Culture Vs. Race Essay, Research Paper
Anthropologists have always had their discrepancies with the word culture and its background significance. There have been numerous definitions that have filtered through the field, yet not one that everyone can accept or agree with. Franz Boas, an anthropologist in the early 20th Century, and his students, had a difficult time figuring out the objective of what culture is. Culture is about learning and shared ideas about behaviour. Although Boas and his students had a slightly different idea in mind. They ultimately reached a conclusion, a definition of culture in their view that is a contradiction in terms. Boas sates that, ? culture was expressed through the medium of language but was not reducible to it; more importantly, it was not race. Culture became everything race was not, and race was seen to be what culture was not; given, unchangeable biology,? (Visweswaran, p. 72).
Not only focusing on culture, but anthropology has a substantial connection as well. Anthropology is the field in which the study of cultural and biological variations among human groups is studied. The difficulty that some people have with characterizing culture
2
is that they associate it with race, whereas that is not the case. The two are remarkably distinct. Race is something biological, a genetic trait that is innate, while culture is something that is educated and experienced.
Kamala Visweswaran and Lila Abu-Lughod are two well distinguished anthropologists that are currently teaching at Universities in the United States. In their own articles, they speak about culture through an anthropologists view and detail their own opinions within. They may have some different opinions but each has their own strong arguments that prove their points.
Lila Abu-Lughod?s article ?Writing Against Culture,? was written in 1991, and was published inside the book, Recapturing Anthropology. Within the article, she discusses culture and many problems with it. The title of her article speaks for itself, writing against culture. There are many issues that she brings up about culture, and various influential strategies for shifting over from the culture concept. She reflects on culture and its need to be redefined. In her discussion of culture and difference she opens with, ? most American anthropologists believe or act as if ?culture,? notoriously resistant to definition and ambiguous of referent, is nevertheless the true object of anthropological inquiry,? (Abu-Lughod, p. 143). She illustrates how essential culture is to anthropology and how anthropology helps to balance culture, as well as its ties with race. She considers culture and race as opposites. ?Culture is learned and can change,? (Abu-Lughod, p. 144), and
3
race is something inborn. Although she can only depict and explain the concept of culture, and how it has become necessary and not the reasons behind it.
Lila Abu-Lughod also writes about feminism in regard to culture. ? It has been important for most feminists to locate sex differences in culture, not biology or nature,? (Abu-Lughod, p. 144). There have been many cultural differences between women and men, ? a different voice? perhaps from Anglo-American feminist Gilligan and her followers, (Abu-Lughod, p. 145), as well as an explanation of the differences, ? whether through a socially informed psychoanalytic theory, a Marxist-derived theory of the effects of the division of labour and women?s role in social reproduction, an analysis of maternal practice or even a theory of sexual exploitation,? (Abu-Lughod, p. 145). With that there has been an increasingly large demand for more women oriented culture, a place where they can express themselves and learn about their gender culture, and not that of men. ?That is to say, if women share something in common, it is not the result of a universal bodily maturational process but of mutually experienced interpolations of race, class, and sexual orientation through patriarchal formations,? ( Visweswaran, p. 79).
One of the strategies that Abu-Lughod states is ethnography of the particular, which in part is assumed to upset the culture concept. It is a fact that anthropologists write about what they study and in turn many generalize that what they are observing is quite the same or similar throughout. ? Generalization, the characteristic mode of operation and
4
style of writing of the social sciences, can no longer be regarded as neutral description, ( Abu-Lughod, p. 149-150). Moreover, writing against culture is to shift from writing in generalized terms. Ethnography of the particular is a way to write in more familiar terms as well as to write about the particulars. ? And the particulars suggest that other live as we perceive ourselves living, not as robots programmed with ?cultural? rules, but as people going through life agonizing over decisions, making mistakes, trying to make themselves look good, enduring tragedies and personal losses, enjoying others, and finding moments of happiness, ? (Abu-Lughod, p.158).
