Analogy Essay, Research Paper
analogy
Similarity in several respects between discrete cases. A logical argument
by analogy relies upon an inductive inference from the supposition that things
are similar is certain known respects to the likelihood that they are also similar in
some further unknown respect.
Example: “Jennifer enjoys listening to the music of Beethoven,
Mahler, and Bartok. Susan and Harold also like Beethoven, Mahler, and
Bartok. Chris enjoys listening to Beethoven and Mahler. Therefore, Chris
would probably like the music of Bartok, too.”
The degree of reliability achieved by such an argument depends upon the
extent and nature of the similarities that hold between the instances in its
premises and the new case in its conclusion.
Also see DPM, Keith J. Holyoak and Paul Thagard, Allison Barnes and
Paul Thagard, and Am?lie Frost Benedikt.
Analogical Reasoning
The simplest variety of inductive reasoning is argument by analogy, which takes note
of the fact that two or more things are similar in some respects and concludes that they are
probably also similar in some further respect. Not every analogy is an argument; we
frequently use such comparisons simply to explain or illustrate what we mean. But
arguments by analogy are common, too.
Suppose, for example, that I am thinking about buying a new car. I’m very likely to
speak with other people who have recently bought new cars, noting their experiences with
various makes, models, and dealers. If I discover that three of my friends have recently
bought Geo Prizms from Burg and that all three have been delighted with their purchases,
then I will conclude by analogy that if I buy a Geo Prizm from Burg, I will be delighted, too.
Evaluating Analogies
Of course, this argument is not deductively valid; it is always possible that my new car
may turn out to be an exception. But there are several considerations that clearly matter in
determining the relative strength or weakness of my inductive inference:
1.Number of instances. If five friends instead of three report their satisfaction with
the model I intend to buy, that tends to make it even more likely that I will be satisfied,
too. In general, more instances strengthen an analogy; fewer weaken it.
2.Instance variety. If my three friends bought their Prizms from three different
dealers but were all delighted, then my conclusion is somewhat more likely to be true,
no matter where I decide to buy mine. In general, the more variety there is among the
instances, the stronger the analogical argument becomes.
3.Number of similarities. If my new purchase is not only the same make and model
from the same dealer but also has the same engine, then my conclusion is more likely
to be true. In general, the more similarities there are between the instances and my
conclusion, the better for the analogical argument.
4.Relevance. Of course, the criteria we’re considering apply only if the matters with
which they are concerned are relevant to the argument. Ordinarily, for example, we
would assume that the day of the week on which a car was purchased is irrelevant to
a buyer’s satisfaction with it. But relevance is not something about which we can be
terribly precise; it is always possible in principle to tell a story in the context of which
anything may turn out to be relevant. So we just have to use our best judgment in
deciding whether or not some respect deserves to be considered.
5.Number of dissimilarities. If my friends all bought Geos with automatic
transmissions and I plan to buy a Geo with a standard transmission, then the
conclusion that I will be delighted with my purchase is a little less likely to be true. In
general, the fewer dissimilarities between instances and conclusion, the better an
analogical argument is.
6.Modesty of conclusion. If all three of my friends were delighted with their auto
purchases but I conclude only that I will be satisfied with mine, then this relatively
modest conclusion is more likely to be true. In general, arguments by analogy are
improved when their conclusions are modest with respect to their premises.
?1997, 1998, 1999 Garth Kemerling.
Questions, comments, and suggestions may be sent to:
gkemerling@delphi
Inductive Inferences
When an argument claims merely that the truth of its premises make it likely or
probable that its conclusion is also true, it is said to involve an inductive inference. The
standard of correctness for inductive reasoning is much more flexible. An inductive
argument succeeds if its premises provide some legitimate evidence or support for the truth
of its conclusion. Although it is therefore reasonable to accept the truth of that conclusion, it
would not be completely inconsistent to withhold judgment or even to deny it.
Inductive arguments, then, may meet their standard to a greater or to a lesser degree,
depending upon the amount of support they supply. No inductive argument is absolutely
perfect or entirely useless, although one may be said to be relatively better or worse than
another in the sense that it recommends its conclusion with a higher or lower degree of
probability. In such cases, relevant additional information often affects the reliability of an
inductive argument by providing other evidence of the likelihood of the conclusion.
