Herbal Supplements Essay, Research Paper
Jeff Reese was a bright, energetic scholar-athlete at the University of Michigan when he died suddenly on December 9, 1997. His death came as a total shock because, as a wrestler, Reese was a fit young man without any known medical conditions. The autopsy said the cause of death was “rhabdomyolysis,” a cellular breakdown of skeletal muscle. His family, friends, doctors, and the NCAA all think Reese’s death was caused by the supplement creatine Reese was taking to improve his wrestling skills.
This unfortunate story highlights a growing problem in America today, namely the use of supplements. The September 22, 1998 New York Times states that supplements can be broadly defined to include herbs, amino acids, botanical extracts, quasi-vitamins as well as real vitamins and minerals. According to the September 8, 1998 Los Angeles Times, the supplements business is becoming big business, grossing $18 million dollars in annual sales. The April 30, 1998 USA Today reports that more than 130 million Americans regularly use supplements. Unfortunately, there are number of problems related to supplements that pose a number of critical dangers to consumers. The majority of these dangers can be linked to one single problem overall, the lack of adequate labeling.
Today we will explore one of the most troubling problems in society today, that being supplement labeling. We will begin by first, exploring the dangers associated with supplement labeling. Second, we will identify why these dangers exist. And finally, we will examine what steps we can take to protect ourselves when taking supplements
Ira Flatow in NPR’s September 25, 1998 edition of Talk of the Nation points out that there are over 20,000 supplements on the market today. Unfortunately, there are a number of dangers associated with these supplements because of their labeling. Those dangers include misleading labels, poor FDA regulation, and the lack proper medical research on supplements.
The first danger associated with supplements labeling is that current labels mislead the public. The August 28, 1998 Regulatory Intelligence Data Agency states that the DSHEA or the Dietary Supplement Health and Education Act of 1994 allows dietary supplements to make claims that a product MAY affect the structure or functioning of the body – but CANNOT make claims that they can treat, diagnose, cure or prevent a disease.
In addition, supplements labels are not always clear about what they may or may not do, thus confusing consumers about the supplements different uses. For example, the February 1998 Scientific American states that manufacturers have interpreted the law very liberally, making package statements like “Clinically Proven to Improve Memory and Concentration.” To the uninformed consumer, this statement implies legitimacy to supplements when that legitimacy really has not been established.
A second danger stems from the lack of adequate FDA regulation regarding supplements. According to the September 1, 1998 FDA Consumer, the DSHEA expanded the types of products that could be marketed as “supplements” beyond essential nutrients to include vitamins, minerals, herbs or other botanicals, amino acids, and any concentrate, metabolite, constituent, extract, or any combination of such ingredients. This means ANYTHING could be considered an essential nutrient and thus be marketed as a supplement.
A third danger centers on the lack of proper research on supplements and their effectiveness. The New York Times of September 17, 1998 reports that unlike drugs, dietary supplements do not have to be proven safe and effective before they are put on the market. Bruce Silverglade, legal affairs director for The Center for Science in the Public Interest , said in the August 7, 1998 Biloxi Sun Herald that Congress and the DSHEA has handcuffed the FDA by “allowing dietary supplement companies to make claims without first proving they’re true.” Dr. Marcia Angell, executive director of the New England Journal of Medicine, states that if supplements were held to the same standards as drugs, the “onus would be on the manufacturers to prove safety and efficacy, and I think most of them would shut down.” Because supplements are not tested, consumers are putting themselves at risk when they use them.
Now that we are more familiar with the dangers that exist, we can now turn our attention to why these dangers will continue to exist in the future. To do this, we will turn our attention to the new FDA supplement law and explore why this new law will not address current labeling problems.
According to the January/February 1998 FDA Consumer, new labeling rules will take place next month. These news labels will contain information about appropriate servings, how supplements should be referred to on a label and when products can use the terms “high potency” and “antioxidants.”
What is alarming about this new law is that it does not address the fundamental problems linked to supplements. The first reason why this new law will be ineffective is because these new labels still will not protect consumers from supplements or warn them of side effects. Prevention’s Guide to Healing Herbs from September 29, 1998 states that manufacturers are prohibited from labeling herb products to specify possible side effects. That’s because the FDA views posting this information as making medicinal claims. What that means to us is that we cannot be really sure what is in a supplement because of incomplete labeling.
