De Tocqueville Essay, Research Paper
Amanda Hugankis
Dr. I. P. Freely
A.P. British Literature Portfolio
May 2, 1997
Alexis De Tocqueville, Democracy in America
Aristocracy is a phenomenon that is perhaps as natural a summer crop, and as devastating as the locusts that eat it. De Tocqueville?s position on aristocracy is quite clear. He is a strong advocate of the aristocracy, it is a part of the natural order and necessary. His position may have some basis, however I have yet to see the ?upside? of a caste system or a good defense of it.
De Tocqueville believes that aristocracy provides stability and fellowship. De Tocqueville?s support of aristocracy is weak and ill founded. His first point of aristocracy is that of stability, ?Among aristocratic nations, as families remain for centuries in the same condition,?. Stationary families have the stability to resist most circumstances and become fixed. This also allows families to gain power that they have no real right to hold. Old things often become stagnant and rotten, as did the aristocracy when families intermarried beyond their genes capacity, as well as becoming corrupted.
De Tocqueville?s second point is that the aristocracy have great lineage and pay homage to their ancestors, ?A man almost always knows his forefathers and respects them;?. This is quite true, however De Tocqueville does not mention that because of the family ?blood?, wars have been fought, and many lives lost. De Tocqueville continues to say, ?He willingly imposes duties on himself towards the former and latter [ancestors and descendants], and he will frequently sacrifice his personal gratifications . . .?. It is a nice sentiment, however, history has taught us that it is rare to find a self-sacrificing person, and even rarer is the benevolent overlord. De Tocqueville?s argument lacks a solid and provable basis. The fact that aristocrats look only for their ancestors or descendants is a very self-centered act. They are concerned with only their family and it?s success. De Tocqueville does not mention the ?sacrifice? an angry lord makes for his serfs and servants by throwing them off his land. It would destroy De Tocqueville?s argument to show that lords were hard, if not cruel at times, on their tenets. History has proven it.
De Tocqueville tries to justify the isolation of the aristocracy by claiming that it binds people together by ?fixed positions one above another, the result is that each of them always sees a man above himself whose patronage is necessary to him, and below himself another man whose cooperation he may claim.?. A community bound by social class is often referred to as a slaving society. The people at the bottom of this system are indebted to those above with nowhere else to turn. The man who is bound to another of a higher class is most likely to be exploited, for in an aristocratic society one has only the aristocrats to turn to for justice. Unfortunately, a man needs justice most when he is mistreated by the aristocracy.
The aristocracy is ?closely attached to something placed out of their own sphere,? is another idea that De Tocqueville had of the aristocracy. In reality, the aristocracy probably had very little to do with anything outside of their ?sphere?. He also claims that ?they are often disposed to forget themselves.?. If aristocrats thought about anything besides themselves, then perhaps they would have eased some of the suffering in the world. They could not know or care about anything that was not in their immediate world. It is unlikely that they would be so out of their ?sphere? that they could have possibly known the poor man?s plight, or have cared. It does not hurt the aristocrat if families live on the street.
De Tocqueville concludes his avocation of an aristocratic system by discussing fellowship, ? . . . the notion of human fellowship is faint and that men seldom think of sacrificing themselves for mankind; but often sacrifice themselves for other men.? True, human fellowship is faint, however it is more faint in the feudal system. The aristocrats do not sacrifice for men. It is the masses who work for the few that sacrifice. The system is against the majority of people, the very people whose backs keep it running.
Fortunately, for the advocate of democracy, De Tocqueville gave a fine defense for it. All his criticism are the very ideas upon which Democracy is based. De Tocqueville felt that Democracy brings about equality and breaks the social structure. Oddly enough, I must agree with him.
De Tocqueville begins criticizing the stability of the democratic system, ?new families are constantly springing up, others are constantly falling away,?. This creates opportunity for individuals to move up in social standing. The mobility of the democratic class system was designed to allow equal opportunity for people to decide their own position on the ?social ladder?.
De Tocqueville continues to go on and say, ?the interest of man is confined to those in close propinquity to himself.?. This is true, though it is true in any political system. A man is more likely to know his neighbors. This does not seem to be a valid argument for or against democracy. In an aristocracy one can know many people form one class. In a democracy, it is possible to know a few people from all classes. Speaking further on the subject of classes, De Tocqueville remarks on the fact that all classes mingle, and ?its members become undifferentiated and lose their identity for each other.? De Tocqueville found one of the goals of Democracy. It is to equalize people, and give no persons special treatment.
De Tocqueville continues to uphold feudalism by claiming again that it binds people together. His metaphor for the bond was his greatest error. De Tocqueville plainly says, ?Aristocracy has made a chain of all members of the community, from the peasant to the king; democracy breaks that chain and severs every link of it.?. This is precisely what democracy is meant to do. A democracy is meant to free people from such slavery and servitude. De Tocqueville chose poor words in this statement. It is a rare occasion when the image of chains brings a pleasant or light feeling. Chains are meant to bind and restrain. The are meant to dehumanize. This, as De Tocqueville says, is what the feudal system does. Aristocracy creates chains which bind those on the bottom, with the leads of the chains held by those at the top. Democracy was founded on the belief of liberty, and with this foundation we try to break the chain of slavery so people can live lives of their own.
