Boys And Girls Essay, Research Paper
In her story, “Boys and Girls,” Alice Munro depicts the hardships and successes of the rite
of passage into adulthood through her portrayal of a young narrator and her brother.
Through the narrator, the subject of the profound unfairness of sex-role stereotyping, and
the effect this has on the rites of passage into adulthood is presented. The protagonist in
Munro’s story, unidentified by a name, goes through an extreme and radical initiation into
adulthood, similar to that of her younger brother. Munro proposes that gender
stereotyping, relationships, and a loss of innocence play an extreme, and
often-controversial role in the growing and passing into adulthood for many young
children. Initiation, or the rite of passage into adulthood, is, according to the theme of
Munro?s story, both a mandatory and necessary experience. Alice Munro’s
creation of an unnamed and therefore undignified, female protagonist proposes that the
narrator is without identity or the prospect of power. Unlike the narrator, the young
brother Laird is named ? a name that means “lord” ? and implies that he, by virtue of his
gender alone, is invested with identity and is to become a master. This stereotyping in
names alone seems to suggest that gender does play an important role in the initiation of
young children into adults. Growing up, the narrator loves to help her father outside with
the foxes, rather than to aid her mother with “dreary and peculiarly depressing” work done
in the kitchen (425). In this escape from her predestined duties, the narrator looks upon
her mother’s assigned tasks to be “endless,” while she views the work of her father as
“ritualistically important” (425). This view illustrates her happy childhood, filled with
dreams and fantasy. Her contrast between the work of her father and the chores of her
mother, illustrate an arising struggle between what the narrator is expected to do and what
she wants to do. Work done by her father is viewed as being real, while that done by her
mother was considered boring. Conflicting views of what was fun and what was expected
lead the narrator to her initiation into adulthood. Unrealistically, the narrator believes
that she would be of use to her father more and more as she got older. However, as she
grows older, the difference between boys and girls becomes more clear and conflicting to
her. Her first experience with this was when a salesman stopped by one day. In the midst
of working for her father, she was introduced as her father’s “new hired hand,” but the
salesman, instead of smiling benevolently, remarks ” I thought it was only a girl” (425).
Being at the ‘tomboy’ stage, and implying, by the use of ’stage’ that the condition is a
temporary one that all right-thinking, demurring girls will outgrow, the narrator is once
again confronted with the conflict of gender stereotypes. She shows no intention of
putting away childish androgyny, but rather, shows an increased desire and ability to do a
man’s job ? a tendency that disturbs her mother. It is at this time, that the mother, good
intentionally shackles her daughter to her correct place in the world to prepare her for
stereotypes later on in life. However, after talking with her mother, the narrator realises
that she has to become a girl; “A girl was not, as I had supposed, simply what I was; it
was what I had to become” (427). Here, the narrator realises that there is no escape from
the pre-determined duties that go along with the passage of a child into being a girl and a
girl into a woman. Knowing that she is expected to become a girl and conform to
society’s beliefs and norms, she expresses her desire to rebel against what is expected. As
with initiation, it is unknown what is lying ahead, but it is known that one must conform to
the expected nomenclature, or face societal ridicule. As for example, when the narrator’s
grandmother is visiting, she explains the do’s and don’ts of being a girl, “Girls keep their
knees together when they sit down ” (427). However, the narrator expresses her resistance
by continue to do things against the norm, “thinking that by such measures [she] kept
[herself] free” (427). Now exposed to what she must become, the narrator’s freedom is
killed. In many ways, this loss of innocence and freedom can be compared to the horse
that her father raised. In making an effort to aid in the escape of Flora, the narrator shows
her resistance to what she knows she now must become, and that ultimately her resistance
is futile. This rebellion against her father’s orders to cage the horse illustrates the narrator’s
last final attempt at avoiding her stereotype. In consciously making the decision to set the
horse free, the narrator goes against her set stereotype. Because of this conscious act, she
loses her innocence in her father?s eyes; however, this doesn?t matter as she is ?only a girl?
