, Research Paper
It sounds like very good news for the low-income workers and their families whenever the government increases the minimum wages. On the surface minimum wage laws seem like the best prescription to treat poverty and improve living standards of the working poor. Promoters of minimum wage laws are taking positions that such laws alleviate poverty and improve the conditions of life of the working poor. However, upon closer analytical examination, it can be seen that such laws have perverse effects. Opponents are concerned about costs of statutory wage minimums in terms of the hardships they impose on other workers, employers, and regions as well.
The United States Congress adopted the Fair Labor Standards Act in 1938. Congress created the minimum wage toward the end of the Depression era to ensure a “minimum standard of living necessary for health, efficiency and general well-being for workers.” (Fair Labor Standard Act, 1938) In 1993 some 4.8 million people worked for minimum wage or less. (Mishel, Bernstein & Rasell Table 7) According to the Department of Labor, nearly 6.45 percent of the labor force is earning minimum wages. (Tannenbaum and Gupta B1) By having minimum wage laws the government is trying to ensure that everyone has a better standard of living and a more equal chance of competing with the higher income families and a fairer chance to improve their economic condition.
In talking about low-income families the topic of equal rights arises and what an individual can do to get fair treatment regardless of their income. In 1962, President John F. Kennedy enacted the Kennedy rights, and among them is the right to be a minority consumer without a disadvantage. The word minority not only refers minorities but also to low-income consumers. What this law means is that a consumer regardless of their income has the right to safety, which is knowing if a product is hazardous to their health. The right to be protected against false advertising, the right to have products and services at competitive prices, and the right to be heard.
These rights have often been bent when it comes to low-income minority consumers. Often times minorities are exposed to unsafe products, have less access to information, have fewer choices of brand alternatives, and have less access to means of redress. There are many reasons for these problems. One reason is that low-income individuals do not have the time or money to find more information and pick from different brand alternatives. Having less choice of brand alternatives minority-group consumers tend to be more brand loyal because there is more of a financial risk in choosing a different brand. Many times brand loyal consumers will also be store loyal.
There are a couple reasons why low-income consumers also tend to be store loyal. One reason is to reduce the risk of shopping in an unfamiliar store. Studies have found that store loyal customers tend to have a lower income and be less educated. Often times these consumers do not have the chance to shop much because of lack of time or lack of transportation. A question now arises as to if and how the government should help these consumers. Should the government play a role in increase price and brand awareness and possibly even transportation for low-income consumers or should the government raise the minimum wage?
The reason that raising the minimum wage does not ensure that low-income consumers will not be at a disadvantage is shown by the graph.
As you can see that at the equilibrium point of $4.25 all participants in the market are doing as well as they can, given the condition in the labor market. (Goodman & Dolan 171) If minimum wage is raised to $5.50 unemployment will grow. The reason for this is that the supply exceeds the demand. The equilibrium point does not change because of the legal requirements and the net effect is unemployment and/or less work for the workers. Just as a worker will only offer his labor time for a wage he finds beneficial, so an employer will only be willing to pay workers a wage that permits him to earn a profit. The higher the wage, the fewer workers the employer will employ. This is what economists mean when they invoke the law of supply and demand. Low-wage workers are most affected by these laws. Some workers will gain from the wage increase through higher income, however these gains come at the expense of other workers. Groups with the lowest levels of productivity suffer the greatest loss. Low-wage workers will be forced into second-best employment or into unemployment which often include the teens, minorities, elderly, handicapped, and those without skills.
