Madison Vs. Marshall Essay, Research Paper
Upon the Declaration of Independence, a “plan of confederation” was offered to be prepared for the colonies. This plan, known as The Articles of Confederation, established a “league of friendship” among the states rather than a national government. The most significant fact about the created government was it’s weakness, it could not enforce even the limited powers it had. In James Madison’s words, in his Federalist Paper #10 “complaints are everywhere heard…that our governments are too unstable”. The states had won their freedom but had been unable to form a nation. They fought among themselves, suffered from severe economic depression, and came close to losing the peace they had won in war. These political and economic factors generated pressure for the creation of a new national government and a constitution.
In Madison’s view, politics was overrun by different “factions”, which were groups of people who shared the same interests, different from other people or the opinion of the whole. These factions, he thought, prevented the government from its most important task, which in his opinion was to protect the owner’s of the land and property. The ownership of the land was divided according to people’s different skills, faculties, and according to Madison, “the protection of these faculties is the first object of the government”. And since the majority of the people were farmers and poor, and since “those who hold and those who are without property have ever formed distinct interests in society”, Madison wanted a constitution that would give the government the power to control the majority.
In his address to the American Bar Association, Thurgood Marshall criticizes the constitution by saying that “ I do not believe that the meaning of the Constitution was forever “fixed” at the Philadelphia convention”. In his opinion “ the government that they devised was defective from the beginning”, meaning that the Constitution required several amendments before it became what people today consider as “the basic structure of the American government”. The constitution is very different today than what the framers began to construct two centuries ago. Marshall thinks that there was much wrong with the original document, he finds many “inherent defects”, but is willing to admit that it was “a product of its times and embodied a compromise that, under other circumstances, would not have been made”. By this he means the contradiction between promising “liberty and justice for all” and denying both from blacks. He seems very bitter about the events in history considering the black people as he says that the Constitution, as originally written was “a document that laid a foundation for the tragic events that were to follow”, meaning slavery. But what both Madison and Marshall agree on, is that the constitution was not perfect and complete in the beginning, it required amendments.
The word “democracy” was not popular at the Constitutional convention in Philadelphia, because at the time it meant rule by the masses, and the framer’s thought that majority rule would be mob rule. According to Madison “such democracies…have ever been found incompatible with personal security, or the rights of property”. At that time it was difficult for the average person to be aware of national issues, and that’s why a republic, a representative democracy was created. Madison wanted a system of representation, which would not allow the majority rule, in his opinion the representatives would be more “enlightened” than the average people. Also because of the size of the area, it was easier than direct democracy. The constitution left voting requirements up to the state government, and only free white males were allowed to participate. Madison didn’t believe in the equality of all citizens, as he says “by reducing mankind to a perfect equality in their political rights, they would, at the same time, be perfectly equalized and assimilated in their possessions, their opinions, and their passions”. This idea, “rage for…an equal division of property, or for any other improper or wicked project”, seems impossible and dangerous to him.
Considering majority rule as a part of the definition of democracy, in Thurgood Marshall’s opinion the Founding Fathers did not have in mind the majority of the American people when they used the phrase “we the people”. Most of the people, women and slaves, were not allowed to participate, only the “free persons”. In Marshall’s view the representation was also defective since it was based on “the population of free persons in each state, plus three fifths of all other persons”. And all men were not “created equal”, the moral principles against slavery were compromised in the economic interests of the states. The constitution needed the Bill of Rights and the 14th amendment in order to “protect individual freedoms and human rights”. The credit for guaranteeing these rights, in Marshall’s words, “does not belong to the framers”.
Bibliography
James Madison, Federalist # 10
Thurgood Marshall, Letter to the American BAR Association
Другие работы по теме:
Marbury Vs Madison Essay Research Paper Under
Marbury Vs Madison Essay, Research Paper Under the administrations of Washington and his successor, John Adams, only members of the ruling Federalist Party were allowed to be on the bench, and under the Constitution, they held office for life during “good behavior.” So when the Republicans won the election of 1800, the Jeffersonians found out that even though they controlled the presidency and Congress, the Federalists still had control of the judiciary.
Mcculloch V Maryland Essay Research Paper The
Mcculloch V. Maryland Essay, Research Paper The Supreme Court case of McCulloch v. Maryland set forth important principles in American government. The case itself dealt with whether or not the Congress had power from the Constitution to establish a national bank; also, it dealt with whether or not a state could tax or interfere with the national bank.
Mcculloch V Maryland Essay Research Paper McCulloch
Mcculloch V. Maryland Essay, Research Paper McCulloch v. Maryland The case of McCulloch v. Maryland was brought to the United States Supreme Court in 1819. The decisions of Chief Justice John Marshall in this case would set precedence for all future cases involving the expansion of federal power and any impediment on federal powers by state governments.
