Slavery – Benito Cereno And Douglass?s Narrative Essay, Research Paper
When inquiring about the comparisons and contrasts between Melville?s Benito Cereno and Frederick Douglass?s Narrative of the Life of an American Slave, Written by Himself, the following question almost inevitably arises: Can a work of fiction and an autobiography be compared at all? Indeed, the structure of the two stories differs greatly. Whereas Douglass?s Narrative adapts a typical pattern of autobiographies, i.e. a chronological order of birth, childhood memories, events that helped shape the narrator etc., Benito Cereno is based on a peculiar three-layered foundation of a central story recounting the main events, a deposition delineating the events prior to the first part, and an ending.
There are other contrasting aspects of the stories that call for attention. Most significantly Benito Cereno ? ultimately ? portrays slaves as evil and Babo as the mind behind the cunning plan that deceives Captain Delano. The reason for this one-sided representation is naturally the fact that we experience the story from Delano?s point of view. In the beginning, we perceive Babo as the typical docile, helpful, and faithful servant so often portrayed in other slave characters such as Stowe?s Uncle Tom and Jim in Twain?s Huckleberry Finn. Babo is more than just a slave; he is a ?faithful fellow?, ?a friend that cannot be called slave? . And despite all the underlying hints of a slave insurrection, Delano does not grasp their meaning. Examples are the slaves? treatment of the Spanish sailors and the hatchet polishers , but in Delano?s narrow-minded world, only the white man is capable of conceiving plans of ?evil?. And when he ? and the reader too ? finally sees ?the mask torn away, flourishing hatchets and knives, in ferocious piratical revolt?, he is embarrassed and ?with infinite pity he [withdraws] his hold from Don Benito? . From this moment on, Babo is a malign devil and Melville removes speech from Babo?s mouth. This strengthen our opinion of Babo as ?evil? even more, for how can we sympathise with him without hearing his version of the story? Apparently, Melville proposes no other alternative for the reader than to sympathise with the white slave owner Don Benito, whom Babo so ingeniously deceives.
This is fundamentally different in Douglass?s narrative. It is written in the first person singular and offers the reader a very subjective angle. The result is a deep felt sympathy for Douglass?s situation. When he writes, ?Mr. Covey succeeded in breaking me. I was broken in body, soul, and spirit ? the dark night of slavery closed in upon me; and behold a man transformed into a brute!? , the suffering of the slave Frederick Douglass becomes real; something we can grasp, feel, and almost touch. Mr. Covey is the worst example but all slave owners are portrayed as uncongenial oppressors of freedom. Even Master Hugh in Baltimore, who is compassionate and bestows Douglass with as much freedom as possible, is criticised by Douglass . This is significantly different from Benito Cereno. Here the slave owner is portrayed as the puppet of the slaves ? a highly unusual approach ? and even though Babo is free in some sense, he is still dependent on Don Benito on his road to freedom. Just as the scenery enshrouding the San Dominick is unclear and grey, so is the question of who the slave really is. The text also suggests this ambiguity, for example when it is described how Don Benito?s falling stature is supported by Babo , or the way Babo has control over the conversation with Delano . In Douglass?s Narrative there is no doubt about the relation between slave and slave owner, although Douglass, after the fight with Mr. Covey, resolves that ?the day had passed forever when I could be a slave in fact?, he still ?remained a slave in form? . Where Benito Cereno works with highly symbolic terms, Douglass?s Narrative is straightforward and plain when it comes to interpretation . Jonathan Arac argues that ?Douglass?s goal ? was much less to recover the language and experience of slavery than to end them.? Perhaps Douglass?s Narrative was not a literate masterpiece, but it was a gust of fresh air for abolitionists and an example for his brethren.
Douglass?s fight with Mr. Covey is the turning point in Douglass?s career as a slave, and in the aforementioned passage lies also the key to understanding the connection between the Narrative and Benito Cereno. ?Give me liberty or give me death?, Patrick Henry said , and it may well be stated that this became Douglass?s mantra. In the 1855 revision of his Narrative Douglass changed the above-mentioned passage. It ends with this:
I had reached the point where I was not afraid to die. This spirit made me a freeman in fact, while I remained a slave in form. When a slave cannot be flogged he is more than half free. While slaves prefer their lives, with flogging, to instant death, they will always find Christians enough ? to accommodate that preference.
