Nafta Expansion Essay, Research Paper
Should the United States Pursue the Expansion of NAFTA?
Statement of the Problem
The North American Free Trade Agreement (NAFTA) entered into force on January 1, 1994. It created the world’s largest free trade area: 380 million people producing nearly $8 trillion worth of goods and services. One of NAFTA’s primary objectives is to, “contribute to the harmonious development and expansion of world trade and provide a catalyst to broader international cooperation” (US Trade Rep.). To ensure its role in advancing world trade NAFTA must expand its boundaries to the Caribbean as well as Central and South America.
Assumptions
The NSS claims that enhancing access to foreign markets is necessary for promoting prosperity. It states, “Our prosperity as a nation in the twenty-first century also depends upon our ability to compete and win in international markets”(NSS). The expansion of NAFTA into Central and South America will benefit US trade by reducing tariffs in one of the fastest growing regions in the world. The reduction of tariffs will improve the US’ ability to access foreign markets by virtually eliminating the costs to enter the markets. This will enable US corporations to sell their goods at lower prices, therefore allowing the people of the region to purchase US goods. This ability to access such markets will eventually increase the number of capital intensive jobs available in the US. The institutions and mechanisms that NAFTA created have smoothed the path to allow North American businesses to trade, invest and position themselves for better productivity and comparative advantage, thus making our economies stronger against shocks, such as Mexico’s 1994 peso crises. NAFTA does not just safeguard US businesses, it protects the markets that provide employment for our workers.
Internationally, the advancement of NAFTA will help create new employment opportunities, and improve working conditions and living standards abroad by opening up the US marketplace to their major industries. Opening up trade will also enable the countries of the region to sustain economic development. Improved economic conditions have become an important political stabilizer, as it has effectively increased the cost of instability (Harvard Int. Review, Fall 97; pg. 28). The expansion of NAFTA will have as much of an impact on political advancement as it does on economic advancement. Free trade is a necessary ingredient in creating sustainable development, which is important in the consolidation of democracies. In order to assist in the transformation to stable democracies, the countries of Central and South America need access to the North American free market (H.I.R., Fall 97; pg. 28). Free trade increases economic competitiveness. This will aid in establishing the norms of political competitiveness, a key factor in stabilizing a democracy.
The NSS states that, “our prosperity at home depends on our leadership in the global economy” (NSS). The US’s involvement in future agreements will enable it to maintain its leadership role in the globalized market. An agreement with Chile and MERCOSUR (Southern Common Market) will strengthen the US’s presence in the region.
Facts
In relation to the size of the economies, US trade with Canada and Mexico has become much larger than that with any other trading partners. In 1996, almost one-third of the US two-way trade in goods with the world was with Canada and Mexico, at $412 billion. Two-way trade with our NAFTA partners has grown 44 percent since NAFTA was signed, compared with 33 percent for the rest of the world (Democratic Leadership Council, 9/97). Mexico and Canada accounted for 53 percent of the growth in total US exports in the first four months of 1997. Canada remains our largest trading partner, and Mexico has recently surpassed Japan as the US’s second largest export destination in 1997 (Tracking US Trade, 2/98). In 1996 trade with these regions supported an estimated 2.3 million US jobs. This is an increase of 311,000 jobs, 189,000 because of exports to Canada, and 122,000 from exports to Mexico (Tracking US Trade, 2/98). In contrast according to The Economist only 117,000 Americans have signed up for benefits offered to workers displaced by NAFTA.
The US must look to the Western Hemisphere for further economic prosperity. Within the last five years, the Western Hemisphere has become the largest regional destination for US exports, accounting for almost 40 percent of US trade in 1996. Goods exported to the Hemisphere in 1996 totaled $242 billion (Tracking US trade, 2/98). Latin America, including Mexico and the Caribbean Basin has a large consumer market, with a population estimated at more than 470 million. The total gross domestic product of Latin America and the Caribbean Basin was about $1.5 trillion in 1995, with growth expected to average 5 percent or more through the year 2000 (Dem. Leadership Council). The US supplies over two-fifths of the region’s imports. There is no other part of the world where the United States is so competitively positioned.