It should be possible to differentiate arguments of these two sorts with some accuracy
already. Remember that deductive arguments claim to guarantee their conclusions, while
inductive arguments merely recommend theirs. Or ask yourself whether the introduction of
any additional information, without changing or denying any of the premises, could make the
conclusion seem more or less likely; if so, the pattern of reasoning is inductive.
Truth and Validity
Since deductive reasoning requires such a strong relationship between premises and
conclusion, we will spend the majority of this survey studying various patterns of deductive
inference. It is therefore worthwhile to consider the standard of correctness for deductive
arguments in some detail.
A deductive argument is valid when the inference from premises to conclusion is
perfect:
If the premises of a valid argument are true, then its conclusion must also be true.
It is impossible for the conclusion of a valid argument to be false while its premises
are true.
(Considering the premises as a set of propositions, we will say that the premises are true
only when each and every one of those propositions is true.) Any deductive argument that is
not valid is invalid: it is possible for its conclusion to be false while its premises are true, so
even if the premises are true, the conclusion may be either true or false.
Notice that the validity of the inference of a deductive argument is independent of the
truth of its premises; both conditions must be met in order to be sure of the truth of the
conclusion. Out of eight distinct possible combinations here, only one is ruled out:
Premises
Inference
Conclusion
True
Valid
True
XXXX
Invalid
True
False
False
Valid
True
False
Invalid
True
False
The only thing that cannot happen is for a deductive argument to have true premises and a
valid inference but a false conclusion.
Some logicians designate the combination of true premises and a valid inference as a
sound argument; it is a piece of reasoning whose conclusion must be true. The trouble with
every other case, in which either one of the premises is false or the inference is invalid or
both, is that it gets us nowhere. The conclusions of such arguments may be either true or
false, so they are entirely useless in any effort to gain new information.
?1997, 1998, 1999 Garth Kemerling.
Questions, comments, and suggestions may be sent to:
gkemerling@delphi
Другие работы по теме:
Television Candy For The Mind Essay
, Research Paper A man once said, “Televevision is candy for the mind.” He was right. Making an analogy to candy is ideal ; either, if taken in excess can have a negative affect on the human. At one point or another you watched too much TV. And at one point or another you ate too much candy. Maybe it was on Halloween or Christmas…it doesn’t matter.
Leguin
’s Omelas Essay, Research Paper Living out Omelas In Le Guin s The Ones Who Walk Away from Omelas, we find ourselves faced with a moral dilemma. What is it that we as people base our happiness on? The idea of societal and personal happiness is played out through the analogy of Omelas and the abandoned child. In this story, we are drawn into Le Guin s world by use of her vivid descriptions.
Censorship Essay Research Paper The negative messages
Censorship Essay, Research Paper The negative messages kids receive via the media have a damaging affect on their psyche and can create serious societal problems. In truth “[t]he violence to which American children are exposed in the name of
F Scott Fitzgerald Essay Research Paper Jeremy
F. Scott Fitzgerald Essay, Research Paper Jeremy A. Griffin Fitzgerald Literary Analogy Winter Dreams hits closer to home. In fact, it is one of the few Fitzgerald stories obviously set in and around White Bear Lake, the summer playground of Saint Paul’s elite. Dexter Green first encounters Judy Jones when he is caddying at her club.
Mocking Bird Essay Research Paper To kill
Mocking Bird Essay, Research Paper To kill a mockingbird Harper Lee This book is not only recommended by me, but it is, in fact, named the best book of the century.
Persuasion Essay Research Paper Why Jerry Rockwoods
Persuasion Essay, Research Paper Why Jerry Rockwood?s Essay ?Life Intrudes? is Effective Jerry Rockwood?s reflective essay ?Life Intrudes? is effective because of the way in which he has constructed the piece. He uses the four Reflective Strategies that are derived from Reading Critically, Writing Well by Axelrod and Cooper.
Thing Fall Apart Essay Research Paper Things
Thing Fall Apart Essay, Research Paper Things fall apart All the cultures in a bigger or smaller grade had always been under the possibility of colonization. Even today where there is a greater control and knowledge about the territories we still see some powerful country trying to colonize other. In the book by Chinua Achebe “Things Fall Apart” we see how the English people in the name of the Queen of England try to colonize small African villages.
