It is unfortunate that the U.S. chose to use automobiles as its wedge to open the alleged “closed” markets of Japan. One Japan-based managing executive of the Big Three has even admitted that they consider the Japanese automobile market to be open. Japan is not the island of protectionism in a sea of free trade that its critic allege. The problem for the U.S. auto-makers is not a lack of market access, but a lack of effort. The first step required for the U.S. auto makers to sell competitively in Japan is not to impose of ridiculous tariffs, but to have Detroit bring up the quality to Japanese standards. All in all, the U.S.’s decision to use automobiles as its wedge to open the Japanese market was surely a dangerous one. In addition, the utilization of unilateral actions by the U.S. is clearly a violation of international trade law. Not only is this decision a resemblance of managed trade but a policy which will weaken the leadership position of the U.S. in the world economy as well.
The U.S. needs to do what the Japanese did when they penetrated the American market; hard market research and heavy investment. The Japanese spent billions of dollars studying American taste and manufacturing models that suited them. The Big Three have generally confined their efforts to sending models that they have made specifically for Americans. Bill Duncan, the head of the Japan Automobile Manufacturers Assn. states that “it was the basic principals of competition that made the Japanese automobile industry strong.”
One example which reflects the short-sightedness of the Big Three is the insufficient number of right-hand models available in Japan. Since cars in Japan are driven on the left side, all domestic makers produce right-hand drives. It’s simple, the inconvenience of a left-hand drive, at tolls, parking lots or when overtaking another car is too dangerous. Naturally when the Japanese export their cars to the U.S., in each of the 190 versions sold, they provide American drivers with a steering wheel where they expect it; on the left side1. On the other hand U.S. exports have a grand total of 2 models which feature a right-hand drive. The Big Three sold a measly 22,000 left-hand models in 1994. Jeep sold 11,000 on their Cherokees alone, just because they remodeled it to a right-hand model2.
Another area in which Detroit must seek change is in car size. In Japan, the normal American cars are just too big. 80% of the cars in Japan are under 2000cc (2L.) Imagine yourself driving on the jammed packed, narrow streets of Tokyo. The Big Three exports not a single model which falls within these specifications. In comparison, the successful Europeans have 124 models under 2000cc and listen to this Detroit, a selection of over 100 models which are right-hand drive3. This clearly implies that efforts by the Big Three seem to be insufficient compared to that of Europeans.
An area of the Japanese car industry in which America showed tremendous dissatisfaction during the negotiation was the exclusive dealerships, or as Professor Morrison noted in his class, the “keiretsu.” It is true, each domestic manufacturer is closely linked with dealers, but as the New York Times (June 28, ‘95) reports, the dealership issue is largely beside the point: the Big Three already have twice as many outlets in Japan as all the European auto makers combined, yet they sell fewer cars. In the past, America succeeded in cracking the European market with GM and Ford, putting extra care and money over the decades into establishing dealer networks. This shows in the statistics; as the two companies occupy 25% of the European market4. This brings us to a question: Why doesn’t the U.S. after enjoying such a success in Europe, put in the same kind of effort into the Japanese market. Maybe U.S. companies should reconsider just what it takes to succeed. German auto-makers alone, who have commanded over 50% of the import market in Japan, have invested nearly $1 billion in Japan. “The massive investments helps. Dealers wonder how serious we are” says Volkswagen Japan manager Minoru Suzuki. Comparatively, American spending is estimated at $120 million, with Ford eating $100 million of the pie5.
Along with the complaint about the keiretsu, Americans plead that astronomical land costs makes it hard to set up their own dealerships. However the same applies to Japanese makers as well. A couple years ago, Mazda, who is considered a minor player in the Japanese market, established a new dealership network for its new model. The fact is they competed under the same harsh conditions as the American but with fewer resources and still succeeded in establishing a very stable and profitable network. There are many other examples as well. The U.S. should keep their mouth closed and intensify their efforts in the Japanese market.
As explained above, the reason for America’s continued failure in taking a strong hold on the Japanese car industry is mostly a lack of effort. For that reason, the U.S.’s complaining about a lack of market access, their blaming market shortcomings on Japan and their utilization of unilateral actions to pry open the Japanese market will endanger America’s position as an economic leader of the world. Automobiles is a large issue in trade negotiations, but a small part of the macro-economy. If the U.S. were to keep a stance similar to that which they held during the automobile negotiations in June and other nations retaliated to this stance, the world economy will head into a generation of managed trade.
