Alexis De Tocqueville Essay, Research Paper
Frankly, the French have no idea of what America truly is. In Tocqueville s Democracy in America, the caustic Frenchman describes the governmental aspects of America, as well as highlighting upon some social aspects. He states the truth, however not all of Tocqueville s truths do not transcend time and are rendered obsolete in modern times. Tocqueville brings forth justified theories of aristocracy and democracy, but also presents obsolete prototypes of the American man and woman.
Tocqueville presents a biased perspective of democracy and its relation to aristocracy. He states the simple and the obvious: Democratic laws generally tend to promote the welfare of the greatest possible number; for they emanate from the majority of the citizens, whoa re subject to error but who cannot have an interest opposed to their own advantage (p.101). Tocqueville simply highlights upon the truths of democracy. In an uncontrolled environment, the greatest advantages will tend to lean toward the majority. This factor results in the absence of representation among the extreme ends of the spectrum (both social and economic) and an inundation of a median perspective. Tocqueville then contrasts this with his view on the excellence in aristocracy.
In retrospect aristocratic rule often has a negative connotation. Tocqueville attempts to justify an aristocratic theory: Aristocracies are infinitely more expert in the science of legislation than democracies can ever be. They are possessed of a self-control which protects them from the errors of temporary excitement; and they form far far-reaching designs (p.101). Tocqueville seems to be biased, and can even be considered elitist. His view of aristocracy is one of approval; he projects a view that aristocratic government is feasible and perfect. This seems to contradict what he states earlier: The laws of an aristocracy tend, on the contrary, to concentrate wealth and power in the hands of the minority, because an aristocracy by very nature, constitutes a minority (p.101). Putting absolute power in the hands of a minority appears absurd. If anything the absolute power in the hands of a minority would constitute an abuse of power. Perhaps Tocqueville construes this view because of his upbringing in the aristocratic, French setting.
Tocqueville s probable aristocratic background reflects itself on his view of American social aspects. His regard for American woman presents a contrast to aristocratic women that he has observed in his past: It is rare that an American woman, at any age, displays childish timidity or ignorance (p.234). This is contrasted by his view of European (French) women: In France Women commonly receive a reserved, retired and almost conventual education as they did in aristocratic times (p.234). The contrast between that Tocqueville makes between the two types of women is interesting. He states that American woman are more independent and free-thinking, while French woman are constrained in thinking. Tocqueville also highlights upon the goals of American men: Men living in democratic times have many passions, but most of their passions either end in the love of riches or proceed from it (p.254). This statement can be painted on American men, but can also be allotted to any man, regardless of race and transcendent of time.
Although I believe that most of Tocqueville s statements are slightly off-based, I can agree with him on his social observations. Tocqueville s presumptions of American women are correct, however in contrast to Tocqueville s negative connotation, I believe that the lack of timidity and ignorance are assets. Women are empowered in contemporary America, and I believe it has only helped us. Women carry important voices and opinions, and should not be overlooked because of their sex.
I also feel that his depiction of American men is also accurate. The one word that America fears the most is (arguably) mediocre . No one wants to grow up, and just struggle. As individuals, we want to live in luxury and comfort; no person in their right mind would want to live on the bare minimum. Although I agree with Tocqueville at this juncture, I highly attest to his concept of proficient aristocracy.
Tocqueville detests democracy, or from his work, it can be inferred that his view of democracy is condescending. His affection for aristocracy is evident, but someone skewed. Tocqueville actually makes a point that democracy will tend to give the greatest number of people the greatest number of advantages. This is true, however, if one were to have a primarily aristocratic government rule, the needs outside of this minority would suffer. The same situation can be assured if a primarily lower class government attained power. Although it may seem unfair to some minorities, the Democratic government that America employs is the only way that our population can sustain itself. Documents such as the Constitution and the division of power ascertain the power to the people, thus eliminating (or attempting to eliminate) unfairness to the minorities.
In essence, Tocqueville s negative view of America has shifted over time. What once were cases for weakness and debilitation are now achievements we pride ourselves on. Sure, the French may have the culture to set themselves apart, but in America our hard work and equality (or attempt at it) set us head and shoulders apart from every other nation. Our democracy and our drive to become achievers make America what it is today.
Другие работы по теме:
The Relationship Between Snowball And Napoleon In
Animal Farm Essay, Research Paper The relationship surrounding Snowball and Napoleon in George Orwell s Animal Farm tends to be on rocky grounds. Snowball, a clever pig, tends to be loyal, brave, and outgoing. These are just a few excellent qualities of a leader. Napoleon, a boar, on the other hand, is quite frankly rude, wretched, and full of greed.
