Rodney Gordon
(r_w_gordon@hotmail)
——————————————————————————–
1. What is the philosophical problem of self-deception?
Just as Akrasia of actions is considered weakness of will, Akrasia of beliefs is considered self-deception. Self-deception refers to the way in which we (humans) can work our minds around something to trick ourselves into rationalising something that is irrational.
It can be considered as knowing what we ought to believe, but believing something else. This leads to a problem of inconsistency, in that how can we hold inconsistent beliefs, while being rational beings?
Most people would agree with the idea that humans deceive themselves, and there are a number of examples (as given in the lectures) that outline exactly how everyday this problem is, some including people who are sick but deny that they are, or addicts that deny that their addiction. Both cases show how someone clearly is being affected, but they deceive themselves into believing that they aren t.
Audi sees the main problem with self-deception as being when self-deceivers both believe and disbelieve the same proposition .
2. How does Audi attempt to solve it?
In dealing with the idea that the self-deceiver believes and disbelieves the same proposition he offers that in such cases one of the beliefs is an unconscious belief, this meaning that the belief is hidden from the subject at the time, but in all other respects is almost entirely like any other … [and works] in directing behaviour and serving as a basis for inferences.
By saying this Audi is attempting to explain how a person could deceive themselves into believing something that contradicts itself, and in explaining this he claims that the rational belief is held at an unconscious belief, leaving the subject with a conflicting irrational belief.
3. Is his solution satisfactory? Consider his example.
In his example Audi outlines an example of a subject who is attempting to gain attention by making it appear that they are attempting suicide. In using this example he is trying to show that when the subject admits that they are attempting suicide, they are not lying, even though they know they are not. The subject s belief of the suicide attempts is an irrational one (because they knows that they are false) and thus deceiving themself. The rational belief (that the suicide attempts are incorrect) has become an unconscious one.
This is how I currently understand Audi s attempt to solve the problem of self-deception. Based in this account, Audi s explanation seems to overcomplicate the matter. It seems more reasonable that despite the beliefs being contrary, that they could both exist in the subject s consciousness. As I understand it, there seems no reason why a person could not believe two contrasting views, or at least think they do. In the example of the person attempting suicide, they know that they aren t serious about taking their life (i.e. they have a reason to believe that they are not), but if they can trick themselves into believing it as well, then the affect of the ruse is amplified. If you like, the person would think to themselves If I think I believe I m genuine about the suicide attempts then I m not lying. so they attempt to believe that the attempts are genuine (i.e. they have a reason to believe that they are). In this case both beliefs are justified, and while there in an internal conflict between the beliefs, and that the rational one would probably override the irrational one, for a period of time the subject would have been self-deceived.
Some might say that this is an example of self-delusion rather than self-deception, but I would reply that I see self-delusion as referring to cases of self-deception in which the deception is not strong enough, or lasts long enough to really deceive the subject. Or in other words, self-deception refers to cases of self-delusion which are strong enough to carry through and effectively deceive the subject for a substantial period of time.
Другие работы по теме:
Romeo An Juliet Essay Research Paper hi
Romeo An Juliet Essay, Research Paper hi i need an essay about a character in romeo and juliet that demonsrtated maturity. in a well developed multi pagraph essay and say why you think the character’s maturity was greater than the other characters in the play.
Tempest And Othello Essay Research Paper TOPIC
Tempest And Othello Essay, Research Paper TOPIC 3 The central issue depicted in both plays The Tempest and Othello is about money. Money in substantial amounts can represent great power and strength over the ruling nation. It plays a major role in our everyday society and one that is fully illustrated in both of Shakespeare’s play.
Beowulf Vs Bond Essay Research Paper James
Beowulf Vs. Bond Essay, Research Paper James Bond, created by Ian Flemming, shows the attributes of a modern hero: he is Intelligent, charismatic, attractive, and cool and collect at all times. Anything is justified in getting the job done, and he uses deception, trickery, and gadgets to surpass his opponents.
