Cultural Relativism Essay, Research Paper
Topic 1: Cultural Relativism
Cultural relativism, as defined by Ruth Benedict in her article A Defense of Cultural Relativism, is the theory that human morality is based on the society in which an individual is a part of. The basis of a society?s morality comes from cultural traditions, habits, and what the majority believes to be right and wrong. Benedict uses her anthropological studies to support her ideas concerning cultural relativism. The theory of cultural relativism is criticized and questioned by many; and it is considered one of the weakest arguments pertaining to the basis of morality. Some of these criticisms come from William Shaw in his paper Relativism in Ethics. In his paper, Shaw sets out to prove that Cultural Relativism is not a strong enough theory on which to base the existence of human morality. In this paper I will discuss the ideas of cultural relativism and the problems with them. Whether cultural relativism is a viable basis for morality or not, society must play some roll in determining the way people act and perceive right and wrong.
Cultural relativism as an explanation for the morals of human beings is a logical and convincing idea. According to the theory, people base their individual thoughts, actions and beliefs on the morals of the society in which they are a part. The individual builds their own morality around what society believes is good, bad, right or wrong. Society sets its own morals by choosing a direction in one way or another on a certain belief. This belief is then incorporated into society and becomes the norm. Anything not considered to be moral is tossed aside and considered to be abnormal. This is what the theory of cultural relativism is based on. It is an explanation of why different societies have different ideas concerning morals.
According to Ruth Benedict, the normality of a society is defined by its culture as what is good and abnormality as what is bad. This in turn defines what is socially acceptable and unacceptable in a society. Views as to what is good and what is bad changes from culture to culture. For example, the society in which we live believes it is morally acceptable to eat animals, and we see no harm in that. Another society might believe that the eating of animals is inhumane and thus immoral. The two societies disagree as to what is right or wrong, moral or immoral on the behavior of eating animals, and cultural relativism explains why. The norms of a society are the standards by which to live. Those who live their lives within the moral boundaries of society are accepted and viewed as a good, moral people. Those who do not conform to the norms of society are seen as outcasts and are not accepted by the whole of society. As cultural relativism explains, a person who does not follow the norms of one society may well fit into another society where their views are more socially acceptable.
Ruth Benedict?s argument supporting cultural relativism is a convincing explanation of the morality of individuals. Be it convincing or not, the idea of cultural relativism is a weak view of the basis of morality. Arguments opposed to cultural relativism are set forth by William Shaw in his paper Relativism in Ethics. Shaw concludes with the dismissal of cultural relativism as a valid theory of the explanation of social morals.
Shaw starts out in his paper with the explanation of cultural relativism, much like I have previously, explaining the basis of the theory. He then points out several arguments that question the theory of cultural relativism. The first opposition introduced by Shaw is the question ?What proportion of a society must believe in a certain behavior or idea to make it moral?? In cultural relativism, what is believed to be right or wrong is a standard set by what the majority believes is right or wrong. The minority of a society can never be right unless it can convince the majority to agree with them. Shaw goes on asking what makes up a majority? Is there a set percentage of people that have to agree on something to make it moral or immoral? If that percentage is set high then it will be difficult meeting the criteria of a moral majority. One example Shaw gives has to do with abortion. If 75% of people are needed to make a behavior (in this case abortion) or belief right, what happens if say only 60% of society condone abortion? The majority of society believes that abortion is morally permissible, but it is still wrong because the majority did not reach the criteria of 75%. If the majority of society is overwhelming on an issue then the question becomes less of a problem. In contrast to having a high standard for a majority is setting a low one. If a majority is considered to be 51% of the people then the problem of moral ?flip-flopping?, as Shaw calls it, becomes a problem. One year 51% of people think abortion is good and therefore moral. The next year only 49% of people agree with abortion making it immoral. The issue of abortion in society can and probably will continue to change as time goes on. This is one example of a problem with majority rules in the theory of cultural relativism.
Another question raised by Shaw concerning the relevance of cultural relativism is ?what defines a society?? According to Shaw we are all a part of several different societies. For example, I am a member of the society of the United States, the society of the University of Minnesota, and my own social society consisting of my friends. Each of these individual societies share the majority of the morals that I follow, but they all have several of their own individual moral standards not shared with the others. Which society that I am a part of sets the standards of right and wrong that I am to live up to? The relativist would say that each society that I am a part of is right in its own way, even though I may be getting inconsistent moral ideals from each society.
Shaw concludes that cultural relativism is ?false as a theory of normative ethics?. He states that the questions he set forth are not to refute relativism but to seek answers. Answers a relativist, such as Ruth Benedict, can not give. According to Shaw, relativists maintain that society sets the ideas of what is right and wrong and ?this is the only standard by which an individual?s actions can be judged?. Shaw goes on to contend that not only does a relativist avoid giving a decent reason in support of their theory, cultural relativism does not coincide with our values of morality. A relativist believes that whatever a society considers to be right and moral is right and moral for them. Shaw concludes his article by saying ??it seems clear that a society that applauded random torture of children would be immoral, even if it thought such a practice was right. It would simply be mistaken, and disastrously so.? With this statement, Shaw states his disagreement with ethical relativism.