Bibliographic Sources
“Big 3 and Japan.” New York Times, June 26, 1995.
Borrus, Amy with Bill Javetski. “Who’s Afraid of the World Trade Organization.” Business Week, June 5, 1995, p.35.
Borrus, Amy with John Templeman, Keith Naughton, Edith Updike and Bureau Report. “Good Deal? Yes. Great Deal? No.” Business Week, July 10, 1995, p.32-33.
“Clinton’s Phoney Peace.” The Economist, July 1, 1995, p.13.
Dornbusch, Rudi. “Sanctions against Japan: A Necessary Evil.” Business Week, July 3, 1995, p.20.
Hamilton, David. “Calmer Voices Amid the Trade Bluster.” Wall Street Journal, June 22, 1995.
“Ignorant Armies.” National Review, June 26, 1995, p.20.
Kelly, Kevin with Zachary Schiller and Edith Updike. “Buy Our Car Seats. Japan, or It’s War.” Business Week, June 26, 1995, p.42.
Kuttner, Robert. “You Could Drive a Lexus through the Holes in the WTO.” Business Week, June 12, 1995, p.24
“OK Mickey, Let’s Say You Won.” The Economist, July 1, 1995, p.65.
“The New Thirst for Imports in Japan.” Business Week, June 5, 1995, p.52.
Updike, Edith. “Roadblocks, Roadblocks Everywhere.” Business Week, June 19, 1995, p.58
Updike, Edith with Brian Bremner, Amy Borrus, David Woodruff and Larry Armstrong. “Japan’s Auto Shock.” Business Week, May 29, 1995, p.44.
The New Strategies to Expand by Big Three (as of Dec. ‘95)
GM
– together with Toyota, will unveil a right-hand model of subcompact Cavalier
– plans to offer U.S. built right-hand drive Saturn by 1997
– aims to sell right-hand drive Cadillacs in near future
Ford
– displayed right-hand version of new Taurus mid-size sedan and Explorer
– Taurus will be available in spring ‘96 and Explorer in fall ‘96
– aims to expand distribution outlets to 700 from 310 by year 2000
– aims to push sales to 200,000 annually by year 2000 from 56,000 this year
Chrysler
– displayed five right-hand drive model which will be available by fall ‘95
– aims to expand oulets to 200 by next yeat from 100 this year
– payed Seibu group $100 million to expand distribution network
Другие работы по теме:
Shoes Essay Research Paper Dear Tom and
Shoes Essay, Research Paper Dear Tom and Ben: I will come down this afternoon to pick up the banner, drop off the cashier?s check for the shoes and batons (I forgot to mail it!), and trade the shoes for black patent (shiny) shoes. I believe that you said that you had the Dinkles in stock. We have Showstoppers, but I will take the Dinkles if that is all we can get our hands on. (I?m the one who screwed up! It was one of my students who pointed it out to me that I ordered the wrong shoes!)
BenHur A Tale Of Christ By Lew
Wallace (1827 – 1905) Essay, Research Paper Wallace’s mixture of adventure, melodrama, period language, and accurately-depicted intercultural relations make Beti-Htir
The Kanagawa Treaty Essay Research Paper The
The Kanagawa Treaty Essay, Research Paper The Kanagawa Treaty In 1852 the United States appointed Commodore Mathew Perry to lead an expedition to Japan in efforts to open diplomatic and trade relations. Japan had been closed off from the rest of the world for over two hundred years. Only the Dutch and Chinese had limited contact with Japan.
African Slave Trade Essay Research Paper With
African Slave Trade Essay, Research Paper With exploration arising in the 1400 s, so did the completion for success between Portugal and Spain. Both countries were in search for the ultimate prize of exploration, gold. Portugal sought after Africa and Spain attempted to find more in the Americas. Even though the African slave trade seemed racist in historical perspective, it was indeed more for economic benefits instead because of the necessity of workers by Spaniards and fact that slavery was accepted in Africa.
