argues in his book the “Republic” that the just life is better that the unjust life. Although, Glaucon has legitimate arguments, Plato refutes them effectively by showing that the just life is better.
The Crucible And Inherit The Wind
– Injustice Essay, Research Paper Both Cates, in Inherit the Wind by Lee and Lawrence, and Procter, in The Crucible, by Arthur Miller, are both subjected to unjust laws. Both demonstrated that , “if the law is of such a nature that it requires one to be an agent of injustice toward another, then I say break the law,” as stated by Henry David Thoreau.