In the early 1940’s, the teenage unemployment rate was not much higher than the unemployment rate for adults. However, as the teenage population grew, the unemployment rate grew with it. “By 1960, when the minimum wage was $1.00, the teenage unemployment rate was two and a half times the rate for all workers. By 1977, when the minimum wage had reached $2.30, the teenage rate climbed to over three times the rate for all workers.” (Goodman & Dolan 170)
The preponderance of evidence indicates that the problem for black teenagers has become even worse. In the early 1940’s, black teenagers seemed to have few problems finding work. The jobless rate for the black youths was less than that of white teenagers but by 1949 things had altered. The jobless rate for the black youths was 2.8 times the national rate. By 1971, that rate was 3.2 percent and by 1977 the rate for blacks youths had reached 40 percent. (Goodman & Dolan 171) President Lyndon Johnson stated, “The question is not whether the minimum wage should be increased but when and by how much.” (Cullen 32) In a survey that was conducted of 19 and 20 year olds at Ohio University, 60% of the students said the minimum wage should not be raised. The reasons that were given against raising the minimum wage is that it increases inflation and more money is paid for taxes. The 40% that said minimum wage should be increased gave the reason that it helps the low-income families that are on welfare get off of welfare. (Survey)
The loss of teenage jobs has been estimated at 11 percent. ( Renolds A14) In a study of dozens of federal and state minimum wage hikes since the 1970’s, David Neumark of Michigan State University found that total employment consistently dropped by one to two percent for every 10 percent rise in the minimum wage. (McNamee 36) Consider an analysis done of data from 1979 to 1992 by David Neumark of Michigan State and William Wascher of the Federal Reserve Board found that President Clintons’s proposed minimum wage hike will put 120,000 16 to 19 year old teens out of work and school. (Aley 48) The higher minimum wage cajoles teenagers into the labor force who would otherwise have stayed in school. Higher minimum wages tempt high school students to sacrifice education and future higher income by dropping out and taking jobs. The new workers entering the market due to the hike, push aside less educated working teens who end up with neither schooling nor jobs. (Entin A16)
The median income of African-American households is less than two-thirds that of whites and one reason is that African-Americans have less education. Only 13 percent of African-American adults have college degrees in 1995, compared to 24 percent of whites; and 74 percent had high school degrees, compared to 83 percent for whites.(Textbook) The lack of income and education has led African-Americans to spend more of their money on necessities such as cosmetics and toiletries, while whites spend more on medical care and entertainment.
Hispanics also spend more of their money on necessities because they also are less educated and have lower incomes. Their median income is about two-thirds that of the average American and their educational levels are well below average.(Textbook) However Hispanic Americans are highly brand loyal. One survey found that 62 percent of Hispanics buy the same food, beverage, and household items on a regular basis. A reason for this is that minority consumers in lower socioeconomic groups are often at a disadvantage when it comes to adequate brand alternatives, fair prices, and the assurance of product safety. (Textbook) Hispanics along with being brand loyal have a tendency to believe that advertising is honest and portrays information and products honestly. This is why there are laws that the Federal Trade Commission (FTC) has established protecting consumers from false advertising. In order to help alleviate these problems should the government raise the minimum wage so that consumers can purchase more and seek more alternatives. When minimum wages are raised business must compensate for the extra expenses incurred with the raise. Some businesses may reduce their work force to save money or they may charge the consumer more.
The argument of advocates of the minimum wage floor that the firm can pass the costs occurred by the wage hike to its customers is not a valid one. Robert Shapiro, lead economist at the Progressive Policy Institute says that about 80 percent of the costs of an increase in the minimum wage are passed on in the form of higher prices. A survey of small businesses found that after a wage increase 28 percent raised prices, 26 percent postponed expansion plans, 14 percent terminated at least one employee, and 9 percent did two of the preceding. Many firms have also turned to automation to reduce the threat of wage increases. (Horwitz A4)
The minimum wage laws do not alleviate low-wage and unskilled workers from poverty. They serve a purpose of keeping the poor people poor. The minimum wage laws make unskilled workers handicap forever by taking the element of incentive away from them. One’s labor is the most valuable property one has to sell. Variance in wages and earnings among workers at different levels of skill provide and incentive system of investment in skill acquisition. Different occupations have different wages. An interview with a small business owner in Cleveland revealed an interesting point. The owner stated that he would rather employ one skilled worker that can do the job in one day than hire three unskilled workers that can do the job in one day. The reasoning behind this is that one skilled worker requires less monitoring than the unskilled workers. The extra money paid to the skilled worker is worth the time of training and monitoring the unskilled workers.(Interview) If minimum wages compress that spread and cause the differences between the wage rates in unskilled and skilled occupations to be too small, the average quality of the labor force is diminished, output is lower, and poverty tends to be intensified. The lower class makes up 16 percent of the population and represents the unskilled, poorly educated, and socially disadvantaged. This diagram shows that the poor in America are getting poorer while the rich are getting richer.
