’s Faith And Guilt Essay, Research Paper
A Commentary on Man s Faith and his Guilt
Archibald MacLeish raised many thought provoking questions in the play J.B.. The Book of Job had already asked some of these questions, while others were very original and insightful. MacLeish offers many powerful thoughts on the relationship between man and God, some of which are disturbing to consider.
Nickels lost his faith in both God and man. He believes that the purpose of life is merely to survive and not to live. Nickles says,
There must be thousands!… Millions and millions of mankind burned, crushed, broken, mutilated, slaughtered, and for what? For thinking! For walking around the world in the wrong skin, the wrong shaped noises, eyelids: sleeping the wrong night wrong city- London, Dresden, Hiroshima. (MacLeish, 12)
In fact the only thing that Nickels did have faith in was that J.B. would curse God if tested. Mr. Zuss, on the other hand, has complete faith in humanity and J.B. He knows of J.B. s strength and his ability to love God. In short, Mr. Zuss has faith in J.B. s faith. However, J.B. s faith in God is ill founded. J.B. s faith in God is based on the fact that he believes God to be just, but is God really just? If he is then why does J.B. suffer so? Maybe it is just J.B. s notion of justice that is incorrect. Bildad comments on the notion of justice, History is justice! Time inexorably turned to truth! One man s suffering won t count, no matter what his suffering; but all will. At the end there will be justice! Justice for All! Justice for everyone! (MacLeish, p121). This can be taken to mean that there is no justice for individuals only for mankind as a whole. So if this is the case, how does J.B. manage to keep his faith when he finds out that there was no reason for his suffering? The deaths of his children, the loss of his wealth and the corruption of his health were all done for no cause and yet J.B. maintains his love for God. Why? Perhaps J.B. now puts his faith in the fact that God is all knowing and has a plan for each of us that we cannot hope to understand. After all, is that not the definition of faith, to put ones trust into something that is beyond comprehension. J.B. realizes this in the end,
I know that thou canst do everything… and that no thought can be withholden from thee. .. Therefore have I uttered that I understood not: Things too wonderful for me, which I knew not. I have heard of thee by the hearing ear… but now… mine eye seeth thee! Wherefore I abhor myself… and repent… (MacLeish, 132)
The three comforters offer some intriguing thoughts on the concept of man s guilt. Bildad states that guilt is merely a sociological accident . That is, guilt is simply determined by chance; if you are in the wrong place at the wrong time you are guilty. Should the man who survives a fatal car accident feel guilty? Should the other deaths be on his conscience, he was merely going about his business when his car staled and plowed into a group of pedestrians. There was nothing he could have done to prevent this, yet those people are dead because of him. However, this idea of guilt also has a lot to do with perception, You may be guiltier than Hell as history counts and not one smudging thumbprint on your conscience. (MacLeish, p121). What at one time may have been considered a sin might not be today and what may be a sin today might not be considered a sin tomorrow. An example of this can be seen in the idea of Manifest Destiny which America practiced though the 1800 s. People of the time felt they were doing God s will and so had a free conscience. Yet today we look back at all of the injustices that came as a result of Manifest Destiny and are haunted by our misdoings.
Eliphaz suggests that guilt is a psychophenomenal situation . He says that our ignorance causes our guilt and that we are all actually victims of our guilt because of this. Many immigrants who come here are often ignorant of the finer points of the American justice system. As a result of this they are frequently penalized for carrying out customs that are a part of their culture. This type of situation could hardly be seen as an intentional provocation of guilt.