Equality is one of democracy?s foundations. De Tocqueville does not see this, however as he writes, ?As social conditions become more equal . . . [people cannot] . . . exercise any great influence over their fellows,?. The idea behind this strange equality is that people are free to make decisions with out the fear of outside influences.
Democracy, though it works as a system designed for the masses, also works for individual rights. De Tocqueville notes that, ?they are apt to imagine that their whole destiny is in their own hands.?. This is a foundation of democracy, that we have right to life. This includes the right to shape our ?destiny?.
De Tocqueville wrote sensible arguments, save the fact that they were totally unfounded and not supported in any way. I cannot say whether it is better live under democracy or feudalism. It is possible to see that in most circumstances, a democracy is better for the people. In fact, it?s better for any person to live under a democracy, except for the aristocrat.
Другие работы по теме:
Lauren Essay Research Paper The Glass Menagerie
Lauren Essay, Research Paper The Glass Menagerie by Tennessee Williams is a touching play about the lost dreams of a southern family and their struggle to escape reality. The play is a memory play and therefore very poetic in mood, setting, and dialogue. Tom Wingfield serves as the narrator as well as a character in the play.
Insights On De Tocqueville
’s Democracy In America Essay, Research Paper Insights on De Tocqueville’s Democracy In America It has been said that a French aristocrat Alexis de Tocqueville, who
Tocqueville Essay Research Paper In the book
Tocqueville Essay, Research Paper In the book Democracy in America, Tocqueville describes why he believes democracy, especially in America, is going to turn into a despot. Tocqueville believes that despotism is going to rise in America because when the inhabitant of a democratic country compares himself individually with all those about him, he feels with pride that he is the equal of any one of them; but when he comes to survey the totality of his fellows and to place himself in contrast to so huge a body, he is instantly overwhelmed by the sense of his own insignificance and weakness (Tocqueville v2, p10).
Alexis De Tocqueville Essay Research Paper Frankly
Alexis De Tocqueville Essay, Research Paper Frankly, the French have no idea of what America truly is. In Tocqueville s Democracy in America, the caustic Frenchman describes the governmental aspects of America, as well as highlighting upon some social aspects. He states the truth, however not all of Tocqueville s truths do not transcend time and are rendered obsolete in modern times.
The Glass Meragerie Essay Research Paper The
The Glass Meragerie Essay, Research Paper ?The Glass Menagerie?, is a adorable little play written be Tennessee Williams. The play takes place in tiny apartment, behind an ally,
Disspossessed Essay Research Paper Text ResponseDispossessed1 The
Disspossessed Essay, Research Paper Text Response: Dispossessed 1. The reclamation of the land has had a strong impact on the lives of Liz, Len, Max and Amanda. They are a family loosing their identity struggling to accept their imminent dispossession and the optimism held by Amanda in regard to it.
One Evil Summer Essay Research Paper Its
One Evil Summer Essay, Research Paper It?s finally summer and a time to do what you want and have as much fun as you can. Well that?s not the case with Amanda Conklin?s who lives in a cruel and
Descriptive Essay 2
Descriptive Essay – The Dentist’s Office Essay, Research Paper The phone rings and I answer, ?Thank you for calling Business Systems this is Mandy how can I help you?? The voice on the other end asks for Amanda and I reply, ?This is she?. The voice says she is calling to remind me of my 4:00 PM dental appointment.
Special Delivery Essay Research Paper BOOK NAME
Special Delivery Essay, Research Paper BOOK NAME: Special Delivery This book is a romance novel about two people who at first hated each other and because of ones kindness became lovers. Jack Watson was 59 years old an old actor who bought a woman’s clothing store with money his uncle left him. He named the store after his nine-year-old daughter Julie.
Constitutionalism The Tyranny Of The Majority Essay
, Research Paper In this excerpt from Democracy in America Alexis Tocqueville expresses his sentiments about the United States democratic government. Tocqueville believes the government’s nature exists in the absolute supremacy of the majority, meaning that those citizens of the United States who are of legal age control legislation passed by the government.
Is Gentleman Jim The Savior Essay Research
Paper Is Gentleman Jim the Savior? Is a man the solution to a family’s problems? In The Glass Menagerieby Tennessee Williams, Jim O’Connor, the gentleman caller, could be theresolution to the Wingfield’s predicaments. Throughout the play LauraWingfield, the daughter, lives in her childhood. If she married Jim O’Connor,it would fulfill a dream from her days of youth.
Glass Managerie Essay Research Paper The Glass
Glass Managerie Essay, Research Paper The Glass Menagerie The theme of this play is memories. This is demonstrated through the plot, characters, and setting. The play is a reflection of memories that Tom tries to breakaway from but he cannot because they have such a strong hold of him. He described the way he left the life he portrayed as misery or something other than paradise.
