Confucian And Legalist Essay, Research Paper
?n the history of Imperial China the issue of the authority of rulers has been worked out in relation to the prevailing philosophies of their times. The longest, most influential and enduring of these is Confucianism.The philosophy and the w?? in which it demands virtue and duty from a ruler has n?t always gone down well with rulers of a more autocratic nature and has at times been displaced by the school of thought known as Legalism. “Notably the Legalist believed that the people existed for the sake of the state and its ruler while the Confucians believed that the state and its ruler existed for the sake of the people”. (Dawson 1978, ?? 15). I will make ? comparison and contrast of the ideas of the two schools ?n how to govern.
Confucius was apart from contemporary and later philosophers, the original and chief contributor to the school of thought known as Confucianism.Confucius put forth an ethical system in which harmony was founded upon the right functioning of five key relationships:
Father-son filial piety
Ruler-subject loyalty
Brother-brother brotherliness
Husband-wife love and obedience
Friend-friend faithfulness
(Hucker 1975, ?? 84)
The “Mandate of Heaven” was a concept that had its basis in the relationship ruler-subject. It was used by many historians as a wa? of explaining the fall and rise of Dynasties as being subject to the will of Heaven, based ?n the conduct of the ruler, who was the son of Heaven.The idea was as follows: ? ruler can not rely upon military and political power alone to maintain his rule. If he neglects the right relationship to Heaven and to his people he may lose the Mandate of Heaven and be overthrown ?r meet defeat in battle.
One very important feature of Confucian ideas ?n how to govern was the less active, more spiritual and ritual role of the emper?r, which was expressed in perhaps its most radical form by the Confucian philosophers of the ?an Dynasty: “He who is the ruler of men takes non-action as his Way and makes impartiality his treasure.He sits upon the throne of non-action and rides upon the perfection of his ?fficials. His feet do not move but his ministers lead him forward; his mouth utters no word but his chamberlains give him words of support; his mind does not concern itself with problems but his ministers put in effect the appropriate action. Thus nobody sees him act and yet he achieves success. This is how the ruler imitates the ways of Heaven.? (Dawson 1987, PP 7)
China in ancient times was split into smaller states and it was ?nly under the Ch’in that a unity was achieved. Under the ?an a lot of the harshness of Ch’in rule was ameliorated and the ?an permitted the rise of an inteIlectual Confucian scholarly class who quickly achieved prominence in administrative roles and became prominent in p?litical roles as counselors to the emperor. Confucian thought found its way into the highest circles and the r?ya? children were drilled in the Confucian classics. Emperors then were encouraged by sculars to live ?? to the ideals of Confucianism.
This affected their government, and the role of ministers in relation to the power of the ruler, a?? ?f which were refered to in Confucian philosophy. The aristocrats n? longer had a monopoly of government and the Confucian tradition strongly emphasized the importance of family ties and the hereditary principle. Even after the decline of Confucianism, its philosophy continued influencing the ??? period.
The Legalist school had as major idea the obedience t? the law. This approach, as applied by the Ch’in, can be viewed as too extreme and was not accepted by the people that is why the Ch’in Dynasty and Legalist rule was short-lived.
The Legalists believed that officials must be obedient instruments of the rulers will. Following the thought of the early Legalist thinkers, the later Ch’in legalists took their theories into practical application of government. They also believed that peoples’ names and actions should match, in the sense that people should follow their designated occupational roles to the letter.”When names and actualities are in accord with each other, there is good government. When they are not in accord with each other there is disorder”. (Dawson 1978 ?? 113). ‘
Having looked at the approaches of ?an and Ch’in government in regard to their application of Confucianism and Legalism, it is possible to highlight some areas of similarity comparisons and contrasts::
Confucians idealized past antiquity but Legalists did not; they were concerned ?nly with the problems of present rule.
Confucians believed that law should be flexible and take account of circumstances. Legalists believed that law should be applied without discretion.
Confucians were pro-education. Legalist disliked scholars, favoring soldiers and manual workers.
Legalisi didn’t like the merchants since they were seen as profiteering rather than working the state. The Confucians agreed that the activities of merchants had a bad effect, they weakened the state.
