Persian Gulf War Essay, Research Paper
A Shot in the Dark
Since the end of the Persian Gulf War, the United States along with the United Nations has struggled with Saddam Hussein to locate his “weapons of mass destruction”. Saddam’s persistence and dubious manner towards the United States military has raised concern for military protection. To combat biological threats, Secretary of Defense William Cohen implemented a mandatory military wide vaccination of all military members. Since the inception of the program, the program has been the subject of criticism by military members, Veteran Associations, Doctors, and many Senators on Capital Hill. The criticisms have stirred questions regarding the safety and effectiveness of the vaccine. Questions that the military has not given clear answers to. Until the many questions regarding the vaccine are answered, service members should not be forced to undergo the vaccination program against anthrax.
Bacillus anthracis or anthrax is bacteria that infect thousands of people a year worldwide. Mostly found in the hinds and hair of grazing animals like cattle and sheep, the bacteria can stay dormant for years until contacted. Contact can occur through broken skin, eating infected meat, or inhaling infected dust from hides through the mouth or nostrils. Normal contact through the skin begins forming malignant skin ulcers that are dark black in appearance. If left untreated, the blisters lead to blood poisoning and eventually death. Eating contaminated meat not fully cooked can cause intestinal infection also leading to death. Surprisingly, many people survive contact of the skin and very few cases of intestinal infection exist. However, inhalation of infected dust or spores are much more deadly because the symptoms resemble a common cold. Once inside the lungs, the bacteria induces coughing and high fever within 24 hours. The bacteria multiply by eating tissue eventually causing internal bleeding, shock, and death within 36 hours. Protection against aerosolized anthrax is unknown, but exposure to skin can be reduced through early recognition, antibiotics, and vaccination (Eitzen et al. 1-3).
The vaccine that is being questioned is produced exclusively by the Michigan Biologic Products Institute. In 1970, the Food and Drug Administration (FDA) approved the vaccine for controlled use in high-risk occupations. Veterinarians and agricultural laborers were given the vaccine to prevent contracting anthrax through the mishandling of animals and animal products (Anthrax n.pag.). The vaccination process consists of six doses administered over an 18-month period, then followed by annual booster shots. To accommodate the Department of Defense (DOD) Anthrax program, thousands of batches had to be produced quickly.
During mass production, the Michigan Biologics Products Institute has come under disapproval for illegal manufacturing practices. Since 1993, the FDA has cited the Michigan plant several times on quality control. A year before the military was to start the program; an investigation conducted by the FDA found the following problems. Mixing of different batches, replacing old batches with new expiration dates, weakened harvest filters used in producing the vaccine serum, and no documentation of tests performed for contaminants in the vaccine batches. One particular batch manufactured on April 13, 1993 was relabeled Feb. 6, 1998 and sent to the USS Independence in the Persian Gulf where thousands of sailors were given the vaccine. Astonishingly, the FDA did not shut down the anthrax production line at the Michigan plant. However, in a letter written by the FDA’s senior advisor for regulatory operations stated, “Significant improvements must be made prior to continuing production of the vaccine” (Hafem n.pag.). Facts related to the FDA’s lenient attitude towards the Michigan plant are unknown, but suspicions lead to Department of Defense pressure.
Secretary of Defense, William Cohen proposed the mandatory vaccination of all active and reservist military personnel on May 18, 1998. Cohen concluded, “The vaccination is the safest way to protect highly mobile US military forces against a threat that is 99 percent lethal to unprotected individuals”(Anthrax n.pag.). The program will consist of four phases of inoculation starting the summer of 1998. By the year 2003, every service member will be fully protected; including new recruits.
Military members that refuse to participate in the program face serious charges of disobeying a “direct order.” Consequences result in loss of pay and benefits, demotion in rank, complete discharge from the military, and court martial. The Surgeon General of the Army states, “The armed forces cannot tolerate opposition to the inoculations if military discipline is to be maintained”(Graham A3). Nonetheless, sailors and soldiers, continue to oppose the vaccine. Nhut M. Nguyen is a Vietnamese immigrant from California stationed aboard the carrier USS Independence. He along with 13 other sailors, including six officers has refused the shots. That decision not only jeopardized Nhut’s Navy career, but also his pending US citizenship (Hafem n.pag). Private First Class Mathew Baker from Fort Stewart also refused to be vaccinated. Baker’s First Sergeant threatened to tie him down to a gurney if he continued to refuse. After the first shot, Baker disappeared and resurfaced months later with an attorney to contest the Army’s charges against him (Phillips n.pag; Muller).