Average Income Average Income Percentage Change
1970 1993 1970-1993
Top 5% by income $87,018 $120,043 +40%
Bottom 20% by income $18,301 $17,940 -2.0%
A raise in minimum wages does not insure that low-income consumers will not be at a disadvantage. If minimum wage is raised then people are put out of work in the process of downsizing or replaced by more efficient machines. A few do make more money but that extra money is also taxed and businesses will have less capital to expand and hire more workers. Without the minimum wage raises businesses will expand because they have more capital. Along with this expansion businesses will hire more people and create more jobs, thus putting more money into the economy, which will reduce inflation and keep prices on items relatively low. If businesses can not expand and can not afford to fire people then the businesses will raise their prices. The raised prices will hurt people working for minimum wage. Therefore when minimum wages are raised all the price of goods are going up so the consumer maybe making more money but is also paying more money for goods. Simply, the minimum wage floor is not a way to help the poor Americans.
Другие работы по теме:
Unemployment Essay Research Paper Unemployment ever think
Unemployment Essay, Research Paper Unemployment, ever think about what happens to people when they loose their job? Where do they go? What do they do? How do they provide for their family? These are everyday facts about unemployment, one of the largest measuring sticks for an economy. Before you can answer any of these questions.
Obstacles Immigrants Face(Using The Book Lupita Ma
Essay, Research Paper Run!Run! Run! La migra is coming! Immigrants especially illegal immigrants like Lupita and Salvador, face many obstacles in adjusting to life in the United States. Some obstacles they face are being taken advantage of. Also, being poor in Mexico just carried over here. “Ice cream sundae? What is that? Asked Lupita who had never heard these words before 75 cents!?! So much! Lupita shook her head in dismay.
Minimum Wage Essay Research Paper An increase
Minimum Wage Essay, Research Paper ?An increase now will boost income for the poorest workers without the danger of creating more unemployment.?, states the New York Times in September 1999. Is this statement about an increase in minimum wage really true? There are two sides to the debate about minimum wage that both hold valid points.
South Dakota Vs Dole Essay Research Paper
In 1987, the power of the 21st Amendment of the Constitution was in question by South Dakota and the State Secretary of Transportation (1983-87),1 Elizabeth Dole. The 21st Amendment declares that states have complete control over production, sale, and transportation of alcohol and that liquor importation and sale are no longer prohibited among states of the US (since the prohibition law of the 18th Amendment).
The Subway Franchise Essay Research Paper The
The Subway Franchise Essay, Research Paper The Subway Franchise The Subway story started in 1965 in Bridgeport, Connecticut during the summer of 1965. 17 year old Fred DeLuca was trying to earn enough money to pay for his college tuition by working in a hardware store. He wanted a way to add money to his minimum wage salary.
Military Deserves Increased Pay Essay Research Paper
MILITARY DESERVES INCREASED PAY Today s armed forces do more by five am than anyone in the world. Military deserves increased pay because we do more with less, especially during time of war. I am a veteran. I am currently in the United States Navy. I am on call twenty- four hours a day, and seven days a week, including holidays without holiday pay.
Prices And Money Supply Essay Research Paper
Prices, money, knowledge, and technology may not seem that they should be together, but all of the terms connect in one category. Money is a big issue when talking about prices in the past and present. Knowledge and technology are important, too.
Controlling Immigration Essay Research Paper With the
Controlling Immigration Essay, Research Paper With the many different groups of people coming to this country in search of a better life. I believe that we should better control Immigration to the U.S.. Since I am born native to the U.S. it is hard for me to say that others are not allowed to come into the U.S. But throughout this report there is evidence why control of immigration is needed.
My Political Party Aflliation Essay Research Paper
In With the Donkeys. Ryan Schilb April 26, 2001 Ryan Schilb April 26, 2001 In With the Donkeys. Americans have been consumed by politics since the beginning. It is even easier now, especially in a presidential election year. It seems you can?t watch television without seeing an advertisement for the Republican Party and the Democratic Party.
Mexicans Essay Research Paper HOW IS THE
Mexicans Essay, Research Paper HOW IS THE MIDDLE CLASS MEXICAN VIEWED IN THE UNITED STATES? “The middle Mexican sector comprises approximately 30 percent of the nation. Like its upper-income counterparts, this sector is largely urban and has educational levels superior to the national average. It consists of professionals, mid-level government and private sector employees, office workers, shopkeepers, and other no manual workers.