Then there is Zophar s argument, which I find to be the most interesting of the three. Zophar argues that it is man s guilt that makes him human. He believes that it is guilt that separates us from the mindless beasts, for animals are incapable of sin. This seems to be a perversion of the truth. It is man s ability to distinguish between sin and piety that makes him human, not his ability to practice the former. Zophar also contests that it is God s fault that sin exists. He feels that God created man with a predisposition towards sin. Zophar responds to J.B. s questioning thusly, …Man s heart is evil! …Man s will is evil. Your fault, your sin, are heart and will: the worm at heart, the willful will corrupted with its foul imagining. (MacLeish, 126). Yet there is one argument of Zophar s that I do agree with, that the beginning of mankind can be traced back to the fall of man. For it was at this moment that man acquired the ability to distinguish between good and evil and it is this knowledge coupled with our free will that makes us human. If man simply acted on instinct what would be the point of life. We would have no control over are actions, we would be automatons only concerned with the thought of survival. Would there even be religion? Would we have the time or the desire for it?
What is man supposed to base his faith on if God does not always act justly? What is there to believe in? Is God to blame for the existence of sin? These are a few of the questions that one must consider if one believes in God. Whether or not any answers can be found has yet to be seen.
Другие работы по теме:
Romeo And Juliet Commentary Essay Research Paper
Romeo and Juliet – Commentary There are three characters in this extract: The servant (the Clown), Benvolio and Romeo. The servant plays only a minor role, being merely a device to allow Romeo to meet Juliet. Benvolio’s name in Latin may be translated loosely to “I mean well” this is a fitting moniker for one who always offers good advice to Romeo.
American Dream Lost Essay Research Paper American
American Dream Lost Essay, Research Paper American Dream Lost Gatsby as a Social Commentary on American Life The Great Gatsby, by F. Scott Fitzgerald, has been celebrated as one of the greatest, if not the greatest American novel. Yet this is ironic for the society which has so hailed the book is precisely that which is criticized throughout it.
Religion Paper Essay Research Paper
“Food is for the belly and the belly for food, you say. True; and one day God will put an end to both. But the body is not for fornication; it is for the Lord–and the Lord for the body.” 1st Corinthians 6:13 The Broadman Bible Commentary In the Broadman Commentary it talks most about how the Corinthians were using a phrase of the day to justify the practice of sexual immoralities.
Bacchae Essay Research Paper MoralSocial Values in
Bacchae Essay, Research Paper Moral-Social Values in The Bacchae One prevailing argument about The Bacchae as with many of his other works is whether Euripides propounds a revolutionary or a reactionary message about society. This outlook, however, is skirting an essential element of The Bacchae’s theme.
Lotus Sutra Essay Research Paper One of
Lotus Sutra Essay, Research Paper One of my questions is in regards to the assembly which is referred to in the section on Devadatta. Who makes up this assembly? Is this assembly composed solely of Buddhas? Or is the assembly comprised of Bhodisattvas as well as Buddhas?
Japan At War Essay Research Paper Commentary
Japan At War Essay, Research Paper Commentary: Japan at WarThe book for me was a difficult reading experience. I myself as a Chinese who have never live through that time can only imagine the horrors that people of my race encountered through the many atrocities the Japanese committed on us. As I read this book the recurring thought on my mind was what if the Japanese massacred my family and that would have meant that I would have never been born and given the life as I know of as today.
Juniper Flower Essay Research Paper Term Paper
Juniper F;lower Essay, Research Paper Term Paper Sites – Only the Highest Quality Sites on the Net We are currently charging an application Fee of only $50 for the first 10 sites to join. Your payment and participation guarantees that within seven business days a member of Term Paper Sites’s editorial staff will look at your site and consider it for a membership.
CommentaryJane EyreRedRoom Essay Research Paper Commentary on
Commentary-Jane Eyre(Red-Room) Essay, Research Paper Commentary on Jane Eyre This particular excerpt of Charlotte Br nte s Jane Eyre is in prose, told in a first person narrative. It is about the last moments that Jane Eyre is locked in the red room after being wrongly accused of pouncing on Mrs. Reed s son, in which her mind has drifted off to the topic of ghosts and spirits coming back from the dead to take revenge on the living and then, upon thinking she has seen a ghost, flies into a panic, waking the whole household and being severely scolded.