Questions regarding the long-term effects of the vaccine have also been under protest. Surprisingly, no recorded experiments exist; the long-term effects are unknown. However, the studies of short-term effects show that the vaccine is safe and resemble any other vaccination. Common effects like redness, swelling, and tenderness usually occur around the injection site. Reactions can also vary from low-grade fevers to more severe flu-like symptoms like in the case of 22 year old Eric Julius. After receiving his injection, Eric complained of headaches and tightness in the chest. The vaccine given to Eric and thousands of other service members was from an expired batch (Graham A3).
In addition to the side-effects, the effectiveness against the inhalation of anthrax has also raised questions. A doctor at Fort Detrick conducted tests on the effectiveness of the vaccine on guinea pigs. The vaccine protected only a small percentage of the animals. Other tests done with monkeys showed opposite results, with all monkeys surviving (Anthrax n. pag.). The DOD alleges that the vaccine is only useful if given before exposure to anthrax. However, the US State Department claims that using the vaccine after exposure is just as effective. It was also noted that the immunization must be given within 24 to 48 hours of an attack (Fact n. pag.). If the vaccine is just as effective after exposure, why is the military forcing all personnel to be immunized? This contradiction between federal departments questions not only the credibility of the government, but all claims on the effectiveness of the vaccine itself.
The government has consistently claimed that the anthrax vaccine is safe and there are no major side effects. Nevertheless, prior publicized cases like nuclear testing in the 1950s and use of Agent Orange in Vietnam has caused apprehension towards government claims. More recently, the US government hid the risks of drugs given to military personnel during the Gulf War. Other drugs along with the vaccine were given to thousands of service members for protection. Those returning complained of weakness, nausea, aches of joints, dizziness, and other life threatening illnesses. The illness known as Gulf War Syndrome (GWS) is suspected of being connected to the vaccine. Angry and concerned veterans demanded explanations for their illnesses from the US Government. An investigation conducted by the DOD concluded that, “the vaccine given to troops could not be correlated to Gulf War Syndrome” (McIntyre n.pag.). However, Surgeon General of the Army, Ronald Blanck stated in a senate report that “the vaccine should still be considered one of the main causes of GWS “ (Motavalli n. pag.). In addition, independent expert Dr. Maryl Nass claims that, “symptoms of GWS appeared in troops that were vaccinated for preparation of deployment, but never deployed to the gulf”. Also, British and Canadian soldiers during the Gulf War were given the vaccine, excluding French troops. Surprisingly, French troops were the only ones to return without cases of GWS (Smith n.pag.).
Government distrust, vaccine effectiveness, and unknown long-term side effects are a few reasons why military members should refuse to take the vaccine. Violations of human rights and religious beliefs can also present a conflict. Unfortunately, military members have few rights when subjected to direct orders. However, until further research has been completed, and all issues resolved, many members will continue to challenge those orders. It becomes a question of how much right does the military have to place suspicious chemicals into a service member’s body. Time will only tell if the military will be responsible for the damage caused to the lives of 2.4 million service members.
327
Другие работы по теме:
Alexander The Great Essay Research Paper He
Alexander The Great Essay, Research Paper He was the ruler of Greece in the fourth century B.C. He was one of the greatest military geniuses of all time. He was born in Macedonia, the son of Phillip II, King of Macedonia. He received his military education from his father and was tutored by Aristotle, the great philosopher, and other great teachers of his time.
Alexander The Great Arriving In Persepolis Essay
, Research Paper I am Alexander the Great, King of Macedonia ruler of Greece. I have been king of Macedonia since my father?s assassination five years ago. Since his death I have conquered much of the world. I am ruthless, and should anyone attempt to defeat me in battle, they are sure to die. The year I became ruler of Macedonia I set out to the city of Thessaly to restore Macedonia rule.
