Essay, Research Paper
Path of Least Resistance: Implicit Power
In his book, Power and Choice, W. Phillips Shively introduces to students of political science the importance of power within the framework of politics. According to him, Politics consists of the making of a common decision for a group of people through the use of power (Shively 9). And that power is, the ability of one person or group to cause another person or group to do what the first wishes, by whatever means (5). Power, therefore, is of extreme importance within the arena of politics for any group who wishes to institute reform or maintain order. And yet, the question of analyzing power, and understanding how it is used, is not as clear as one might imagine. There is a split among political scientists as to who has the power, and how those in positions of power keep it. The debate seems to be centralized over the difference between observable power (manifest) and indirect power (implicit). When deciding the question of who has the power, it seems that the arguments of Hunter and Dahl are mainly concerned with the observable power exercised by those in positions of authority. The other, and more sound, theory of Baratz, Bachrach, and Lukes, maintains that actual power lies within the manipulation of issues from behind the scenes. In answering the question of power, the arguments of Baratz, Bachrach, and Lukes, go beyond the those of Hunter and Dahl, and show that the most effective uses of power are those which are the hardest to see, (implicit power).
Manifest power is, based on an observable action by A that leads B to do what A wants (7), and it is this power that both Hunter and Dahl, describe in their studies. These men, although they disagree on specific details, believe that those people with political power take an active and visible part in their community s important issues. When Hunter did his inquiry into
the political currents of Atlanta, he asked his advisors who the most influential men in the city were. He found that there existed a group of powerful individuals who greatly influenced the policies of the downtown area. He concluded that the wealthy elite were in control and had the greatest influence on the politics in the Atlanta area. However, a political scientist named Dahl did not agree. Dahl argued that the flaw with Hunter s research was that it was based on reputation only. Everyone thought that the small elite had the power, no one knew for certain. Dahl decided to approach the subject using the scientific methods of research and observation. He believed that by finding out the important issues of the community, seeing who had the most to gain in the situations, and observing the outcome of the issues, the group with the most power would be the clear winner. From his research he concluded that the power in a community lay within many smaller groups. He believed that each group exercised power over the issues that were closest to their best interests. While the wealthy had power over economic aspects, the families had power over such things as education.1 Therefore, power was not centralized, and was more dispersed throughout a community.
Baratz and Bachrach differ from Hunter and Dahl in that they believe the power that is not readily discernable (implicit power)2, is more influential in deciding political policy than the observable power of contested issues. They believe that there are, two faces of power, neither of which the sociologists [Hunter] see and only one of which the political scientists [Dahl] see (Baratz and Bachrach 947). The biggest flaw that they found in Hunter s assessment
of power was the same that Dahl had voiced: Hunter …wrongly equates reputed with actual power (947). Those who are thought not to be influential in politics, i.e. the family, are ignored
because they are not perceived to have power. However, Baratz and Bachrach also believe that Dahl is ignoring an important aspect of power. They maintain that because Dahl limited his study to only observable power, he disregarded the significant contributions of implicit power. They realized that many of the important issues that were studied, were not of the utmost importance in the community. The issues that should have been discussed, i.e. segregation, were not on any agenda. The black community was not engaged in a political fight for equal rights even though such a fight would have been beneficial to its needs. Baratz and Bachrach, therefore, concluded that group A was exercising power to keep issues beneficial to group B, from becoming topics of legislation. To the extent that a person or group-consciously or unconsciously-creates or reinforces barriers to the public airing of policy conflicts, that person has power (949). These important non issues were kept from discussion, while the observable issues were minor in comparison. Baratz and Bachrach never gave the methods used by group A to suppress these topics, but a political scientist named Lukes developed this question further.
Lukes argued that it is not a question of the suppression of ideas, but of group B actually being unaware that they are disadvantaged. He argued that B does what A wants because B wants to. But B should not want to do it If B acts contrary to her objective, real interests then power is being exercised the very desires and wants of B are manipulated (Digeser 979). This type of power is akin to Marx s theory of false consciousness. It asserts that a powerful group lures the mind into believing that it is free, when in reality it is not in the person s best interest to do what that group wants. Not only does group B not see the issues that are being suppressed,
they don t even realize that there are issues. This method, if true, is the most effective use of implicit power. There is no chance that a suppressed issue will come to forefront because there are no perceivable conflicts.