The Ch’in Dynasty had a harsh philosophy of reward and punishment and encouraged a mutual surveillance of the ???ulace to ensure social control. The rule of law in the ?an was relatively gentle in comparison and took individual circumstances into account in cases of transgressions.
Confucians had ideals for the role of the ruler and ? conception of people as needing ? worthy emperor ?ho fulfilled the mandate of Heaven.,
Legalist had the view of a ruler, who was regarded as a son of Heaven, as the Confucians want, and was also to be obeyed as an autocrat whose officials were expected to fulfil their duties and be obedient to the letter of the ?aw.
? The Confucians had a belief that human nature was essentially good and that the people would respond well to a kind ruler. The Legalists in contrast had a pessimistic view of human nature, which resulted in their philosophy of legalist rewards, and harsh punishments.
?n conclusion, the two schools of thought when applied to governmental administration resulted in different approaches.lt might a?pear that Legalist rule in the Ch’in Dynasty achieved a kind of social control; but in fact among people and in a nation of such a size as China their approach proved impossible to maintain in the long term. After the fall of the Ch’in Dynasty, the ?an did not rule by pure Confucian principles either. The most positive and enduring contribution of th Ch’in Dynasty was inherited and perpetuated by the ?an along with any practical policies which seemed to work. Philosophically, the ?an permitted Confucianism to rise during the ?an Dynasty.The ?an rulers wanted to avoid the harshness of the former regime and made the contentment of the people a matter of greater concern wh?ch enabled that Dynasty to achive greater public co-operation and success.
Dawson, Raymont (1978) The Chinese Experience.
Hucker, Charles (1975) China?s Imperial Past
Другие работы по теме:
Romeo An Juliet Essay Research Paper hi
Romeo An Juliet Essay, Research Paper hi i need an essay about a character in romeo and juliet that demonsrtated maturity. in a well developed multi pagraph essay and say why you think the character’s maturity was greater than the other characters in the play.
Was Confucianism Responsible For China
’s Failure To Modernize Essay, Research Paper Was Confucianism Responsible for China’s Failure to Modernize? How significant was China’s more than 1000-year tradition of a stable, hierarchial, Confucian society in keeping China from seeing the need to modernize?
Judge Dee Essay Research Paper The character
Judge Dee Essay, Research Paper The character of Judge Dee is largely molded by the ideas of his time. During his reign, the philosophies of Legalism, Confucianism, and Taoism, were heavily relied upon for the basis of ethics within the common people and magistrates alike. Judge Dee?s persona is derived directly from the strictest teachings of these philosophies.
Oh Really Essay Research Paper Oh Reallyyou
Oh Really? Essay, Research Paper Oh Really, you think i am a lark, the dogs they run and bark, but when i say to them, shut up shut up shut up, you say to be nice to them,
Chagnon Debate Essay Research Paper Confucian Doctrine
Chagnon Debate Essay, Research Paper Confucian Doctrine in Modern Society Robert Bruce’s article titled “The Return to Confucius?” asserts that Confucianism may be the answer to Asian economic strife. However, he fails to draw a clear link between economic prosperity and Confucianism, instead leaving the reader to hypothesize using the information given in the article, and, in our case, the Analects.
Confucian Transformation Of Women Essay Research Paper
Korea adopted Confucianism as the guiding principle for reform with the founding of the Chos?n Dynasty in 1392. For women in Korean society, this meant virtual doom. The Chos?n period is considered to be the dark age for women’s culture and women in general. The philosophy of Confucianism considered the relationship between man and woman to be the root of all human relations.
Confucianism And Raise The Red Lanturn Essay
, Research Paper What has happened to Confucianism. For a long time, Confucian was accepted as the idea that a healthy society depended on a solid traditional family. Confucius himself, for example, called for people to put principle above selfish desires. People supported hierarchy. The rulers moral example would inspire the people to live good lives.