The second article is written by Kamala Visweswaran, ?Race and the Culture of Anthropology,? which was published in the American Anthropologist Magazine, in March of 1998. She discusses culture, although in a slightly different manner then Abu-Lughod and she elaborates more on the connection with race. Her main argument within the article she states clearly at the beginning, ? Multiculturalism and culture studies have emerged as counterdisciplinary formations that radically foreground race and racial identity precisely because the modern anthropological notion of culture cannot so do,? (Visweswaran, p. 70). She quotes and details a lot of what Franz Boas studied and wrote in his books and incorporates it with her own views on race and culture. Boas himself had more of a ?race theory,? then a theoretical view on culture, although he later fixed that. ? It was rather the distinctions Boas made between race, language, and culture that provided the foundation
5
of a Americanist anthropology, with each term tending toward the provenance of a particular subdiscipline,? (Visweswaran, p. 71).
Although Boas was a very racist and prejudice man, he did influence much thought about culture and anthropology. When discussing the Negro problem in society in conjunction with anti-Semitism, (since he was a member if the Nazi party), he associated it with blood, since he is comparing blood towards a secondary race. His thoughts on the black population was that if they got enough white blood in their bodies through transmissions, that their colour would dissolve and become white, which would solve the racial and cultural problem. In other words, if culture which represents race and racial identity, were to be Aryan then the blood would be superior and the race would have high biological quality. A place where Boas wanted everyone to be the same and there would be no racial or cultural problems. With this new connection to anthropology, the American Anthropological Association, ? passed a resolution denouncing Nazi racism: ? Anthropology provides no scientific basis for discrimination against any people on the ground of racial inferiority, religious affiliation or linguistic heritage, ? (Visweswaran, p. 71).
?The solution is not to replace culture with race but to keep the two terms in contructivist tension with one another,? (Visweswaran, p. 79). Anthropology cannot strive without culture, yet there must be a distinction with race. Culture is something that society is taught and learned, while race is something biological, and something to be
6
proud of. Boas and his ideas were not yet educated as to what culture means. He was overlooking and only saw his own perspective. Culture creates this diverse world and in turn race creates life with culture.
Bibliography
7
References
Abu-Lughod, Lila. (1991) Writing Against Culture. Recapturing Anthropology. Richard Fox, ed. P, 137-162. Santa Fe, NM: School of American Research Press.
Visweswaran, Kamala. (March, 1998) Race and the Culture of Anthropology. American Anthropologist. p. 70-83. American Anthropological
Другие работы по теме:
Acculturation And Assimilation Essay Research Paper Acculturation
Acculturation And Assimilation Essay, Research Paper Acculturation and Assimilation Culture deals with thoughts, norms, and productions of a certain people. These modes are communicated among humans and not passed down genetically. Therefore, culture is the base from which the study of acculturation and assimilation use to trace similarities with other cultures.
Religion Is Important Essay Research Paper I
Religion Is Important Essay, Research Paper I think culture, religion, ethnicity is very important in one’s life. They should know where there from and who they are. Everyone comes from somewhere around the world, even if they were born in another country, they still
Race In The Context Of Reading And
Writing Essay, Research Paper Race In the Context of Reading and Writing Hurston is saying in effect, I am colored but I am different from other members of my race in that I am not different from my race ( Race, Reading, and Difference 319).
Black Essay Research Paper Black Soldiers in
Black Essay, Research Paper Black Soldiers in the Union Army During the Seventeenth, Eighteenth and part of the Nineteenth Century the White People of North America used the Black people of Africa as slaves to benefit their interests. White people created a climate of superiority of their race over the Black African race that in some places, still lingers on today.
What Importance May The Sex Of The
Anthropologist Have On The Ethnographic Process? Essay, Research Paper There are many factors which can influence the ethnographic process for an anthropologist, and a very important one is
Italy Essay Research Paper Anthropologists and other
Italy Essay, Research Paper Anthropologists and other social scientists define human culture as learned behavior acquired by individuals as members of a social group. The concept of culture was first explicitly defined in 1871 by the British anthropologist Edward B. Tylor. He used the term to refer to “ that complex whole which includes knowledge, belief, art, morals, law, custom and any other capabilities and habits acquired by man as a member of society.” Since then anthropologists have offered numerous refinements and variations on this definition, but all have agreed that culture is learned behavior in contrast to genetically endowed behavior.