Martyrdom. That could very well have been the outcome of Douglass?s resolution. And indeed Babo became one. In an allegorical sense, the uprising of the slaves on board San Dominick equals Douglass?s struggle with Covey. Babo inhales freedom, and though he is a slave in form when Delano boards the ship, he is never a slave in fact. With this in mind, Babo?s reckless jump for freedom into Delano?s boat makes sense; he prefers instant death to life in the chains of slavery. It seems justifiable then that if Benito Cereno had been written from Babo?s point of view, the same passage might have occurred.
So Babo is sacrificed on the altar of martyrdom and Douglass gains his freedom. Apparently, this is as contrasting as can be but again, in an allegorical sense, there is a similarity. For although Babo suffers a literary death, he is the one with the last laugh. Don Benito enters a monastery and dies shortly after as a weakened and beaten man, while Babo?s ?head [on a spear] ? meets, unabashed, the gaze of the whites?.
Slave rebellions are the common topic of the two stories. Melville plays with the anxiety whites had of such and Douglass of its possibility to elevate slaves out of their misery. If paraphrased, the end of chapter X in Douglass?s Narrative serves as a perfect illustration of this: Douglass describes his Master Hugh seizing the money Douglass had earned; ?not because he [Hugh] earned it, – not because he had any hand in earning it ? but solely because he had the power to compel me to give it up.? Exchange ?money? with ?liberty? and Babo?s right to revolution as that ?of the grim-visaged pirate upon the high seas?, becomes as right as the white man?s enslavement of blacks. In understanding this, Babo turns into a true hero ? albeit a literate one ? on a level with Nat Turner, Madison Washington and others. His quest for freedom and his struggle to achieve it deserves to be remembered, just as Douglass is remembered today.
BibliographyArac, Jonathan, ?Narrative Forms? in The Cambridge History of American Literature, Sarcvan Bercovitch, ed., Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, 1995; 1996 pp 6xx-7xx
Douglass, Frederick ?Narrative of the Life of an American Slave, Written by Himself? in The Norton Anthology of American Literature?, Nina Baym ?[et al.], ed., New York: Norton, 4th ed., shorter, 1995, pp 885-916
Melville, Herman ?Benito Cereno? in The Norton Anthology of American Literature, Nina Baym ? [et al.], ed., New York: Norton, 5th ed., shorter, 1999, pp 1134-90
Sundquist, Eric J. ?The literature of Expansion and Race? in The Cambridge History of American Literature, Sarcvan Bercovitch, ed., Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, 1995; 1996, pp 2xx-326
- – - . To Wake the Nations ? Race in the Making of American Literature. Boston: Harvard University Press, 1993
Yellin, Jean Fagan ?Black Masks: Melville?s Benito Cereno? in American Quarterly, Volume 22, Issue 3, Autumn 1970 ? pp 678-689
The Oxford Companion to African American Literature, William Andrews … [et al.], ed. New York: Oxford University Press, 1997
The Oxford Dictionary of Quotations, Angela Partington, ed. New York: Oxford University Press, 1941; 1992
Другие работы по теме:
Slavery Essay Research Paper The issue of
Slavery Essay, Research Paper The issue of slavery has been often touched upon in the course of history. Many political leaders and property owners tended to see slavery as an element that supported the economy. These people believed that if slavery and the slave trade were to be abolished, they would lose their colonies, commerce would collapse and as a result the agriculture and the arts would decline.
Before Freedom Essay Research Paper The author
Before Freedom Essay, Research Paper The author of the book is Belinda Hurmence, she is well qualified to write a book such as this which she well demonstrates. She has done many long hours of research on slavery and the affects on the former individual slaves themselves. She has written many volumes on slavery and the opinion of many former American slaves on slavery.
Beloved By Tony Morrison Book Report
Essay, Research Paper Everything in a novel is there only because the author chooses it to be there: characters, plot devices, structure and pacing, tone, etc. all are ways in which the author says what he/she has to say. Morrison implements different characters and ideas to enhance the slavery of the time and its lasting affects.