(432). Unlike her sister however, Laird, is seeking to becoming initiated, and is given the
chance when he is allowed to go and recapture the horse which the narrator let loose. This
contrasts the willingness of the narrator to conform to society’s beliefs and her own. In
each their own, both Laird and the narrator are accepted into their new niche with their
rite of passage. Laird’s passage was symbolised by the horse blood on his arm, blood from
doing a man’s job. Similarly, the narrator’s passage was complete when her father found
out she purposely let the horse loose, but didn’t get mad because “She’s only a girl” (432).
The narrator doesn’t protest this, “even in her heart. Maybe it was true” (432). “Boys and
Girls” by Alice Munro highlights and emphasises the theme of initiation. The story depicts
initiation as a rite of passage according to gender stereotypes and a loss of innocence.
Conformity plays a vital role in determining the outcome of the narrator’s passage into
adulthood. Throughout the story, the narrator is confronted with conflicting thoughts and
ideas regarding her initiation into adulthood. Ultimately, she wishes to work with her
father, and stay a ‘tomboy,’ but through a conflict with her mother and grandmother, she
comes to realise that she is expected, like the women before her, to adopt the gender
stereotype which comes with her growing and passing into adult hood. Similarly, her
younger brother, Laird, is also initiated, but into man-hood, something he yearns for. In
conclusion, Munro’s story illustrates the struggles between the dreams and reality of the
rite of passage and initiation, based on gender stereotypes society has placed on men and
women.
Другие работы по теме:
A day at an Russia school
Автор: Разное It is Monday morning. Soon it will be 9 o'clock and the boys and girls are coming to school after Saturday and Sunday which are free days. Some of them are walking to school, and some come on their bicycles. Others, who live very far from the school, come by bus.
Why Essay Research Paper After seeing the
Why? Essay, Research Paper After seeing the film The Virgin Suicides, I found myself asking the question why. While talking to other students about the film again came the question, why? Why would these girls, with so much to look forward to, commit suicide? This question, “why” is the central theme of the whole film.
The Haunted House Essay Research Paper The
The Haunted House Essay, Research Paper The Haunted House It all begin on a Friday the 13th on a Halloween night. Stella Ayana, and Sabrina were getting dressed for Trick or Treating. They were going to meet down by the pond with their classmates named Derekand David. Derek
Single Sex Classrooms Essay Research Paper Dear
Single Sex Classrooms Essay, Research Paper Dear Miss King, Your article introduces us to the new idea of having single sex classrooms as well as single sex schools. This examines the experiment that has been implemented in Mountain View California where they recently opened a middle school for girls. This school is primarily geared towards higher levels of math and science, which in the past have been viewed as male dominant subjects.
LOTF Essay Research Paper Introduction
LOTF Essay, Research Paper Introduction The first main problem the boys have in the novel Lord of the Flies is that they are unprepared for survival on an uninhabited
Sex Roles Essay Research Paper Are boys
Sex Roles Essay, Research Paper Are boys and girls treated differently by the teacher in classroom situations? This is a question that has frustrated many psychologists and educators. In many cases, I think gender does play a significant role in the education process. Teachers may unconsciously give more attention to the boys in a classroom.
Teen Sex Stats Essay Research Paper Alarming
Teen Sex Stats Essay, Research Paper Alarming Statistics: - 1 of 10 women b/w 15-19 years of age get pregnant every year, 83% are unwanted or unplanned - 50% of unmarried teens who get pregnant do so within six months of their first sexual experience
Images Of Freedom And Confinement In
“Boys And Girls” Essay, Research Paper Many of the images and events in “Boys and Girls” have to do with freedom or the lack of it. The narrator defines freedom in a number of situations. In this story, the male world represents freedom while the female world represents confinement. In the narrator’s perspective, her mother was confined to the kitchen of their house and “never came out unless it was to hang out the wash or dig potatoes.” On the contrary, the narrator’s father was not confined to a specific place and worked outside killing and skinning foxes.