Relations Essay Research Paper Events That Helped
Relations Essay, Research Paper Events That Helped Events that Hurt Neutral Events 1647 – The Commercial Alliance Between Quebec and New England was good because it shows a business partnership between two sides. 1690 – The Iroquois Peace Treaty was a neutral event because it involved the British, Iroquois, and the tribes around the Great Lakes, it had nothing to do with the New England. 1755 – The Acadians being expelled from Nova Scotia was neutral because it dealt with the French Canadians being expelled from the Maritimes to other colonies, it did not affect the Americans. 1774 – The Quebec Act hurt relations because it enraged American settlers , and they considered the it one of the Intolerable Acts which contributed to the outbreak of the American Revolution. 1775 – The American Invasion Of Quebec hurt relations because the American forces invaded Canada, and tried to take
The Ftaa Essay Research Paper The FTAA
The Ftaa Essay, Research Paper The FTAA is the Free Trade Area Americas. Its main goal is to extend the North American Free Trade Agreement to the entire Hemisphere. The FTAA brings together all the leaders of North, South and Central America (except for Cuba) to Quebec for several meetings and negotiations.
Mercantilism Essay Research Paper Mercantilism as a
Mercantilism Essay, Research Paper Mercantilism as a global economic policy tends to subscribe to the following premises: wealth is an essential means to power, power is essential as a means to the acquisition of wealth, wealth and power are each proper ultimate ends of national policy, and there is a long run balance of trade between these ends.
Environmental Scanning Essay Research Paper This paper
Environmental Scanning Essay, Research Paper This paper will discuss environmental scanning, marketing procedures, and describe how the environment affects marketing in relation to the automobile detailing business.
Automobile Essay Research Paper HistoryAfter the steam
Automobile Essay, Research Paper History After the steam engine was invented in the early 17th century, various attempts were made to apply this source of power to self-propelled road vehicles. Early efforts were unsuccessful, except for those that produced interesting toys such as the machine developed about 1680 by the English scientist Sir Isaac Newton, wich was propelled by the back pressure of a jet of steam directed to the rear.
Slave Trades Essay Research Paper African slave
Slave Trades Essay, Research Paper African slave trade to the America and the European was much worse than slavery in Africa. In this essay ,I will show you the differences. Where were the slave trade took place. Slavery was mostly happing in North America in the carribean and in Europe.The ships full of slaves mostly come to Cuba.
Finale Essay Research Paper The United States
Finale Essay, Research Paper The United States has been a super power for many years now. Will they continue to be so??? Part of this reason is that since gaining world leadership it has had an enormous impact in trading affairs.
Sulfuric Acid Essay Research Paper Sulfuric AcidFew
Sulfuric Acid Essay, Research Paper Sulfuric Acid Few chemicals affect people’s lives in as many ways as does sulfuric acid. It is used in making thousands of everyday products and has been called the single most important indutrial chemical. One of its most familiar uses is in automobile batteries. Sulfuric acid is alos used in such manufacturing processes as the production of fertilizers, drugs, detergents, and many metals.
Henry Ford Essay Research Paper Transportation has
Henry Ford Essay, Research Paper Transportation has become a major necessity in today’s society. Without the industrial revolution introducing the automobile, most people would find it very hard and frustrating to get around. Henry Ford had become a big part of starting this faster and safer “transportation era”.
The Silk Road Essay Research Paper The
The Silk Road Essay, Research Paper The Silk Road is the most well-known trading route of ancient Chinese civilization. Trade in silk grew under the Han Dynasty in the first and second centuries. Originally, the Chinese trade silk internally, within the empire. Caravans from the empire’s interior would carry silk to the western edges of the region.
European Union Essay Research Paper EUROPE ESSAYThe
European Union Essay, Research Paper EUROPE ESSAY The European Union is a movement that will let Europe trade easier. Europeans are removing the borders to let it be easier to enter into a different country. They figured that the U.S. had few problems with it, they are going to try.
Automobile Accident Data Essay Research Paper Recent
Automobile Accident Data Essay, Research Paper Recent studies in automobile accident data shows that students who have fewer accidents also receive good grades in school as opposed to students with poor grades. In the future, we may see a Maine law that would issue temporary licenses to students, only to be renewed with proof of passing grades.
The Driving Age In Tennessee Essay Research
Paper The Driving Age in Tennessee The driving age should be raised to the age of eighteen for many reasons. The group of people at highest risk for having an automobile accident are those who are sixteen years of age. Many accidents within this age group can be attributed to
Trading Places Essay Research Paper Advanced English
Trading Places Essay, Research Paper Advanced English Ted Korolchuk Mrs. Feldhausen 8-23-95 Trading Places If I could trade places with somebody, it would be Atticus Finch, from the book, To Kill a Mockingbird, by Harper Lee. There are many reasons I would trade.
