Mandatory Sentencing Essay, Research Paper
In recent years several mandatory sentencing laws have been put into motion. The original goals of the mandatory sentencing laws were to stop repeat offenders and to exhibit a “get tough attitude” on crime. These laws have not been working as intended, instead mandatory sentencing has led to some unfortunate consequences. Some of these consequences are overcrowding in prisons and less prison based rehabilitation. Mandatory sentencing laws do not narrowly target major drug traffickers.
Today there are 100 separate federal mandatory minimums located in 60 different criminal statues. An example of mandatory sentencing is New York’s Rockefeller laws which order terms extending from 15 years to life for nonviolent drug offenses. Five years ago in California the “three strikes “ law was passed sending people away for 25 years to life for a third felony conviction. The “three strikes” law is overcrowding prisons and weighing down the courts with appeals. Under the “three strikes” laws a violent first time violent offender may be let out of jail to accommodate a third time nonviolent offender. In 1993, 71% of all federal prisoners were non-violent offenders and in 1994, 92% of federal prisoners were non-violent offenders. The 1994 Crime Act requires offenders to serve up to 85% of their sentence. (Casa) The “War on Drugs” is nothing but a war on the “weak and those unable to defend themselves” (Cose). 95% of non-violent drug offenders who are getting out of prison are getting little to no redirection. As many as 75% of drug offenders released from prison will re-offend and be back in jail within four years.
Non-violent drug addicts are getting more time than murderers. These people have neither the desire nor the ability to become productive members of society. Rehabilitation programs are becoming scarce; the public money for these programs is being diverted into money for additional beds for the bulging prison population.
Mandatory minimums are resulting in a losing war on drugs and over crowding in the prison system. As of 1999 almost 1.8 million Americans are incarcerated. Seven times as many women since 1980 are incarcerated largely due to new mandatory sentences. (Cose) This means that thousands of children will be without mothers, and put into the system. America has reverted to locking up their problems. Overcrowding is not only a problem for the Department of Corrections (DOC) but also for the inmates. Overcrowding means less space and more violence between inmates. Overcrowded prisons also means overcrowded county jails, where state offenders will be held. Prisoners often complain of unbearably high noise levels, inadequate exercise and poor ventilation. This 1.8 million figure gave the “Land of the Free” the second highest confinement rate in the world, right behind Russia (Levitt). The criminal justice system needs to find another way to fight crime.
Mandatory sentencing laws state that a mandatory sentence must be imposed regardless of a person’s role in the crime or other mitigating factors. Prosecutors, not judges, have the discretion to decide what charge to bring; whether to accept or deny a plea bargain. Mandatory sentencing is defined as: a sentence determined by statutes and requiring that a certain penalty be imposed and carried out for convicted offenders who meet certain criteria. This definition should include required drug intervention, mental health treatment, and drug education with the possibility of early release if the prisoner successfully completes the programs.
Th fact that incarceration rates have tripled since the 1994 Crime Act and crime has not dramatically fallen, commentators have labeled the new confidence in the prison system as a policy failure. Commentators have recommended that there be a halt on building new prisons. They have also suggested that the criminal justice system look at alternative correctional programs, and/or decriminalization of drug offenses. (Levitt)
The United States needs to reevaluate their mandatory sentencing laws and find new ways of winning the “War on Drugs”. America should strongly consider reevaluating the two–million-prison population and take each crime and sentence into special consideration. America needs to give judges their discretion back in all cases and get rid of mandatory minimums. Also, the U.S. should stop using “one size fits all “ prison systems and seriously think about separate prisons for the drug offenders with mandated drug treatment programs. “The answer to these criminals problems can’t just be in prison” (Casa). America needs to deal with our problems not incarcerate them.
References
“ All About Mandatory Minimum Sentences (MMS).” 1988.
famm/about.htn (12 July 2000).
Call, Jack E.; Cole , Richard “Prison Journal” v76 n1 p92 (15)
March 1996. web1trac-college/wadsworth (15 June 2000).
Casa, Kathryn. “Prisons: the new growth industry.” v35 i33 p15
2 July 1999. web1trac-college/wadsworth (15 June 2000).
Cose, Ellis “Locked Away and Forgotten: We’re going to have to face up to it –
the prison system doesn’t work.” V135 i9 p54 Feb 2000.
Gibbons, Rodney; Pisciotta, Frank. “Corrections in the 21st Century.” V61 i4 p62
(5) July 1999. web.1trac-college/wadsworth (15 June 2000).
Levitt, Steven D. “The Effect of Prison Population on Crime Rates.” v1111 n2
p319 (33) May 1996. web1trac-college/wadswor (22 June 2000).
web1trac-college/wadswor (15 June 2000)
Prison Rehabilitation
by
Amanda Myers
Другие работы по теме:
Education Today Essay Research Paper Education TodayEducation
Education Today Essay, Research Paper Education Today Education today isn?t quiet what I would like it to be; although it is improving if I was in power I think I would make a few changes. In high school there are certain classes that are mandatory for an individual to graduate history, chemistry and biology are a couple.