Student Loans Essay Research Paper The federal
Student Loans Essay, Research Paper The federal government has the power to cutback the funding of student loans. There are several different ways the government can go about doing this. One way is to keep the amount of each loan the same and reduce the number of loans granted. Another option the government has is to reduce the amount of each loan and issue the same number as in the past.
Inflation Essay Research Paper InflationInflation is defined
Inflation Essay, Research Paper Inflation Inflation is defined as ?a period of rising prices when the purchasing power of the dollar is falling.? What this boils down to is that as time goes by the dollar bills worth decreases while at the same time prices rise. Now when I say the dollar bill?s value decreases I don?t mean a dollar reduces to ninety cents.
Devolution Essay Research Paper President Ronald Reagan
Devolution Essay, Research Paper President Ronald Reagan was in his sixth year of office in 1985 when the Supreme Court held 5-4, and against a previous 1976 decision, that federal minimum wage standards covered public transportation workers. The case was Garcia v. San Antonio Metropolitan Transit, and it once again confirmed the power of the federal government to regulate the states.
Marx And Marxism Essay Research Paper Marx
Marx And Marxism Essay, Research Paper Marx and Marxism 2. First noted by John Locke in his Second Treatise on Government, labor is a source of value. Stated simply, the work a person does is worth money or a wage. This is a fundamental, arguably the fundamental principle, in the capitalist economic system.
The Age For A Driver
’s License Essay, Research Paper Raising the minimum age for a driving license: Necessary or useless? The question about raising the minimum age for a driving license has been
Reasons To Raise Minimum Wage Essay Research
Paper Raising minimum wages actually promotes growth (Meroney, 1995) and will have a positive effect on the economy. The positive effect will come from promoting job growth. This statement was made by U.S. Labor Secretary Robert Reich. Reich recommended that the minimum wage of $4.25 and hour be pushed up to $5.15 an hour over a two-year period.
Welfare Essay Research Paper In brief first
Welfare Essay, Research Paper In brief, first, the global economy has brought with it high rates of unemployment and economic inactivity in much of Europe. It has also generated strong pressures to de-regulate and create flexible labour markets with sharp rises in wage dispersion, part-time, temporary and casual employment particularly in the UK and USA.
Magnetic Anisotropy Of Fine Particles Essay Research
Paper “Magnetic Anisotropy Of Fine Particles” In nature, single domain particles are magnetized to saturation, where the magnetization has an easy axis, or several easy axes, along which it prefers to lie. In this case the total internal energy is minimum. Rotation of the magnetization vector away from the easy axis is possible only by applying an external magnetic field.
Did Fdr Endanger The Economic Essay Research
Paper Did FDR endanger the economic prosperity and well being of the nation? Contrary to the charge, FDR did not endanger the economic prosperity and well being of the nation. In fact, FDR s actions as president have rescued the nation s economy and have improved our economic future. The setting of a national minimum wage and giving workers the right to organize (through the NRA) will result in a happier, wealthier American working class that will have more disposable income to spend on consumer goods and services.
Welfare Reform Essay Research Paper Econ 251Welfare
Welfare Reform Essay, Research Paper Econ 251 Welfare Reform will hit economy hard A new law is going to be implemented in the near future, which requires welfare recipients to work increasing amount of time for their benefits, and places a five year limit on aid! This new policy is thought to make some people and some of their problems go away…but people don s just go away.
Conservatism Essay Research Paper In the world
Conservatism Essay, Research Paper In the world of politics there are two very basic concepts that govern political thought and give rise to policies and laws. These two concepts are conservatism and liberalism. Liberalism supports a more active role of government, policies to help minorities and the disadvantaged, higher spending and more regulation and policies to redistribute wealth through taxation.
Prop 209 Essay Research Paper Prop 209On
Prop. 209 Essay, Research Paper Prop. 209 On November 5, 1996 we will have the opportunity to have our voice heard when we go to the polls on election day. Not only will we be able to vote on who will be the next U.S. President, but we can also help determine the fate of issues that will help shape the future of our state, from water to healthcare to campaign reform to minimum wage.
Spanning Tree Essay Research Paper A spanning
Spanning Tree Essay, Research Paper A spanning tree is an application of a network. There is another type of spanning tree called the minimum spanning tree. This data structure is used in many business applications. I will be discussing what a spanning tree is and what a minimum spanning tree is, and how they work.
