Ending Racial Profiling Essay, Research Paper
Ending Racial Profiling
The federal government should end racial profiling by requiring policemen and other law enforcement officers to keep detailed records of each individual they stop to question or search. These records should include the person?s race; the reason stopped; how long the car was detained; and whether a ticket was issued, the car searched, or any illegal goods or weapons were found when the traffic stop was made. Racial profiling is the police practice of stopping and searching African-American and Hispanic drivers at rates far disproportionate to their numbers on the road. I personally, have repeatedly been an innocent victim of racial profiling in the city in which I reside and while visiting other cities in the United States. Famous African-American men such as Congressman Harold Ford, Jr. of Tennessee, Wesley Snipes, Blair Underwood, Christopher Darden, and NAACP President Kweisi Mfume have also been stopped by police, allegedly for no other reason than the color of their skin. Robert L. Wilkins, a Harvard-educated Washington attorney, was traveling along U.S. Interstate 68 in 1992, returning from his grandfather?s funeral, when a Maryland state trooper pulled the families rented Cadillac over for speeding. When the trooper asked to search the car and its contents, Wilkins refused. But the trooper set loose a drug-sniffing dog to comb the car?s exterior, including the windshield, the hubcaps, and the taillights while Wilkins and his family stood in the rain. No drugs were found. The Wilkins family was completely humiliated. They were humiliated. They were later awarded a $95,000 settlement from the Maryland State Police, as well as an agreement by the agency to keep records to help prevent discrimination (Jones 38-40).
Statistics on racial profiling are controversial, but in a recent study, Temple University Professor John Lamlberth determined that about 75 percent of the motorists and traffic violators along one stretch of U.S. Interstate 95 were white, but 80 percent of searches were of minorities. The attitude of certain high-ranking law enforcement officials also helps to compound the problem. For instance, New Jersey Governor Christine Todd Whitman fired the state police superintendent; Carl Williams for saying that while he did not condone racial profiling, minorities were responsible for most of the country?s illegal drug trade (Cannon 72).
Statistics confirm that African Americans-particularly young black men-commit a dramatically disproportionate share of street crime in the United State. This is a sociological fact, not a figment of a racist media (or police) imagination. In recent years, victims report blacks as perpetrators of around 25 percent of violent crimes, although blacks constitute only about only about 12 percent of the nation?s population.
Statistics such as these make it seem as if racial profiling is not the result of bigotry, and that the factual claim upon which the practice rests is sound. But, racial profiling is still wrong because racial distinctions are and should be different from other lines of social stratification. That is why, since the civil rights revolution of the 1960s, courts have typically ruled-based on the 14th Amendment?s equal protection clause-that mere reasonableness is an insufficient justification for officials to discriminate on racial grounds. In such cases, courts have generally insisted on applying ?strict scrutiny?-the most intense level of judicial review-to government actions. Under this tough standard, the use of race in governmental decisions making may be upheld only if it serves a compelling government objective and only if it is ?narrowly tailored? to advance that objective (Kennedy 70-74).
Racial profiling should be ended even if the generalizations on which the technique is based are supported by empirical or factual evidence. There are actually many contexts in which the law properly forbids us from playing racial odds even when doing so would advance legitimate goals. For example, public opinion surveys have established that blacks distrust laws enforcement more than whites. Thus, it would be rational-and not necessarily racist-for a prosecutor to use ethnic origin as a factor in excluding black potential jurors. And, because demographics show that in the United States, whites tend to live longer than blacks, it would be perfectly rational for insurers to charge blacks higher life-insurance premiums. However, the law forbids both practices, and it should forbid racial profiling (Kennedy 70-74).
The fact that racial profiling insults and humiliates blacks is not the primary reason is should be ended. A number of cases have led to altercations, slayings, and national protests. In Chicago recently, two unarmed Black motorists were slain after traffic altercations. One was former Northwestern University football player Robert Russ, who was killed shortly before his graduation after he reportedly refused to get out of his car following a short chase. According to the police version, the officers broke the back window of Russ? car and pointed a gun inside. The police said Russ grabbed the gun and tried to wrestle it away from the officer, and gun fired.
A second Chicago case involved La Tonya Haggerty, a young computer analyst who was a passenger in a car with a man who had been pulled over. Haggerty, who was about to announce her engagement and who had a bright future before her, was shot and killed as she sat in the car. A police report said she was shot because the officer thought her cell phone was a gun. A witness said the woman had her hands up and was getting out of the car when she was shot. In both instances the victims were in unarmed cars and the policemen approached the victims with their weapons drawn (Kinnon 62-66).
