AFFIRMATIVE ACTIONIn the November elections of 1996, California voters passed proposition 209. This ballot measure, also known as the California Civil Rights Initiative, is currently being held up in appeals courts and is expected to be heard by the United States Supreme Court in the near future. According to the California Voter Information Guide Ballot Pamphlet Proposition 209 is:The measure prohibits the state, local governments, districts, public universities, colleges, and schools, and other government instrumentality from discriminating against or giving preferential treatment to any individual or group in public employment, public education, or public contracting on the basis of race, sex, color, ethnicity, or national origin. Does not prohibit reasonably necessary, bona fide qualifications based on sex and actions necessary for receipt of federal funds. Mandates enforcement to extent permitted by federal law. Requires uniform remedies for violations. Provides for severability of provisions if invalid. This measure, and other attempts to demolish affirmative action programs, are based on two basic premises, both of which are ostensibly false. One belief is that affirmative action is no longer needed; the other is that they are in all forms, unfair. While it is true there may be an abundance of useless affirmative action programs throughout the nation, and many programs’ structures and/or purposes may be flawed, the foundations intention attached to these programs is still very much necessary in our society. The debate over proposition 209 has become more emotional than intellectual, and has generated more tension than shed light on the issue. Participants in the debate have over examined the moral and ethical issues that affirmative action raises while forgetting to examine the system that has created the need for them. According to Ward Connerly, Glynn Custred and Tom Wood; all of whom authored CCRI and are responsible for getting it on the ballot, affirmative action policies aimed at helping minorities and women often violate the 14th amendment of the Constitution and civil rights laws. Their argument is based on the notion that these programs will ruin what is now a level playing field, and could give preferential treatment to undeserving minorities because of their skin color. However, any elementary look at the history of this country should infer a contradiction to the idea of a level playing field. There are also those who argue that affirmative action programs such as the ones proposition 209 would eliminate, create stigmas. I would argue that minorities have always been questioned and stigmatized in this country, being labeled a minority, alone carries with it a slanderous stigma. The idea that prop. 209 would introduce any stigmas that did not already exist is ridiculous.
Another extremist view is that affirmative action is why a lot of white men are out of work, and that unqualified minorities are replacing them in America’s corporate sector and at colleges and universities. This is a fallacy that, unfortunately, many white men are believing, just as there are many black men who believe absolutely that their color is the only reason that they are out of work. The reason for the trend of corporate downsizing is a direct result of technological advances and computers playing a more integral role in companies’ output. As for the economic ramifications involved, many proponents of proposition 209 contend that there is a dire need to stop these programs because of the money being spent on them. However, since the state budget has set-asides for educational purposes and programs–at least for the educational portion of proposition 209–if these programs are cut, the money saved will only be used to start other educational projects of which I would argue cannot be of more assistance than affirmative action. Furthermore, on contracting side of the measure, the variable would be who wins a bid acceptance. Either way it goes, state or federal funding would not play into it. Historically speaking, there are no direct precedents from the Supreme Court of the United States. Bakke v. Board of Regents of the University of California dealt with the issue of quotas in university admissions, calling them wrong. However, there was no mention in any of the opinions regarding the issue of constitutionality, or more generally, affirmative action. Many issues of strong debate have arose from the passing of proposition 209 with a fifty-four to forty-six percentage points and from the numerous legal challenges that have followed. It looks like any way you can spin the issue, everyone will still not be content with the results. It is very likely that the Supreme Court of the United States will have a chance to fumble with the issue, and they will have the last say. Bibliography California, 15 September 1998 from the World Wide Web: yahoo/Regional/U_S_States/California/Government/Politics/Elections/1996/Ballot_Measures/Propostion_209_California_Civil_Rights_Initiative/ California, 17 September 1998 from the World Wide Web: vote96.ss.ca.gov/Vote96/html/BP/209.htm California, 21 September 1998 from the World Wide Web: vote96.ss.ca.gov/Vote96/html/BP/209anaylsis.htm The Associated Press, (1996, October 27). Prop 209 measure divides Californians. USA TODAY.