The question of power is an important one when trying to understand politics. Because different groups within a political framework have different agendas, power is continually exercised. One group will always try to manipulate another into seeing issues its way. Yet no one willingly goes against what is in their best interest, or, if they do, power according to Lukes is still being exercised. It is beneficial for a group, therefore, to exercise power in as subtle a manner as possible. Because this is so, it becomes essential when analyzing questions of power, to look at what is not said, as closely as one looks at what is said.
357
Другие работы по теме:
Road Not Taken By Frost Essay Research
Paper Little Lessons I’ve learned on my way Lesson 1: Don’t Lose Your Path In his poem, The Road Not Taken, Robert Frost wrote, “Two roads diverge in the woods, and I took the one least
Nuclear Power Essay Research Paper People use
Nuclear Power Essay, Research Paper People use a lot of natural resources on the earth. These resources are gradually being diminished. As these resources are diminished we will continue to look for alternative energy sources. Currently the only short term solution to this problem is nuclear power. The problem with that though is that nuclear power is not as safe as burning coal, gas, or oil.
Cycloids Brachistochrones And Other Archaic Words Essay
, Research Paper This didnt get a very good grade but it works to help set it up. Cycloids, Brachistochrones, and other Archaic Words Introduction: Everyone with a decent math background knows that a straight line is the shortest distance between two points. Intuitively, many would think that it would also be the path taken that took the shortest amount of time.
Analysis William Cullen Bryan Essay Research Paper
William Cullen Bryant’s “To a Waterfowl” Analysis: By the title of this poem one can only come to the conclusion that the poem is about nature. Bryant loved nature as a young boy. The beginning of this particular poem starts
Series And Paralel Circuits Essay Research Paper
Ohm’s law states that current in a resistance varies in direct proportion to voltage applied and inversely proportional to resistance.It is the relationship between voltage, current, and resistance. (V=IR) When more then one resistor is connected to a circuit they can be in either series or parallel patterns.
Metamorphasis Essay Research Paper Title metamorphasisThe Power
Metamorphasis Essay, Research Paper Title: metamorphasisThe Power of Language”The living language is like a horsepath: it is the creation of the horses themselves, who, having created it, follow it or depart from it according to their whims or their needs. From daily use, the path undergoes change. A horse is under no obligation to stay in the narrow path she helped make, following the contour of the land, but she often profits by staying with it and she would be handicapped if she didn t know where it was or where it led to” (E.B.
Telescreens And Technology In 1984 Essay Research
Paper Through out George Orwells 1984, the use of telescreens is very efficient and effective for the Party. On the other hand it plays a very hard role on our main character, Winston. Through out the novel, he lives in fear of the telescreen and is ultimately taken by the mighty power that is the Party, all in help by the telescreen.
Norms Essay Research Paper NORMSNorms have a
Norms Essay, Research Paper NORMS Norms have a large impact on what makes a quality group. Without them, the group would basically go to pieces. When a group gets together for the first time there really aren?t any norms relevant. After one or two group meetings norms will start to come up, whether they be explicit or implicit.
Physics Project Plan Essay Research Paper Physics
Physics Project Plan Essay, Research Paper Physics Project The Planning Key V A ????? Variable resistor ??????? Ammeter???????? Light bulb??????? Voltmeter ???????? I am carrying out an experiment to
Music And Pop Culture Essay Research Paper
One theme involves revenge. One’s bad side is brought out by the evil effects of revenge. Madame Defarge is the main subject of this implicit theme. She turns into a killing machine because she must get
The Paths Of Yoga Essay Research Paper
?Yoga? comes from the Sanskrit verb yui, which means to yoke or unite. It is a ?union of the individual consciousness with the Infinite consciousness? (Fisher, 89). The goal is to unite oneself with God and the practice of yoga is one of the paths that are taken to accomplish that goal. There are four main paths of yoga: Raja is the path of physical and mental control.
English 101 Essay Research Paper In comparing
English 101 Essay, Research Paper In comparing and contrasting the stories ?Worn Path? and ?Young GoodMann Brown?. Several things come to mind . We see that both authors use a lot of symbolism
Antibiotic Resistance Essay Research Paper Antibiotic ResistanceAntibiotic
Antibiotic Resistance Essay, Research Paper Antibiotic Resistance Antibiotic resistance occurs when bacteria that cause infection are not killed by the antibiotics taken to stop the infection. The bacteria survive and continue to multiply causing more harm. Widespread use of antibiotics promotes the spread of antibiotic resistance.