Minimum Wage Essay Research Paper It sounds
Minimum Wage Essay, Research Paper It sounds simple raise the minimum wage, reward hard work, and strike a blow against the society’s inequalities. It’s an emotional argument that blurs out the truth and make’s people forget one important economic lesson: There’s no such thing as a free lunch. The minimum wage has not been increased since the industrial welfare commission raised it to $4.25 an hour.
Minimum Wage Essay Research Paper Minimum Wage
Minimum Wage Essay, Research Paper Minimum Wage Legislation I am going to pose the question to you the students of Sir Sandford Fleming College, do you really want the minimum wage legislation left in affect? As college students you are not benefiting or gaining anything from minimum wage legislation. The minimum wage legislation requires all employees to be paid at least some fixed given dollar amount per hour.
Minimum Wage Essay Research Paper The Minimum
Minimum Wage Essay, Research Paper The Minimum Wage and Why We Should Leave it Alone When was the last time a "value" meal from McDonald, let alone any other fast food chain, did not cost five dollars or more? When was the last time premium gas was under a dollar a gallon? It’s hard to remember, isn’t it? Wouldn’t it be great if everything cost a nickel, like back in the good ol’ days? According to the laws of economics, it’s not logical for things to have gotten more expensive competition should drive prices down.
Minimum Wage In Labor Economic Essay Research
Paper In the article The Minimum Wage and Product Differentials Brodley S. Wimmer discusses the effects of a minimum wage increase on employment level, productivity,on different industries.
Minimum Wage Essay Research Paper Economy Jobs
Minimum Wage Essay, Research Paper Economy, Jobs, and You Term Paper Minimum Wage Minimum wage is the lowest rate employees may legally pay for an hour of labor (Merriam, 741). The United States has a minimum wage law to guarantee minimum hourly wages and to prevent the exploitation of workers and provide unskilled and part-time workers with a wage floor.
Minimum Wage Essay Research Paper Minimum WageMinimum
Minimum Wage Essay, Research Paper Minimum Wage Minimum wage is the least amount of pay that a person receives for the job that he/she performs. The minimum wage in Massachusetts is $5.50. A job that pay s minimum wage offers little or no opportunity for improvement. Majority of the people who work for minimum wage are students, people with little education, or immigrants.
Minimum Wage Essay Research Paper Should We
Minimum Wage Essay, Research Paper Should We Abolish The Minimum Wage? Should We Abolish the Minimum Wage is not a question that should be ignore. From the time President Roosevelt signed the Fair Labor Standards Act (FLSA) in 1938 the $.25 minimum wage has rose up to its current condition to $5.15 an hour. (Industrial and Labor Relations Review) With many types of conflict that imposed upon it the minimum wage has been a debate ever since it has been in effect.
Nike Essay Research Paper Nike is a
Nike Essay, Research Paper Nike is a huge supplier if athletic shoes for the world these days. Philip H. Knight, the founder of this corporation came up with an idea of an athletic shoe at the track field of the University of Oregon.
The New Deal Essay Research Paper New
The New Deal Essay, Research Paper New Deal Essay Some people argue that theforward thinking policies of the New Deal did not radically alter U.S business,but instead conserved and protected it. This statement is extremely valid. Roosevelt developed his New Deal policies to help to bolster Americaneconomy not to reshape the capitalistic economy that America had adoptedhundreds of years ago.
Minimum Wage Regression Essay Research Paper Jadro
Minimum Wage Regression Essay, Research Paper Jadro 1 John Jadro Webonomics Mr. Haessler 17 February 2000 Minimum Wage Regression The proposed increase in minimum wage will do a number of things to the economy. The greatest effect it has will be on inflation. There is a strong correlation between raises in the minimum wage, and raises in inflation.
Cambodia Essay Research Paper Cambodia is known
Cambodia Essay, Research Paper Cambodia is known for its war torn history as well as its factor in international business. By using Griffins framework, and reading the article A Bumpy Road to Reform out of the September 11. 2000 issue of Business Week it is easy to see why such large companies such as Nike, Target, Gap, JC Penny and Wal-Mart see interest in this war ravaged nation in need of export earnings and investment.