Twenty trade agreements have been negotiated within the hemisphere without US participation. The EU has agreed to sign a free trade agreement with the nations of MERCOSUR. MERCOSUR is the largest preferential trade agreement in Latin America. It consists of Argentina, Brazil, Paraguay, and Uruguay. The MERCOSUR countries alone represent a market of 220 million consumers with a combined GDP of more than $1 trillion. Two-way trade between the US and MERCOSUR was about $30 billion in 1996 (US Trade Rep). Brazil is the eighth largest economy in the world and is the single largest economy among the US export markets in the Latin America and Caribbean region, with a GDP of $472.5 billion in 1994. US goods accounted for 21.1 percent of Brazil’s total imports in 1995. Argentina is the second largest economy of the Latin American and Caribbean nations with a GDP of $227.4 billion in 1994, while in 1994 Paraguay and Uruguay have a combined GDP of $22.5 billion and are the thirteenth and seventh biggest economies in those regions (US Trade Rep). The EU has also agreed upon having negotiations with Chile on creating a reciprocal agreement with them. Chile is the fifth largest economy among the US’ major export markets in the Latin America and the Caribbean region, with a GDP of $49.3 billion in 1994. Chile also posted 6 percent growth in 1996 (US Trade Rep).
Discussion
The heads of 34 American and Caribbean countries, all except Cuba, met in Miami where they agreed to aim for a Free-Trade Agreement of the Americas (FTAA) by 2005. This agreement would consolidate the already existing agreements of NAFTA, MERCOSUR, CARICOM (Caribbean Common Market), and the Andean Region (Bolivia, Colombia, Ecuador, Peru and Venezuela). It would be a great failure for the US not to take the lead in negotiating this trade pact. Canada and Brazil have already stated their proposals for an FTAA. It is time for the US to do the same. With the US as the most important player in the negotiations, opponents of the expansion of NAFTA such as Dick Gephardt can play an active role in establishing firm environmental and labor laws within the region. With the opponents out of the way it is possible to imagine a prosperous trade union with powerful markets such as Brazil and Chile. Brazil alone has already reduced its tariffs on US goods to 13.6 percent in 1996, from 45 percent in 1986 (US Trade Rep.). During this time US exports to Brazil have tripled. Brazil, Chile, and Argentina are considered by Corporate Locations annual investment survey as the 2nd, 3rd, and 4th most attractive regions in the world for investment (H.I.R., Fall 97, pg. 21). By joining an FTAA and in turn reducing trade restrictions we can expect even higher levels of growth in the future.
The expansion of NAFTA will positively affect the US’ labor force. Through the creation of a free trade arena with Mexico and Canada, the US labor force has benefited more than it has been hurt. The high skill worker has profited greatly, while the low skilled worker has somewhat struggled. Today, export related jobs pay on average 15 percent higher wages. While, those without the necessary skills to compete in the global market may find themselves with even lower wages or possibly job displacement. For the prospect of further market integration, it is important that the US increases investment in its labor force. This requires increased funding for quality education and training programs. Although it is true that approximately 117,000 Americans have lost their jobs due to NAFTA, this is not a large number in comparison to the 1.5 million Americans who lose their jobs each year from factory closures and corporate restructuring, and the 2.8 million new jobs created each year in the US (When Neighbors Embrace). It is estimated that the US economy now creates in one month the total number of jobs lost due to NAFTA in three years (Democratic Leadership Council). From this it may be concluded that market integration has produced more jobs than lost, and that further integration may expect to produce similar results.
Enlargement of NAFTA will stimulate democratic advancements in Latin America and the Caribbean, an area where 19 of 20 nations have recently established the institutions of democracy. NAFTA has already assisted Mexico in its first transition of political power. The Mexican democracy took a large step in redistributing power among the three leading political parties. After 60 years of control, the PRI, no longer controls a majority in the Mexican Congress. This change reveals that the economic reforms made by NAFTA have been accompanied by a process of significant political reform in Mexico (Democratic Leadership Council). A widened open market will have similar effects on the rest of the Western Hemisphere.
Conclusion
NAFTA was created with the intention of expansion. Canada and Mexico are both willing to take on new members, it is the US’ lack of direction that has halted such advancements. It is time for the US to end a tiresome debate and step forward to lead the Western Hemisphere to global economic prosperity in the 21 century. If the US fails to do so, other trade areas may surpass the US’ regional hegemony.
Recommendations
By 2005, the 34 nations of Latin America and the Caribbean have agreed to join in the FTAA. It is possible to draft an entirely new trade agreement, or merge the existing ones. It is recommended that the US takes part in leading the Western Hemisphere into agreement in the FTAA by merging NAFTA, MERCOSUR, CARICOM, and the Andean Region. This will be made possible by first getting Congress to renew Fast Track, and second, informing the public of the continuous benefits of free trade.
“Ah, Pan American Free trade” 1997, economist/archive, April 10. 1998.
Clinton, Bill. “Clinton Asks Congress to Renew Fast Track Authority” Harvard International Review, Harvard University Press. Fall 1997. Pgs 82-84.
