, Research Paper
Summary and Critique of Two Articles on O Connor s A Good Man is Hard to Find
The article Flannery O Connor s A Good Man is Hard to Find: The Moment of Grace by Michael Clark focuses on the climax of the story: the Grandmother s final act, her touching of the misfit, and its religious and realistic implications. Clark questions her last gesture by asking,
Should the Grandmother s final act– her touching of the misfit be taken as a token of true,divine grace and spiritual insight? Or should the story be interpreted strictly as a naturalistic
document? (1) O Connor refers to the Grandmother s final gesture as a moment of grace. Sloan states that many critics tend to disagree with O Connor s belief that the final act was a moment of grace; rather they prefer to stress the realistic explanation of grace, a more naturalistic grace. Stanley Renner is also uncomfortable with the religious explanation of the climax; he describes
the final gesture as, a vague touch, a parental blessing, or the ceremonial dubbing of knighthood (Clark 1). According to Clark this explanation sees the Grandmother s response as one that not so much reflects divine grace as it touches her instinctive springs of sympathy and human kinship (Clark 1). Other critics interpret the Grandmother s final act as expressing her
final hope that her noblenesse can alter her fate (Clark 1). Clark believes this particular interpretation gives the final gesture a selfish, mundane, and unredeeming sense about it. The question of whether O Connor s interpretation should be judged as right or wrong emerges. Clark believes the old dictum of trust the tale not the teller applies. He also believes you must consider the stories connection with the books of 1st and 2nd Timothy of the bible.
Hallman Bryant, in an article written before Clark s, noted that there is no Timothy, Georgia,and persuasively argues that O Connor is referring to the book of Timothy in the New Testament of the bible. Bryant points out that 2nd Timothy can help explain the crux of the story, it provides a subtext for the central and problematic episode in O Connor s story, the grandmother s moment of grace (Clark 2) 2nd Timothy also stresses that true grace is associated with the tradition of the laying on of hands. Clark believes that the Grandmother is immolating Paul s action in 2nd Timothy in the touching of the misfit. Both events emphasize the grace which accompanies charismatic physical contact (Clark 2) Clark suggests that all critics must acknowledge and account for O Connor s biblical allusions, as well as the fact that all human beings, even the self-satisfied grandmother, have the potential to experience
epiphanies that could save them from the sour and life-denying restrictions that human beings may labor under. These are moments that historically we have come to define as religious. The article O Connor s A Good Man is Hard to Find by Gary Sloan focuses on the character of the Misfit, mainly concentrating on how his mental capabilities and religious beliefs impact his behavior. Sloan openly agrees that the misfit is the bad seed in the story, and although
evidence of the Misfit s intellectual ability is not readily available, he is still pictured as a man of great mental acumen and of no mean wit. O connor herself states, the grandmother s wits are no match for the Misfits (Sloan 1) Sloan also believes his skepticism had been greatly exaggerated, belief is his dominant gene, doubt recessive, almost nil. He acknowledges the miraculous efficacy of prayer while disavowing and desire for it (1) The misfit believes in God,his conception is based on deity coming from magical feats. He thinks the crux of religion is whether or not what is dead stays that way. Sloan suggests what impresses him about Jesus Christ is that he reportedly could raise the dead (2) The Misfit later contradicts himself by saying Jesus shouldn t have raised the dead because it threw everything off balance. Sloan says he uses this to justify his criminality and if he simply knew for sure whether or not he raised the dead he wouldn t be the way he is. He wants to continue in his life as it is without fear of retribution for his actions. O Connor characterized the shooting of the grandmother as a recoil,a horror at her humaneness (Sloan 2). Sloan believes he may also be recoiling from his own
humaneness. The murder is perhaps vicarious attempt at self-slaughter: He seeks to destroy his compulsion to believe because, in his moral computations, belief cannot be squared with pleasure (Sloan 2)Sloan suggests that although the grandmother is at the dramatic center of the story it is the misfit who changes her outlook on life and forces her to think, and due to her connection
with the misfit she dies redeemed. Sloan states, treated as a catalyst for the grandmother s epiphany, the Misfit is a fruitful device (Sloan 2) Sloan concludes by stating, the Misfit s sniveling befuddlement, self-justification, and skewed ethics betray a muddled intellect and, worse, a dangerous one (Sloan 2) Michael Clarke s article Flannery O Connor s A Good Man is Hard to Find: The Moment of Grace questions the story s climax, and whether or not it was a sincere moment of grace. Clarke and the many critics included in his article tend to go against O Connor s belief that the climax was a sincere moment of grace, and prefer the realistic naturalistic explanation of