Analysis Of A Socratic Dialogue Essay Research
Paper Analysis of a Socratic Dialogue It is known that Socrates has many dialogues that involve a single thought or point of his. This early dialogue, Hippias Minor, is a great example of that. The dialogue goes along very detailed and methodically surrounding one point. It shows us, the readers, a different way to go about understanding Socrates? thought process.
China 5 Essay Research Paper Commentary on
China 5 Essay, Research Paper Commentary on China The press in China has come a long way since the CCP took over the Chinese government in 1949 and it will continue to expand it’s freedom as we go into the 21st century. They were denied the right of freedom of speech and freedom of the press for all those years, that now the Chinese people have a hunger for information and knowledge of other countries culture and industrialization.
Analysis Of Susan Niditch
’s Commentary Of Genesis Essay, Research Paper Title: Analysis of Susan Niditch’s Commentary of Genesis in the WBCSubject: ReligionType: Type of Paper Analysis of Commentary Academic Level: CollegeContent: An analysis of Susan Niditch’s approach to the study of women in Genesis (from her commentary in THE WOMEN’S BIBLE COMMENTARY- cited in the paper).
Commentary Essay Research Paper While reading the
Commentary Essay, Research Paper While reading the September 1999 issue of Social Work: Journal of the National Association of Social Workers, I came across an article entitled ?Symbolic Interactionism, African American Families and the Transracial Adoption Controversy?. It was written by Leslie Doty Hollingsworth PhD, the assistant professor in the school of social work at the University of Michigan.
Young Bear
’s Poem "Our Bird Aegis" With His Commentary Essay, Research Paper Our Bird Aegis An immature black eagle walks assuredly across a prairie meadow. He pauses in mid-step
Huck Finn 5 Essay Research Paper Cynicism
Huck Finn 5 Essay, Research Paper Cynicism, idiocracy, facades are all words that come to one s mind as one reads The Adventures of Huckleberry Finn by Mark Twain as he comments on the bitter commentary upon Man and his behavior. Throughout the novel Twain speaks through Huckleberry Finn, the protagonist of the novel.
The Ways In Which The Relationship Of
Tom Buchanan And Myrtle Wilson Influences The Great Gatsby’s Commentary On Social Classes In 1920′S America Essay, Research Paper The relationship between Myrtle Wilson and Tom Buchanan helps portray the themes of social classes in F. Scott Fitzgerald’s novel The Great Gatsby. The ways in which Tom and Myrtle’s relationship influences the novel’s commentary on social classes are basically two fold.
Bradbury Essay Research Paper Ray Bradbury BiographyUS
Bradbury Essay, Research Paper Ray Bradbury Biography U.S. author, born in Waukegan, Ill., on Aug. 22, 1920. In his stories, Bradbury wove together the intrigue of changing technology with insightful social commentary. One of his best-known works was ‘The Martian Chronicles?; a collection of interrelated stories concerning colonization of the planet Mars those attracted readers both young and old.
Nora
’s Neurosis: A Doll’s House Essay, Research Paper Nora?s Neurosis Act I of Ibsen?s A Doll House sets the scene for a disturbing commentary on the woman?s place in society at the time. Nora?s psychological makeup is one of an
Snapshots Of A Wedding Commentary Essay Research
Paper Peter Giese Formal Commentary Snapshots of a Wedding Bessie Head s Snapshots of a Wedding is a perfect example of excessive uses of imagery, which projects ideas and concepts in my mind. The main underlying concepts and comparisons are that of tradition and modernity. Bessie Head projects multiple perspectives on the issues of tribal tradition and modernity.
Rashomon Commentary Essay Research Paper Rashomon CommentaryIn
Rashomon Commentary Essay, Research Paper Rashomon Commentary In Ryunosuke Akutagawa’s short stories In A Grove and Rashomon, an epic conflict of appearance vs. reality is reinforced by the world-renowned movie “Rashomon”. Although the stories and the movies use different symbolism and have many distinct differences, they both support this theme.
