Absolutism And Relativism Essay, Research Paper
Absolutism and relativism are two extreme ethical approaches to reality. While
they are both valid and supported by facts, they are very contrasting in their
views. Values are what a person cares about and thinks is worthwhile. For
example, values can include life, love, religious faith, freedom, relationships,
health, justice, education, family and many other things. Usually these values
are what provides the passion in a person’s life, and gives them hope and a
reason for being. A person might go to any lengths to protect what they feel is
right and to preserve these values. Values can be divided up into two
subcategories: absolute and relative. Absolute values deal with conventional
ethics. In absolutism, everything is certain. Relativism, on the other hand, is
more subjective. It includes concepts such as utilitarianism and idealism.
Relativism stresses the idea that nothing is certain. These two ideals are
extremes when approaching reality and values. An ethical absolutist believes
that there is a single or universal moral standard that is equally applicable to
all people at all times, and each society must adhere to them. There is one
moral law, one universal code, and one eternal standard that govern all people.
Right is right and wrong is wrong; everything is black and white. There is a
distinct difference between what is "actually" right and what is
"thought" to be right. Actions are inherently good or bad, regardless
of the consequences. They also feel that if two people are in disagreement about
what is right, then obviously one of them must be mistaken, since ethical
standards are either right or wrong. Immanuel Kant and his categorical
imperative support the absolutist’s opinions. Kant, a German philosopher, was
one of the greatest thinkers of all time, and his writings are widely used to
study ethics and morality. According to him, to possess moral worth is more
important than to possess intelligence, humor, strength or any other talent of
the mind or body. He feels that moral worth has absolute value. When faced with
a moral decision, one test of a moral act is to ask oneself, "Is this the
kind of act that everyone should perform?" This question can determine
whether a given principle is moral and objective or merely subjective. Immanuel
Kant stated, "There is?but one categorical imperative, namely, this: Act
only on that maxim whereby thou canst at the same time will that it should
become a universal law" (M-WDQ). Universal principles impose categorical
imperatives that demand that a person act in a certain fashion. A categorical
imperative is unconditional and moral. For example, "Keep your
promises" or "Don’t lie". The opposite of this is the
hypothetical imperative, which is conditional on something. People who follow
Kant’s theories, Kantians, defend his principles. In his article in The New
Republic, Michael Sandel wrote, "Kant argued that empirical principles,
such as utility, were unfit to serve as basis for the moral law. A wholly
instrumental defense of freedom and rights not only leaves rights vulnerable,
but fails to respect the inherent dignity of persons" (Sandel). In the view
of modern-day Kantians, certain rights are so fundamental that even the general
welfare cannot override them. The extreme opposite of absolutism is relativism.
Relativists feel that circumstances arise that can alter cases, and make
exceptions to any rule. It is okay to have everyday standards to live by, but
exceptions are always welcome since they are right and good. The judgment of
good of bad is based upon the result of consequence of the act rather than the
act itself. Contrary to ethical absolutism, ethical relativism claims that if
two individuals disagree on a moral view, both can be right, since moral views
are not right or wrong. The two people can both be right because "Cultural
circumstances alter the way people think about their environment, thus emphasis
of moral or immoral judgment is placed on differing actions in differing
cultures" (Sherman). Relativism is subjective and seeks to gain happiness;
therefore, this ideal makes perfect sense. The article "The Paralysis of
Absolutophobia" by Robert Simon gives reasons why relativism is so
prevalent among students today. He feels that students’ have their own
individual interpretations of multiculturalism and postmodernism, and that any
criticism of another culture’s practices is a kind of cultural imperialism.
Also, because we all speak from some particular perspective, truly objective
moral knowledge is impossible to attain (Simon). In the same article Robert
Simon speaks about having absolute values. He feels that to be tolerant and
willing to consider the viewpoints and arguments of others is in itself a moral
judgment. Also, there is nothing about moral judgment that requires
inflexibility, intolerance, fanaticism or an inability to recognize that people
will disagree. And finally, Simon feels that people should replace
absolutophobia with a greater appreciation and openmindness. Part of the
relativist view deals with utilitarianism, which was supported by John Stuart
Mill. His view defends liberal principles in the name of maximizing the general
welfare. Referring to Mill’s utilitarian views, in his article, Sandel remarks,
"The state should not impose on its citizens a preferred way of life, even
for their own good, because doing so will reduce the sum of human happiness, at
least in the long run; better that people choose for themselves even if, on
occasion, they get it wrong" (Sandel). In On Liberty, Mill writes,
"The only freedom which deserves the name is that of pursuing our own good
in our own way, so long as we do not attempt to deprive others of theirs, or
impede their efforts to obtain it". In one respect, utilitarianism would
seem well suited to liberal purposes. Seeking to maximize overall happiness does
not require judging people’s values, only aggregating them. Utilitarians
sometimes defend individual right on the grounds that respecting them now will
serve utility in the long run. All of Immanuel Kant’s opinions strongly opposed
this. It is obvious that ethical absolutism and relativism are extreme
opposites. They each have strong evidence backing them up and forming separate
opinions. Even great philosophers took stands on absolutism and relativism.