Gold Rush Essay Research Paper The California
Gold Rush Essay, Research Paper The California Gold Rush had many effects on the American people, westward expansion, the environment, economy and Indian relations ultimately affecting the world as a whole. When John Marshall first found gold in January 1848 at Sutter’s Mill in California many people on the east coast did not believe the news.
Communication Essay Research Paper CommunicationCommunication is very
Communication Essay, Research Paper Communication Communication is very important to your customers. An aspect of communication is personal trade. Personal trade is a customer that comes into your store and asks for you by name. This customer might be someone you spoke with over the phone and a relationship was developed.
Should Canada And The Us Trade Essay
, Research Paper Should Canada and the US trade with China? With all the civil rights abused in China, should the Canada and the US be trading with them? In the view of one side, we should not trade with China because of these abused rights. It is thought that if we stop all trade with them, we will have an impact on their economy and they will at least cut down on their civil rights abuses in order to regain our trade and economy.
Trade Relations With China Essay Research Paper
“A Paper Tiger on Trade” It seems that the major question surrounding the United States and its foreign relations these days is whether or not we grant China Permanent Normal Trade Relations(PNTR). Some feel that we should give it to them, while many oppose the move as well. However, the reasons to not grant China PNTR are not nearly as conclusive as those reasons to grant it to them.
Volvo Essay Research Paper ESSAY
Volvo Essay, Research Paper ESSAY #4 Volvo the collectable classic In this article it stated that when Volvo was introduced to the states in 1956. The PV444, was the first US bound automobile ever. The car had resembled a smaller version of the 1946 Ford Tutor. The car featured a two piece windshield, small engine, and all of the standard features of a car of it?s time.
Pro Nafta Essay Research Paper I believe
Pro Nafta Essay, Research Paper I believe that NAFTA should stay in Mexico. It is vital for the growth in the value of the Mexican peso. Not many people are sure what exactly NAFTA does. It reduced tariffs, opened previously protected sectors in agriculture, energy, textiles, and automotive trade. It opened up the U.S.-Mexico border to trade in services with specific rules in finance, transportation and telecommunication.
Automobile Industry And World Politics Essay Research
Paper The Automobile Industry has seen sweeping changes in the recent past -Thanks to the entry of many Multinational Companies such as, Ford, Hyundai, Mitsubishi, Daewoo. These Multinational companies have set up their operations internationally not only to cater to the domestic market but also to tap the international market.
Henry Ford Essay Research Paper The Life
Henry Ford Essay, Research Paper The Life and Achievements of: Henry Ford Period 4/5 Mr. Cline Henry Ford was born near Dearborn, Michigan, on July 30, 1863. His mother died while he was 12 years old. As an early teenager he helped on the family farm in summer and in winter he attended a one-room school. Watches and clocks fascinated Ford.
Great Depression Essay Research Paper Great Depression
Great Depression Essay, Research Paper Great Depression began in the early 1930’s, and lasted about a decade. The main cause for the Great Depression was the combination of the greatly unequal distribution of wealth throughout the 1920’s and extensive stock market speculation that took place during the later part that same decade.
Naval Warships Essay Research Paper The Navy
Naval Warships Essay, Research Paper The Navy in World War I Prior to World War I, the U.S. Navy was not a prominent factor in the foreign economy. However, it was World War I that brought about the true potential power of the U.S. Navy. After World War I, the U.S. Navy became a prominent instrument in the foreign policy of the world.
Good Neighbor Policy Essay Research Paper The
Good Neighbor Policy Essay, Research Paper The Good Neighbor Policy The Good Neighbor policy was the idea that the United States should branch away from isolationism and establish relations with Latin American Countries in order to increase trade. The U.S. was especially concerned with trade in Latin America because of the problems created by the war between Japan and China, which began in 1937, the outbreak of World War II in 1939, and finally with the military and diplomatic efforts necessitated by the entrance of the United States into the war in 1941.
International Relations Realism Essay Research Paper In
International Relations: Realism Essay, Research Paper In the discipline of International Relations realism, which developed as a reaction to idealism during the Cold War, has become the dominant school of thought . Realism makes power the currency of international politics. Realist argue that by accumulating power states can ensure the security of the population within the state.
Retail Trade Essay Research Paper Write a
Retail Trade Essay, Research Paper Write a structure-performance study of the retail trade industry Paper should include the ff structure 1 Introduction. In this section you give an overview of the industry, its size, growth over the past 10-20 yrs, its important to the economy and other significant factors. 1-2 pages