Animal House Essay Research Paper Social commentary
Animal House Essay, Research Paper Social commentary is sometimes found at the heart of good art, whether that art form is literature or popular music. The novel, Animal Farm by George Orwell, and the rock album, Animals written and performed by Pink Floyd share the same characteristic of scathing social commentary.
Boethius
’ Argument Against Universals Essay, Research Paper Boethius’ Argument Against Universals In the essay From His Second Commentary on Porphyry s Isagoge Boethius discusses
John 1 15 Exegesis Essay Research Paper
The Gospel of John is the fourth book of the New Testament. The passage that we will be dealing with from the book of John is chapter one verses one through five. In the outline from the background study it is under the section, ?The eternal Word incarnate.? This passage is the prologue, which John uses in order to establish the foundation that he will use to build his presentation of the life of Christ, as it was not portrayed in the synoptic Gospels.
The World Of Uncle Tom And Company
Essay, Research Paper Bibliographical Data: Uncle Tom’s Cabin Written by Harriet Beecher Stowe. 446 pages. Published by Bantam Books First published in 1851-52. It has never gone out of
Our Town Essay Research Paper Thornton Wilders
Our Town Essay, Research Paper Thornton Wilder?s Our Town spans twelve years in the life of Grover?s Corners, New Hampshire. Throughout this time period the play portrays both routine daily life and major events in the lives of George Gibbs, Emily Webb, and their families. Present throughout is the Stage Manager who gives informal commentary and explanation of the play?s characters and events.
Commentary On Brave New World Essay Research
Paper COMMENTARY ON BRAVE NEW WORLD In chapters four through six of brave new world Christianity is shown to be unnecessary.”People,” as Birnbaum states, “are never taught religion, and are conditioned
Commentary On The Bhagavad Gita Essay Research
Paper Commentary on the Bhagavad Gita by Farhan Abbasi This modern day translation of the Bhagavad Gita, written by Barbara Stoller Miller, focused briefly on Krishna’s Counsel in Time of War. It was a fairly short yet in depth description of Hindu beliefs and the conflicts that humans encounter when deciding which path to follow.
A Commentary On One Of Darl
’s Sections Of William Faulkners ‘ Essay, Research Paper Deborah Whelan English A1 HL 28/1/97 Commentary As I Lay Dying by William Faulkner -Darl’s Section (p.128)
Macbeth Commentary Essay Research Paper Josh BakerJune
Macbeth Commentary Essay, Research Paper Josh Baker June 2, 1999 Macbeth Commentary Sixth Hour Mr.Yoder Betrayal From Within In the play Macbeth by William Shakespeare, Macbeth, co-leader of King Duncan’s army, kills Duncan in order to take over the throne. Throughout the rest of the play, Macbeth attempts to overcome obstacles following the murder, in order to conceal his guilt.
Rome And Juliet the Balcony Scene Essay
, Research Paper Commentary on Romeo and Juliet Lines 25-45 In the play Romeo and Juliet Shakespeare uses many different writing techniques to make his work entertaining as well as engaging. In lines 25-45 of Act II, Scene II, he uses extremely skillful writing to show how each of them feels while in the state of love.
Are Smaller Classes Beneficial Essay Research Paper
Commentary: Are smaller classes beneficial? We all know what it feels like. Everyone hates it when his or her arm goes numb. Why do students’ arms go numb? Contrary to popular belief, it is not from sniffing white out or permanent markers. Numb arms are a common result of raising your hand for an extended period of time.
Siddhartha By Herman Hesse Essay Research Paper
In Herman Hesse?s Siddhartha, Unity is a reflecting theme of this novel and in life. Unity is ?the state of being one or a unit; harmony, agreement in feelings or ideas or aims, etc.? Unity is first introduced by means of the river and by the mystical word ?Om.? Direct commentary from Siddhartha and the narrator also introduces the theme.