Immanuel Kant supports absolutism, while J.S. Mill supports relativism. Many
people, however, feels that the best solution lies as a "happy medium"
that lies somewhere in the middle. I agree with that notion. As the saying goes,
"Moderation is key"; I don’t feel that an extreme is ever the way to
go. Relativists see happiness and idealism, which I feel is important. I also
think that it is important to seek the greatest good for the greatest number of
people. Absolutism, on the other hand, has absolute certainty. I feel it is
important to also have assured realities that you can look forward to relying
on. I disagree with the absolutist opinion that people cannot have different
views on moral issues. I think that people, depending on their experiences,
culture, age, religion, and social status have differing opinions on topics.
That is all a part of the world, and its diverse qualities and characteristics.
Halpin, James. Good Conversation: An Invitation to Moral Disclosure. Simon
& Schuster Custom Publishing. Needham, Massachusetts, 1997. Kant, Immanuel.
Merriam-Webster Dictionary of Quotations. Merriam-Webster, Inc. New York, New
York, 1992. p 15. Sandel, Michael. "Morality and the liberal ideal: must
individual rights betray the common good?". The New Republic. May 7, 1984
v190 p15 Sherman, Bob. Basic Ethics and Morals. World Wide Web: flash/~bob001/basics.html.
Simon, Robert L. "The Paralysis of Absolutophobia". From The Chronicle
of Higher Education.
Другие работы по теме:
Morality Is Culturally Relative Essay Research Paper
Within this world that we live on, there is an enormous amount of people. Each of these people belongs to different cultures and societies. Every society has traits and customs that make it unique. These societies follow different moral codes. This means that they will may have different answers to the moral questions asked by our own society.
Totalitarianism Essay Research Paper I IntroductionPrint sectionTotalitarianism
Totalitarianism Essay, Research Paper I. Introduction Print section Totalitarianism, in political science, system of government and ideology in which all social, political, economic, intellectual, cultural, and spiritual activities are subordinated to the purposes of the rulers of a state. Several important features distinguish totalitarianism, a form of autocracy peculiar to the 20th century, from such older forms as despotism, absolutism, and tyranny.
Morality Is Relative Essay Research Paper James
Morality Is Relative Essay, Research Paper James Rachels’ article, “Morality is Not Relative,” is incorrect, he provides arguments that cannot logically be applied or have no bearing on the statement of contention. His argument, seems to favor some of the ideas set forth in cultural relativism, but he has issues with other parts that make cultural relativism what it is.
Benjamin Franklin And His Views On Religion
Essay, Research Paper Benjamin Franklin, the most important figure among the anti-mystics who, more than any other man, represents the spirit of the Enlightenment movement in America. These ideas and attitudes are not harmonious, simple and unified,or totally new, but they do share a determination to break from dogmatic religion, feudal social relationships, and political absolutism.
THE MENO Essay Research Paper The Meno
THE MENO Essay, Research Paper The Meno asks the question ?what is virtue and can it be taught??. Meno?s conversation with Socrates is an attempt to know exactly what virtue means and how it can be defined to come to the decision of whether or not it
911 And JeanJacques Rousseau Essay Research Paper
L?Etat C?est Moi : Absolutism in the Age of ReasonBy analyzing the Taliban regime and their motives, Jean-Jacques Rousseau?s ideas, and by comparing the two, it will be made evident that Jean-Jacques Rousseau?s ideas of government rule over people?s lives is true in this specific case.
Baroque Art Essay Research Paper The baroque
Baroque Art Essay, Research Paper The baroque has been called a theatrical style, one that deals in spectacle, grandeur, and dramatic contrast. Test these concepts in an essay that discusses the baroque as an expression of the Catholic Reformation, Protestant devotionalism, the Scientific Revolution, and the Age of Absolutism.
