Paper
Sherman Anti-trust in the 21st Century
Whilst approaching the Twenty-first Century, America has taken significant strides in the advancement of high technology. With the unveiling of this new frontier comes continued innovation and government regulation. One aspect of the government in particular, the Sherman Anti-Trust Act of 1890, has impeded the progress of exploration into this new field; for the effectiveness of government is a nefarious hindrance to the efficiency of technology. Thus comes the age old question of who governs and to what ends. As a solution government should adopt a more Adam Smith approach to the regulation of high technology; the Sherman Anti-Trust Act should be amended by the legislature to allow more leeway for the technological and dynamic computer industry. The result of such an amendment, especially in a world economy such as ours, would allow American computer companies to thrive and compete with foreign companies as well as lead the way into the technological future of the Twenty-first Century.
In the age of reform as a result of public sentiment, Congress passed the Sherman Anti-Trust Act of 1890, named for Senator John Sherman. The one hundred and eight year old Sherman Act forbids monopolizing a market or engaging in any ?restraint of trade.? Today ?unlawful restraints? fall under three categories: 1) having too large a market share; 2) tying the sale of one product to another; 3) predatory pricing. For the past century the federal government has been pursuing a populist attack on big businesses–RCA, U.S. Steel, IBM, AT&T, Brown Shoe, A&P, etc. Most of the companies were ahead of their time and their competitors allowing them to become a successful, albeit big, businesses; however, due to government intervention and anti-trust investigation on the basis of the outdated Sherman Act, many of these cutting edge businesses were hindered in their progress for success. The market became a better trustbuster than the Department of Justice, maybe even better than big-stick, trust-busting Teddy Roosevelt.
In 1969 the International Business Machines Corp. dominated the market with a 65% share of the computer industry. As a result of this success, the U.S. government sued IBM for having too large a market share and demanded the company be dismantled. As the ?effectiveness? of government and the Sherman Anti-Trust Act were played out in the courts the advancement of technology increased significantly with new companies sprouting up (i.e. Intel, Microsoft). After the battle between IBM and the Justice Department was dropped in 1982, 13 years later, the fiercely dynamic computer industry had already checked the growth of IBM and the once monolithic enterprise was now headed into troubled waters. Another prime example is General Motors, who although were never investigated by the government for anti-trust, always had the fear of encountering the trust problem if they were too successful. Consequently automobile technology and manufacturing in America remained dormant while the Japanese in the 1980s rocked the American market.
The current mammoth corporation under the Justice Department anti-trust microscope is Microsoft. This software oriented company stands accused of tying the sale of one product to the sale of another (Microsoft operating system and Internet Explorer) and predatory pricing. The following table illustrates the historic timeline of Microsoft verses the United States government.
August 1993The Justice Department begins investigating Microsoft?s business practices.
October 1994Microsoft announces plans to buy Intuit, developer of Quicken, the leading personal finance program. When the Justice Department sues to block the acquisition, Microsoft calls off the deal.
June 1995Court upholds the Justice Department/Microsoft consent decree. Microsoft agrees not to tie the licensing of Windows to the licensing of other applications, but retains the right to develop ?integrated products.?
September 1996The Justice Department begins investigating Microsoft?s bundling of Internet Explorer with Windows 95.
April 1997Justice Department investigates Micorsoft?s plan to buy WebTV Networks; later allows deal to go forward.
August 1997Justice Department reviews Microsoft?s investment in Apple Computer.
October 1997Department charges that by requiring computer vendors to load Internet Explorer on all systems, Micosoft is in violation of the 1995 consent decree.
December 1997U.S. District Court Judge Thomas P. Jackson orders that the ?tying? of IE 4.0 to Windows be temporarily halted. Microsoft appeals.
On December 11, 1997, Judge Jackson?s ruling against Microsoft could forever alter the technological landscape. If the United States government were to succeed in its efforts it would establish a risky precedent: governmental meddling in software development. In his testimony to Congress, Mr. Gates asked members of the Senate Judiciary Committee, ?Will the United States continue its breathtaking technological advances? I believe the answer is yes–if innovation is not restricted by government.? Chairman, Senator Orrin G. Hatch (R. Utah), and other committee members heard from six computer industry figures on March 3, 1998. Microsoft asserts that Explorer is not a separate product but an ?integrated feature? of Windows–and thus an allowable improvement to the operating system under the consent decree.
By having the legislature modify the antiquated anti-trust law to accommodate the rapid technological pace two things will happen. The first of which is the efficiency and innovation of the computer industry will be able to run its course and reach its full potential with limited government intervention. Secondly, the effectiveness of the Judiciary in regulating trusts will not be compromised, only shifted to a new arena, one which is acclimatized to the digital age.