Gulf War Essay Research Paper The attack
Gulf War Essay, Research Paper The attack of Iraqi military forces to a small Arab state called Kuwait on orders from president Saddam Hussein caused The US to interfere with the situation resulting in a war called The Gulf War of 1991 starting in January 16 ending in February 28. The military campaign against Iraq had two phase: The Air War and the Ground War .
Herodotus Essay Research Paper Herodotus Essay Herodotus
Herodotus Essay, Research Paper Herodotus Essay Herodotus of Halicarnassus was born about 484 B.C. he died 60 years later. For the time he lived in this age was very old though by today’s standards it is not. The reason why his age was so outstanding was in his time the average man live for maybe half that because of the harsh living conditions.
Ancient Greece Essay Research Paper Sparta one
Ancient Greece Essay, Research Paper Sparta, one of the powerful city-states, retains this name for good reason. They took over Messenia and used the land wisely, by making a government using the Code of Lycurgus. The Spartan women were given a lot more freedom compared to other Greek city-states; thus, every person provided a part in the development of their city.
Epilogue Justinian And The Reconquest Of The
Mediterranean Essay, Research Paper 532 ? Justinian tries to break loose from circle ? enormous um money to East ? beats Vandals and then contends with Ostrogoths and Persian almost simultaneously. Did he know it was
Relevance Of Recent War With Persia Essay
, Research Paper Rationing system does not help the mobility of Byzantines against Muslims Question marks over command structure and logistics Cases of non-payment ? Arab stipends, waggoners in
Theodoisus Ii Yazdgard I And The Mediterranean
Essay, Research Paper 420 Crisis ? followed 2 decades of peace with Yazdgard I (399 ? 420) ? not liked did not have booty or war to keep nobility happy. Important allies in Saracen princes of al-Hira ?
90S In Usa Essay Research Paper Over
90?S In Usa Essay, Research Paper Over the past year there has been vast improvements political or economical event The 90’s has been a decade full of controversial and world changing events. The first one I could think of would have to be the Persian Gulf War with Iraq. I think that war brought together the United States, stopped our fighting with each other, and helped us focus on one common enemy, Saddam Hussein.
Gulf War Essay Research Paper Controversial Issues
Gulf War Essay, Research Paper Controversial Issues: Justifying the Persian Gulf War On January 16, 1991 the Gulf War had officially started, and for good reason. In August of 1990, Saddam Hussein sent armies to Kuwait, to take it over. When the United States had unwittingly given Saddam help when fighting against the Iranians, we had also given him a military that was one of the world’s largest and most lethal.
Gulf War Essay Research Paper The Gulf
Gulf War Essay, Research Paper The Gulf War On the 2nd of August 1990, Iraq invaded Kuwait. Millions of trees, wildlife, marine life, humans and the environment in general, were destroyed. This invasion, was called the GULF WAR. The social, environmental and economic impacts will be felt for years.
Sparta Vs Athens Essay Research Paper Sparta
Sparta Vs Athens Essay, Research Paper Sparta and Athens – Explain and Contrast Both Sparta and Athens were Greek city-states. Sparta was a strict military ruled city-state where the people established themselves as a military power early. However Athens was more of a political city-state that was more involved with their economical stature than their military forces.
The Gulf War Essay Research Paper The
The Gulf War Essay, Research Paper The Gulf War The Gulf war originally started between Iraq and Kuwait. These two countries had a border dispute over the Persian Gulf Islands for many years but had never let it elevate to a level as bad as the Gulf War.
Persian Wars Essay Research Paper The Persian
Persian Wars Essay, Research Paper The Persian Wars In the 5th century BC the vast Persian Empire attempted to conquer Greece. If the Persians had succeeded, they would have set up local
Persian Wars Essay Research Paper Persian Wars
Persian Wars Essay, Research Paper Persian Wars In 519 BC Darius I ascended the throne of the expanding empire ofPersia. A group of people called the Ionians, lived along the coast of AsiaMinor. They were under Persian rule, having been conquered by EmperorCyrus (ruled 550-530 BC), and at this time were unhappy about theirconditions.