Herman, Alexis. “Sharing Prosperity: Us Workers In the Global Economy.” Harvard International Review, Harvard Universtiy Press, Winter 97/98 pgs. 78-80.
King, Robin and Maises Naim. “Free Trade Express? The Future of Hemisheric Intergration” Harvard International Review. Harvaed Universtity Press, Fall 1997-1998. Pgs. 20-59.
LevinsonMcPhail,Brenda. NAFTA Now! The Changing Political Economy of North America. University Press of America, Inc. 1995.
National Security Strategy. 1997. Washington, D.C.: US Government Publishing.
Office of the US Trade Representative, “Future Free Trade Area Negotiations.” May 1,1997.
Solis, Luis. “Peace Equation: The need for Further Regional Cooperation.” Harvard International Review. Harvard University Press. Fall 1997, pgs. 16-19.
“Trumka on NAFTA”, 1997, aflcio/publ/press97/pr05053.htm.April 13, 1998.
“Toward a New Trade Policy”1996, house.gov/democrats/speech.trade.htm.March 17,1998.
“Tracking US Trade.” 1997, lanic.utexas.edu/cswht/tradeindex/html. March 17, 1998.
“The Democratic Leadership Council” 1997, dlcppi/releases/970911.htm. March 17, 1998.
“When Neighbours embrace.” 1997. Http;//www.economist/archive. April 10, 1998
Works Cited
Office of the US Trade Representative, Future Free Trade Area Negotiations, May 1, 1997.
National Security Strategy. 1997. Washington, D.C.: Us Government Publishing.
Solis, Luis. “Peace Equation: The need for further regional cooperation.” Harvard International Review; Harvard University Press. Spring 1995. Pg. 28.
Solis.
National Security Strategy.
Democratic Leadership Council, 1997, dlcppi/releases/970911.htm., March 17, 1997.
Tracking US Trade, 1997, lanic.utexas.edu/ cswht/tradeindex.html, March 17, 1997.
Tracking US Trade.
Tracking US Trade.
Tracking US Trade.
Democratic Leadership Council.
Office of US Trade Rep.
Office of US Trade Rep.
Office of US Trade Rep.
King, Robin and Maises Naim. “Free Trade Express? The Future of Hemisheric Intergration” Harvard International Review. Harvard University Press, Fall 1997. Pg 21.
“When Neighbours embrace.” 1997. Http;//www.economist/archive. April 10, 1998.
Democratic Leadership Council.
Democratic Leadership Council.
Другие работы по теме:
September 11 Essay Research Paper During the
September 11 Essay, Research Paper During the summer of tenth grade, I took a number theory course at Johns Hopkins University with students from Alaska, California, and Bogota, Colombia. My attendance of the New Jersey Governor’s School in the Sciences is another accomplishment that exemplifies my dedication to knowledge.
Trade In Europe In The 18Th Century
Essay, Research Paper The competition for trading advantages started with overseas expansion at the end of the sixteenth century. It started with the increase in the supply of silver in Europe. That caused for prices to change, which caused inflation. All of this caused furhter economic instabilit. The most visible evidence of the economic expansion in early modern Europe was the overseas trading posts.
Poly-Sci Market Values Effect On Politics.
. N Essay, Research Paper Poly-Sci 1 Market values play a significant role in government policy and can have a dramatic affect on all citizens. Because the overall goal of capitalism is in conflict with that of democracy, historically we have had to struggle to maintain an acceptable social contract. I believe it has been through the relative balance between democratic goals, and capitalistic goals that the United States has been able to achieve the degree of social stability which has occurred.
The Ftaa Essay Research Paper The FTAA
The Ftaa Essay, Research Paper The FTAA is the Free Trade Area Americas. Its main goal is to extend the North American Free Trade Agreement to the entire Hemisphere. The FTAA brings together all the leaders of North, South and Central America (except for Cuba) to Quebec for several meetings and negotiations.
NAFTA Essay Research Paper The North American
NAFTA Essay, Research Paper The North American Free Trade Agreement (NAFTA), which built on the 1989 U.S.-Canada Free Trade Agreement (CFTA), is the most comprehensive regional free
Boundaries Essay Research Paper This article tells
Boundaries Essay, Research Paper his article tells us the early conflicts, fears, vagueness and historical backgrounds over territorial expansion. The United States had been established with obscure concept of national boundaries. The constitution itself did not articulate geographic limit of the states, partly because the members of the constitutional convention were unsure of their territorial limit and expansion.