French Revolution 4 Essay Research Paper The
French Revolution 4 Essay, Research Paper The causes of the French Revolution, being provoked by this collision of the powers of the rising bourgeoise and an sinking aristocracy defending its privileges, was the Financial debt of the government and the long-standing political differences in the government.
Richelieu Essay Research Paper RichelieuRichelieu was a
Richelieu Essay, Research Paper Richelieu Richelieu was a French cardinal and statesman, who more than anyone else promoted absolutism in France and laid the foundations of the country’s 17th-century grandness. He was born in Paris on September 9, 1585, and set out on a military career. In order to retain the bishopric of Lu on in the family, however, Richelieu switched to theology and at age 22 was ordained a bishop.
Socrates Arguments Regarding Moral Conventionalism Essay Research
Paper In assessing the validity of Socrates? arguments regarding moral conventionalism, Plato presents a multitude of premises on which Socrates? argument is based. These premises both support and weaken Socrates? beliefs against Sophist teachings. Using The Crito and The Apology, it is relatively easy to understand Socrates? reasoning in opposing the sophistic position of moral relativism.
Gns Vs Italian Fascism Essay Research Paper
Fascism is a relative latecomer onto the scene of political ideologies, and according to a few a rather short lived one. The creator of fascism is without a question Benito Mussolini. Although he never wrote a definitive doctrine on what fascism is, he did explain the main concepts of his ideology, Absolutism, Organicism, and Irrationality.
What Arguments Did The Supporters And Opponents
Of Absolutism Use To Defend Their Respective Positions Essay, Research Paper During the 17th century the leaders of France and England wanted absolute rule. Both countries wanted absolutism in the form of a Monarchy, with the king being the single ruler. However, France succeeded and obtained absolutism but England was forced into a more constitutional form of government where multiple political institutions ruled.
Absolutism And Limited Government Essay Research Paper
Absolutism and Limited Government Thomas Hobbes and John Locke set up the basis for the two major forms of government in the 17th century. Hobbes believed that the only successful government would be an absolute monarchy. Locke believed in a limited monarchy form of government. Both of these systems were practiced over many years preceding their writings.
Cultural Relativism Vs Ethnocentrism Essay Research Paper
Cultural Relativism VS Ethnocentrism Sexuality, in the Western World, has been a taboo for hundreds of years (essentially from the time of the Roman Empire), however, it has always been openly discussed and practiced in other parts of the world. A cultural relativist would look at different cultures and their habits and practices, and he would not judge them as being wrong.
Cultural Relativism Essay Research Paper Topic 1
Cultural Relativism Essay, Research Paper Topic 1: Cultural Relativism Cultural relativism, as defined by Ruth Benedict in her article A Defense of Cultural Relativism, is the theory that human morality is based on the society in which an individual is a part of. The basis of a society?s morality comes from cultural traditions, habits, and what the majority believes to be right and wrong.
Cultural Relativism Essay Research Paper The thesis
Cultural Relativism Essay, Research Paper The thesis of meta-ethical cultural relativism is the philosophical viewpoint that there are no absolute moral truths, only truths relative to the cultural context in which they exist. From this it is therefore presumed that what one society considers to be morally right, another society may consider to be morally wrong, therefore, moral right’s and wrongs are only relative to a particular society.
Abolute Monarchs Essay Research Paper ABSOLUTE MONARCHS
Abolute Monarchs Essay, Research Paper ABSOLUTE MONARCHS During the middle of the seventeen century and early eighteen century, the system of central authority was established. King Louis XIV (Sun King), Frederick William (The Elector), and Tsar Peter I (The Great) their achievements, policies, and similarities were in view of obtaining desired goals.
French Revolution Essay Research Paper The French
French Revolution Essay, Research Paper The French Revolution began on 1789. It is the most darkest period of France s history, blended with confusion and chaos which many innocent victims were killed or
Thomas Hobbes John Locke And Montesquieu Essay
, Research Paper Many men and women had significant impacts on the historical period known as the Enlightenment. Three men that had such an impact on the Enlightenment were Thomas Hobbes, John Locke, and Montesquieu. Each of these men had different theories and ideas about what type of government there should be.
Thomas Hobbes And John Locke Essay Research
Paper Ever since the two men themselves walked the Earth, there has been considerably debate as to whether the political thought of Thomas Hobbes or John Locke was closer to the truth. Hobbes, characterized as the “Apologist for Absolutism” in The Western Heritage, believed that the natural state of man was one of continuous competition and would generally be “solitary, poor, nasty, brutish and short.” Therefore, he believed in a strong absolute monarch to keep the people under control.