grace. I agree with Clark and the other critics in going against O Connor s belief. However, I think the best critic interpretation in the article of the final gesture is; her final act was simply part of a desperate hope that her nobleness could change her fate. I disagree with Clark and the other critics who read more into it than that. I also disagree with the presentation of the idea that the epiphany was this great spiritual awakening of the grandmother, I think the epiphany was superficial and just another part of her desperate attempt alter her impending demise. However, I agree with Clark s suggestions that O Connor uses biblical allusions in the writing of the story. Considering the fact that Timothy, Georgia does not exist it makes a lot of sense that she came up with the name of this town based on the book in the New Testament. I disagree with Sloan s belief that the touch of the grandmother upon the misfit replicates Paul s laying of hands on Timothy in the New Testament. I find it a unique coincidence, but I see no solid evidence to support a replication of Paul s act. I like the way Clark broke down the climax and looked at it from more than one perspective. Again, I think the most solid point of the article was the point of the critics who believed the grandmother s final act was not a sincere moment of grace,instead just a desperate attempt to prolong her life and maybe alter her gloomy fate. Gary Sloan s article O Connor s A Good Man is Hard to Find focuses solely on the character of the Misfit from his mental capabilities to his religious beliefs and his way of life. Sloan looks at the Misfit as a very mentally capable man of no mean wit. I don t necessarily
disagree with the view of the Misfit as a mentally capable man despite a lack of evidence in the story. However, I strongly disagree with Sloan s belief the Misfit was of no mean wit. He killed five people that we know of in cold blood and probably more, and yet he does not seem at all remorseful. I think Sloan presents a strong critique throughout the rest of his article. I also believe that the Misfit believes in Jesus and he is obviously fascinated with Jesus ability to raise the dead. I think Sloan makes a great point in saying that the Misfit uses the fact that he is unsure of whether or not Jesus actually raised the dead to justify his hardened criminality. Sloan also makes a strong point in saying that the Misfit wants to continue his life of criminality without
having to pay for his actions. I also think Sloan makes a strong point in saying that the grandmother s humane final plea was starting to get to the Misfit, and the shooting of her was a recoil, a horror at her humaneness. Finally, although I don t think the grandmother s epiphany was a sincere religious, grace filled occurrence, I do agree that the Misfit was the catalyst for the climax of the story, the grandmother s final act.
Другие работы по теме:
Dracula Summary Essay Research Paper DRACULABasically the
Dracula Summary Essay, Research Paper DRACULABasically, the setting of the book is in the Castle Dracula, on a high mountain in Transylvania. Here the Count, Dracula lives. He has never been seen during the day, and most of the residents in Transylvania know that something evil takes placein the castle in which Count Dracula lives in, but none of them will speak about it.Jonathan Harker, a young Englishman, is invited to stay in the castle of Dracula to stay in as a guest.
Beowulf Summary Essay Research Paper Basically the
Beowulf Summary Essay, Research Paper Basically, the story of Beowulf is about a monster who is repetitively attacking a mead-hall called Herot. This monsters name is Grendel. At first, he comes up to the town only to find out what they?d do, and when the guards attack him, he laughs at their pitiful attempt and kills them.
The Argument Culture Essay Research Paper In
The Argument Culture Essay, Research Paper In The Argument Culture, Deborah Tannen describes our adversarial society in debates and dialogues. Tannen discusses our culture?s style of seeing issues, questions, and conflicts as having two sides that battle each other for one goal, victory. She says that not only does this argument culture or culture of critique we live in make life more challenging and alienating, it also reduces the amount of information made available to viewers or information seekers.
Critique Of Recitatif Essay Research Paper Critique
Critique Of Recitatif Essay, Research Paper Critique of Recitatif Sometimes, the mere fact of being from a different race can influence people’s way of thinking or attitude toward other people with different color skin. That is the theme of Toni Morrison’s short story Recitatif. In the story, two eight year old girls, Roberta and Twyla, from different races (black and white) meet in an orphanage called St.
Holocaust Unit Summary Essay Research Paper I
Holocaust Unit Summary Essay, Research Paper I was mostly affected by this unit because it showed me that in the midst of all the unkindness of the Nazi party, that there were still some people left who were kind
Art Critique Essay Research Paper The first
Art Critique Essay, Research Paper The first artwork that I had had looked at was Radio Tori, a ceramic arch built by Peter King. It was my first time inside the WUWF radio station building. I found the building to be quite beautiful. The architecture was well done outside the building. Inside, there were various artworks inside the hallway.