A second reason this new law will not work is because the FDA does not check supplement labeling to ensure they contain the correct ingredient contents. The New York Times reminds us that “There are currently no federal regulations that establish scientific criteria for purity, identification, and manufacturing procedures of dietary supplements,” which means “producers can put in just about anything they want, including no active ingredient at all, and there is still no guarantee that what is says on the label is what is in the bottle.”
And that is exactly what supplement producers do. The June 22, 1998 Business Week reports that a Mississippi watchdog group checked 107 products to check their label accuracy. It found that over one-half deviated in ingredient content by 20% or more. Despite this, the new law still will not require the FDA to check products to make sure labels accurately list dosage amounts.
Finally, without any type of proper research on supplements, no amount of rules regulating the supplements will help us the consumer determine if they are safe or not. Manufacturers are not required by the FDA to test their products, so most do not. Prevention’s Guide points out that herb marketers are unwilling to shell out the $200+ million dollars it would take to get a medicinal claim on a herb, one because of the cost, and two, because marketers cannot patent the benefits of a plant. So herbs remain classified as herbs. And we, as the consumer, may not really know what we are taking or in what amounts.
It is clear that there are a lot of danger associated with supplement labeling, and that the new law taking effect next month won’t solve those problems. But there are steps we can take as consumers to protect ourselves from supplements.
First, we need to remember that supplements are indeed drugs. The September 6, 1998 Chicago Tribune states that people simply don’t view the increasingly popular ‘natural supplements’ as drugs because they way the products are described on their labels. But supplements are drugs, and caution should be exercised when taking them.
Second, look at your supplement’s label closely. The May 1, 1998 Medical Education and Research Foundation suggests that you buy products with an U.S.P. label, indicating that the supplement meets dissolution standards created by the US Pharmacopoeia. If the product doesn’t have a U.S.P label, consider purchasing a different one.
Third, keep on the lookout for fraudulent products. These products may have written on their labels questionable statements like “laboratory-tested” and “quality and potency guaranteed.” Or supplements may use pseudomedical jargon like “detoxify,” “purify,” or “energize” to describe a product’s effects, jargon that is really vague and hard to measure. Also be wary of products that claim to be a “secret cure” or use such terms like “breakthrough,” “magical,” “miracle cure,” or “new discovery.” The only discovery you might make is how much you are spending on worthless products.
Fourth, always check with your doctor before taking supplements, especially if you are taking prescription medicine. The September 22, 1998 New York Times states that most people who take over-the-counter dietary supplements never report that fact to their physicians. For example, those who take the medicine Prozac are told not to take St. John’s Wort as a supplement. Combining the two could cause adverse reactions and decrease the effectiveness of the prozac. Also, if you are hospitalized for any reason, make sure your doctor knows of all drugs you are taking, including supplements. By informing your doctor, he or she may be better able to diagnose your problems as well as make sure you don’t take any drugs that might adversely react with the supplements.
Finally, if you continue to take supplements, take them with meals, when everything is passing through the digestive tract at a slower rate and the pill is therefore more likely to dissolve properly. This will help in preventing any unwanted problems, medical or otherwise.
Today we have looked at the problem of supplements labeling, the causes of the problem, and what we can do to protect ourselves from supplements. We found that the FDA is not doing enough to inform or warn consumers about supplements, despite new rules increasing the amount of information on supplement labels. Until the rules change, it’s up to us to make sure we are protecting ourselves from potential dangerous supplements.
So, as you cruise the aisle of your local health food store or WalMart, and are tempted to reach for a bottle of Gingkoba or Ginseng, look before purchasing. Remember Jeff Reese’s death, a death that could have been prevented. Supplements may sound good, but until the FDA tightens up its labeling requirements and consumers know what they are taking, you might be better off avoiding natural supplements altogether.
Другие работы по теме:
The Plot Synopsis Of Murphy
’s Boy Essay, Research Paper My story, Murphy’s Boy, by Torey Hayden, is a famous true story about the life of a teacher/psychologist lady, Torey, who helps a non-talking boy, Kevin. This story started off with Torey meeting Kevin for the first time. She noticed that he was crouched underneath of a table, all closed in, and not talking.
Marijuana Essay Research Paper For many years
Marijuana Essay, Research Paper For many years the legalization of marijuana has been debated all over the world. The use of marijuana has been used for recreation and medicinal purposes for thousands of years. The hemp plant, the source of the drug hashish, is one of the commonest weeds in the world. There is little danger that it will seriously promote the drug habit.