George C Marshall Essay Research Paper George
George C. Marshall Essay, Research Paper George C. Marshall was born on December 31, 1880, in Uniontown, Pennsylvania. He graduated from the Virginia Military Institute (VMI) in 1901 and was commissioned a Second Lieutenant. During World War I he was stationed in France and won acclaim for his direction of the Meuse-Argonne offensive.
Lawgrtt Essay Research Paper The Constitution of
Lawgrtt Essay, Research Paper The Constitution of the United States and Madison’s Federalist Paper 51 draw upon the philosophy of John Locke, as expressed in his Second Treatise of Government. Madison and the framers of the Constitution looked to Locke’s ideas for justification and guidance. The Preamble of the Constitution reflects the intentions of its authors and shows the influence of Locke’s ideas.
Federalist Papers Essay Research Paper 1 The
Federalist Papers Essay, Research Paper 1. The Federalist #10, Madison’s problems with factions. According to Madison, a faction is a number of citizens, whether a majority or a minority of the whole, who are united and actuated by some common impulse of passion, or of interest, adverse to the rights of other citizens, or to the permanent and aggregate interests of the community.
Marbury Vs Madison Essay Research Paper Marbury
Marbury Vs. Madison Essay, Research Paper Marbury V. Madison As the government was newly establishing its stronghold on the nation, forging its way to a powerful republic and instituting precedents for the future, a struggle to preserve the foundations of American Society instituted by Washington and John Adams existed as Thomas Jefferson took office.
Marbury V Madison Trial Essay Research Paper
Marbury v. Madison The issue before the Supreme Court was the question of the court?s own constitutional authority, and to decide whether or not to issue the writ and if this would
John Marshall Essay Research Paper George Washington
John Marshall Essay, Research Paper George Washington may have been the Father of Our Country, but his friend John Marshall defined for the new nation what it meant to be united and to live under the rule of law.
Madison Vs Marbury Essay Research Paper Between
Madison Vs. Marbury Essay, Research Paper Between 1800 and 1835, the Supreme Court dealt with many cases of great importance to the United States of America. John Marshall served as the Chief Justice of the Supreme Court during this time. The case of Marbury v. Madison, in 1803, was one of the most crucial court cases and decisions made in this time period.
John Marshal Essay Research Paper The Influence
John Marshal Essay, Research Paper The Influence of Marshall s Court The Supreme Court, under John Marshall, had a great influence on the development of the powers of our present day government. John Marshall s court was responsible for greatly increasing the powers of the Supreme Court and the Federal Government.
Jeffersonian Republicans Vs Madison Administratoin Essay Research
Paper In the time period between 1801 and 1817 the Jeffersonian Republicans were regarded as strict constructionists however this political party made many decisions that were characterized as broad constructionism. The Federalists who were characterized as broad constructionism also abandoned their method of interpreting the constitution more than once and interpreted the constitution quite strictly.
Making Of A Writer Essay Research Paper
By: Paule Marshall One woman tries to convey the “variety of voices” from West Indians and black American Engilsh which are her heritage. She gained her knowledge through her
Street Soldier Essay Research Paper Street SoldierStreet
Street Soldier Essay, Research Paper Street Soldier Street Soldier, by Joseph Marshall, is a inspiring well written book. The book is about his life and how he started the Omega Boys Club. The Omega Boys Club is a club that helps keep inter city kids off the streets. There is a connection between the author’s life and certain events in the novel.
A History Of The Early Assertion Of
Judicial Power Essay, Research Paper A History of the Early Assertion of Judicial Power Once upon a time there were several men planning out the best way to divide the power in a fledgling new country. Some of them wanted one big power, and others wanted three smaller ones where the power was roughly equally divided.
Judicial Review And J Marshal Essay Research
Paper As the fourth Supreme Court Chief Justice of the United States of America, John Marshall created a legacy that has endured nearly two hundred years. While writing the majority opinion for the Supreme Court case of Marbury v. Madison in 1803, he single-handedly changed the course of our judicial system.
Federalist Papers Essay Research Paper James Madison
Federalist Papers Essay, Research Paper James Madison begins the Federalist No. 10, possibly one of the greatest political papers, by stating an argument in favor of the Constitution. Madison supports the Constitution because it establishes a government that is capable of controlling the ?violence of faction.? Factions are groups of people with like political or economic interests that gather to promote their own views.
