R. Overton Essay, Research Paper
Samir Kumar September 15, 1996
ANALYSIS OF THE OPINION OF JUDGE WILLIAM R. OVERTON
Judge William R. Overton sets out five criteria in examining the validity of “creation science” as a scientific theory in the case McLean vs. Arkansas. Two of these characteristics are testability against the empirical world and the tentativeness of a theory’s conclusion. Overton explains why he thinks these criteria are important and why creation science fails to satisfy them.
Overton feels that testability against the empirical world is a fundamental tenet of modern science. According to Overton testability or falsifiability is what makes a theory scientific. Overton believes that creation science fails to meet this criteria. Creationists belief states that we do not know how God created, what processes he used, for God used processes which are not now operating anywhere in the natural universe. They believe we cannot discover by scientific investigation anything about the creative processes used by God. Thus the theory is not even open to the concept of testability because they claim that processes which brought about the universe are no longer in existence. Overton goes on to say that this aspect of creationist belief is straight out of the bible and the story of Genesis. The bible is not science but religion.
To be able to test a theory is essential to all science. How else does one determine a hypothesis from reality, or fact from fiction? Science is only limited by technology and the tools of the era available to it. To say that a theory is not testable via scientific means is a rash statement. Einstein’s theory of relativity made many predictions which could not be tested at the time the theory was presented. For example measuring time dilation and the distortion of space-time was only possible with the onset of extremely accurate atomic clocks. The bending of starlight could not be observed until the appropriate solar telescope was available. This is a perfect example of how technology empowers science to prove or disprove its theories. The purpose of science is to explain the universe based on a premise that the properties of the universe are rational and logical. These same standards also apply to the formation of the earth and the subsequent rise of life on this planet. There is no evidence yet to show otherwise. The same elements that form all living things and the planet we live on also form the rest of the universe. The same forces that governed the earth when life came about also govern the universe today. It is only the short lifetime of human beings and the limitation of our knowledge to gain a complete and concise picture of the events that led to the formation of life. Thus at this time it is very difficult to test the validity of any theory concerning creation. We can make cHowever no one can say that will be the case in the future. Who would have guessed that only 66 years after the Wright Brothers first flight man would land on the moon. Back then there were people who were audacious enough to say that space flight would never be possible. In science there is no absolute. least of all the concept that certain scientific theories can never be tested against the empirical world. This also leads to one of the other criteria that Overton uses to judge creation science, the tenativeness of a theory’s conclusions.
Tentativity is considered to be a natural aspect of a scientific theory. To date there has not been one scientific theory which has been absolute.
Другие работы по теме:
Microsoft Essay Research Paper Microsoft has had
Microsoft Essay, Research Paper Microsoft has had a couple of though months since July last year, when Judge Thomas Jackson ordered the company to break up in two. However, since the beginning of this year things have just looked better for Microsoft.
William Shakespeare
William Shakespeare was born on the 23rd of April 1564 in Stratford-upon-Avon. Father of William Shakespeare, John Shakespeare, was a merchant. He sold leather gloves and was rather successful. He was even going to be become the Head of Stratford-upon-Avon.
The Merchant Of Venice A Tragic Play
Essay, Research Paper The Merchant of Venice: A Tragic Play In my opinion the play The Merchant of Venice is a tragic one which is discised as being comic. Many factors of this play are derived from the current
Woburn Essay Research Paper The Woburn trial
Woburn Essay, Research Paper The Woburn trial was an incredibly complex case involving thirty-three plaintiffs, two defendants, a mountain of conflicting hydro-geological and medical testimony regarding causation, and multiple claims including negligence, nuisance and emotional distress. That is why, in my professional opinion, Judge Skinner changed the complete outcome of the trial with his actions, concerning both the procedure of the trial, and his own personal interactions with myself.
Analysis William Cullen Bryan Essay Research Paper
William Cullen Bryant’s “To a Waterfowl” Analysis: By the title of this poem one can only come to the conclusion that the poem is about nature. Bryant loved nature as a young boy. The beginning of this particular poem starts
Kive Essay Research Paper
# a b c d e f g h i j k l m n o p q r s t u v w x y Grapes of Wrath, The – Book Summary and Analysis Grapes of Wrath, The – Book Analysis Grapes of Wrath, The – Joads’ Journey Great Expectations – Powerful Themes in the Novel
Stereotypes Essay Research Paper StereotypesTo Judge or
Stereotypes: Essay, Research Paper Stereotypes: To Judge or Not To Judge If a man commits a crime is he bad? A person with pink hair is a drug user? Interracial relationships make unnatural children? These are all types of stereotypical comments that make life hard for people to deal with in many ways. To judge or not to judge it s a simple concept that many of us take for granted.