Every Day Use Essay Research Paper 2
Every Day Use Essay, Research Paper “Everyday Use” by Alice Walker, written in 1944, narrates the story of black family composed of a Mother and her two daughters: Maggie and Dee. Dee is the oldest one. A point that we can easily notice as the story is developed is that Maggie is extremely jealous of her sister.
Philosophy Of Mind Essay Research Paper In
Philosophy Of Mind Essay, Research Paper In this paper I plan to show that Searle is correct in claiming that his Chinese Room Analogy shows that any Turing machine simulation of human understanding of
Defending Materialism Essay Research Paper Defending MaterialismDualism
Defending Materialism Essay, Research Paper Defending Materialism Dualism means the complete separation of the mental world and the physical world. In philosophy, it is the theory that the world is explicable only as a world composed of two distinct and mutually exclusive factors: the mind and the body.
Doctrine Of Creation Essay Research Paper Doctrine
Doctrine Of Creation Essay, Research Paper Doctrine of creation ‘What do we mean by creation? How helpful are making, emanation and/or artistic work as analogies? Is it a doctrine about the world’s beginnings or origin, or about its present or future existence, or what?
The Sculptress Essay Research Paper Olive Martin
The Sculptress Essay, Research Paper Olive Martin was sentenced to life for killing and dismembering her mother and sister, earning herself the nickname the Sculptress. The way in which she mutilated the bodies was horrific but in a crude sense artistic (like a Sculptress). In addition, Olive is also dubbed “the Sculptress” for the crude wax and clay figures she moulds in her cell of imaginary people as well as people she is familiar with (pg 97).
The Animal Farm Essay Research Paper George
The Animal Farm Essay, Research Paper George Orwell s, The Animal Farm, depicts how power can corrupt society. If one person receives too much power, one will most likely lead up to dictatorship. To exemplify this idea, Orwell uses a farm to represent a society and the animals inside to portray the people. Orwell s use of the pigs and animals are also an analogy that people sometimes act as mindless pigs .
Plato Essay Research Paper The Use of
Plato Essay, Research Paper The Use of Dialectic to Define Justice Through the use of Socratic dialogue, Plato has an advantage at obtaining answers by refuting other philosophers. Plato is able to achieve an answer to the question, what is justice. He derives this answer through an analogy of the ideal city.
Bc Speech Assignment Essay Research Paper Research
Bc Speech Assignment Essay, Research Paper Research Assignment #4 Your fourth speech is a research-based persuasive speech. Since your primary goal will be to convince your audience to take a specific action your research burden is higher. Your research is due via email on the date listed on your course schedule.
Question Can A Person Perform Evil Acts
Voluntarily? Essay, Research Paper Question: Can a person perform evil acts voluntarily? ?Evil corrupts the evil doer.? ?Is there anyone, then, who wishes to be harmed by those he associates with, rather than to be benefited?? In defending himself against accusations of corruption and evil, Socrates argues in his apology that no person performs evil acts voluntarily.
Perception Essay Research Paper All perception of
Perception Essay, Research Paper All perception of truth is the detection of an analogy; we reason from our hands to our heads. This statement can be interpreted in many ways but I m going to try to analyze this from the Judaic point of view. According to the Biblical text also known as Torah everything that a person perceives has meaning and can be referred back to the Torah.
Nature In Emerson Essay Research Paper Analogy
Nature In Emerson Essay, Research Paper Analogy of Nature Ralph Waldo Emerson explores the intricate tie amongst nature, man, and language. His function is to define reason and understanding through nature. Emerson uses the analogy between mans life and the transformation he finds through his soul. He changes the idea of logic and reason, but its meaning remains similar.
Tweedledee Essay Research Paper In defining the
Tweedledee Essay, Research Paper In defining the analogy of Tweedledum to Tweedledee with that of the major political parties we must look at their relationship with each other. They are similar, foolish, stubborn and argue for augments sake. The analogy of Tweedledum and Tweedledee does hold true for our major parties.
Life Vs Death Essay Research Paper Life
Life Vs Death Essay, Research Paper Life verses Death You listen to the speeches, they draw up the ballot, and you vote. Simple you say? I hope you don t. The matter always depends on what is on that ballot. What if the ballot read: Should the Death Penalty be used to dispose of harmful criminals? Having a hard time on which box to check? Have you ever realized the irony involved when a convicted criminal is put to death? Most of the supports see this, and delight in the “eye for an eye” mentality.