The Jilting Of Granny Weatherall And Worn
Path: Compare And Contrast Essay, Research Paper The short stories, ?The Jilting of Granny Weatherall? by Catherine Anne Porter and ?A Worn Path? by Eudora Welty, have many similarities as well as differences. Both stories have a simple plot with a theme that is symbolic of their lives. These stories include great characterization, description of elements in the stories, and the point of view.
Resistance And Length Of Wire Essay Research
Paper IntroductionElectric charge on an object is often called static electricity. Objects charge up because they gain or lose electrons. The electron is the smallest part of the atom. The electron
Macbeth Literary Essay Essay Research Paper Literary
Macbeth Literary Essay Essay, Research Paper Literary Essay – Macbeth In William Shakespeare s Macbeth, the play s central character Macbeth displays the atrocities created by greed, one of the play s many themes. The play Macbeth, illustrates to the reader how greed for power and wealth can destroy oneself and everyone in his treacherous path.
Electrical Energy Essay Research Paper Electrical EnergyA
Electrical Energy Essay, Research Paper Electrical Energy A capacitor can store electrical energy. Connecting it across a resistor or other device discharges it. Across the resistor there is a potential difference that creates the electric current. When the charge in the capacitor decreases, at the same time the voltage decreases.
Does The Resistance Rate Depend On How
Much Constantan Wire Is In The Circuit? Essay, Research Paper Aim The aim of this experiment is to investigate or find out how the resistance of a wire is affected by different
Investigating The Effect Of Resistance On Wires
Essay, Research Paper I am going to be studying the resistance of wire. The purpose of this investigation is to see how length and thickness of wire affect the dependent variable, resistance. Prediction
Antibiotic Resistance Essay Research Paper Darwins theory
Antibiotic Resistance Essay, Research Paper Darwin?s theory of evolution can be explained like this; the environment acts as a selective agent, weeding out organisms less able to survive. Darwin described natural selection as a process in which organisms become better adapted to their environment. The organisms that evolved with beneficial variations are more likely to survive and reproduce, they pass on the favorable genetic material.
Life Essay Research Paper Both violent and
Life Essay, Research Paper Both violent and non-violent resistance are major themes in the movie The Mission. Even tough the Jesuits are peaceful of God they used both violent and non-violent resistance in this story to stand for what they believe in. Violent protest is aggressive and commanding while non-violent resistance is truly standing up for something.
Resistance Of A Wire Essay Research Paper
I am conducting this experiment to determine how a certain variable affects the resistance of a piece of wire in a circuit. PLANNINGSafety To make the experiment safe I will: ·
Titanic Movie Poster Essay Research Paper The
Titanic Movie Poster Essay, Research Paper The cover box for Titanic reveals two different meanings to the audience. The first is an explicit meaning, of which is clearly presented through the various images on the cover. The second meaning, the implicit meaning, is subtlety suggested amongst the images and requires some thought to grasp.
Bacterial Resistance Essay Research Paper Bacterial resistance
Bacterial Resistance Essay, Research Paper Bacterial resistance is a problem that has profoundly impacted the medical community. Bacterial resistance results when bacteria become resistant to individual antibiotics through the development of specific defense mechanisms which render the antibiotic ineffective.
Douglass Essay Research Paper DouglassIn Frederick Douglass
Douglass Essay, Research Paper Douglass In Frederick Douglass? writings I learned that his physical struggles and his writing as resistance are nearly parallel. When Douglass is living in Baltimore with the Auld family, Mrs. Auld began to teach him the alphabet. After this was discovered by Mr. Auld, the teaching ceased, and Douglass was carefully watched to be sure that he was not reading when alone.
International Joint Ventures Essay Research Paper Summary
International Joint Ventures Essay, Research Paper Summary: Knowledge, Bargaining Power, and the Instability of International Joint Ventures The purpose of the journal article is to identify the primary reason for instability within international joint ventures. The authors begin by defining instability and then continue by linking it to bargaining power.
Road Not Taken Essay Research Paper Robert
Road Not Taken Essay, Research Paper Robert Frost The Road Not Taken The poem “The Road Not Taken” by Robert Frost is about the choices that one makes in life. It tells about a man who comes to a fork in the road he traveling upon, he feel