Indulging In Escapism Essay Research Paper Indulging
Indulging In Escapism Essay, Research Paper Indulging in Escapism In The Glass Menagerie, Tennessee Williams presents us with a Family whose lives seem to be trapped in avoiding reality instead of facing it. The play, which is much like our own lives, is constantly pointing out ways of escaping. The characters in the play each try to find there way to escape but find that they continue to tangle themselves into there problems even more.
Escape Essay Research Paper In The Glass
Escape Essay, Research Paper In The Glass Menagerie, Tennessee Williams uses the theme of escape to portray the inutility and disparity of each of the character?s dreams. The Glass Menagerie takes place in the small, ghetto apartment of the Wingfield family. Poverty is what has trapped them in their meager living quarters.
The Glass Menagerie Essay Research Paper Worlds
The Glass Menagerie Essay, Research Paper Worlds of Escape In The Glass Menagerie, Tennessee Williams creates a world in which the characters escape from the present situation. The characters, Laura, Amanda, and Tom Wingfield, achieve this by creating their own world in which they can escape to. Each world consists of an imaginary place where the feeling of security is present.
Glass Menagerie Essay Research Paper Who is
Glass Menagerie Essay, Research Paper Who is the Main Character in The Glass Menagerie Who is the main character in The Glass Menagerie ? This is the question that many people contemplate about since there is a number of characters who are fit for the part. To help figure out exactly who the main character is, think about what is a protagonist? A protagonist is defined as the principal character in a literary work or a leading actor, character, or participant in a literary work or real event.
Glass Menagerie Essay Research Paper In The
Glass Menagerie Essay, Research Paper In The Glass Menagerie, Tom Wingfield is perhaps the most prominent character. He is burdened with not only being a main character of the play but the narrator as well. He is given the unenviable task of being the voice of reason in the Wingfield house. Almost every action of his reveals an important detail about his personality and motivation.
Juvenile Justice System Essay Research Paper The
Juvenile Justice System Essay, Research Paper The German playwright, Schiller, once said that in good drama every good character is right. In this paper, I am going to discuss Schiller’s comment with regard to Amanda Wingfield, Laura Wingfield, and Tom Wingfield.
Glass Essay Research Paper The Glass Menagerie
Glass Essay, Research Paper The Glass Menagerie By: Tennessee Williams Tennessee Williams won two Pulitzer Prizes for A Streetcar Named Desire and Cat on A Hot Tin Roof. Many others believe that The Glass Menagerie deserved one as well. The Glass Menagerie (”memory play”) won the New York Drama Critics’ Circle?s award as the best play of the season.
Tennessee Williams S The Glass Menagerie Essay
, Research Paper In Tennessee Williams s original script of The Glass Menagerie, he explains that there is much to admire in Amanda, and as much to love and pity as there is to laugh at. This statement explains Tom s view of Amanda at that point in time. He feels that she admirable, lovable, capable of being laughed at, and felt pity for at the same time.
Glass Menagerie 2 Essay Research Paper Glass
Glass Menagerie 2 Essay, Research Paper Glass Menagerie Everyone has their own little world in which they indulge themselves in whether it be real or just a fantasy. In The Glass Menagerie by Tennessee Williams, everyone in the play experiences their own little world, and the shock it is to be thrown from it.
The Glass Menagerie Essay Research Paper First
The Glass Menagerie Essay, Research Paper First of all, I liked the way that The Glass Menagerie was not specifically dated. What I mean by this, is even though the play was written in the forties, today we (people in general), can still relate to some of the issues in it. Like take for example the disability issue.
Glass Menagerie 3 Essay Research Paper CHARACTER
Glass Menagerie 3 Essay, Research Paper CHARACTER S ILLUSIONS THROUGHOUT THE GLASS MENAGERIE Tennessee Williams The Glass Menagerie is about the struggle with the hardships reality throws at the characters. In this American memory play, produced in 1945, Amanda Wingfield hides from life and lives hers through separate illusions.
Glass Menagerie Essay Research Paper In Tennessee
Glass Menagerie Essay, Research Paper In Tennessee Williams’ play The Glass Menagerie, Williams uses many symbols which represent many different things. Many of the symbols used in the play try to symbolize some form of escape or a link to a world of illusion. Just a few of these are the fire escape, the movies, and even more important, Laura’s glass unicorn.
Glass Menagerie 2 Essay Research Paper
“The Glass Menagerie”, “Blue Mountain”, “The Fire Escape” and “The Unicorn” are symbols in the ” Glass Menagerie” Discuss Williams use of these symbols in the “Glass Menagerie”.
Symbolism In 2
Symbolism In “The Glass Menagerie” Essay, Research Paper Throughout “The Glass Menagerie”, Tennessee Williams utilizes a variety of symbols. The symbols create innusual vibes that make the entire play. The symbols range from the jonquils to the unicorn.
Case Study Essay Research Paper Case Study
Case Study Essay, Research Paper Case Study : Media ups and downs Summary: The Australian made midday television program ?Day time with Amanda? first aired in 1993, showing good ratings and high advertising revenue during its early stages.