Maya Angelou 3 Essay Research Paper The
Maya Angelou 3 Essay, Research Paper The readings from “Graduation Day” by: Maya Angelou and “On Becoming A Chicano” by: Richard Rodriguez were different but they the same point across. They were of different cultures, race, and time era, and they both overcame adversity to excel in their schooling.
The Glass Menagerie Essay Research Paper In
The Glass Menagerie Essay, Research Paper In The Glass Menagerie there was a character that was alienated. Writers often highlight the values of a culture or a society by using characters who
Social Evolution Essay Research Paper Herbert Spencer
Social Evolution Essay, Research Paper Herbert Spencer and Franz Boaz had two opposing theories on the social evolution theory. Each theory was difficult to prove but great theories. But both theories had it s ups and downs . Herbert Spencer was born in England, he is best known for developing and applying the evolutionary theory to philosophy and psychology.
Epic Essay Essay Research Paper What an
Epic Essay Essay, Research Paper What an epic says about its culture is that that was the way they lived like in the Epic of Gilgamesh, Faerie Qveene, and Iliad (Comical Version). The three are epics from their own time and culture they are the same in some ways and different in other ways.
Franz Boas Essay Research Paper Father Franz
Franz Boas Essay, Research Paper Father Franz Boas–Father of American Anthropology Franz Boas is often referred to as the father of American anthropology because of the great influence he had
Race Labels Essay Research Paper Will the
Race Labels Essay, Research Paper Will the United States ever be a place where the citizens are referred to as Americans, like the citizens of Cuba are referred to primarily as Cubans? Can the people of America ever erase race? I think the United States would be a better place if racial labels were not placed on individuals.
Definition Of Culture Essay Research Paper Definition
Definition Of Culture Essay, Research Paper Definition of Culture Culture, a term that entails everything and everyone in our society today, is used to describe the relationships that people?s traditions, actions, arts, and styles share throughout the world in different places, times, and ages. Culture can be described as the actions, arts, beliefs, institutions and all other products of human work and thought.
Responsibilities Of Anthropologists Essay Research Paper Responsibilities
Responsibilities Of Anthropologists Essay, Research Paper Responsibilities of Anthropologists There is much blindness in the way ?civilized? people first percieve people of other cultures. Often times this blindness can lead to arrogance. Anthropology has been important for hundreds of years, describing unknown cultures and explaining their histories.
Farewell To Manzanar Essay Research Paper Farewell
Farewell To Manzanar Essay, Research Paper Farewell to Manzanar Jeanne Wakatsuki Houston and James D. Houston’s novel, Farewell to Manzanar ,discusses the internment of Japanese-American people in a relocation camp from 1943-1945. The autobiographical work reveals, through the eyes of a Japanese American teenage girl, her inner struggle with her identity as a person of the Japanese race living in California during World War II.
Speaker
#3 Essay, Research Paper He was born on Essen of Germany. He was an ordinary citizen of Germany. The keyword to this essay is that word “was.” After the NAZI came into power, he was treated as an “inferior race.” He did not beat anyone up or abuse anyone. So, why was he being treated badly? He was a Jewish person in a new era.
Supreme Court Bakke Essay Research Paper BakkeI
Supreme Court Bakke Essay, Research Paper Bakke I do not wish to reverse history and go back to the period of time, where discrimination was present and influential in every aspect of our society. However, I do wish to make sure that while making sure that the once oppressed minorities do not have to endure the discrimination ever again, the rights of persons such as myself are not violated in the name of doing the supposed higher good.