John Bardeen Essay Research Paper Bardeen John
John Bardeen Essay, Research Paper Bardeen, John 1908-91, American physicist; b. Madison, Wis. He was known for his studies of semiconductivity and other aspects of SOLID-STATE PHYSICS. The first
Federalist NoS 10 51 By James
Madison Essay, Research Paper The Federalist No.?s 10 and 51 The Federalist, No. 10, by James Madison is a clear expression of views and policies for a new government. Madison was a strong supporter and member of the Federalists whose main beliefs favored the Constitution. They also believed that the Articles of Confederation needed to be rewritten so that a new central government would control the power of the states.
John Marshall The Great Chief Justice Essay
, Research Paper John Marshall: The Great Chief Justice John Marshall was born in Fauquier County, Virginia on September 4, 1755. He was the first son of Thomas Marshall and Mary Randolph Keith. His role in American history is undoubtedly a very important one. As a boy, Marshall was educated by his father. He learned to read and write, along with some lessons in history and poetry.
John Marshall Essay Research Paper John Marshall
John Marshall Essay, Research Paper John Marshall was born on September 24, 1755 in Prince William County, Virginia. When John was ten, his father decided that they were going to move into a valley in the Blue Ridge Mountains, almost thirty miles from the house they lived.
John Marshall Essay Research Paper John MarshallThe
John Marshall Essay, Research Paper John Marshall The United States of America, 224 years young, has gone through enumerable changes and stages. Many changes have gone through the constitution and its definitions of a perfect government. The intricate pathways of the branch system and checks and balances have proved to be extremely successful in the course of its existence.
John Marshall Essay Research Paper John MarshallIn
John Marshall Essay, Research Paper John Marshall In early American history, the powers of the executive and legislative branches of the government were already well defined. However, the judicial branch needed to establish its position as an equal of the other two branches. John Marshall was crucial in making this happen.
John Marshall Essay Research Paper My name
John Marshall Essay, Research Paper My name is John Marshall. I am the son of Thomas and Mary Marshall. I was Born on the 24th of September, 1755. I was the oldest of fifteen children in my family. As a child I lived in the near frontier region of Virginia. I was mostly educated by my parents at home. I had more teaching at an academy in Westmore land County.
The Marshall Decision Essay Research Paper Who
The Marshall Decision Essay, Research Paper Who: Donald Marshall (a Mikmaq fisherman), Native and non-native fisherman, Supreme Court of Canada and Herb Dhaliwal (minister of Fisheries and ocean).
Thurgood Marshall Essay Research Paper Thurgood MarshallThurgood
Thurgood Marshall Essay, Research Paper Thurgood Marshall Thurgood Marshall was born on July 2, 1908, in Baltimore, Maryland. Thurgood was the grandson of a slave. His father, William Marshall, instilled in him from youth an appreciation for the United States Constitution, and the rule of law. His father became Chief Steward of the prestigious Island Club, while mother Norma Marshall, a graduate of an all black college in Maryland, taught in a segregated Baltimore Elementary School.
John Marshall Influence On The Supreme Court
Essay, Research Paper In the beginning years of the United States Constitution, the Supreme Court was a struggling institution due to the lack of effectiveness of the Chief Justices and was not highly regarded by the executive and legislative branches of the government. The third Chief Justice in only twelve years, John Marshall put an end to the Supreme Court’s lack of influence after his appointment by President John Adams in 1801.
Thomas Riley Marshall Essay Research Paper Thomas
Thomas Riley Marshall Essay, Research Paper Thomas Riley Marshall was born in North Ranchester, Indiana on March 14, 1854. He graduated from Wabash College in 1873 where he studied law. Afterwards he was admitted to the Indiana bar in 1875, practicing his profession in Columbia City. His father was a physician.
Gold Rush Essay Research Paper The California
Gold Rush Essay, Research Paper The California Gold Rush had many effects on the American people, westward expansion, the environment, economy and Indian relations ultimately affecting the world as a whole. When John Marshall first found gold in January 1848 at Sutter’s Mill in California many people on the east coast did not believe the news.
Constitutional Law
– Marbury V. Madison Essay, Research Paper Constitutional Law Marbury v. Madison Marbury v. Madison, one of the first Supreme Court cases asserting the
Government By The People For The People
Essay, Research Paper Government by the People, For the People The new constitution, thought to bring to power a centralized form of Government, actually establishes a Democratic Republic. In “Federalist #39″, Madison’s
AntiEminem Essay Research Paper We the undersigned
Anti-Eminem Essay, Research Paper We, the undersigned, have committed ourselves to living in this crumbling society. We all know that it is losers such as Marshall Mathers (Eminem) that are at fault for the constant downgrading of our society and social values.
Eminem The Real Marshall Essay Research Paper
You would be surprised how many people judge and descrimenate Marshall Mathers *Eminem*. He has been protested against and hated on throughout the most important years of his life- the years that he will remember for the rest of his life. Marshall was born in Detroit Michigan, 1974 and lived there for most of his childhood.