Oh Really Essay Research Paper Oh Reallyyou
Oh Really? Essay, Research Paper Oh Really, you think i am a lark, the dogs they run and bark, but when i say to them, shut up shut up shut up, you say to be nice to them,
Much Ado About
‘Noting’ Essay, Research Paper Much Ado About Nothing is a play that centers around the question and battle between deception and reality. One first notices of the image of deception as we witness the masking and unmasking at the masquerade. In the play, most overhear discussions are deceptions. It is through eavesdropping that we see the true battle between deception and reality as we look at the subplots of Benedick and Beatrice, Hero and Claudio, as well as the comedy of Dogberry and his crew.
Political Propaganda Essay Research Paper The Deception
Political Propaganda Essay, Research Paper The Deception of Political Propaganda Have you ever heard a political speech? Did you find you self in favor of the speakers idea after his speech sometimes even if you weren?t before. Politicians use political language to make us have a certain felling about something.
Glass Menagerie 2
Glass Menagerie – Symbolism Of The Unicorn Essay, Research Paper The symbolism of the unicorn has two very different meanings. One of the symbols is happiness and love. The other one symbols sadness and hatred. You first come into contact with the unicorn when Jim sees it. This is where the first symbolism comes into place.
The Chrysalids Essay Research Paper The
The Chrysalids Essay, Research Paper The Chrysalids Imagine living in a place where there seemed to be a sense of evil in the eyes of everyone, except David Strorm. This place was called Waknuk. Waknuk was a place
The Adventures Of Huckelberry Finn
– Critique Essay, Research Paper Critical Biography Mark Twain, the pseudonym of Samuel Clemens, was, as a literary writer, a genius. His use of numerous literary devices throughout the novel are quite unique. Examples of them would be, irony;
Epistemology Essay Research Paper Epistemology is the
Epistemology Essay, Research Paper Epistemology is the nature of knowledge. Knowledge is important when considering what is reality and what is deception. The movie “The Matrix” displays a social deception in which Neo, the main character, is caught between what he thought was once reality and a whole new world that controls everything he thought was real.
Medea Essay Research Paper Love and Deception
Medea Essay, Research Paper Love and Deception There are many pieces of literature that may entail more than one theme throughout the story. The tragedy, Medea, by Euripides is very good example of this. Throughout this story, the themes of betrayal and love, revenge, and women s rights arise. Euripides brings these points up to help the reader to realize that women are powerful also.
Discuss The Theme Of Deception In Act
One Of Twelfth Night Essay, Research Paper The theme of deception runs very strong in Act One. Almost all the characters seem to either be deceiving someone, or being deceived themselves.
DECEPTION IN OTHELLO Essay Research Paper Deception
DECEPTION IN OTHELLO Essay, Research Paper Deception, which by its definition is a bad thing and has only one level or degree, is truly not this way at all. Deception appears many times in Othello, but in almost every incident the degree of deception is different. There are only a few characters that use deception, and those characters all use different degrees of deception to get what they want in the play.
Deception Experiment Essay Research Paper AbstractWe often
Deception Experiment Essay, Research Paper Abstract We often give nonverbal cues as to whether or not we are trying to deceive someone. These nonverbal actions are involuntary. Subjects were asked three questions provided with no reason to lie. They were then asked three questions they were asked to lie about.
Blade Runner Essay Research Paper The plot
Blade Runner Essay, Research Paper The plot of the movie “Blade Runner” becomes unrevealed till the end of the movie. Many assumptions about the plot and the final of the movie appear in the spectator’s mind, but not one of these assumptions lasts long. Numerous deceptions in the plot grip the interest of the audience and contribute for the continuing interest to the movie eighteen years after its creation.
Hamlet 13 Essay Research Paper In Shakespeare
Hamlet 13 Essay, Research Paper In Shakespeare’s tragedy, Hamlet, there are many themes that appear throughout the play. During the sequence of events in the play we see that there are many obvious themes and many underlying themes. One of these themes that can be seen throughout the play is the way characters appear as one thing, and really are different in their actions at different times.
Chief Tecumseh Essay Research Paper The demise
Chief Tecumseh Essay, Research Paper The demise of the Native Americans In my opinion, having only the education of experience, Chief Tecumseh was a very intelligent and insightful man. He realized, and refused to accept that the Native Americans were being stripped of their lives and lands through deception and violence.