King Lear Essay Research Paper King LearIn
King Lear Essay, Research Paper King Lear In the play King Lear written by William Shakespeare a collection of images are used to express different points Shakespeare is trying to relay to his audience. One reoccurring image that kept popping up was animal images. Shakespeare displays these animal images when King Lear and many of the other characters in the play talk about Goneril and Regan.
Thomas Paine Essay Research Paper Thomas Paine
Thomas Paine Essay, Research Paper Thomas Paine: Propaganda and Persuasion Thomas Paine, often called the ?Godfather of America? was an eighteenth century writer who used propaganda and persuasion techniques to motivate Americans in the fight for freedom from Britain. In one of several editions of his pamphlets titled The Crisis, Paine used several propaganda and persuasion techniques including over generalization, either/or fallacy, bandwagon appeal, parallelism, analogy, repetition, anecdote, and loaded language.
Technical Def Of Cavitation Essay Research Paper
CAVITATION Cause and Effect The word cavitation is a process that a Hydraulics Technician does not want to encounter. Cavitation can occur due to entrained air bubbles in the hydraulic fluid or vaporization of the hydraulic fluid. This occurs when the suction lift is excessive and the inlet-pressure falls below the vapor pressure (pressure which a liquid starts to boil and thus begins changing into vapor) of the liquid.
Can Machines Think 2 Essay Research Paper
Can Machines Think? With the recent advances of technology, a computer being able to think for themselves is not a far cry away. But is it a reasonable analogy? Computers have been built as goal-oriented systems. Whether the goal is to beat the best chess player humankind has come to acknowledge or figure out the microscopic measurements for the distance between us and another planet.
A Critique Of Neil Campbell
’s Problem With Voluntary Euthanasia Essay, Research Paper A Critique of Neil Campbell’s Problem with Voluntary Euthanasia Dr. Neil Campbell, author of “A Problem for the Idea of Voluntary Euthanasia,” questions whether there can be a such thing as voluntary euthanasia. Euthanasia, or physician-assisted suicide, is the intentional termination of life by another at the explicit request of the person who dies.
Cry Freedom Essay Research Paper In the
Cry Freedom Essay, Research Paper In the movie Cry Freedom Steven Biko is a black human rights leader. He is loved by the black community but hated and feared buy the white South African community. James Wood, the editor of a white newspaper, befriends Biko and agrees to go to a black township with him. Biko, however, is banned from these townships by the government.
St Augustine Postmodernity Essay Research Paper What
St. Augustine- Postmodernity Essay, Research Paper What does St. Augustine have to say to post-modern culture? I think that the most vital aspect in Augustine’s Confessions, more specifically his books “Student at Carthage” and “The birth-pangs of Conversion”, is the concept of True Love. Augustine tells us that love is paradoxically balanced between reason and passion, as both reason and passion can be both good and evil at some time or another.
The Existence Of God 2
The Existence Of God – Approaches/Criticisms Essay, Research Paper There are three major arguments that attempt to explain the existence of God. Firstly, it is important to establish a definition of God. According to philosophers God is an infinitely perfect being that upholds a divine unity of ultimate goodness and of ultimate power.
Argument From Design Essay Research Paper Argument
Argument From Design Essay, Research Paper Argument from Design In ?The Watch and the Watchmaker,? William Paley argues through analogy that since an intelligent designer must be assumed for the purpose-revealing watch, an intelligent Grand Designer may be inferred in explaining the purpose-revealing world.
Argument Of Design Essay Research Paper DesignThis
Argument Of Design Essay, Research Paper Design This is the argument that the universe exhibits evidence of design because it contains order, complexity and life. The person using this argument simply assumes that without a creator, the universe could not contain order, complexity and life. Why? Since the universe is all that we know of, the entirety of our experience, we have no way of understanding how a “designed” universe would compare to an “undesigned” universe.
Speech Observations Essay Research Paper Speech ObservationsPublic
Speech Observations Essay, Research Paper Speech Observations Public communication is the process by which a group of individuals are identified as the receivers or listeners and a single individual is identified to provide the primary source of conversation. Today’s Government training classes are somewhat typical of this scenario.