Several recommendations have been made as to ways to end racial profiling. The American Civil Liberties Union (ACLU) make the following recommendations: (1) an end to the use of pretext stops as a crime-fighting tactic, (2) passage of remedial legislation in every state, and (3) collection of city-by-city traffic stop data on a voluntary basis.
The NAACP recommends withdrawing federal funds from police departments with high levels of unresolved brutality cases, or police departments that have been slow to react to complaints. The organization also suggests creation of police/civilian review boards to review not only profiling but also stop-and frisk procedures and strip searches of Black women, and additional federal funds for data collection on profiling, stop and frisk procedures and police brutality (Kinnon 62-66).
Some of these suggestions may be effective in ending racial profiling; especially the NAACP?s suggestion of withdrawing federal funds from certain police departments. Hitting anyone where it hurts-in the pocket- is almost always effective. But, police departments may tend go to the opposite extreme of being too lenient out of fear of losing funds. And, collecting the city-by-city traffic stop data on a voluntary basis is very similar to my suggestion of ending racial profiling, however, I believe that if this is done voluntarily, it will not be done at all. Leaving it up to individual states is not a good idea, either because some states with heavy African-American populations would probably enact such legislation to prevent racial profiling, whereas other states would feel it unnecessary to do anything about the practice.
If the federal government passed legislation that required law enforcement officers to keep traffic data, the practice of racial profiling would end because nothing is as convincing as written record, and nothing is as powerful as the authority of the law.
President Bill Clinton referred to racial profiling as ?a morally indefensible and deeply corrosive practice? that should be banned (Kinnon 62-66). It undercuts a good idea that needs more support from both society and the law: Individuals should be judged by public authorities on the basis of their own individual conduct and not on the basis of racial generalization. Race-dependent policing retards the development of bias-free thinking; indeed, it encourages the opposite (Kennedy).
As a reasonable person I firmly believe that even if the suggestions I recommend to end racial profiling are enacted and routine racial profiling is profiling is prohibited, the practice will not cease quickly. I have been in a courtroom before and I know that if an officer says he did not base his actions on race, a judge would hate to disagree with his statement. Racism is a deeply entrenched disease that is almost incurable. A new rule prohibiting racial profiling might be made just to be broken, but it could set a new standard for legitimate government. And no matter the outcome, something needs to be done about this unfair problem of racial profiling.
Cannon, Angie. ?DWB: Driving While Black? U.S. News &World Report
March 15, 1999: 72.
Jones, Joyce. ?Policing the Police? Black Enterprise June 2000: 38-40.
Kennedy, Randall. ?You Cant? Judge a Crook by His Color.? Utne Reader January- February 2000: 70-74.
Kinnon, Joy Bennett. ?DWB Driving While Black.? Ebony September 1999: 62-66
Другие работы по теме:
Historical Notes In The Handmaid
’s Tale Essay, Research Paper Historical Notes on The Handmaid?s Tale? The Handmaid?s Tale by Margaret Atwood is an intriguing look into a darker one of infinite possibilities that our future as a country offers. The
Do Fairy Tales Loes There Mean Essay
, Research Paper Comparison Paper One chilly night you decide to pull out your old book of fairytales. As you dust off the cover you start reading along, and as you finish the tale. You re struck with a large volt of curiosity, you realize that it was not the same as the tale you were told when you were little. You reread the authors name and see it is the Charles Perrualt.
Euthanasia Essay Research Paper Is euthanasia the
Euthanasia Essay, Research Paper Is euthanasia the mercy killing of someone who is in extreme pain in order to end suffering, an immoral or amoral act? Simply put, it is an immoral act even though it is intended to help another person. It is assisting in killing another human being, and ending their existence.
Book Reporte The Eye Of The Tiger
Essay, Research Paper Question 1) Write a different beginning or a different ending for the story. Answer 1) I chose to write a different ending for the story.
How The Ending Of The Novel Manages
To End Or Resolve The Novel’s Key Themes Essay, Research Paper ?To Kill A Mockingbird? by Harper Lee is a classic novel that deals with two ?mockingbirds? in Boo Radley and Tom Robinson. ?They don?t do one thing but sing their hearts out for us. That?s why it?s a sin to kill a mockingbird,? says Atticus. Despite the stigma involved with such an action, Maycomb physically and socially kill two Mockingbirds.