Letter To Shareholder Essay Research Paper March
Letter To Shareholder Essay, Research Paper March 5, 1998 Ms. Mary Ruiz 321 Orange Way Green Valley, Ca 90272 Dear Shareholder: This year has been an exciting and profitable one at Nomad. As a shareholder, let us tell you about our recent successes and the challenges we expect in the coming year and beyond. This letter summarizes the high points of the year and provides valuable details about our work in individual areas of the organization, including finance, communications, quality assurance, and travel.
Statutory Rape Essay Research Paper In the
Statutory Rape Essay, Research Paper In the face of unjust laws, I believe that civil disobedience is mandatory. I have a scenario to defend my argument. I introduce to you Stan Lippy. Stan is a 19 year old student at Louisiana State University and he loves his girlfriend. Unfortunately, she is a 17 year old high school student with over-protective parents.
Teenagers In Jail Essay Research Paper Should
Teenagers In Jail Essay, Research Paper Should teenagers spend their young lives in jail Recently in Detroit, Michigan a teenager was convicted in criminal court for a crime he committed. The judge place him in a juvenile facility and ordered him to mandatory psychiatrist evaluation, and base on his improvement, he will be set free at the age of twenty one.
Gun Control Essay Research Paper Gun ControlPeople
Gun Control Essay, Research Paper Gun Control People for Gun Control The recent events that has happened, such as the school shootings and all the violence seen on television, has without a doubt made many of us consider gun control as a possible solution to the violence that has spread across the nation. On the other hand there is other ways to reduce the violence besides using gun control to do that, which are teaching proper gun handling and making mandatory licensing to obtain a gun.
Beloved A Review Essay Research Paper Beloved
Beloved (A Review) Essay, Research Paper Beloved I decided to delve into the issue of slavery in this novel. SETHE, the mother of Beloved, and was owned by the character Schoolteacher . SETHE had three children by another slave. Schoolteachers sons would take her milk so she couldn t feed her children. She grew tired of this mistreatment so she decided to run away.
Cameras In The School Essay Research Paper
Cameras in the School In recent years, security has become a major issue. This occurs in schools as well as other locations. The recent security issue is due in large part to the technological advances or our generation. It has become commonplace to have computers and other items of higher price and quality, thus providing more reasons for higher security.
Victims Still Essay Research Paper Robert Elias
Victims Still Essay, Research Paper Robert Elias book, Victims Still , presents a very controversial stance that the victims movement is, perhaps, not at all. Elias suggests that all the programs, laws, and institutions that have been created in the 1980s and 1990s have done absolutely nothing to help the victim.
Crime And Gender Essay Research Paper Crime
Crime And Gender Essay, Research Paper Crime and Gender: Does the punishment fit? Before the jury stands the defendant. There is overwhelming evidence in the favor of the prosecution. The verdict comes back from the jury, not guilty. Why? The defendant is a woman. In our era of equal rights and civil liberties women have made great strides in their advancement and role in society, yet it seems that gender segregates when it comes to crime.
Mandatory Minimum Drug Sentences Essay Research Paper
Mandatory minimum drug sentences should be eliminated. First and foremost the mandatory minimum punishment that is given does not fit the crime. Second of all, Judges can not sentence below a mandatory minimum unless the defendant provides ?substantial assistance.? The final reason that they should be eliminated is because they have a more of an impact on minorities.
No 2 Essay Research Paper The population
No 2 Essay, Research Paper The population increase in jails is a problem with no easy answer. Many feel the increase is the result of mandatory sentencing for drug related crimes. I also believe this is true but I don t think letting criminals back into the society is the solution. More money needs to be put into the prison systems, along with more mandatory sentencing into the legal systems.
Modern Science Is Bullshit Essay Research Paper
Note: Less of an essay, more a branching statement. Recent medical experiments by some distiguished doctor person reveals that sun-light is actually good for your skin, despite medical evidence
Senior Citizen Driving Essay Research Paper A
Senior Citizen Driving Essay, Research Paper A. Introduction One day, not long ago…I came out of my house to leave for work. On the way to my car I noticed the little old lady across the street walking to here
Mandatory Minimums Cruel And Unusual Punishment Essay
, Research Paper Mandatory Minimums: Cruel and Unusual Punishment Two decades ago it was not uncommon for Americans to believe they had one of the best criminal justice systems in the world. Unfortunately, with the enormous drug trade coming to a pinnacle and the effects of drugs on more and more suburban youth, the government felt a desperate measure had to be taken.
Violent Kid Profile Essay Research Paper THE
Violent Kid Profile Essay, Research Paper ?THE VIOLENT-KID PROFILE? Are students being judged by the way they act, by what they say, or even by the way they dress? Sadly, the answer is yes. Not by their peers, but
Drugs Essay Research Paper In today
Drugs Essay, Research Paper In today’s society, drugs have been a very obvious problem espescially amongst teenagers and young adults. . I feel that an answer can be found if people stop
Mandatory Sentencing Essay Research Paper No degree
Mandatory Sentencing Essay, Research Paper No degree of persecution complex on the part of the Northern Territory Chief Minister, Mr. Denis Burke, can change the fact that the death of a 15-year old Aboriginal, Johnno Warramarrba, is a result of the territory s draconian sentencing laws. People will rub their hands with glee and say Burke s got blood on his hands because of mandatory sentencing, Mr.