After reading the two articles I used to write this paper I feel I got a good understanding of the concept of cultural relativism. When I first read Ruth Benedict?s article supporting cultural relativism I was sold. I have always believed that the morals individuals hold are a direct result of the society they are a part of day in and day out. People want to do what is right so that they can play a productive and respectful roll in society. If a person did not abide by the social standards in a society it would be hard to be respected. After reading the second article, this one written by William Shaw, my belief in cultural relativism was in question. Shaw pointed out several key arguments that really made the idea of cultural relativism lose its black and white simplicity that Benedict proposed in her article.
Even though I do not believe that cultural relativism should be accepted as a theory on which to base the way we live; I do believe that society plays some roll in the way we live our lives. Cultural Relativism is too simple of a theory on which to base the entire existence of human morals on. I believe that people for the most part act the way society wants them to act. If people did not follow socially acceptable standards they would not function well in the society. This would be undesirable for both the individual and the society. This is what society is all about and what makes it work. If everyone followed their own ideas of what is moral and immoral society could not function. I believe that morals come from more than one source and no one thing can be given credit for the morals an individual possesses. Society may play a roll in the morality of human beings, but it does not account for all morality as claimed in the theory of cultural relativism.
Другие работы по теме:
What Is Science Essay Research Paper What
What Is Science Essay, Research Paper What is Science? Several dictionary definitions of science in Merriam-Webster’s Collegiate Dictionary define science as a system of knowledge about a specific topic. The systems come from systematic, or precise, observations of natural events; a random example would be the study of the movement of a caterpillar.
Mystification Essay Research Paper Mystification
Mystification Essay, Research Paper Mystification According to McNeil, mystification is a technique used by teachers who are not fully informed on the topic in which they are instructed to teach. Teachers
Morality Is Relative Essay Research Paper James
Morality Is Relative Essay, Research Paper James Rachels’ article, “Morality is Not Relative,” is incorrect, he provides arguments that cannot logically be applied or have no bearing on the statement of contention. His argument, seems to favor some of the ideas set forth in cultural relativism, but he has issues with other parts that make cultural relativism what it is.
Sexual Abuse Essay Research Paper I have
Sexual Abuse Essay, Research Paper I have decided to do my paper on the repression of sexual abuse in adults. In my research though I came across a lot of things that I didn?t agree on.
Moral Universalism Essay Research Paper Moral Universalism
Moral Universalism Essay, Research Paper Moral Universalism should be a worldview. I believe that it would be better for the human race to live in a world where moral universalism is the accepted worldview. I believe this because moral universalism almost offers the world a moral view that has no conflicts, no differences and has no bias.
Ethnocentrism And Cultural Relativity Essay Research Paper
It is always troublesome not to understand another culture, especially, in New York City where we live in a society that is rapidly changing. The City has increasingly brought people of various cultures, to interact closer with each other. This interaction can be either positive or negative depending on the level of sensitivity and respect people have for other culture groups.
Treatment Of The Prisoners In The Concentration
Camps Essay, Research Paper Interdisciplinary Research Research Proposal The Treatment of the Prisoners in the Concentration Camps The topic that I plan to focus on in my research paper is treatment inside different concentration camps during the Holocaust. I plan to focus on three different camps, but I have not narrowed down my choices yet.
Gun Control Essay Research Paper Topic
Gun Control Essay, Research Paper Topic: Gun regulation 1. Do you believe firearms should be banned all together including police and military? 2. Do you believe firearms should be banned from civilians only?
Socrates Arguments Regarding Moral Conventionalism Essay Research
Paper In assessing the validity of Socrates? arguments regarding moral conventionalism, Plato presents a multitude of premises on which Socrates? argument is based. These premises both support and weaken Socrates? beliefs against Sophist teachings. Using The Crito and The Apology, it is relatively easy to understand Socrates? reasoning in opposing the sophistic position of moral relativism.
Archeo Essay Research Paper A Cross Cultural
Archeo Essay, Research Paper A Cross Cultural Perspective of Polygyny As an institution, polygyny, the social arrangement that permits a man to have more than one wife at the same
Essay Writing Essay Research Paper email 7cdgqlinkqueensucaEssay
Essay Writing Essay, Research Paper email: 7cdg@qlink.queensu.caEssay Writing An essay is a literary composition. The purpose of a good formal essay is to try out an idea, thesis, or opinion, within the confines of a proper literary composition. To do this successfully one must know their topic, formulate a thesis, and finally write the essay.
Group Work Outline Essay Research Paper Group
Group Work Outline Essay, Research Paper Group Conflict Resolution Annotated Outline I. Introduction In this section, we will state our topic, which is group conflict resolution. We will present the subtopics we will focus on in the paper. We will briefly tie the four subtopics into each other under the umbrella topic of group conflict resolution.