Chromium Supplementation Essay Research Paper One of
Chromium Supplementation Essay, Research Paper One of the most controversial supplements on the market is chromium. In the body, its natural functions consist of potentiating the activity of insulin and influencing lipid and protein metabolism. It may also be involved in the formation of glycogen in muscle tissue and facilitate the transport of amino acids to the muscles.
Creatine Essay Research Paper CreatineAthletes and regular
Creatine Essay, Research Paper Creatine Athletes and regular people alike try many different supplements to find one that they can use to help increase their muscle mass. They may not realize it, but their bodies already produce a chemical that is great for that purpose and consuming more of it in form of a supplement can be exactly what they are looking for.
King Hussein Essay Research Paper Jeffery SheuINTRODUCTIONHi
King Hussein Essay, Research Paper Jeffery Sheu INTRODUCTION Hi, my name is Jeff, my topic is about Jordan and the peace talks, or in other words about King Hussein dying, the fights with Palestinians. I personally chose this theme because it really interests me. I could have done Y2K, the space station, or even the President, but those did not interest me so if I did do it I wouldn t have gotten a good grade.
Vdg Essay Research Paper Raintree
Vdg Essay, Research Paper Raintree’s website is dedicated to providing information and education on the important plants of the Amazon Rainforest, therefore this section is the most extensive. The Plant Database section is continuously under construction as we continue to add more rainforest plants which are under research.
Nature Vs Science Essay Research Paper In
Nature Vs Science Essay, Research Paper In the article The Myth of Beneficent Nature: The Risks of Herbal Preparations , is a persuasive article by Ryan J. Huxtable. In the article Huxtable is arguing that herbal teas and medicines are not healthy and should be band. After reading the article, I disagree with Huxtable, and he was not able to convince me.
Jeffrey Dahmer Essay Research Paper Jeffrey Dahmer
Jeffrey Dahmer Essay, Research Paper Jeffrey Dahmer, was born in Bath, in Ohio, where he had an obsession with death that started early in his childhood. Jeff used to take dead animals and skin them, use chemicals on them to remove all the flesh, leaving the bones. He also cut off a dog’s head and put it on a stick, leaving it in the woods.
Fight Essay Research Paper At a huge
Fight Essay, Research Paper At a huge party in Long Beach Island, locals show up at the party. The house is small, but it has a front lawn that is a nice size to throw a party. The house and lawn is surrounded by a fence that is sharp at the top to prevent anyone from climbing over it easily. The house is between several other houses that are owned by families.
Algae Essay Research Paper Recently I interviewed
Algae Essay, Research Paper Recently, I interviewed someone from the Island of Orkney, off the northern shore of Scotland. He described the seas as being nutrient rich and crystal clear. Traditionally, sea weed, (called sea vegetables in Scotland) has been used for herbal remedies, food products, animal food, cosmetics, and fertilizers.
Aol Essay Research Paper Amy LinkEIU 4051Paper
Aol Essay, Research Paper Amy Link EIU 4051 Paper 1 The dietary supplement industry is booming. People are striving for a healthier lifestyle, but our vitamins and minerals supplements really needed? The Food and Nutrition Board recommends that those who choose to take these supplements follow the FDA guidelines.
Friendship Essay Research Paper Dr Levensohn you
Friendship Essay, Research Paper Dr. Levensohn, you asked the three of is to write you a paper on what we think that friendship is. Truly friendship is something that can t be placed into words. It is more of a concept than a literal translation. For the purpose of this paper though, I have compiled what I feel is notion of friendship.
Time Travel Essay Research Paper Sitting in
Time Travel Essay, Research Paper Sitting in the court room, Bryan does not pay attention to anything that is going on around him. All he can think about is the accident and if he could change things he would. If he could go back in time and make himself the one that was killed and not Jeff, he would do it in a heartbeat.
Vincent
’s Musuem Essay, Research Paper ARTIFACTS GENUINE!!!BY,JEFF MCCLURE VINCENT?S MUSEUM?S ARTIFACTS PROVED REAL see below Recently at Vincent?s museum alot of talk was about the artifact?s
The Drug War Essay Research Paper Everyday
The Drug War Essay, Research Paper Everyday someone is thrown in state prison for anywhere from 3 years to life for the “illegal” use of the drug known as marijuana. It has come down to it that thousands of pounds of marijuana are smuggled over the border of Mexico and into the United States. Regardless of the fight or struggle of people to insure the so said safety of our younger generations from the use of these drugs more and more comes into the Unites States.