Equality Essay Research Paper Equality
Equality Essay, Research Paper Equality I have a vision, that all people be treated equally. Race, religion, sex, age, and other petty differences should not mater. Every one has a rite to me
Race Essay Research Paper Race a
Race Essay, Research Paper Race ? a sense of identity What is the definition of race? We divide people into groups by their skin color – black, yellow and whites. Maybe it is time to change this. The Swedish population and other populations as well, are nowadays a mixed group of people. White people are black people’s neighbors, doctors and friends.
WHAT IS LOVE Essay Research Paper WHAT
What Is Love? Essay, Research Paper What is this thing called love? This simple question begs for an answer. The symptoms of love are familiar enough. A drifting mooniness in one?s behavior and thought, the fact that it
Ebonics Essay Research Paper One of the
Ebonics Essay, Research Paper One of the conflicting issues among African Americans and Caucasians is the issue of ebonics. It s not just an issue facing one race or the other it effects both races
Song Of Solomn Essay Research Paper Guitar
Song Of Solomn Essay, Research Paper Guitar loves his race and will do anything for it. He wants to keep the number of black and white people equal so that the whites do not become the dominant race. Guitar wants the blacks to have the ability to achieve a better life. But his love and attempts to preserve and advance his race actually turn him against himself and his race.
Anthropologists Essay Research Paper Although anthropology dates
Anthropologists Essay, Research Paper Although anthropology dates back to Aristotle (384-322 BC), it became an established science during the era of colonial exploration and expansion, because of increased contact with different peoples of the world. Anthropology developed during the Industrial Revolution, along with the study of geography, and Charles Darwin’s theory of evolution.
Dinosaur Essay Research Paper In the middle
Dinosaur Essay, Research Paper In the middle of this century, both biological and cultural anthropology experiences a major change in theory. In biological anthropology, biological anthropologists adopted an approach which focused on the gene. They saw the human evolution as the process of genetic adaptation to the environment.
Geoffrey Chaucer Essay Research Paper Does Chaucer
Geoffrey Chaucer Essay, Research Paper Does Chaucer truly understand human nature? Geoffrey Chaucer, author of The Canterbury Tales, is known as the Father of English poetry. Some have said that Chaucer has the perfect understanding of human nature. All people identify with this piece of poetry in every time period, culture, and race.
Summary Of The Future Essay Research Paper
This is a summary of the 16th chapter, a chapter in which it is written about the societies in the future. Actually I didn’t understand many words, but I think that I understood the concept, which I myself think is the most important. The chapter is about the future, how the anthropologists cannot tell how a future society will look like because there are human decisions that we can’t predict.
Social Class Differences Essay Research Paper Social
Social Class Differences Essay, Research Paper Social Class Differences Peer Influences?researchers say some low-SES students become part of resistance culture, these kinds of kids see it as "selling out" or
Interracial Adoption Essay Research Paper Interracial AdoptionToday
Interracial Adoption Essay, Research Paper Interracial Adoption Today, the United States has become more racially and ethnically diverse than it has been in the last few decades. Although there is basic equality among people of different cultural backgrounds, racial bigotry still lies beneath the surface.
Tour De France Essay Research Paper Tour
Tour De France Essay, Research Paper Tour De FranceThe tour de france is the most popular bike race in the world. It is held in July Of every year. In France.More than 200 competitors race for about 3200km in 25-30 days. This race was started back in 1903 by an ex-biker named Henri Desgranges. Who at the time was the owner of a struggling french newspaper.
Color Of Water Essay Research Paper One
Color Of Water Essay, Research Paper One aspect of identity where feedback can be given almost instantaneously is race, as it involves a person’s skin color. Young children often ignore each others’ races unless they
Culture Of Poverty Essay Research Paper Culture
Culture Of Poverty Essay, Research Paper ?Culture of Poverty? The ?culture of poverty? was introduced or was popularized by Oscar Lewis while studying poor families in Mexico and Puerto Rican families San Juan and New York. The theory maintains that culturally based attitudes or predisposition such as ?present-mindedness? and ?obsessive-consumption? are the major barriers to economic mobility for many of the poor.