Movie Arsenic And Old Lace Essay Research
Paper Movie: Arsenic and Old Lace The movie Arsenic & Old Lace is based on the play about a movie critique who’s two aunts , choose to put lonely men out of there reason by
Galaxies Physical Properties Essay Research Paper SummaryWe
Galaxies: Physical Properties Essay, Research Paper Summary We were given a photograph of a number of galaxies. In order to locate a particular galaxy a series of numbers were laid out vertically and a series of letters were laid out horizontally. We were also given a magnifying glass with a built in scale to measure the length of the galaxy in millimeters.
Becket Essay Research Paper Summary of Becket
Becket Essay, Research Paper Summary of Becket by Jean Anouilh Becket is a movie that portrays the conflict of power between the throne and the church. It is the story of Henry II and his companion Thomas Becket. The movie begins by giving a brief summary of the history up to the point where the movie begins. This information is crucial to the understanding of the situation.
Araby Essay Research Paper Araby1 SummaryThis short
Araby Essay, Research Paper ?Araby? 1) Summary: This short story is about a boy (narrator) who is attracted to his friend?s sister, she is also his neighbor. Narrator is a boy who has probably just started his
Summary Of Orwells
’ Animal Farm Essay, Research Paper Summary of Orwells’ Animal Farm In the beginning of Orewell’s novel the animals rebel against the “Manor Farm” they take it over, and drive the humans off of the farm. In doing this
Theo Essay Research Paper SummaryThis article shows
Theo Essay, Research Paper Summary This article shows us how Christianity has changed throughout the ages. We can see how Jesus has become the dominant figure in today?s western culture. It tells of how Christianity differed with the teaching of the ancient Romans, and how God wanted us to live our lives. People stopped being afraid of death and their values were changing, becoming much different than those of the Romans.
Journalism Today Essay Research Paper Summary Leads
Journalism Today Essay, Research Paper Summary Leads ( Why are they are effective) The summary lead is the most widely used lead. It provides a brief summary of the facts in the article in the first sentence. Summary leads work best in inverted pyramid stories. I think that summary leads are effective because if the reader has an interest in the subject after reading the short summary at the beginning, then they will read the whole article.
Wuthering HeightsBronte Essay Research Paper Critique Wuthering
Wuthering Heights-Bronte Essay, Research Paper Critique- Wuthering Hieghts Wuthering Hieghts is the prototype of all the gothic novels. It contains all the literary elements such as, symbolism, supernatural, and the dark solemn mood classic to all gothic novels. Although the book was well written and rich with literary devices, it did not retain my attention.
John Locke Summary Essay Research Paper John
John Locke: Summary Essay, Research Paper John Locke: The Empiricist Theory of Knowledge: Summary Understanding and knowledge is what makes man superior to all other beings according to John Locke. However, the bounds of this understanding and knowledge are questionable. Is some knowledge innate? How certain can we be about beliefs and the knowledge we have? John Locke attempts to give some insight as to the answers of these questions in his work, The Empiricist Theory of Knowledge.
Crucible Essay Research Paper Summary of The
Crucible Essay, Research Paper Summary of The Crucible This story takes place during the late 1600’s. In the beginning Abigail, Mary Warren, and Betty were in the forest conjuring up spirits of the dead. They wanted to find out why children were dying in their infancy. Tituba knew how to conjure so she was the one who did it, while the other three danced.
Storage Technologies Essay Research Paper Summary of
Storage Technologies Essay, Research Paper Summary of findings about Innovations in Magnetic and Optical storage systems. Using Nanotechnology scientists ar Rice University have been able to store 10 billion gigabytes of data on physical storage small enough to fit into a small vial. The story appeared in The Philadelphia Inquirer.
Summary Essay Research Paper Summary
Summary Essay, Research Paper Summary 10-16-96 By Rick R. Lopez The American family today, has the same problems that the American family of yesterday had. Daniel A. Sugarman, a psychologist in “Family Practice” introduces us to several case studies that seem to be the main nucleus of family problems today.
Contrast Papers Essay Research Paper A Summary
Contrast Papers Essay, Research Paper A Summary of Poe s Short Story The Cask Of Amontillado One of the main themes of Edgar Allan Poe’s The Cask Of Amontillado is revenge. In this summary theme I intend to demonstrate how dramatic irony is used all along the short story as a way of reminding us the true intentions of the character who vowed revenge.