Slavery In Us Essay Research Paper Slavery
Slavery In Us Essay, Research Paper Slavery, one of the most horrible experiences for blacks in the U.S. they were tortured and beaten. They had to do anything that their owner told them. Soon a man named Abraham Lincoln came to their rescue and freed the slaves. Soon after Blacks gained independence they were allowed to use public bathrooms, and most important their right to vote.
Slavery In Us Essay Research Paper It
Slavery In Us Essay, Research Paper It is my intent to assess the plight of African Americans at a time when they were slaves. They were forcibly taken by rich white merchants to a new and strange land called America. Right from the very start, slavery was a controversial issue and it was argued with the constant reminder of man’s inhumanity to man.
Was The Civil War Inevitable Essay Research
Paper Was the war that took the lives of six-hundred thousand people avoidable? Did young men from the North and South die in a conflict that could have been solved through negotiation? The Civil War was an inevitable conflict which was bound to explode due to the failure of politics and the North and South’s dispute over the issue of slavery.
Slavery In The Territories Essay Research Paper
SLAVERY IN THE TERRITORIES It has been said that the institution of slavery caused The Civil War. In the years leading up to America s bloodiest war, the new territories the United States acquired began to get enough citizens so that they may become states. The question that ripped Congress and this country apart was whether or not these new states would be admitted as free or slave states.
Slavery Is The South Essay Research Paper
Slavery is the South Essay #3 Slavery played a dominating and critical role in much of Southern life. In the struggle for control in America, slavery was the South?s stronghold and the hidden motive
Slavery And Evolution Of The Cherokee Essay
, Research Paper ENC3240 A Review of Slavery and Evolution of the Cherokee Society 1540-1866 by Theda Perdue In this well-written book by Theda Perdue, he discloses much of the history of slavery among the Cherokee people and their evolution during this 326 year period. He begins with their abduction by the Spanish.
Slavery Essay Research Paper Slavery the practice
Slavery Essay, Research Paper Slavery the practice of one person owning another ? this type of practice has existed since ancient times. In the United States slaves from Africa were bought and sold like property. Although at first there were slaves in both the northern and southern part of the United States, by the early nineteenth century, slavery had died out in the North.
Tempest Essay Research Paper Slavery in The
Tempest Essay, Research Paper Slavery in The Tempest Slavery occurs on a widespread basis in The Tempest. Occurrence of slavery to many of the characters, all in different ways, helps to provide the atmosphere for the play. The obvious slaves are not the only slaves, as Prospero has basically got everybody entranced when he wants, to do whatever he wants with them.
To Be A Slave Essay Research Paper
To Be A Slave Essay submitted by Anonymous The only things that come to my mind when I think of slavery and of the book To be a Slave are either misunderstanding or very negative. During the slavery years, African
Slave Trades Essay Research Paper African slave
Slave Trades Essay, Research Paper African slave trade to the America and the European was much worse than slavery in Africa. In this essay ,I will show you the differences. Where were the slave trade took place. Slavery was mostly happing in North America in the carribean and in Europe.The ships full of slaves mostly come to Cuba.
Civil War By Edward Hagenlocher Essay Research
Paper Migration west brought South and North into conflict over slavery. Earlier compromises between the sections had succeeded because slavery had been a relatively minor issue; major differences usually revolved around culture, economics, and the balance of power. However, by the 1840s, slavery and its expansion became a central, pivotal issue.
Lincoln Essay Research Paper Abraham Lincoln is
Lincoln Essay, Research Paper Abraham Lincoln is an American hero. A lot of important events occurred that changed America forever. Three of them are giving the Gettysberg address, ending slavery, and becoming assassinated.
The Impeding Crisis Essay Research Paper An
The Impeding Crisis Essay, Research Paper An Impending Crisis The Missouri Compromise provided for the admission of Maine into the Union as a free state, the admission of Missouri into the Union as a slave state, and the removal of slavery north of Missouri. Importantly, this compromise reaffirmed the principle established in the Northwest Ordinance that Congress could, if it chose, prohibit slavery in the territories.
Slavery And The American Bigot Essay Research
Paper Slavery and the American Bigot We Americans are interesting people and we have an interesting history. Slavery is part of that history. From time to time we forget just how much of part slavery plays in our history. I was reminded of that once again by the news story on the family reunion of the Thomas Jefferson family.