Poem Thank You Essay Research Paper THANK
Poem: Thank You Essay, Research Paper THANK YOU There for me through thick and thin Never hesitates to lend a hand Comforts me when everything seems dim Always listens when I feel the need to express to them
Violence Essay Research Paper Violence is a
Violence Essay, Research Paper Violence is a one of the biggest problems for many communities, but the community isn’t the real problem, almost all the problems start at homes, and at schools there are many ways of solving them, starting for ourselves and our family, and ending up helping to the other people.
That Place In Your Mind (What Is
Hell, Related To Dante’s Inf Essay, Research Paper That Place in Your Mind Hell is a place that is created in one’s mind. It is different for each person, depending on what they believe. It can be a never-ending pit, or a room a barren room at the center of the earth, that is super hot. It can be a table with mounds of food, that people are sitting at, but cannot eat the food.
Racial Profiling Essay Research Paper Despite the
Racial Profiling Essay, Research Paper Despite the civil rights victories of 30 years ago, official racial prejudice is still reflected throughout the criminal justice system. For people of color in cities large and small across this nation, north and south, east and west, Jim Crow “justice” is alive and well.
Jacob
’s Wake Essay, Research Paper What did the ending mean to me and how I would have changed it. The ending of a play can be one of purpose, one that leaves you with a sense of completion and fulfillment. In the play ?Jacob?s Wake? the ending was, to say the least, odd. I didn?t really get a sense that the ending belonged to the play.
Racial Profiling Essay Research Paper The topic
Racial Profiling Essay, Research Paper The topic of racial profiling amongst minority individuals in the state of New Jersey has been a heated issue for the past several years. This department has been charged with numerous allegations of racism and is the main focus for racial based events in police departments nationwide.
Those Winter Sundays Essay Research Paper Joshua
?Those Winter Sundays? Essay, Research Paper Joshua Erd, Box 630 Fawn Knight ASEN 101-02 29 November 2000 Those Winter Sundays Review The poem of ?Those Winter Sundays? has a very interesting and peculiar ending. The author of the poem leaves the ending open. By an open ending I mean the author ends the poem with a question.
A Good Man Is Hard To Find 2
?A Good Man Is Hard To Find? By Flannery O?Connor Essay, Research Paper “A Good Man is Hard to Find: Foreshadowing” In “A Good Man is Hard to find” by Flannery O’Connor, one is struck by the unexpected violence at the end of the story. However, if the story is read a second time, reader can see definite signs of foreshadowing that hints to the ending of the story.
Power Of One Essay Research Paper Power
Power Of One Essay, Research Paper Power of One I did not enjoy this movie. I thought it was poorly done, the camera shots were very basic, it was extremely predictable and ?deja vu?. Since I am no
Lincoln Essay Research Paper Abraham Lincoln is
Lincoln Essay, Research Paper Abraham Lincoln is an American hero. A lot of important events occurred that changed America forever. Three of them are giving the Gettysberg address, ending slavery, and becoming assassinated.
William Shakespeare S Sonnet
#18 Essay, Research Paper In William Shakespeare s Sonnet #18 , he compares his feelings towards nature to his beloved. Shakespeare talks about the beauty of a summer day and how it is beautiful to him. He has strong feelings towards the summer s never ending beauty and compares it his love for one particular person.
The Chamber Essay Research Paper A Question
The Chamber Essay, Research Paper A Question of Life or Death The novel The Chamber, by John Grisham, is an emotional account of a lawyer’s struggle to liberate his racist grandfather from death row. This attorney not only battles to save a life but skirmishes against of the most debated topics of modern society: capital punishment.
Quality Report Essay Research Paper Main characters
Quality Report Essay, Research Paper Main characters: The main characters are Uncle Beazley the dinosaur, Nate Twitchel the owner of the dinosaur and Doctor Ziemer the scientist. The setting is in Freedom New Hampshire and it is summer there.
Edgar Allan Poe Essay Research Paper Poe
Edgar Allan Poe Essay, Research Paper Poe’s Never Ending Loneliness “From childhood’s hour I have not been/as others were; I have not seen/ as others say I could not bring/ my passions from a common spring. From the same source I have not taken/ my sorrow; I could not awaken/ my heart to joy at the same tone;/ and all I loved, I loved alone.”