Jeffersonian Democracy Essay Research Paper Thomas Jefferson
Jeffersonian Democracy Essay, Research Paper Thomas Jefferson supported the territorial expansion of the U.S., for the progress and successful domination of the Western Hemisphere by a Republican, agrarian society. Thomas Jefferson held firmly to the belief that this domination would occur naturally and function in balance, with the absence of governmental interference, resembling the laws of supply and demand.
American Expansion Essay Research Paper In a
American Expansion Essay, Research Paper In a sense, the United States has been “expansionistic” from its very beginning. The 13 English colonies, clinging to the eastern seaboard, were determined to push westward despite all natural and political obstacles. Once established as a nation, the United States went about acquiring even more land, including Florida, the Louisiana Purchase, and the Mexican Cession.
Islam Expansion Essay Research Paper The Islamic
Islam Expansion Essay, Research Paper The Islamic civilization spread to such an extensive empire through many techniques. They conquered neighboring areas rapidly. They spread Islam onto the people in three ways. One practice that caused them to spread was their expertise on war. Another would be the forced conversion of Islam to the people.
The Westward Expansion Essay Research Paper The
The Westward Expansion Essay, Research Paper The westward expansion was a new concept for Americans in the 1770s. In their minds there was a abundance of land out west just waiting to be claimed. The people that moved out west thought they were doing no harm, but in reality they committing genocide which is the complete annihilation of an entire race of people.If somebody is taking things from you that is very special to you what is your natural reaction?.
Comparing Ballistics Of A 3006 And 270
Essay, Research Paper Comparing Ballistics of the .30-06 and .270 I have written this science research paper to compare ballistics of a .270 and a .30-06. This paper will also make my decision on which one I will purchase next. If I fire the .270 and the .30-06 rifles into a 2Ч4, then I will be able to determine from the ballistics which caliber rifle is better.
Recession Essay Research Paper Despite all the
Recession Essay, Research Paper Despite all the recession talk recently, the economy apparently isn’t doing so badly. The Commerce department today (4.27) announced that GDP grew at a 2.0% annual rate in the first quarter. This was up from 1% in the final quarter of 2000.
Dances With Wolves Essay Research Paper A
Dances With Wolves Essay, Research Paper A major problem in the nineteenth century was westward expansion. Although the final outcome was good, it was a struggle to move thecountry into the wilderness. The government was greedy and wanted totake the Native Americans’ land away from them. As a political leaderin that time, I would not allow such a thing to happen.
Environmental Issues Concerning Nafta Essay Research Paper
In the early 1990’s, the United States, Mexico, and Canada, all produced the North American Free Trade Agreement in an attempt to increase trade and reduce tariffs between the countries. With the creation of NAFTA, the world’s largest trading bloc was formed with a population of around 400 million people in 1997.
Mercantilism Vs Physiocracy Essay Research Paper Mercantilism
Mercantilism Vs. Physiocracy Essay, Research Paper Mercantilism and physiocracy are two different systems that comprise of ideas involving wealth in the economy. Each system has different views on how wealth starts, and how much government involvement is necessary to have a successful economy.
Wildlife Protection Essay Research Paper There are
Wildlife Protection Essay, Research Paper There are many ways to protect wildlife in our community, the country, and the world. First of all, there are many parks and reserves available for indigenous life to find sanctuary from human expansion. The ecological concerns of water, forest, and wetlands have been achieved through Congress.
Cons Of Nato Expansion Essay Research Paper
Cons of NATO Expansion Throughout the Clinton years the government has tried to make NATO expansion look like a risk free operation. But the truth is that there are many risks and dangers that
Nafta Essay Research Paper NAFTAOn January 1st
Nafta Essay, Research Paper NAFTA On January 1st, 1994, the North American Free Trade Agreement went into effect, creating the world s largest free trade area. Among the main objectives is the liberalization of trade between Canada, Mexico and the United States, to stimulate economic growth and give the NAFTA countries equal access to each other s markets.
American Expansion Essay Research Paper American expansion
American Expansion Essay, Research Paper American expansion to the Pacific was introduced to the people of the country by several different means. The reasons for expansion did not exclude Politics, economy, nor society. Primarily the contributions that that the rise of expansion can be attributed to include Manifest Destiny, land hunger, suspicion of British intentions as well as trade opportunities.
Islam Spread Essay Research Paper Islam is
Islam Spread Essay, Research Paper Islam is known as one of the fastest-expanding religions in history. Only contained in Arabia in 632, its conquests led to its expansion to Persia and
Polystyrene Bead Molding Essay Research Paper IntroductionOn
Polystyrene Bead Molding Essay, Research Paper Introduction On September 7th and 14th of 2000 my lab partners and I conducted the polystyrene bead molding project. My lab partners are Josh Dick, Mike Ward, and Keith Matlock, and we conducted the procedure in room W126 of the Kansas Technology Center. We were to attempt to make polystyrene bead molds using two different methods.