Robert Bork, an eminent legal philosopher, points out in his 1978 book The Antitrust Paradox, ?The general movement has been away from the ideal of competition and toward the older idea of protected status for each producer, away from concern for interest groups, and away form the ideal of liberty toward the ideal of enforced equality.?
Hopefully, by amending the current law to stay in tune with our technologically advancing society the opposite of what Bork commented on will be true.
349
Другие работы по теме:
Loving In Truth Creating A Society Of
Living In Harmony In The 21st Century Essay, Research Paper Loving in Truth: Creating a Society of Living in Harmony in the 21st Century In the course of one’s existence, one is constantly striving to achieve
Social Culture Essay Research Paper In the
Social Culture Essay, Research Paper In the 21st century and throughout history individuals and groups have been affected by sociocultural contexts. The mass media probably has one of the biggest effects on culture. Through television, magazines and movies, what is in, out, cool and not cool is all portrayed.
Women Essay Research Paper Apples could go
Women Essay, Research Paper Apples could go one better than oranges. The concentration of apples exceeds that of oranges. The firmness of apples goes all the way through, and the firmness of oranges modifies when the outer shell is detached. They tell you to cut up apples when you have braces, but they don?t tell you to cut up oranges.
Electoral College 2 Essay Research Paper Electoral
Electoral College 2 Essay, Research Paper Electoral College: It s time for reform It s not fair. It s not fair to the candidates running for office, not fair to the campaign volunteers and especially not fair to the American people. Although the Electoral College System was originally considered to be a brilliant innovation that cleverly solved a cluster of 18th-century problems, as we approach the 21st century, we confront different problems and our constitutional system of presidential selection does not look so brilliant.
Romeo And Juliet Essay Research Paper Engineers
Romeo And Juliet Essay, Research Paper Engineers have devoted their time and efforts in making great technological advancements for the human race. They have proposed many options and ideas in making the world a great place to live in. The engineers of the 21st Century will follow in the same path. The engineering community must think about change and plan for the coming century.
Dreaming Through Reservation Blues Essay Research Paper
In Reservation Blues, Sherman Alexie extensively uses dreams to portray the relationship between white people and Native Americans. The dreams depict a constant struggle between the two societies, as well as a gradual extinction of the Indian culture. A complete picture of the Native American way of life could be seen from examining these dreams—and its not a pretty one.
College Essay Essay Research Paper There
College Essay Essay, Research Paper There’s a lot of talking these days about what it will mean to live, work and prosper in the 21st century. In fact this century is being hailed as a kind of renaissance. Not the rebirth of classic art and culture, as in the 15th century, but a rebirth of what we understand to be knowledge, how to acquire it and how to use it productively.
General Shermans Views On Modern War Essay
, Research Paper ?General Sherman?s Views on Modern War? The Civil War was a war of great bloodshed and a war in which brothers fought against brothers and neighbors against
Valiance In The 21St Century Essay Research
Paper Valiance in the 21st Century And suddenly earth and sky were dazed by a pounding roar! And suddenly through the dawn an army began to pour! And lo! Ahead the army, holding aloft his spear came Lancelot to save his dear Guenevere! Camelot, Guenevere
Drunk Teen Drivers Essay Research Paper Teenagers
Drunk Teen Drivers Essay, Research Paper Teenagers Drinking Issues The drinking age is fine, if anything is should get raised. It is hard to ignore the fact that this law is broken everyday. It’s the 21st century all teens just want to fit in. Kids are drinking at a much younger age. Now, even 10 year olds and 11 year olds are trying to fit in with us older kids.
Illuminating The Path Of Progress In The
21St Century Essay, Research Paper Illuminating the Path of Progress in the 21st Century Technological breakthroughs are no longer a thing of the past. In the 21st century there are a few inventions which are common objects in our everyday lives. The internet, cell phones, and computer technology are a few examples of inventions that are paving the road of progress.
China 5 Essay Research Paper Commentary on
China 5 Essay, Research Paper Commentary on China The press in China has come a long way since the CCP took over the Chinese government in 1949 and it will continue to expand it’s freedom as we go into the 21st century. They were denied the right of freedom of speech and freedom of the press for all those years, that now the Chinese people have a hunger for information and knowledge of other countries culture and industrialization.
Down Syndrome Essay Research Paper Down Syndrome
Down Syndrome Essay, Research Paper Down Syndrome or Trisomy 21 as it is also commonly known, is a genetic condition that for many years has been shrouded in fear, darkness & shame. There is absoultely nothing to fear, and there never should be any feelings of shame, it is not the persons fault. The only darkness associated with down syndrome is the ignorance many people have towards it.
James Schoolcraft Sherman Essay Research Paper The
James Schoolcraft Sherman Essay, Research Paper The nation’s twenty-seventh vice president during William Howard Taft’s presidency was James Schoolcraft Sherman. Being a member of the House of Representatives for almost two decades, he stood firmly for the Republican Party as an influential role during the Progressive Era.