Proteins Essay Research Paper Two Animal Products
Proteins Essay, Research Paper Two Animal Products vs. Two Protein Amino Acid Supplements The Protein and Amino Acid supplement make claims to build lean muscle mass in conjunction with a healthy diet and exercise (especially weight training). Protein and Amino Acid supplement companies advocate eating 6-8 small healthy meals a day which allows the body to use food more efficiently throughout the day for increased energy and performance.
Status Characteristics Theory Essay Research Paper Status
Status Characteristics Theory Essay, Research Paper Status Characteristics Theory A group of five college students who each belonged to a Greek association had to decide on what hotel to stay in during their spring break vacation in Cancun. There is a valued, collective task within this situation. They all have invested a lot of money for this trip and they all want to make sure they get the most for their money.
Supplements Essay Research Paper The debate topic
Supplements Essay, Research Paper The debate topic that I had to preside over was the regulation of drug and herbal supplements. Since I broke the debate into six parts Pros & Cons of labeling, claiming and advertising, this paper will follow the same format. I am going to go over in great detail the high points of both sides debate.
Herbal Supplements And Mice Essay Research Paper
A nutritional scientist was trying to get a new herbal supplement approved by the Food and Drug Administration. Her belief is that the herbal supplement can improve endurance in humans. The scientist took 30 mice and split them into 15 groups of two mice. The two mice in each group are of the same species, have same diet patterns, and same size.
The Gallant Boys Of Gettysburg Essay Research
Paper The story I read took place mostly at the Battle of Gettysburg. Tom and Jeff Majors had just enrolled in the Confederate army. Tom enrolled as a private and Jeff as a drummer boy. Their dad, Nelson Majors, who had been
Starting All Over Essay Research Paper Starting
Starting All Over Essay, Research Paper Starting All Over Martian Chronicles Ray Bradbury Ray Bradbury?s the Martian Chronicles is a futuristic story about space travel, invasion and planet colonization. Analyzing characters in this twenty-eight-chapter novel is extremely difficult because every chapter includes different characters, which are oriented to form the plot.
Poem This Is Me Essay Research Paper
I am Jeff, my mind is very magical, My brain is like IBM compatible. My personality is worth knowing, While my heart is always glowing Soccer is my game, A lot of people want the fame.
Sucess From Creatine Essay Research Paper Success
Sucess From Creatine Essay, Research Paper Success From Creatine Many people in athletics avoid using creatine monohydrate because they do not know much about it. They are convinced that something that can help athletes achieve
Herbs Essay Research Paper Your studying for
Herbs Essay, Research Paper Your studying for your final exams when all of a sudden you feel it coming on. A headache. It’s definitely your worst one yet, and to make matters worse, you’ve only just started studying an hour ago. It’s probably from going over all those problems in the small print of your text book.
Untitled Essay Research Paper Jeff is sitting
Untitled Essay, Research Paper Jeff is sitting with a group of children & a couple of counselors doing an inside activity. It appears that the counselor is singing a song that is interactive with the children. Jeff appears to be very active & full of energy. When he is called to stand up he jumps up & down & spins around erratically.
To Soon For Jeff Essay Research Paper
To soon For Jeff (essay) Dashan is a friend of Jeff. Even though Christy became a really good friend of his. Though Dashan wasted his time and also had his heart broken by Christy he has suffered the least. Things could have workout for Dashan and Christy but no.
Jeff Gordon Essay Research Paper Jeff GordonJeff
Jeff Gordon Essay, Research Paper Jeff Gordon Jeff Gordon has won the Nascar Winston Cup Championship in 1995, 1997 and he has almost won the 1998 Nascar Winston Cup Championship. He has won over
Herland As A Feminist Work Essay Research
Paper Feminism is the advocating for social, political, and all other rights of women equal to those of men (Random House College Dictionary). This story depicts just that. It is about a society made entirely of women with no need for men. We see the perspective of men through the eyes of our narrator. He gives us the point of view from three different men about women.
Accounting Project Essay Research Paper Accounting ProjectBAC
Accounting Project Essay, Research Paper Accounting Project BAC 3AA Profile of an Accounting Department My interview with the accountant of Robin Hood Multifoods Inc. was one of the greatest interviews I have ever experienced. The person whom I interviewed was