Jay Gould Essay, Research Paper
Creationism vs Evolution: Through The Eyes of Jay Gould
It has been over 100 years since English naturalist Charles Darwin first
told the world his revolutionary concept about how livings things develop.
Evolution through natural selection and adaptation was the basis of his argument
as it remains to this day a debated subject by many. Across this nation, a
“return” to “traditional” values has also brought the return of age old debated
topics. One issue that truly separates Americans is the issue of creation
versus evolution. Since the 19th century, this divisive topic has been debated
in school boards and state capitols across America. In many instances religious
fundamentalists won the day by having banned the instruction or even the mention
of “ungodly” evolutionary thinking in schools. With today?s social and political
climate, this question is back with greater force than ever. This is why this
subject is more important now than ever. In Jay Gould?s book The Panda?s Thumb,
an overview of and an argument for Charles Darwin?s evolutionary thinking is
conducted with flowing thoughts and ideas. This essay titled “Natural Selection
and the Human Brain: Darwin vs. Wallace” takes a look directly at two hard
fought battles between evolutionists and creationists. Using sexual selection
and the origins of human intellect as his proponents, Gould argues his opinion
in the favor of evolutionary thought.
In this essay titled “Natural Selection and The Human Brain: Darwin vs.
Wallace,” Gould tells about the contest between Darwin and another prominent
scientist named Alfred Wallace over two important subjects. These topics, one
being sexual selection and the other about the origins of the human brain and
intellect were debated by men who generally held the same views on evolution.
However on these two subjects, Wallace chose to differ as he described it as his
“special heresy” (53). The first of these two areas of debate between the two
men was the question of “sexual selection.” Darwin theorized that there laid
two types of sexual selection. First a competition between males for access to
females and second the choice “exercised by females themselves” (51). In this,
Darwin attributed racial differences among modern human beings to sexual
selection “based upon different criteria of beauty that arose among various
peoples” (51). Wallace, however, disputed the suggestion of female choice. He
believed that animals were highly evolved and beautiful works of art, not
allowing the suggestion of male competition to enter his mind. The debate of
sexual selection was but a mere precursor to a much more famous and important
question . . . the question of the origins of the human mind. Gould?s
discussion of the origins of the human mind is one that he in which he vocalizes
his own opinions and feelings in a much more critical manner. Gould begins the
topic of human origins by briefly criticizing Wallace for his different views on
this subject. Wallace believed that human intellect and morality were unique
and could not be the product of natural selection. Wallace suggested that “some
higher power” (53) must have “intervened to construct this latest and greatest
of organic innovations.” Gould sharply chastises Wallace for “simple cowardice,
for inability to transcend the constraints of culture and traditional views of
human uniqueness, and for inconsistency in advocating natural selection so
strongly” (53). The argument that human intelligence was divine along with the
belief that all people of all races have the same capacity of intellect, but are
limited only by their culture was at the heart of Wallace?s opinions. Gould
rebuts Wallace by going into Darwin?s “subtler view.” Gould writes that our
brains may have “originated ?for? some set of necessary skills . . . but these
skills do not exhaust the limits of what such a complex machine can do” (57).
Gould ends by describing Wallace?s thinking as having direct ties with
creationist thought. A school of thought that Gould obviously portrays as wrong
throughout his essay. Throughout The Panda?s Thumb, Gould tells us about the
debate between Darwin and Wallace over sexual selection and the origins of human
intellect. Throughout his essay Gould gives vivid accounts of the different
views expressed by the two men as he analyzes the validity of each. He makes a
clear opinion and backs up his claim. In this, Gould sufficiently argues his
points that he makes. As a writer, Gould tells his opinion through clear and
precise words in a style that anyone could grasp immediately. To make his point
unmistakable, Gould gives direct and continuous analysis, commentary, and
criticism as he digs deeper into his subjects. Gould?s style of writing is not
only appropriate, but is favorable for this type of discussion and can be
applauded. Rather than submitting to a scientists ever present tendency to over
explain and over analyze while using incomprehensible vocabulary, Gould gets the
job done with brief yet fulfilling summaries and statements. In the end, however,
Gould must be judged by his judgement. His argument is the ultimate standard
bearer and in this there are few weaknesses. His excellent use of clear
language and style as he analyzes a particular subject is commendable. Never
does Gould stray into incomprehensible scientific hog wash. Never does Gould
let himself begin to attack mercilessly without a shred of evidence.