The Greatest Oil Man Essay Research Paper
Judson Wright Microeconomics The Greatest Oil Man The majority of people in the world dislike monopolies. People do not like monopolies because they are allocatively inefficient and because they produce less than consumers want. John D. Rockefeller was a good example of a monopolist from 1880 to 1911. Most people in that time period did not like his company, Standard Oil, and wished for an end to it (micheloud).
President Clinton Essay Research Paper The content
President Clinton Essay, Research Paper The content of President Clinton’s speech was elaborated and over zealous. His focus was directed on three topics: the past, the present, and the future. In the introduction, he started by addressing the challenges that will be bestowed upon us in the next century.
Dress Code Essay Research Paper At the
Dress Code Essay, Research Paper At the beginning of the 20th century there wasn’t much discussion about the dress code in schools. During that time kids weren’t dressing so provocative. Now that we are so close to the 21st century. There is a big controversy between the students and the schools about the dress code especially in public schools.
General Sherman And The Civil War Essay
, Research Paper William Tecumseh Sherman was born on May 8, 1820 in Lancaster, Ohio. He was educated at the U.S. Military Academy and later went on to become a Union General in the U.S. civil war. Sherman resigned from
Cindy Sherman Essay Research Paper Terror and
Cindy Sherman Essay, Research Paper Terror and mockery come together in the portraits of Cindy Sherman on display at the Crocker Art Museum. Walking into the large, dimly lit ballroom, one may begin to feel a slight sense of trepidation as the viewer looks around to find nine sets of beady eyes watching one’s every move.
21St Century Essay Research Paper The 21st
21St Century Essay, Research Paper The 21st Century is just around the corner and with it will come many changes in today?s modern society. Changes occur daily, yet taken into view yearly these changes become extremely noticeable. The people of today?s society are changing everyday, and therefore so is the world.
Rockefeller Essay Research Paper ESSAY NO 3American
Rockefeller Essay, Research Paper ESSAY NO. 3 American History 8th February 10, 1997 When the names Carnagie, Rockefeller, and Pullman come to mind, most of us automatically think of what we saw or read in our history
Microsoft Antitrust Court Case Essay Research Paper
As this paper is written there is a landmark court case proceeding in Washington in front of a federal judge. This case involves the charging of the Microsoft Corporation for violating antitrust laws set up by the government to preserve market competition. A general overview of the accusations brought against Microsoft by the Justice Department was given by Hayes in the Scholastic Update article The U.S. versus Microsoft (1999).
Microsoft Essay Research Paper Microsoft the world
Microsoft Essay, Research Paper Microsoft, the world’s largest company by market value, is accused of acting monopolistic in the computer software industry. Microsoft provides for eighty percent of the computers used, operating system. The operating system is a basic program that loads or boots up your computer to make it perform.
Microsoft Antitrust Editorial Essay Research Paper Microsoft
Microsoft Antitrust Editorial Essay, Research Paper Microsoft: The Big Bully Stealing Your Lunch Money A monopoly, by definition, is a business or group that engages in unfair and often unethical business practices to control an industry and eliminate all competition that might lessen their profits.
Microsoft Antitrust Case Essay Research Paper Microsoft
Microsoft Antitrust Case Essay, Research Paper Microsoft Antitrust Case Since 1998, the Microsoft Corporation has been struggling with an antitrust case against the United States Justice Department. They are being charged with violating aspects of the Sherman Act. This act prohibits companies from using their size and power as a monopoly to expand their positions and take hold of new markets.
EBONICS Essay Research Paper FOR AGES AFRICAN
EBONICS Essay, Research Paper FOR AGES AFRICAN AMERICANS HAVE BEE MANIPULATING THE ENGLISH LANGUAGE, WHICH APPEARS TO BE ACCEPTED BOTH THROUGH LITERATURE AND VERBAL SPEAKING. IN THE 21ST CENTURY THE EDUCATIONAL SYSTEM IS FACED WITH A TASK OF REFORMING A LANGUAGE SUPPOSIDLY CALL “BLACK ENGLISH” OR “EBONY PHONICS,” DEPICTING WHAT IS WIDELY KNOWN AS EBONICS.
Microsoft The Company Essay Research Paper Microsoft
Microsoft The Company Essay, Research Paper Microsoft: THE COMPANY The thought of forming a company which supplies its customers with software, was a great idea–especially coming from a college dropout. Bill Gates, along with high-school friend Paul Allen, formed a software company in 1975. From the beginning, Microsoft had a tremendous potential to become a very successful corporation.
Anititrust
– American Airlines Essay, Research Paper I feel American Airlines is in violation of all three of the major pieces of antitrust legislation in one way or another. The three acts are the Sherman Act, the Clayton Act, and the Federal Trade Commission Act.