Strong Response Essay Research Paper Strong ResponseThe
Strong Response Essay, Research Paper Strong Response The expansion of the American frontier played a large part in the history and making of the United States, but how big was that role? Historian Frederick Turner felt that the American frontier played the largest influence on our country?s history.
Manifest Destiny Essay Research Paper For two
Manifest Destiny Essay, Research Paper For two centuries, Americans had been progressively taking over and establishing a continent. People felt that westward expansion between the 17th century and the 1840s
Gold Rush Essay Research Paper The California
Gold Rush Essay, Research Paper The California Gold Rush had many effects on the American people, westward expansion, the environment, economy and Indian relations ultimately affecting the world as a whole. When John Marshall first found gold in January 1848 at Sutter’s Mill in California many people on the east coast did not believe the news.
Expansionism Essay Research Paper In a sense
Expansionism Essay, Research Paper In a sense, The United States has been “expansionistic” from its very beginning. The 13 English colonies, clinging to the eastern seaboard, were determined to push westward despite all natural and political obstacles. Once established as a nation, the United States went about acquiring even more land, including Florida, the Louisiana Purchase, and the Mexican Cession.
World Trade Organization Essay Research Paper THE
World Trade Organization Essay, Research Paper THE U.S. ALLIANCE FOR TRADE EXPANSION The U.S. Alliance for Trade Expansion, representing $2 trillion in annual trade and over 150 million American consumers, farmers, and workers, seeks to promote economic growth, job expansion, and higher living standards in the United States by rules-based multilateral trade liberalization through the World Trade Organization (WTO).
European Expansion Essay Research Paper Matthew PolleyWest
European Expansion Essay, Research Paper Matthew Polley West and the World Professor Morgan October 5,1999 European Expansion Bernal Diaz del Castillo accompanied Captain Hernan Cortez in his march on Tenichitilan (Mexico City) in 1519, resulting in the surrender of this Aztec capital in 1521. Castillo contends that he will give us the honest account of what happened and not to give a bias opinion of what happened.
NAFTA Essay Research Paper If NAFTA made
NAFTA Essay, Research Paper If NAFTA made this agreement, people would be able to move about Canada, the United States, and Mexico with ease. The unskilled workers in Mexico would migrate to “El Norte,” looking for higher paying jobs. The supply of workers in Mexico will drastically decrease. Only the terminally ignorant, or those with families in Mexico, would stay in a poor country and earn low wages.
Nafta A Promising Future For Essay Research
Paper NAFTA: A Promising Future For The U.S. and Mexico After six years of remarkable trade successes, The North American Free Trade Agreement, also known as NAFTA, still continues to cause discussions and debates as to its pros and cons. Even Vicente Fox, the newly inaugurated President of Mexico, failed to receive a commitment from George W.
Nafta Essay Research Paper The Impact of
Nafta Essay, Research Paper The Impact of NAFTA in the U.S. and Mexico The North American Free Trade Agreement, often referred to as NAFTA, is an agreement between the U.S., Canada and Mexico. The purpose of NAFTA is to reduce and eventually erase trade barriers, which would make it easier for the three countries to import and export goods and services more freely between each other.
Pro Nafta Essay Research Paper I believe
Pro Nafta Essay, Research Paper I believe that NAFTA should stay in Mexico. It is vital for the growth in the value of the Mexican peso. Not many people are sure what exactly NAFTA does. It reduced tariffs, opened previously protected sectors in agriculture, energy, textiles, and automotive trade. It opened up the U.S.-Mexico border to trade in services with specific rules in finance, transportation and telecommunication.
Civil War Causes Essay Research Paper Causes
Civil War Causes Essay, Research Paper Causes of the Civil War Although some historians feel that the Civil War was a result of political blunders and that the issue of slavery
Manifest Destiny Essay Research Paper Manifest DestinyWhat
Manifest Destiny Essay, Research Paper Manifest Destiny What does the painting Manifest Destiny represent? Does it show an image of hope, or one of despair? To answer a question like this one would have to understand what manifest destiny is.
Fun Essay Research Paper
“The free trade argument states that, if each nation produces what it does best and permits trade, over the long run all will enjoy lower prices and higher levels of output, income, and consumption that could be achieved in isolation.” The North American Free Trade Agreement (NAFTA), implemented in January of 1994, created a situation in North America in which there are no taxes on most products imported and exported between the three countries.