The European Enlightenment Essay Research Paper Western
The European Enlightenment Essay, Research Paper Western Civilization The European Enlightenment Researchers show the European Enlightenment came about as the result of the new natural science ideas of Isaac Newton, the political and social theories of great thinkers like Hobbes, and the psychology of John Locke.
The Enlightenment 2 Essay Research Paper 2
The Enlightenment 2 Essay, Research Paper “The Enlightenment” The period of the Enlightenment is dated to the middle of the eighteenth century and is primarily about the changes in the worldview of European culture. The term Enlightenment refers to a series of changes in European thought and writings. When writers, philosophers, and scientists of the eighteenth century referred to their activities as the Enlightenment, they meant that they were breaking from the past and replacing the obscurity, darkness, and ignorance of European thought with the light of truth.
Absolutism Essay Research Paper AbsolutismAbsolutism or absolute
Absolutism Essay, Research Paper Absolutism Absolutism or absolute monarchy is the form of government where the king possesses complete control of the government and people in his country; the king’s word is law. Many factors lead to Absolute Monarchy in France, and the style of Absolute Monarchy under Louis XIV differed from traditional Absolute Monarchy.
Absolutism In France And England Essay Research
Paper Absolutism in the Seventeenth Century In the latter half of the 1600’s, monarchial systems of both England and France were changing. In England, the move was away from an absolute monarch, and toward a more powerful Parliament. In France, the opposite was happening as Louis XIV strengthened his own office while weakening the general assembly of France, the Estates General.
Absolute Monarchs Essay Research Paper An absolute
Absolute Monarchs Essay, Research Paper An absolute monarch is a ruler whose power is unlimited, this is known as absolutism. This essay will discuss the characteristics of absolutism and how they affected 17th century absolute monarchs.
MetaEthical Position Essay Research Paper My
?Meta-Ethical? Position Essay, Research Paper My ‘Meta-ethical’ Position When asked the question “Are there any ethical truths?” I respond with a resounding “Yes” and when asked “What makes the ethical truths true?” I respond “Facts independent of anyone’s say-so”. That makes me an ethical realist. I reject all forms of conventionalism and also subjectivism.
Cultural Absolutism Essay Research Paper Take Me
Cultural Absolutism Essay, Research Paper Take Me Out to the Ballgame? I awaited the day before the big game in nervous apprehension. Would the Red Sox be able to rebound from a 0-2 series deficit and advance to face the Yankees? They had already won two straight games and evened the series at 2-2. The next game would be the do or die situation.
Untitled Essay Research Paper Essay IRelativism The
Untitled Essay, Research Paper Essay I Relativism: The Tangible Theory Since the beginning of rational thought, philosophers have searched for the true meaning of morality. Many theorists have attempted to answer this question with
Absolutism And Peter The Great Essay Research
Paper Absolutism and Peter the Great Many monarchs, particularly those of European descent, employed the flourishing absolutist philosophy during their reign in the seventeenth century. Defined as the “absolute or unlimited rule usually by one man,” absolutism is virtually equivalent to the philosophy of despotism.
Louis Xiv Essay Research Paper Jeff NataleEarly
Louis Xiv Essay, Research Paper Jeff Natale Early Modern Europe Prof. Taravella The Age of Absolutism The Age of Absolutism is the period of the seventeenth and eighteenth centuries. Most states in Europe had monarchs who wished to create absolute authority, France had the best system of absolute monarchy because they were able to create a central royal political system.
Absolutism In France Essay Research Paper King
Absolutism In France Essay, Research Paper King Louis XIV of France tamed the nobility by making them the only ones that knew how to behave in the king’s society at Versailles. Thus allowing him the power to grant positions to aristocracy without truly yielding any political power. Louis was a very strict king, and gave up luxuries for beauty.
Ethical Relativism Essay Research Paper Ethical RelativismCannibalism
Ethical Relativism Essay, Research Paper Ethical Relativism Cannibalism, what do you think of it? Is it morally correct? Does the theory of ethical relativism support it or does it knock it down? Throughout this paper I am going to evaluate the pros and cons of ethical relativism for a case concerning cannibalism.
Absolutism And Louis Xiv Essay Research Paper
Absolutism and Louis XIV Louis XIV of France had had both a long and powerful reign on the throne. He was able to achieve this due to the development of absolutism in France. Absolutism is defined as the political idea that absolute power should be vested in a single ruler. The whole idea of absolutism originally came from philosopher Jean Bodin in the 16th Century.