Much Ado About Nothing 4 Essay Research
Paper William Shakespeare’s Much Ado About Nothing is a play involving by deception, disloyalty, trickery, eavesdropping, and hearsay. The play contains numerous examples of schemes that are used to manipulate the thoughts of other characters; it is the major theme that resonates throughout the play.
Twelfth Night Essay Research Paper In William
Twelfth Night Essay, Research Paper In William Shakespeare s Twelfth Night, Or What You Will many relationships are forged or sabotaged for and by the protagonists, and as a result these relationships are made comical. The use of disguise causes deception and misunderstanding which leads to love where it is not meant to be.
Narrative
– Battle Of The Imagination Essay, Research Paper Narrative Essay about truth being nescessart in everyday life. by Anthony Meszaros Hail, travellers! Come to me, all who are weary and burdened and I will provide you with rest. Do you feel tired of all the lies and deception of the world? Do you despair at the lack of trust you perceive all about us? If so, relax yourselves my Wiseman, listen or sleep beneath the wool of the lamb, and ponder this tale of turmoil.
Hacking Essay Research Paper There are two
Hacking Essay, Research Paper There are two different worlds of computer enthusiasts, that of hacking and of cracking. Hacking is the pursuit to further one s knowledge of a system, usually a computer. Hackers (see appendix) are generally much smarter then your average person and try to further the limits of a system through their understanding.
What Makes in The Nick Of Time
? Such A Successful Advertisement For Audi Essay, Research Paper IntroductionAdvertising is: Any paid form of non-personal presentation and production of ideas, goods or
The Uses Of Deception In Twelth Night
Essay, Research Paper The Use of Deception in William Shakespeare’s Twelfth Night Deception is a key theme William Shakespeare’s Twelfth Night. The characters must use deception to obtain good things, escape bad situations, or to play cruel hilarious ticks on other people. One example of deception is when Viola clothes herself in men’s clothing in order to obtain a job under the Duke of Illyria, Orsino.
Panama Deception Essay Research Paper Panama DeceptionWhat
Panama Deception Essay, Research Paper Panama Deception What can I say about the Panama deception that has not already been said it is obvious that this is just another part of US’s great plan to take over the world. I am sick and tired about all the false hope it has given its citizen as well as the rest of the world.
Deception In Shakespeare
’s Macbeth Essay, Research Paper Deception in Shakespeare’s MacBeth”Your hand, your tongue: look like the innocent flower, but be the serpent under t.” (Shakespeare 1.5. 64-66) Throughout Shakespeare s Macbeth, things are not always as they seem. Deception in this play is always present, especially with the main characters – Macbeth and Lady Macbeth.
Othello Essay Research Paper Ultimate VillainIn the
Othello Essay, Research Paper Ultimate Villain In the movie, Othello, the Moor of Venice, I found the play very tragic and sad. It is a love story filled with lies, deception and betrayal. This movie deals with a couple in love played by Othello and Desdemona. Both of them from the beginning have to fight and struggle to stay together.
Emma Essay Research Paper 2
Emma Essay, Research Paper “EMMA” On the surface level, Emma appears to be a novel about the affections and one’s struggle to find the perfect mate. However this may be this case, another theme jointly exists with the previously mentioned motif, which happens to be Emma’s struggle with self-deception. Emma’s life has been hitherto relatively constant and comfortable.
Ethical Obligations Essay Research Paper I believe
Ethical Obligations Essay, Research Paper I believe that the ethical rules of everyday life, should be applied to everything in life. The exceptions to this however, are the games where rules specifically contradict today?s ethical code, and are mutually understood, and agreed upon by all participants.
Othello Essay Research Paper OthelloIn Othello we
Othello Essay, Research Paper Othello In Othello, we encounter Iago, one of Shakespeare?s most evil characters. Iago is an officer in Othello’s army and is jealous of Cassio’s promotion to Lieutenant. Through deception and appearance, we see many lies and clever schemes unfold. The astonishing thing about Iago is that he seems to make up his malicious schemes as he goes along without any planning.