King James Essay Research Paper Chapter Two
King James Essay, Research Paper Chapter Two of William James’s Pragmatism called “What Pragmatism Means” begins with the famous metaphysical question: Does the man go round the squirrel or not? What he means by this is if a man walks around a tree in a full circle, and a squirrel is one of the tree branches, how come it never occurs to the man to say that he not only walked around the tree, but the squirrel as well?
Analysis Of College Pressures Essay Research
Paper Analysis of College Pressures In the essay College Pressures , William Zinsser shows parents the burdens that college students have while they are in school. In the essay he states the four pressures that the students face: economic, parental, peer, and self-induced.
William James Essay Research Paper William James
William James Essay, Research Paper William James, in the first lecture of his work the varieties of religious experiences analyzes the origins of religious phenomena. The theory mostly debated among others is that of medical materialism.
Krypton Essay Research Paper The element that
Krypton Essay, Research Paper The element that I have chosen in . The people who discovered it are known as Sir William Ramsay and Morris William Travers. Sir William Ramsay and Morris William
William Bennett Essay Research Paper In William
William Bennett Essay, Research Paper In William Bennett?s ?Announcing a Public Campaign Against Select Day-Time Television Talk Shows?, William Bennett gives his view of the content that is being
Untitled Essay Research Paper Analysis of Crito
Untitled Essay, Research Paper Analysis of Crito The question is raised within the dialogue between Socrates and Crito concerning civil disobedience. Crito has the desire, the means, and many compelling
Antony Speech Analysis Essay Research Paper Emotional
Antony Speech Analysis Essay, Research Paper Emotional Speech Analysis William Shakespeare?s ?Julius Caesar? is a well-written stage play. Shakespeare included many good speeches in his plays; one of the best was the one delivered by Antony. Antony?s speech came very shortly after Julius Caesar?s death, and the city was in much chaos.
Celebrated Cases Of Judge Dee Essay Research
Paper Sung Yon Kim Asian Civilization Celebrated Cases of Judge Dee In by reading the Celebrated Cases of Judge Dee, I gained a perspective of the people and culture of China. This book showed the analysis of Chinese saw and the background of Chinese history.
Who Are We To Judge Essay Research
Paper Who Are We to Judge Anyone? Sometimes it is easy to form an opinion about someone based on what you see from the outside, but by no means is this an effective way of assessing the way someone is inside. Just like you cannot judge a book a book by its cover, you cannot judge a person without getting to know them.
Lord Of The Flies Analysis Essay Research
Paper Lord of the Flies Analysis The novel Lord of the Flies written by William Golding was a very exciting novel. It wasn t the plot that made the novel interesting; it was the personalities of the characters. The genre is science fiction and the mood is very dark and cold. The writing style of William Golding was very interesting.
Antony Analysis Essay Research Paper Antony Analysis
Antony Analysis Essay, Research Paper Antony Analysis Short Essay The beauty of William Shakespeare s writing does not lie in his actual writing, but the themes in which his plays suggest. Almost all of his plays can be connected to a higher theme, one that most people can relate. In the play, Antony and Cleopatra, the theme of manipulation runs ramped.
A Rose For Emily By William Faulkner
Essay, Research Paper The story A Rose for Emily by William Faulkner in my opinion was a very interesting story. The story was about a old and troubled woman named Emily Grierson who because of her father?s death had become one of the towns obligation?s and also one of it?s problems. Emily a very stubborn old lady who refused to pay her taxes because of a little tale that Colonel Sartoris who was the mayor at the time had told her.
Jesus As A Person Essay Research Paper
In the book Fascinating Bible Facts by David M. Howard Jr., Ph.D. and Gary M. Burge, Ph.D. Jesus is described and seen by the authors in many ways. However I find the most prominent to be Jesus as a Human or a Brother.