Другие работы по теме:
Untitled Essay Research Paper I messed up
Untitled Essay, Research Paper I messed up; I made a mistake, But please, haste do not take. I love you more than any action or words could ever express, Still I find my heart drowning in loneliness.
BDSM Essay Research Paper BDSMBDSM stands for
BDSM Essay, Research Paper BDSM BDSM stands for Bondage Discipline Sadism and Masochism. Most regard this as a perverted form of sexuality limited only to gays who they also regard
Afermative Action Essay Research Paper In times
Afermative Action Essay, Research Paper In times of today most topics of conversation generally have something to do with politics and hot political issues. Everything from abortion to gun control to affirmative action and that?s exactly what I am going to talk about, affirmative action. What exactly is affirmative action? According to Dr.
Affirmative Action Essay Research Paper When it
Affirmative Action Essay, Research Paper When it comes to affirmative action I have mixed emotions and opinions. Although I hate what affirmative action does and what it represents I strongly support its continuance.
Global Warming Essay Research Paper Ocean SolutionsSolutions
Global Warming Essay, Research Paper Ocean Solutions Solutions to Save the Ocean Many years ago nobody would have thoought that the ocean would ever need saving. The covers over 90% of the earth’s surface. People would wonder how something so collosal ever be effected by their actions. Unfortunately, the oceans do suffer from mankind’s carelss, selfish acts.
Goya Essay Research Paper Between the years
Goya Essay, Research Paper Between the years 1810 and 1814 he produced his famous series of etchings “The Disasters of War” and his two masterpieces “The Second of May, 1808″ and “The Third of May, 1808″. These paintings show an extraordinarily powerful and expressive use of colour. Goya concentrated exclusively on achieving a horrific effect, excluding everything that was irrelevant.
God Essay Research Paper To say that
God Essay, Research Paper To say that God does exist, is to say that we can prove God exists by describing some proof we have of this statement, or at least a being with what we think some of the attributes of a God would be. Since we cannot prove beyond reasonable doubt that God exists we have to infer certain things about how we came to be.
Affirmative Action 13 Essay Research Paper Affirmative
Affirmative Action 13 Essay, Research Paper Affirmative action, what’s that mean to you? There are many misconceptions about this act; for example, many opposing sides of this will argue that affirmative action will cause employers to turn down a qualified white man for a job, and higher a unqualified minority, or woman instead.
Elements Of Personality Essay Research Paper Theories
Elements Of Personality Essay, Research Paper Theories of Personality: (The Elements of Personality. Pp.40-42) The personality others are presented with is composed of our words and our actions. Yet our words and actions are, or can be, consciously chosen. We decide what we’ll say, and what we’ll do. The construction of a personality is simply selecting an action while considering the impression it will make.
Affirmative Action Essay Research Paper Effects of
Affirmative Action Essay, Research Paper Effects of Affirmative Action on Society and the Quality of Life of the People Now that we have been given a brief overview of the history of affirmative action, I will discuss the positive and negative aspects of the policy, which effect society and the quality of life of the people.
Definition Of Drama Essay Research Paper 1
Definition Of Drama Essay, Research Paper 1. Write a brief history of drama from its beginnings to the twentieth century. Drama is defined by Aristotle as “a criticism of life, on a stage, with action, characters and dialogue.” The Greek word for “deed” or “action” is dram. In traditional Greek drama, the chorus is also considered as a character in the development of the plot.
Proposition 25 Essay Research Paper Proposition 25Prop
Proposition 25 Essay, Research Paper Proposition 25 Prop 25 is a proposition which was put on the ballot by petition signatures Prop 25 provides for public financing of candidate and ballot measure campaign costs, the disclosure of top contributors and fund raising time restrictions. Results of this would be that it establishes contributions, sets spending limits, and it bans corporate contributions.
Kant Essay Research Paper KANTKant begins to
Kant Essay, Research Paper KANT Kant begins to claim that there is nothing in the world that can be regarded as good without qualification except good will. He says that qualities of temperment such as
Quotes About Life Essay Research Paper Quotes
Quotes About Life Essay, Research Paper Quotes About Life “The answers to life s problems aren t at the bottom of a bottle: they re on TV!” Homer Simpson “It s a funny thing about life; if you refuse to accept anything but the best, you very often get it.”