King Lear Essay Research Paper The ending
King Lear Essay, Research Paper The ending of King Lear has proven itself very controversial in its history. in shakespeare’s other play, the conclusions are simple: Othello kills himself, Macbeth is executed, ans everyone dies in hamlet. lear, however, is not as simple as the preceding, and in fact, leaves many questions unanswered.
Racial Profiling Unfair To The Innocent Essay
, Research Paper Racial Profiling: Unfair to the Innocent The issue of racial profiling in America is one of great importance to the future of American society. This issue fairly new, in terms of being recognized is old in its ways. Racism and stereotyping are issues that date back to hundreds of years ago. Racial profiling in America is one that needs to be addressed by the government and society if we ever want America to truly be, “The Land of The Free.” One of the main examples of racial profiling is called DWB (Driving While Black).
Racial Profiling Essay Research Paper Racial profiling
Racial Profiling Essay, Research Paper Racial profiling is a law enforcement strategy that encourages police officers to stop and question African-Americans simply because of their race. Employers and government agencies that require job applicants to list their “race” or “ethnicity” on employment and contracting applications perform racial profiling thousands of times every day.
The BhagavadGita Subdued Essay Research Paper The
The Bhagavad-Gita Subdued Essay, Research Paper The Bhagavad-Gita most likely begins with philosophy instead of ending with it because it gives people the major message of the whole text. If you keep reading and find out the details of how you are supposed to be a good Hindu is up to you. If it were at the end, it would probably not be a holy book, but just a story with a couple morals attached to the ending.
Princess Of Cleves Essay Research Paper Princess
Princess Of Cleves Essay, Research Paper Princess Of Cleves The princess of cleves is the first important novel because it s the first written by a woman, and it s the first non-romance. This is the first story where the ending is a tragedy rather then a happy ending. The psychological aspects of the characteristics are more realistic then ever before.
Shakespear To Be Or Not To Be
Essay, Research Paper Shakespeare s The Tragedy of Hamlet, Prince of Denmark Act 3 Scene 1- To be, or not to be Should I kill my fathers murderer, or not? What should I do? Would it be better for me to deal with my misfortunes, or should I fight against my many troubles. By fighting I might die; I will sleep, I will be no more.
Romeo And Juliet Essay Research Paper In
Romeo And Juliet Essay, Research Paper In many dramatic plays there are many points in the story that could have prevented the tragic ending. Such as shown in the play of Romeo and Juliet, by William Shakespeare. The ending of Romeo and Juliet was very tragic. In all there were six deaths. Including that of the star-crossed lovers, Romeo and Juliet.
The Cycle Of Never Ending Cause And
Effect Essay, Research Paper The Cycle of Never Ending Cause and Effect There is no such thing as first or second, or as cause and effect. Humanity has constantly searched for the beginning of things asking questions
Immortality Essay Research Paper Immortality
Immortality Essay, Research Paper Immortality – (a) the quality or state of being immortal. (b) never ending existence. Although that is the Webster definition of immortality, what is never-ending existence?
Racial Profiling Essay Research Paper The United
Racial Profiling Essay, Research Paper The United States is not a healthy democracy The United States is not a healthy democracy. A basic requirement for any healthy democracy is its founding on the basic principle that all men are created equal. This means that man is judged on the fact that he is man, and only that.
When Legends Die Essay Research Paper Response
When Legends Die Essay, Research Paper Response to WLD Movie and Novel When the Legends die was very similar in the novel and in the motion picture. There were some differences, but most remained the same.
Review Of A Review Essay Research Paper
Review of a Review Mark Caro seems to let one flaw ruin an entire movie. In his review of “Unbreakable” Caro admits that the duration of the film is commendable, but its ending is too disappointing to look past. He begins by comparing “Unbreakable” to the highly acclaimed “The Sixth Sense”. By saying that “The Sixth Sense” viewers will be, “on the lookout for clues that might telegraph the inevitable final twist” Caro puts the idea in our minds that we should all expect the same type of ending.
An Explication Of To The Virgins To
Make Much Of Time Essay, Research Paper The tiltle To the Virgins, to Make much of time, gives a hint as to the meaning of the work. We gleam from the title that Time is going to be significant. However, we cannot know what the context of time is without the benefit of reading further. We also learn that Virgins plays an integral part of this work.
Antigone Essay Research Paper Creon is the
Antigone Essay, Research Paper Creon is the tragic hero in the play Antigone by Sophocles. A tragic hero must a major character that shows high rank and is generally respected as courageous. The character shows nobility but has a fatal flaw or fatal flaw in judgment. The tragic hero will have an unhappy ending.