The Chimmney Sweeper Essay Research Paper
"The Chimney Sweeper" By William Blake Poem Analysis Unlike the one in Songs of Innocence, "The Chimney Sweeper", in Songs of Experience is very dark and pessimistic. This poem also seems to be very judgmental and gives motives for everything, but unlike Song of Innocence, the sweeper in this poem does not free himself from his misery.
Jane Hodgson Vs Minnesota Essay Research Paper
Ravi Singhvi September 10, 2000 Legal Brief Title: Dr. Jane Hodgson v. Minnesota U.S. 417 Legal Issue: Whether or not Dr. Jane Hodgson actions were justifiable and if Minnesota?s law against abortion is unconstitutional.
Laws Courts And Policies Essay Research Paper
Sep. 16 1999 Law, Courts, Politics Data/ Analysis The American President’s and Their Judges The appointing of judges to the United States Circuit Court of Appeals is the responsibility of the United States President. This responsibility does not go without its benefits. Because the law can at times be “flexible” when deciding a case, a president is most likely going to choose a judge with the same background and goals as he.
People Accused Of Violent Crimes Should Not
Be To Post Bail Essay, Research Paper People accused of violent crimes should not be allowed to post bail and remain out of jail while their trial is pending. There are many reasons to why I strongly agree with this statement. Many factors are unknown to the public without conducting some sort of extensive research.
Lord Of The Flies Character Analysis Of
Piggy Essay, Research Paper Lord of the Flies Character Analysis of Piggy Lord of the Flies With evil lurking around every corner, it became harder and harder to find a good soul on the mysterious island. In William Golding’s Lord
Poem Analysis The Tiger Essay Research Paper
Analysis: William Blake s The Tiger contains six four-line stanzas, and uses pairs of rhyming verses to create a sense of rhythm and continuous flow of the words. It is hard to tell whether it is an observational poem because of its strong use of imagery and the magnificent creation of a picture in the reader s head or self-expression because of the message it has which strongly depends on the personal attitude of the author.
The Bad Flag Essay Research Paper Some
The Bad Flag Essay, Research Paper Some people think the confederate flag is a symbol of hatred and slavery. Others think it represents the history of America. It’s up to ever person to decide where they stand. The old saying is, “If you don’t stand for something, you’ll fall for anything.” Ever person has a duty to respect the other person’s opinion.
Antigone Essay Research Paper Antigone Character Analysis
Antigone Essay, Research Paper Antigone Character Analysis Essay Dealing with enemies has been a problem ever since the beginning of time.In Antigone, by Sophocles, the value of dealing with your family and dealing with your Enemies become a huge problem for a King such as Creon. All throughout this play, Creon holds a title of authority that he must observe.
Law State Of Florida V Michael Canady
Essay, Research Paper On the date of November 27, 2000, I visited the Hillsborough county Courthouse and witnessed the Thirteenth District Circuit Court of Florida in its proceedings. The case was the State of Florida v. Michael Canady and his honor that presided over the case was Judge William Fuente. The case was called at 10:30 AM and opened with the Judge splitting the charges against the defendant.
Othello 8 Essay Research Paper Othello EssayEach
Othello 8 Essay, Research Paper Othello Essay Each individual has a different opinion on what love is, but it is amazing how these opinions differ between Desdemona and Emilia in William Shakespeare s, Othello. Othello is a play written about love, betrayal and relationships, and each character has a strong opinion on how a relationship should be.
Sonnet 130 Analysis Essay Research Paper My
Sonnet 130 Analysis Essay, Research Paper My Mistress Eyes Are Nothing Like The Sun William Shakespeare s poem, Sonnet 130 has a rhyme scheme and a rugged tone. It s three quatrains, four-line stanzas, and couplet, two-line stanza expresses that It also has a tone to it that signals some meaning to it.
The Breakfast Club Essay Research Paper The
The Breakfast Club Essay, Research Paper The breakfast club was to say the least a boring 80?s movie. But it was a good movie for the purpose of analysis. Simply put, it will not be on my list of movies to rent next time that I am at the rental store. I chose to explain the points of view of Andrew, the jock, and Allison the loner/quite person.
The Judges Wife Essay Research Paper Throughout
The Judges Wife Essay, Research Paper Throughout the story ?The Judge?s Wife?, Isabel Allende presents Dona Casilda presented as a powerless woman although later she emerges as the most powerful character in the story.