Stephen KingS Why We Crave Horror Movies
? Essay, Research Paper A Critique of Stephen King?s ?Why We Crave Horror Movies? Elliot Potter In Stephen King?s essay ?Why We Crave Horror Movies? he suggested that
Summary On Odysseus Essay Research Paper John
Summary On Odysseus Essay, Research Paper John Harris February 4, 2001 English 207 (World Literature) Dr. J.K. VanDover Finley, M.I. The World of Odysseus. New York: Viking Press, 1978: 126 ? 129.
Food And Drug Administration Essay Research Paper
Synopsis #1 BIO 131 A. Summary: The Food and Drug Administration is announcing to pregnant women that eating certain kinds of fish may be harmful to their unborn child. These fish include shark, swordfish, king mackerel and tile fish. These fish contain high levels of a form of mercury called methyl mercury.
History Of Lacrosse Essay Research Paper What
History Of Lacrosse Essay, Research Paper What is Lacrosse? Summary: Lacrosse is the oldest sport in North America, and dates back to the 1400 s. Lacrosse did not become well know until the 1600 s.
SummaryCritique Essay Research Paper
fde__________COURSEfde______SECTION/TIME______ SUMMARY/CRITIQUE FORM REFERENCE: Darley, J. M., & Latane?, B. (1968). Bystander intervention in emergencies: Diffusion of responsibility in R. Hock (Ed.), Forty Studies That Changed Psychology (295-303). Upper Saddle, N. J.: Prentice Hall.
Op Essay Research Paper Article Critique
Op Essay, Research Paper Article Critique ? New Hotel Project The article talks about the possibilities of making ?One card, For Many Doors?. They are trying to make a room key with an internal credit card. Using a new system guests will be able to check in and issue a room key (double encoded) using their own credit card.
Delinquent Daughters Summary Essay Research Paper Delinquent
Delinquent Daughters Summary Essay, Research Paper ?Delinquent Daughters Summary? Delinquent Daughters by Mary E. Odem touches on many topics involving women residing in the U.S. from 1885 to 1920. Not only does the book raise issues about women as a whole, but also it breaks the women into a more realistic view.
The Graduate Essay Research Paper Veronica CombsThis
The Graduate Essay, Research Paper Veronica Combs This paper will be both a critique as well as an analysis of the relationships between both my generation and the time period in which the movie took place. In the critique, I which to look at the movie score and the dependency that I felt Ben and Katherine had for each other.
Advertising Critique Essay Research Paper The first
Advertising Critique Essay, Research Paper The first of the three ads that I have selected is from The New Yorker magazine. It is an ad for Russell Athletic. This is a company that makes sports wear. In the ad, you see a man wearing their product. The man is vigorously working out and is in good shape. The outfit from Russell Athletic is supposed to perform, according to the caption on the left.
Summary And Responce To
“Black English” Essay, Research Paper Summary and Response Word Count 366 Summary In the essay titled, ?If Black English Isn?t a Language, Then Tell Me, What Is??
The Color Of Water Essay Research Paper
Critique and Summary of James McBride s The Color of Water Growing up in the home of Ruth McBride Jordan proves to be an ever-testing, but advantageous adventure for her twelve children. As a child, Ruth is abused by her Orthodox Jewish rabbi father, and she is forced to work long hours in the family store. Ruth finds forbidden love in the arms of a Black man.
Demonstration Critique Essay Research Paper Demonstration Critique
Demonstration Critique Essay, Research Paper Demonstration Critique During my demonstration speech, I was affected by my speech anxiety. Some of the viewable symptoms were the shaking of my hands and also the stuttering of speech. I was able to control myself and relax after I started getting into my information.
Critique Essay Research Paper This critique is
Critique Essay, Research Paper This critique is divided into three sections: structure, content, and positive attributes. On the basis of structure the essay is not of high caliber. This is primarily because the thoughts within each paragraph did not correlate to the topic sentence. Within each subtopic the paragraphs supports were also separated and organized poorly.
Robert Frost Critique Essay Research Paper Choices
Robert Frost Critique Essay, Research Paper Choices are never easy- men face multitudes of them in their lifetime. Some decisions to these choices are clear while others are sometimes more difficult to effectuate. The poem “The Road Not Taken” by Robert Frost is a first person narrative tale of a monumental moment in the speaker s life- Frost can be considered the speaker.