Insights On De Tocqueville
’s Democracy In America Essay, Research Paper Insights on De Tocqueville’s Democracy In America It has been said that a French aristocrat Alexis de Tocqueville, who
The Democratic Ideal Essay Research Paper The
The Democratic Ideal Essay, Research Paper The Democratic Ideal Over one hundred years ago Alexis de Tocqueville expressed what would become the American standard when he observed “Americans were born equal without having to become so.” This ideology is also known of as the “democratic wish”: the participation of a united people pursuing a shared communal interest.
Values And Realities Of Economic Sytem In
The Communitarian And Libertarian Debate Essay, Research Paper Question 1 In America, the dominant theory that shapes both our public and private laws is the belief in Individualism. Individualism, first coined by Alexis de Tocqueville in 1838, can be described as “A calm and considered feeling which disposes each citizen to isolate oneself from the mass of one’s fellows and withdraw into the circle of family and friends; with this little society formed to suit one’s taste, each gladly leaves the greater society to look after itself.” Although this term was invented almost 50 years after the Constitution was created, the framers had this concept in mind.
Rasputin Essay Research Paper RasputinGrigory or Gregory
Rasputin Essay, Research Paper Rasputin Grigory (or Gregory) Rasputin is without question one of the most sensational figures in Russian history. This mystic from Siberia arrived in St. Petersburg in 1911 and within a few years had become one of the most influential men in government. His ability to remain in such a high position despite widely publicized periods of drinking and womanizing is no doubt, the source of great envy among political figures around the world today.
Tocqueville Essay Research Paper In the book
Tocqueville Essay, Research Paper In the book Democracy in America, Tocqueville describes why he believes democracy, especially in America, is going to turn into a despot. Tocqueville believes that despotism is going to rise in America because when the inhabitant of a democratic country compares himself individually with all those about him, he feels with pride that he is the equal of any one of them; but when he comes to survey the totality of his fellows and to place himself in contrast to so huge a body, he is instantly overwhelmed by the sense of his own insignificance and weakness (Tocqueville v2, p10).
Democracy In America Essay Research Paper Alexis
Democracy In America Essay, Research Paper Alexis de Tocqueville, “Democracy in America” “After 37 days at sea aboard Le Havre, Tocqueville and Beaumont landed in Newport, Rhode Island on May 9. The journey had been rough, and the passengers and crew had little to eat or drink during the final days. Indeed, the passengers requested that they be allowed to disembark in Newport once it became obvious that fierce winds would prevent the ship from reaching New York as scheduled.
Alexis De Tocqueville
’s Democracy In America Essay, Research Paper Alexis de Tocqueville’s visit to the United States in the early part of the nineteenth century prompted his work Democracy in America, in which he expressed the ability to make democracy work. Throughout his travels Tocqueville noted that private interest and personal gain motivated the actions of most Americans, which in turn cultivated a strong sense of individualism.
Internet Piracy Essay Research Paper In this
Internet Piracy Essay, Research Paper In this day and age where technology is rampant and advance, it is critical that we comprehend the possibilities that such technology has, no matter whether it is good or bad. From our very own households, we can now ?get connected? and experience this technology first hand.
Dante Essay Research Paper Edmund Dantes a
Dante Essay, Research Paper Edmund Dantes, a strapping young sailor, was the prime years of his life during the nineteenth century. He was a good person, was well mannered and frankly had a lot of things going for him. He was affianced to the lovely Mercedes, he captained a good ship, the Pharon, and had whom he thought been good friends.
Authenticity Essay Research Paper AuthenticityIn these days
Authenticity Essay, Research Paper Authenticity In these days and times, it is hard to find people that are authentic. Many people say things that sound good, but when it comes down to acting upon their words, its hard for them to follow through. Being authentic, in my dictionary has not only to do with telling the truth and backing their words.
The Drug War Essay Research Paper Everyday
The Drug War Essay, Research Paper Everyday someone is thrown in state prison for anywhere from 3 years to life for the “illegal” use of the drug known as marijuana. It has come down to it that thousands of pounds of marijuana are smuggled over the border of Mexico and into the United States. Regardless of the fight or struggle of people to insure the so said safety of our younger generations from the use of these drugs more and more comes into the Unites States.
Constitutionalism The Tyranny Of The Majority Essay
, Research Paper In this excerpt from Democracy in America Alexis Tocqueville expresses his sentiments about the United States democratic government. Tocqueville believes the government’s nature exists in the absolute supremacy of the majority, meaning that those citizens of the United States who are of legal age control legislation passed by the government.
Medea Essay Research Paper The play Medea
Medea Essay, Research Paper The play Medea is, quite frankly, the story of a relationship gone very bad. So bad, in fact, that it ends in a quadruple homicide. Where Jason is the abusive boyfriend to Medea, Medea is the woman Scorned to Jason. This play is a fine example of what NOT to do in a relationship. But for all the wrongs that both Jason and Medea commit throughout the play, Medea is by far the character that wreaks the most havoc upon anyone unlucky enough to be in her path at the wrong time.