Persian Empire Essay Research Paper The Persian
Persian Empire Essay, Research Paper The Persian EmpireThe Persian Empire, started in 539 B.C., stretched from the Indus River all the way to Egypt. They are considered a model for the future empires because of their justice, simple religion, and roads. Unlike some of the pharaohs in Egypt, who collected any amount of tax, anytime they wanted to, the Persian rulers collected the taxes fairly.
Golf War Essay Research Paper The Persian
Golf War Essay, Research Paper The Persian Gulf War The war in the Persian Gulf was a war of religious favor, cruel leadership, and greed. Desert Storm or more commonly known ass The Golf War was the same type of war that had accrued in this area for many years except for one fact. In Operation Desert Storm, it was a mix of sophisticated technology and the combined leadership and cooperation from the coalition that was used to end the war in a quick and timely manner.
The Persian Gulf War 2 Essay Research
Paper The Persian Gulf War The Persian Gulf War, also known as Operation Desert Storm, was a war that separated good versus evil and what s right from wrong. It was the war that put the greedy and totalitarian Iraqi dictator Saddam Hussein versus the American President George Bush. It was the 1st major international conflict since the end of the Cold War years earlier.
Marco Polo 2 Essay Research Paper Marco
Marco Polo 2 Essay, Research Paper Marco Polo Marco Polo was born in 1254. He was a Italian traveler and explorer. He was the first European to cross the entire continent of Asia and leave a record of what he saw and heard.
The Persian Letters Essay Research Paper The
The Persian Letters Essay, Research Paper The Persian Letters The book The Persian Letters by Montesquieu is a fictional novel that was written by the author so he could comment on the society in which he was living. This novel has served as a good example of the ideas that were present during the early Enlightenment.
Perisan Wars Essay Research Paper Persian Wars
Perisan Wars Essay, Research Paper Persian Wars The Persian Wars started due to some of the cities in Ionia revolting against Darius I, Persia s king, around 499 BC. Greeks has settled there for many years, but around 520 BC the Persians conquered it. The Greeks after awhile revolted against the Persians and Darius.
Iran Essay Research Paper Iran 2
Iran Essay, Research Paper Iran – HIstory geography climate culture economy government Iran is a country located in the Middle East. Below it is the Gulf of Oman and to the west is the Persian Gulf. On the east is
US Terrorism Essay Research Paper The United
U.S. Terrorism Essay, Research Paper The United States has become the target of the most recent terrorist attacks because of it?s political involvement in the middle east. The United States has had
GrecoPersian War Essay Research Paper In September
Greco-Persian War Essay, Research Paper In September of 490 BC. The Greco-Persian war rages on in the Marathon Plain of Northwest Attica. The Athenians have just repulsed the first Persian invasion of Greece. The Greek army was vested to ten different generals each controlling one day of battle. The generals were evenly divided on whether to wait for the Persians to attack or to attack them.
Analyzing Persian Gulf Crisis Between Iraq And
Kuwait Essay, Research Paper In analyzing the Persian Gulf Crisis originally between Iraq and Kuwait, one must first understand the factors that contributed to the conflict. In 1980, Iraq carried out a major air and land attack on Iran. For eight years, the Iran-Iraq War grew more intense, until the U.S. “accidentally” downed an Iranian plane, killing 290 passengers.
Why Nature Is A Large Matter I
Essay, Research Paper Environmental issues are a major concern facing the world today. The detraction of the Ozone Layer, Deforestation, and numerous oil spills are issues leading to end of the world.
Us Affairs Essay Research Paper The US
Us Affairs Essay, Research Paper The U.S. plays a major role in most of the international affairs because the U.S. is considered to be a powerful nation. The Economy of America is strong, and the military power is one of the biggest in the world. There was a Persian Gulf War back in 1991 when the U.S. attacked Iraq.
Women In Combat Essay Research Paper The
Women In Combat Essay, Research Paper The idea of women in combat is not unusual anymore. They should be able to hold combat positions beacause although physical