But even with Gould?s excellent story telling in his essay, there
remains subtler, yet still present weaknesses in his argument. While Gould
appropriately attacks Wallace for his creationist stance on human intellect, he
in turn fails through his lack of creationist related discussions. While he
does argue and does it well, he leaves something to be desired in his attack on
creationist thought. In addition, Gould doesn?t seem to write enough about
Darwin?s own feelings about the human intellect, though he states Darwin?s
underlying opinion, it would had been beneficial for Gould to have done more in
this area.
Jay Gould?s essay “Natural selection and the human brain” is one that
strikes the readers mind with interest and curiosity. Written in a style and
format that is “reader friendly” while sufficiently and consistently arguing a
clear and precise point are the attributes that make Gould?s essay such a
delight to read. More important, however, is the social implications of this
essay. While school boards across the nation debate the subject of whether
evolution should be taught in the schools, Gould?s work stands out with it?s
overriding validity and straightforwardness. It is an example of reasonable
argument as evolution?s opponents use nothing but rhetoric and fear to displace
scientific analysis. Through Gould?s work, a greater sense of understanding
about how creatures evolved can be gained through these two excellent examples.
Другие работы по теме:
Creation V Evolution An Educational View Essay
, Research Paper Creation v. Evolution: An Educational View Many words have been written about the origins of things. Numerous ancient people believed that several powerful gods were responsible for creating human beings (Warburton 12). Another theory is parallel evolution, humans evolving simultaneously in several parts of the world (Allman, 54).
Creation Vs Evolution Essay Research Paper In
Creation Vs. Evolution Essay, Research Paper In society, there are many diverse issues that raise intense controversy. An ongoing conflict has been between the science world and the religious society. This topic happens to be the theory of creation, versus the theory of evolution. Naturally the science world is backing evolution, while the religious community is strongly supporting creationism.
Creationism Essay Research Paper In a typical
Creationism Essay, Research Paper In a typical American high school, Mr. Doe, the science teacher begins his discussion on the theory of evolution. John, a student opposes the idea the humans came from apes and evolved. John believes that men came from God and that man was created in 6 days. Jane hears this and argues against John, How could anything possibly be created in 6 days? This sort of project would take millions of years! By using up all 45 minutes of class time discussing creationism and evolution, this is a metaphor to the eternal debate as to the origin of the human species.
Creation Vs Evolution Essay Research Paper What
Creation Vs Evolution Essay, Research Paper What Are They Angry About? by Tyler Booman If you’re planning a vacation later this year, better make sure it’s not in Kansas. According to recent reports, the state’s overall IQ has just taken a nosedive. What has caused this “giant step back into the nineteenth century” as one person called it? Quite simply, the State Board of Education voted to de-emphasize evolution in state testing and to give local school boards the option of deciding whether or not evolution would be taught.
2Nd Law Of Thermodynamics Vs E Essay
, Research Paper Second Law of Thermodynamics vs. Evolution According to the second law of thermodynamics, when energy is converted from one form to another, the amount of useful energy decreases. In relation to the theory of evolution, this law is not contradictory. The second law of thermodynamics is not relating to energy within living things because living things retain energy from the sun.
The Mystery Of Human Origin Essay Research
Paper The mystery of human origin is an often-debated topic. It is an issue that can never be proven, something as vague as the existence of God, the proof of a human soul, or even as evasive as the human psyche itself. The debate itself is divided between two main camps: the Evolutionists, who concur with Darwin’s theory of evolution, survival of the fittest, and natural selection.
The Selfish Gene Essay Research Paper Creationism
The Selfish Gene Essay, Research Paper Creationism is a Bible based view of human origin that states humans were created in their current form and have not changed, or evolved, throughout the years. However the belief that our species has changed over time to suit our environment is considered evolution.
Evolution Is Schools Essay Research Paper Position
Evolution Is Schools Essay, Research Paper Position on Evolution In 1925, schools had a very standard and general curriculum. Much of this curriculum was based on Christian beliefs and morals. No one dreamed of challenging these values. Especially in the school classroom, where budding minds strived for new knowledge, and any new ideas could possibly spark secular beliefs totally contradictory to what was taught in Christian households.
Gradualism Vs Punctuationism Essay Research Paper Gradualism
Gradualism Vs Punctuationism Essay, Research Paper Gradualism versus Punctuationism Although modern evolutionists are thought to be divided on the issues surrounding evolutionary theory, a close look at the evidence suggests that both the gradualist school of thought and the punctuationist school of thought share many characteristics in common.
The Great Gatsby 10 Essay Research Paper
The Great Gatsby In the novel, The Great Gatsby, the eyes of Dr. T.J. Eckleburg represents god, the all seeing and all knowing god, which society, cannot fool.