Ethnocentrism At The Top Of The World
Essay, Research Paper In Hans Ruesch’s novel The Top of the World the author describes the life of the polar Eskimos (Inuits) in depth. The main focus of the novel is to show the differences between their culture and ours, and how the introduction of the white mans customs changed their way of life. The concepts of ethnocentrism and cultural relativism are major themes in The Top of the World.
Global Warming Effects Essay Research Paper How
Global Warming Effects Essay, Research Paper How the World is changing due to the effects caused by Global Warming The reason for this topic is our increasingly changing climate. Every year our climate
Religious Edu Essay Research Paper Teacher
Religious Edu Essay, Research Paper Teacher: Raymen E. Grade Level: 6th Date: 08/26/00 Lesson Plan Book One ? Exploring and Discovering. Topic One ? Mapping the world.
Multifaceted Background
– University Of Illinois Essay, Research Paper Writing a self-reflective tirade is perhaps one of the most difficult tasks to perform. I have found myself pondering this topic for an unusually long time; no one has ever asked me to write about my culture– the one thing about myself which I understand the least.
Cultural Relativism Vs Ethnocentrism Essay Research Paper
Cultural Relativism VS Ethnocentrism Sexuality, in the Western World, has been a taboo for hundreds of years (essentially from the time of the Roman Empire), however, it has always been openly discussed and practiced in other parts of the world. A cultural relativist would look at different cultures and their habits and practices, and he would not judge them as being wrong.
Cultural Relativism Essay Research Paper The thesis
Cultural Relativism Essay, Research Paper The thesis of meta-ethical cultural relativism is the philosophical viewpoint that there are no absolute moral truths, only truths relative to the cultural context in which they exist. From this it is therefore presumed that what one society considers to be morally right, another society may consider to be morally wrong, therefore, moral right’s and wrongs are only relative to a particular society.
Mythology Essay Research Paper What is mythology
Mythology Essay, Research Paper What is mythology? Mythology is like a fib that started many years ago in the olden days. It is still around due to people still continuing to use a myth as the truth. They seem to not know the difference between a myth and a legend. People these days are so naive it is ashame to know the rate of people that actually believe those myths.
A Critique Of Cultural Relativism Essay Research
Paper A critique of cultural relativism In his article “Cultural relativism and cultural values”, Melville Herkovits defines the principle of cultural relativism as “judgements are based on experience, and experience is interpreted by each individual in terms of his own enculturation” (26). This is the basic premise of cultural relativism, that beliefs, values, and morals are all based on one’s culture.
Moral Standards Essay Research Paper ARE MORAL
Moral Standards Essay, Research Paper ARE MORAL STANDARDS ?RELATIVE?? Ethics are moral principles or values that specify acceptable conduct, and determine how an institution will be governed. According to Shanahan and Wang, in their book Reason and Insight, the subject of ethics is morality, which is concerned with the practices, judgments, principles, and beliefs that guide people?s actions.
Crosscultural Communication Barriers Essay Research Paper Thesis
Cross-cultural Communication Barriers Essay, Research Paper Thesis: A number of different factors contribute to cross-cultural communication barriers. This thesis will be proven through the examination of Canada?s past history, current policies and future plans concerning immigration and assimilation of immigrants into Canadian society.
MetaEthical Position Essay Research Paper My
?Meta-Ethical? Position Essay, Research Paper My ‘Meta-ethical’ Position When asked the question “Are there any ethical truths?” I respond with a resounding “Yes” and when asked “What makes the ethical truths true?” I respond “Facts independent of anyone’s say-so”. That makes me an ethical realist. I reject all forms of conventionalism and also subjectivism.
Interracial Relationships Today Essay Research Paper Please
Interracial Relationships Today Essay, Research Paper Please cut and pastIn today?s society interracial relationships are more prevalent than ever before. When we view interracial relationships more closely we are able to create an individual opinion based on our own cultural upbringing. We will look at interracial relationships from a cultural relativists perspective, as well as, an ethno centrist?s point of view.
Untitled Essay Research Paper Essay IRelativism The
Untitled Essay, Research Paper Essay I Relativism: The Tangible Theory Since the beginning of rational thought, philosophers have searched for the true meaning of morality. Many theorists have attempted to answer this question with
Ethical Relativism Essay Research Paper Ethical RelativismCannibalism
Ethical Relativism Essay, Research Paper Ethical Relativism Cannibalism, what do you think of it? Is it morally correct? Does the theory of ethical relativism support it or does it knock it down? Throughout this paper I am going to evaluate the pros and cons of ethical relativism for a case concerning cannibalism.
Writing Creatively Essay Research Paper Writing CreativelyCreative
Writing Creatively Essay, Research Paper Writing Creatively Creative writing is used to help regular expository writing become more interesting. You can use creative writing to do many tasks to help compose your paper. For instance, use this technique to select and narrow down your chose of topic. You can also generate and ideas, research ideas, and organize the ideas into a thesis.