Plea Bargaining Essay Research Paper Plea bargainingWhen
Plea Bargaining Essay, Research Paper Plea bargaining When dealing with the Criminal Justice system plea bargaining is something that is a common occurrence. When some type of a negotiation between the prosecutor and the defense attorney takes place and there is no trial, this would be considered a plea bargain. (Criminal Justice, Pg.454) Although the defendant does loose some of his constitution rights by accepting it, he does have some benefits.
Naziess Essay Research Paper Nazi War Criminals
Naziess Essay, Research Paper Nazi War Criminals Still Out ThereAs you walk by and look at hundreds of people everyday, just think, one of these people could have helped Hitler’s Nazi Party. One of them could have been in charge of sentencing thousands of Jew’s to death each day. These heartless terrible people could be walking around in disguise.
Plato Essay Research Paper Laura HarringtonENRU1100Instructor Rob
Plato Essay, Research Paper Laura Harrington ENRU1100 Instructor: Rob Jacobsen November 17, 2000 The Controversy of Capital Punishment(Revision) In my opinion, capital punishment is a controversial issue. This topic is constantly being debated. Some people believe that capital punishment is beneficial to society while others posit that it is detrimental to society.
Overcrowded Prisons Essay Research Paper Many prisons
Overcrowded Prisons Essay, Research Paper Many prisons throughout the United States have been experiencing the problem of overcrowdedness. This is not a new issue though, in April of 1978 New York State was already feeling the affect of crowded prisons. In an attempt to alleviate the problem the state tried to buy Richers Island from New York City.
Kkk Essay Research Paper The KKK is
Kkk Essay, Research Paper The KKK is a totally different group than it used to be. The men who make up the new KKK are very different, and the group is not as feared. The new KKK can t even compete with the old KKK.
Immigration 3 Essay Research Paper Analysis of
Immigration 3 Essay, Research Paper Analysis of a Disagreement over Immigration The authors of the 3 articles on immigration reform all seem to agree that the 1990 immigration law is inadequate, but they agree on little else. They find different impacts on the workforce, positive and negative. And they differ sharply over whether recent levels of immigration help or hurt the economy: one writer suggesting higher levels of immigrants and the other two suggesting a reduced level.
Mandatory Voting Essay Research Paper Political ScienceMr
Mandatory Voting Essay, Research Paper Political Science Mr. Costello 11-18-00 Mandatory Voting Imagine a country where the voter turnout rate was one hundred percent. A country where all of the people of the nation came together to choose their future leaders. Unfortunately, this ideal is impossible without government intervention.
Elderly Driver Dangers Essay Research Paper What
Elderly Driver Dangers Essay, Research Paper What should be done to keep elderly drivers and others safe on the road? As society as a whole gets to be older and more older people are on the road, the safety for the older driver and the other motorists is becoming a problem we are all going to face. The ‘baby boomer’ generation is getting older.
Death Penalty Essay Research Paper The risk
Death Penalty Essay, Research Paper The risk of executing the innocent precludes the use of the death penalty. The death penalty alone imposes an irrevocable sentence. Once an inmate is executed, nothing can be done to make amends if a mistake has been made. There is considerable evidence that many mistakes have been made in sentencing people to death.
Capture The Satellite Essay Research Paper It
Capture The Satellite Essay, Research Paper It was late in the evening when two astronauts approached the spinning 3,000 pound satellite. They reached out to grab the lost satellite and bring it safely back to the U.S. space shuttle. This may sound like a clip out of a recent science fiction movie, but this is the story of the lost SPARTAN satellite.The SPARTAN satellite was sent up in the U.S. space shuttle.
Guns In Texas Essay Research Paper GUNS
Guns In Texas Essay, Research Paper GUNS IN TEXAS Gun control consists of the government restricting the ability of individual citizens to purchase weapons. In recent years many laws have been passed to assist with keeping guns under control, and this has become a topic of significant interest among politicians and US citizens.
Death Sentence Essay Research Paper Almost 90
Death Sentence Essay, Research Paper Almost 90 percent of all convicted killers who are released, kill again. I think that all states should have a mandatory death sentence for certain crimes. It was accepted in the past, but recently certain states have decided against it.
3 Strikes Law
– “Zero-Tolerance? Justice Essay, Research Paper Three Strikes Law In recent years the surge in the population of the world has brought about new areas of concern for sociologists and criminologists. With more and more people populated our nation there is greater need for government-regulated programs to adapt with the increase.
Big Daddy Essay Research Paper Big KidOne
Big Daddy Essay, Research Paper Big Kid One of the most recent movies that i have seen is Big Daddy. When this movie came out in theaters I knew that it was going to be a hit because the main character (Adam Sandler)
Aids In Africa Essay Research Paper Dear
Aids In Africa Essay, Research Paper Dear, Dr. Feedlebom of ?Conspiracies and Cover ups? magazine. I would like to share with you some information concerning the Aids epidemic in Africa. HIV, which causes