Creation Has No Place In Our Schools
Essay, Research Paper Creationism Has No Place In Public Schools In society there are many diverse issues that raise intense controversy. An ongoing conflict has been on what to tech the children in public schools about human creation. Many religious leaders and churchgoers would like to have the biblical theory of creation taught to the children in place of the scientific theory of evolution.
The Beak Of The Finch Essay Research
Paper The Beak of the Finch: Evolution Before my Eyes The Beak of the Finch by Jonathan Weiner has dramatically changed my understanding of the world and also of myself. I remember one of my friends reading it during our AFS trip to Bolivia and asking her if it was any good. “Oh ya, it is!” She responded. “It’s one of the best books I have ever read!” Later, I asked to borrow it.
Craetion Vs Evolution Essay Research Paper Creationism
Craetion Vs Evolution Essay, Research Paper Creationism vs. Evolution The majority of people in this world believe that a spiritual being created earth. In fact, “most religions and cultures believe the universe was created by a ‘creative hand,’ either a sky god or some other physical object” (Encarta 1).
Evolution Vs Creationism Essay Research Paper If
Evolution Vs. Creationism Essay, Research Paper If God and Darwin were in the same room together would they fight it out to the end? This would truly be the ultimate celebrity death match. But who would win? This battle over evolution versus creationism has been going on for over 100 years and the question still stands? who is right? And what should we teach our children?
The Father The Son And The Holy
Spirit. Essay, Research Paper The last line of the Lord’s prayer is, “In the name of the Father, the Son, and the Holy Spirit.” It is a key line in the Christian religion. The intention of this is reminding one of where we came from and to thank Jesus Christ for giving his life to remove humanitie’s sin. There are many key points in the Bible that tells us how we came to be, reminding us everyday to be thankful for what God has done for us.
Science And God Essay Research Paper With
Science And God Essay, Research Paper With each new development in science comes conflict, mostly from those who don’t believe that science follows the teachings of their religion or allies with their beliefs in an almighty power or God. Looking back in history at some of the great names in human scientific achievement, such as Copernicus, Galileo, and Darwin, we see that with each genius discovery came some outcry from religious groups.
Creationism Essay Research Paper Creationism Genesis 11In
Creationism Essay, Research Paper Creationism Genesis 1:1?In the beginning God created the heavens and the earth.? This quote, taken from the Hebrew Bible describes the belief that religious Jews and Christians follow. These two religions think that man, the earth, and the rest of the universe were originally created instead of the theory of evolution.
Evolutionism Vs Creationism Essay Research Paper Joshua
Evolutionism Vs. Creationism Essay, Research Paper Joshua T Hermsmeyer T TH 2-3:30 Essay 1 Evolutionism vs. Creationism The theory of evolution and the belief in a Creator have long been considered separate and mutually exclusive realms of human thought . Strict interpretations by scientists of Darwin?s theory of species adaptation through natural selection must inherently run contrary to equally strict interpretations of Genesis I.
Creationism Vs Evolutionism Essay Research Paper Evolutionism
Creationism Vs Evolutionism Essay, Research Paper Evolutionism vs. Creationism Two separate stories are the basis for how the World was created. The first theory is Evolution. Evolution states that we evolved through time and eventually turning into man. Creation states that God created us and that everything was created at once.
Creationists And Darwinists Essay Research Paper Questions
Creationists And Darwinists Essay, Research Paper Questions on the origin of life and of the universe must have challenged human curiosity and imagination as soon as early man had time for activities other than survival. In 1859, Charles Darwin published the Origin of Species, and since then, people have debated between the creationism and evolutionism theories.
Darwins Theory On Evolution Essay Research Paper
Discuss Evolution Theory according to Darwin In 1838, Charles Darwin put together his Theory on Evolution. Darwin tried to prove his theory that man was the center of the world and not God. He believed that evolution was gradual on both humans and on organisms. Darwin believed in something called natural selection; meaning genes are to be passed on from one generation to the next.
Evolution Essay Research Paper Evolution vs CreationEvolution
Evolution Essay, Research Paper Evolution vs. Creation Evolution versus Creationism is a hot topic that is in constant debate among scientists and Christians. Held in high regard to the world of science, Evolution, is the theory that groups of organisms change with passage of time, mainly as a result of natural selection, so that descendants differ morphologically and physiologically from their ancestors.
Trial And Error Essay Research Paper The
Trial And Error Essay, Research Paper The debate of teaching evolution in the public schools remain one of the most emotionally-charged controversies in the twentieth-century America. Trial and Error, by Edward J. Larson, was organized into five chapters. The first chapter provides historical background by examining evolutionary teaching in America during the years leading up to the anti-evolution crusade.