Bc Speech Assignment Essay Research Paper Research
Bc Speech Assignment Essay, Research Paper Research Assignment #4 Your fourth speech is a research-based persuasive speech. Since your primary goal will be to convince your audience to take a specific action your research burden is higher. Your research is due via email on the date listed on your course schedule.
Affirmative Action Essay Research Paper In years
Affirmative Action Essay, Research Paper In years past, Americas of every race, color, and nationality have been pushing for equal rights and equal representation in everything from politics, to professional sports coaches, to jobs, and colleges. In American colleges there is a little thing called affirmative action.
Intrapersonal Communication Essay Research Paper 2
Intrapersonal Communication Essay, Research Paper INTRA PERSONAL COMMUNICATION FREUD (EGO) Self esteem Ego Ambition EMPATHY Reflection 3. Bierne TRANSACTIONAL ANALYSIS 4. INTERPERSONAL COMMUNICATION Berlo S
Prop 38 Essay Research Paper School Vouchers
Prop. 38 Essay, Research Paper School Vouchers School vouchers are the educational topic of the millennium. In California, if Prop. 38 were passed it would grant K-12 students a $4,000-a-year voucher to receive private schooling. This proposition has some ups and some downs in my viewpoint and in this paper I will tell you about school vouchers, I will also tell you about the opponents and the supporters of the bill, the candidates for President stance on the issue and finally my thoughts about school vouchers.
Aquinas
’ First Proof Of The Existence Of God Essay, Research Paper I have chosen to write St. Thomas Aquinas proof citing motion as proof of the existence of God. Although I must admit to being a little confused the wording, I see it as being in terms of ability too, act of, and the first to act.
Essay On Profanity Essay Research Paper ProfanityBy
Essay On Profanity Essay, Research Paper Profanity By ***** **** My essay is on Profanity in our school. I am against disciplinary action towards profanity for several reasons. I?m writing this essay because I use profanity all the time and I know other people do also, even the teachers. So my argument is going to clearly state if you do it we can do it too.
Prop 63 Essay Research Paper The Official
Prop. 63 Essay, Research Paper The Official English Language Proposition 63 will make English the Official Language of the United States and I am against The official English
Ery Essay Research Paper Affirmative action works
Ery Essay, Research Paper Affirmative action works. There are thousands of examples of situations where people of color, white women, and working class women and men of all races who were previously excluded from jobs or educational opportunities, or were denied opportunities once admitted, have gained access through affirmative action.
Prop 21 Essay Research Paper Prop 21Education
Prop 21 Essay, Research Paper Prop 21 Education is the best part of life. Education can evolve you into a better person. Education can prevent you from committing crimes and will lead you to a prosperous life. Proposition 21; The Gang Violence and Juvenile Crime Prevention Act aims to incarcerate disturbed youth rather then educate them.
Prop 209 Essay Research Paper Prop 209On
Prop. 209 Essay, Research Paper Prop. 209 On November 5, 1996 we will have the opportunity to have our voice heard when we go to the polls on election day. Not only will we be able to vote on who will be the next U.S. President, but we can also help determine the fate of issues that will help shape the future of our state, from water to healthcare to campaign reform to minimum wage.
Prop 16 Essay Research Paper Prop 16
Prop. 16 Essay, Research Paper Prop. 16 Written By: Date: There is a new regulation if you plan to play college sports. It is called Prop. 16; it is based on a sliding scale. You must first graduate from High School; you have to get at least a 2.000 GPA in 13 core classes, a 86 on your ACT, and a 1010 on your SAT; you must also register and be certified by the NCAA Initial Eligibility Clearinghouse.
Study On Judges Essay Research Paper Study
Study On Judges Essay, Research Paper Study on Judges: 1. What are the major findings with regards to the impact of race in each area of study? Finding on this studies have been a major impact on Judges due to minority judges have been well looked at through the eyes of the world. Progress has been made in appointing minorities to the federal bench and nearly three out of four minorities are confirmed.