Rasputin Essay Research Paper Rasputin had a
Rasputin Essay, Research Paper Rasputin had a significant impact on the royal family as well as Russia during the reign of Czar Nicholas II. Rasputin was a staret that worked his way into the royal family. The influence of Rasputin on Alexis, the heir to the throne, gave him great power. The power given to Rasputin had a notable impact among the Russian people as well as Russia.
The Last Royal Family Essay Research Paper
The story of the Last Royal Family and The Russian Revolution is a fascinating one. The last czar Nicholas II, a.k.a. Bloody Nicholas, was a guy who was a nice man to everyone. He married the daughter of Grand Duke Ludwig of Hessen, Alice Victoria Eleanor Louisa Beatrice (Alexandra). They were the people in charge at the time and were the last royal family members.
Despotism Essay Research Paper A despotism is
Despotism Essay, Research Paper A despotism is defined as a system of government in which the ruler has unlimited power. Many of the aristocratic regimes of old can arguably be labeled despotisms, as well as some of the dictatorships of today?s modern world, if one can truly define ultimate power. De Tocqueville delved into this concept in his discussion of the newly forming American democracy and how he noticed this democratic revolution making it?s way towards Europe.
Industrial Rev Essay Research Paper The Positive
Industrial Rev. Essay, Research Paper The Positive Outcome of the Industrial Revolution in Britain The industrial revolution has its share of both positive and negative effects on the society and the country as a whole. There are many aspects you must look toward, to realistically analyze the industrial revolution.
Blithe Spirit Essay Research Paper Anthony J
Blithe Spirit Essay, Research Paper Anthony J. Perrotta October 3, 1999 Blithe Spirit Frankly, I was amazed by the set of Blithe Spirit. I am not sure whether it was because I had a hand in building it and all of the skills I acquired in doing so or just the fact that it was a great set. Either way I was extremely impressed.
Alexis De Tocqueville Essay Research Paper Alexis
Alexis De Tocqueville Essay, Research Paper Alexis Charles-Henri-Maurice Cl?rel de Tocqueville En 1831 deux jeunes Fran?ais sont arriv? aux ?tats-Unis, sur un projet gouvernemental pour ?tudier le syst?me p?nal du pays. Tous les deux ?taient membres de la nobilit? fran?aise, de bons amis et tous parails.
Alexis Detocqueville Essay Research Paper Alexis de
Alexis Detocqueville Essay, Research Paper Alexis de Tocqueville Alexis de Tocqueville was born in Paris on July 29th, 1805. Growing up in Metz, France, the youngest child of Herv? Tocqueville and Mlle. De Rosanbo, he showed great intellectual promise from his earliest days. By the age of 16, his academic career was a brilliant one, his schoolwork earning him a special prize and two first prizes.
Alexis De Tocqueville 18051859 Essay Research Paper
Alexis de Tocqueville (1805-1859) Since beginning to study political science I have heard the name and read the quotes of Alexis de Tocqueville. A Frenchman, historian, political theorist, and student and writer of the French Revolution — Tocqueville has become a scholar in all democratic societies.
Political Freedom Arendt And De Tocqueville
Essay, Research Paper Political Freedom: Arendt and de Tocqueville Freedom in America emanates from the state of political freedom held by the citizens. Both Hannah Arendt and Alexis de Tocqueville provide criticism of the apparent shape freedom maintains in America as well as insight regarding how they perceive true political freedom.
Critique Of American Democracy Essay Research Paper
The introspective argument produced by Alexis De Tocqueville in his literary work entitled Democracy in America of the American democratic system is both cynical and enlightening. His prospective as a Frenchman on the bureaucracy of this nation cast new light on a government that is proclaimed to be superior then all others.
Black Panthers Essay Research Paper I
Black Panthers Essay, Research Paper : I’m not really speaking in first or second hand but… Many brothers and sisters tend to act like we deserve a break in society. The main reason because “our people” were enslaved and brought over here to the U.S. Now frankly, in my generation I did not go through what my ancestors and my older generations of family went through.
Napster Essay Research Paper Napster By Alexis
Napster Essay, Research Paper Napster By: Alexis Alexis Frank IST 333 August 9,2000 Napster In less than one year Napster has become the hot application that has some 20 million users running to their computer. Napster is currently fighting for its life against a court ordered shutdown, but it seems that people will find a way to share and downloud on line music no matter what.
Analysis Of Liberty In Society Essay Research
Paper Both Adam Smith and Alexis de Tocqueville agree that an individual is the most qualified to make decisions affecting the sphere of the individual as long as those decisions do not violate the
Peter Thegreat Essay Research Paper Peter I
Peter Thegreat Essay, Research Paper Peter I the Great 1672 – 1725 Russian Czar Peter was born in Moscow. He was joint czar with his mentally retarded half-brother, Ivan, under the regency of their sister, Sophia (1682-9). On Ivan’s death (1696) Peter became sole czar.