Boys And Girls Comparative Ess Essay Research
Paper The movie remake of Alice Munro s short story Boys and Girls fails to represent the author s intention; in comparison to the short story. The movie eliminates crucial events, which enables the audience to have impression of what the girl is feeling and show sympathy for her. As a result of eliminating the scene in which the horse is getting killed; the audience is unaware of how the girl copes and is affected by the situation.
Puberty Essay Research Paper Let
Puberty Essay, Research Paper Let’s talk about puberty. What is the first thing that comes into our minds when we say puberty? Well, sex is the most common thought that pops out from the head of many people. But there is much more than sex to puberty. Puberty is a very unique and important evolving stage of all males and females.
Single Sex Ed Essay Research Paper Single
Single Sex Ed Essay, Research Paper Single Sex Education? Why would anyone want to go to an all girls’ school? This is a question I have often pondered. Can you imagine school without the obnoxious comments from boys, football games, and gossiping about boys? This doesn’t sound like a lot of fun, does it? You girls may think about this and decide there are no advantages to an all girls’ school, but in reality, all girls’ schools have many.
My Hair Turned Green Essay Research Paper
Title- My Hair Turned Green Three girls were in school talking about Spring Break. After school the 3 girls their names are Melissa, Abigail, and Julia they went to their meeting spot for their club called the 3p.m. club. Then the girls stared talking about how they needed money because they were going into
Saint John Bosco Essay Research Paper John
Saint John Bosco Essay, Research Paper John Bosco was born in Turin, Italy, on August 16, 1815. His parents were poor farmers, but his father died when he was two years old, but John was too young to know what happened, and it forced his mother, Margaret, to raise him along with 3 other children and taught them the importance of their faith.
Females Essay Research Paper Sitting in the
Females Essay, Research Paper Sitting in the cafeteria, there is a group of rare group of females. The girls sitting at the table, slide out their chairs and all get up at the same time. Not venturing more than two
Man And Woman Essay Research Paper The
Man And Woman Essay, Research Paper The differences between boys and girls are the result from the combination between nature and nurture. These two elements not only build up someone s behavior but also have different kind of influences. Both elements cannot be separated because it played in different times and different situation.
The Lowell Girls The Female Workforce Essay
, Research Paper Lowell girls worked in textile mills. They were called Lowell girls because the textile mills were owned my Mr. Lowell. These girls became the first female workforce.
War Against Boys Essay Research Paper Voices
War Against Boys Essay, Research Paper Voices, I hear voices! Are girls of adolescence age hearing voices or are their voices not being heard? What is Carol Gilligan really trying to say in her study about Pre-teen and teen-age girls? She says the study indicates that society is silencing girls in this age range.
Diary Entry
: “A Girl’s Life Long Ago” Essay, Research Paper Dear Diary, I have to leave soon to go to my new job. I?m very happy to have gotten a baby-sitting job at the Hagen?s. These days, its so hard for a young girl to find a job, unless you are someone famous. I consider myself lucky to live in a nice house with a good family.
Puberty Essay Research Paper Up until the
Puberty Essay, Research Paper Up until the age of nine or ten years, there is little difference in the physical appearance of a boy or a girl, except the genitals. Boys and girls behave differently but this is mostly as a result of ’socialisation’ or the way other people have molded the child to behave like a girl or like a boy.
Girls And Boys Essay Research Paper Girls
Girls And Boys Essay, Research Paper Girls and Boys For my entire life I have noticed a prejudice between the genders. Constantly I hear guys saying ?I?m so sick of girls!?, or girls saying ?All men are jerks!?. I personally don?t understand. To me girls are the best people to be around, they always smell good and you don?t have to worry about proving who can drink a beer the fastest or who can beat the crap out of who.