Transformation Of Slavery
’s Defense Essay, Research Paper Elizabeth Braker Mr. Story History Hr. 2-3 24 November 1998 Slavery Essay Transformation of Slavery?s Defense During the early 1800?s the demand for cotton had risen and it was now ?King? of plantations in the southern region of the United States, where the climate was best suited.
The Founding Fathers And Slavery Essay Research
Paper “The Founding Fathers and Slavery” William W. Freehling presents his view of the Founding Fathers and slavery in the article “The Founding Fathers and Slavery.” He contends that America s Founding Fathers were antislavery but gives viewpoints of other historians to the contrary. The first sentence of the article states, “Only a few years ago no man needed to defend the Founding Fathers on slavery.” This implies that there was a change in the interpretation of the Founding Fathers position on slavery and indeed there was.
Uncle Toms Cabin Essay Research Paper Uncle
Uncle Toms Cabin Essay, Research Paper Uncle Tom’s Cabin How realistically and credibly does Stowe present slavery? Stowe presents slavery in the only way she knows how, by using the facts. Several sources of other works in American literature contrast on to how Stowe presents slavery in her novel “Uncle Tom’s Cabin.” The elements of slavery are driven through the reflections of theme, characterization, and setting to show that the way slavery is presented is not contradicting.
Celia A Slave Essay Research Paper Celia
Celia: A Slave Essay, Research Paper Celia: A Slave CELIA: A SLAVE by Melton A. McLaurin is a wonderful book about a single example of the sufferings slavery caused. Piecing together the parts of a life, Mr. McLaurin, tells the story of Celia.
Ending Slavery In The US Essay Research
Paper Ending Slavery in the U.S.- Prior to and during the election of Abraham Lincoln in 1860, slavery was a major issue in the United States. From 1830-1850 (also
ANALYSIS OF THE ROLE OF BLACKSOLDIERS IN
THE CIVIL WAR Essay, Research Paper During the Civil War many blacks chose to fight for the Federal Army against the Confederacy. Black soldiers were discriminated against and at first restricted from combat. Later in the war the colored regiments saw some of the most extensive combat of the war. Thousands of blacks volunteered to fight to free their people from the horrors of slavery.
Abraham Lincoln And Slavery Essay Research Paper
Abraham Lincoln and Slavery What did Abraham Lincoln do and think regarding slavery during the Civil War? In Abraham’s First Inaugural Address he states “I do but quote from one of those speeches when I declare that I have no purpose, directly or indirectly, to interfere with the institution of slavery in the States where it exists.
Fredrick Douglass Essay Essay Research Paper Fredrick
Fredrick Douglass Essay Essay, Research Paper Fredrick Douglass essay Escaping from slavery in 1838 had to be a treacherous experience; escaping slavery at any time would be! Most slaves couldn?t read or write, but one slave, Fredrick Douglass, broke that barrier and many more. In this particular writing he uses a wide-open state of mind to clearly get his thoughts across.
Why Slavery Essay Research Paper Captivity bondage
Why Slavery? Essay, Research Paper Captivity, bondage, restraint, subjugation, and slavery. These words all mean one thing, enslaving someone against their will. Slavery was an episode in history that scarred, many African men, women and children. Slavery tore families apart, shattered dreams, and left African?s feeling shameful and hopeless.
Slavery 2 Essay Research Paper SlaverySlavery was
Slavery 2 Essay, Research Paper Slavery Slavery was the most common form of forced labor in History. Slavery was very bad and wrong. A slave was treated like property and not like a Human Being and owned by other Human Being s.
Dred Scott Decision Essay Research Paper The
Dred Scott Decision Essay, Research Paper The Dred Scott decision of 1865 had many implications on the status of free blacks in the United States, along with the concept of popular sovereignty, and the future of slavery in America.
Frederick Douglass Essay Research Paper Who was
Frederick Douglass Essay, Research Paper Who was Frederick Douglass and what was his view on the anti-slavery movement? That’s a very good question since most people have no idea. Frederick Douglass was born
Civil War Causes Essay Research Paper Causes
Civil War Causes Essay, Research Paper Causes of the Civil War Although some historians feel that the Civil War was a result of political blunders and that the issue of slavery
Slavery And The History Of The Negro
. Essay, Research Paper Slavery and the History of the Negro. The issue of slavery has been touched upon often in the course of history. The institution of slavery was addressed by French