Boys And Girls Essay Research Paper BOYS
Boys And Girls Essay, Research Paper BOYS AND GIRLS Alice Munro’s short story, “Boys and Girls,” is a story of the way of life in the 1940s, where men and women had specific roles controlled by gender. They were expected to learn those roles as children and conform to them as adults. As the title suggested, males and females played separate and distinct roles from each other, with no one role blending into the other.
Chinese Family Essay Research Paper The Chinese
Chinese Family Essay, Research Paper The Chinese Family For the last two decades, Chinese families have gone through a lot of changes. Much of the old structure and many of the old values of the traditional family have been replaced with a modern twist.
Moby Dick Essay Research Paper Exploitation and
Moby Dick Essay, Research Paper Exploitation and discrimination of the female began when god made Adam and Eve. By not making Eve the same way he made Adam god said to society she is not you’re equal she is different.
Gymnastics Essay Research Paper The use of
Gymnastics Essay, Research Paper The use of Motor Skills in Gymnastics Gymnastics involves many movements of the human body. There are varies exercises and performances completed in gymnastics which are performed at different levels of motor skills. This is what allows us to see how children advance in motor skills.
School Girls Essay Research Paper In the
School Girls Essay, Research Paper In the book School Girls by Peggy Orenstein, the focus is on young adolescent girls in middle school, and the effects that the ?Hidden Curriculum? and other elements have on their self esteem. ?Hidden Curriculum teaches girls to value silence and compliance.? (pg.35) The hidden curriculum is a theory that boys often get more attention than girls in the classroom, and that even if it is negative attention, the girls learn that they are not as important, and they eventually give up hope, and stop speaking out in class.
Children And Violence Essay Research Paper JuvenilesChildren
Children And Violence Essay, Research Paper Juveniles Children and violence, were does it start? Some experts say that children from violent environments at home are more likely to commit crimes then others. Some very young children will witness crime at the home and think that it is ok, not knowing what is right and wrong.
Ode To Boys Essay Research Paper We
Ode To Boys Essay, Research Paper We like them But do they like us The ones we do never fuss They don’t stop in And we wonder why We stress, we bitch We sometimes cry
Essay On Poems Essay Research Paper Essay
Essay On Poems Essay, Research Paper Essay on 3 Things The three sources I have selected are all based on females. They are all of change and transformation. Two of my selections, “The Friday Everything Changed” by Anne Hart, and “Women and World War II ” By Dr. Sharon, are about women s rites of passage. The third choice, “The sun is Burning Gases (Loss of a Good Friend)” by Cathleen McFarland is about a girl growing up.
Opinion Girls Vs Boys Sports Essay
, Research Paper Girl?s Sports vs. Boy?s Sports I am a 16-year-old female athlete at Branford High School. I am a goalkeeper for the soccer team at school and have played number one doubles my freshman year for the Varsity Tennis Team. In past years I have played Field Hockey, Basketball, Softball, and swimming.
Gender Equality Report On Education Essay Research
Paper Gender Equality Report on Education This report is designed to inform on Gender Equity in Schools and educational fact; it was produced to raise awareness to those who seek knowledge in this area. StudentsSchools are working to become more gender equitable. Surveys show girls are loosing out to boys in areas such as who takes advancement classes, who graduates college and even the salary of a post college job.
Brave New Girls Essay Research Paper Brave
Brave New Girls Essay, Research Paper Brave New Girls This story sets a great example for teenage girls. All the TV shows and media that Debbie Stoller refers to are good types of media that give the girls girl power. Today girls can be influenced by a lot that is shown on television and it effects their lives. All the role models play a very important part in teenager’s lives.
Genders Essay Research Paper The early childhood
Genders Essay, Research Paper The early childhood socialization plays a major role in a person’s life. Socialization is best described as “a process by which a society’s values and norms, including those pertaining to gender is taught and learned”. This is perhaps the first thing that a child goes thought.