Shane Essay Research Paper Sometimes I need
Shane Essay, Research Paper Sometimes, I need you more than I need air And sometimes I miss you more than I will forever, never forget the times that we have shaared. The are priceless
Poem Belong Essay Research Paper Where I
Poem: Belong Essay, Research Paper Where I belong I am weak, I am strong I will fit where I belong don’t know where it is for now but it will come, if I allow tomorrow, I start a brand new day
Confucius 4 Essay Research Paper Confucianism
Confucius 4 Essay, Research Paper Confucianism, the philosophical system founded on the teaching of Confucius, who lived from 551 BC to 479 BC, dominated Chinese sociopolitical life for most of the Chinese history and largely influenced the cultures of Korea, Japan, and Indochina. The Confucian school functioned as a recruiting ground for government positions, which were filled by those scoring highest on examinations in the Confucian classics.
Him Essay Research Paper I think about
Him Essay, Research Paper I think about him day and night The though won’t go away And, oh, how I would hold him tight every second of the day He is perfect, that is true, not an average me or you
Comparing Taoism Confucianism And Legalism Essay Research
Paper When one mentions the name Lowell High School, one woulda think of academic excellence and first-class education. The students all enter Lowell High School by placing tremendous effort into their academic studies. The motive of the students is to attain one certain goal, which is to be accepted to a prestigious college.
Confucian Essay Research Paper Confucianism the philosophical
Confucian Essay, Research Paper Confucianism, the philosophical system based on the teaching of Confucius (551-479 BC), dominated Chinese sociopolitical life for most of Chinese history and largely influenced the cultures of Korea, Japan, and Indochina. The Confucian school functioned as a recruiting ground for government positions, which were filled by those scoring highest on examinations in the Confucian classics.
Poem She Sat Essay Research Paper She
Poem: She Sat Essay, Research Paper She sat… helpless in her room praying to whatever god there may be to let her call to him. could god ignore such a painful cry?
Lacquer Screen Essay Essay Research Paper Confucianism
Lacquer Screen Essay Essay, Research Paper Confucianism was one of the most influential of the four Great Traditions in ancient China. However, it did not become such a big way of life until after Confucius death, as he only had a small number of disciples following him during his lifetime. Confucianism stressed the importance of some of the greatest virtues of life, including filial piety, Jen, Chi, Yung, and Li, as these represented devotion to the parents, benevolence, wisdom, moral courage, and ritual, and were the keys to achieving moral goodness.
Darmok Confucianism In Star Trek Essay
, Research Paper In the episode of Star Trek: The Next Generation entitled Darmok, which we saw in class this Friday, we saw what impact two cultures could make upon each other. The episode begins with the Enterprise coming out to greet a new race of people, the Tamarians, who are difficult to communicate with because their language has not been figured out.
Han Fei Tzu And Legalism Essay Research
Paper Han Fei Tzu has one aspiration in his basic writings. His sole intent is to keep the ruler in power. We must keep this in mind as we read his views, because many of his beliefs, which may sound strange and illogical, are all centered upon this single idea. His version of legalism, which is also the most influential version in Chinese culture, is also meant primarily for the ruling class and to some extent for their ministers.
Ode To Boys Essay Research Paper We
Ode To Boys Essay, Research Paper We like them But do they like us The ones we do never fuss They don’t stop in And we wonder why We stress, we bitch We sometimes cry
Chinese Culture Essay Research Paper Chinese CultureThe
Chinese Culture Essay, Research Paper Chinese Culture The Chinese Lake Murders were written by author, Robert Van Gulik and can be used to learn about pre-modern Chinese civilization. The book was set during the Ming Dynasty in the town of Han-yuan, which is about 60 miles north west of the imperial capital.
Confucianism 2 Essay Research Paper ConfucianismConfucianism is
Confucianism 2 Essay, Research Paper Confucianism Confucianism is based upon the thoughts of Confucius, whom lived during the Zhou Dynasty, which lasted from 1027 to 221 B.C. Confucius was born around 551 B.C. in Tsou, a small town in the state of Lu, in what is today Shantung Province. His father died when he was three, and grew up in poverty with his mother, as he worked several jobs to help support the family.
Life Is Like Essay Research Paper Life
Life Is Like Essay, Research Paper Life is like a car. When it?s new, it usually works all right. As time drives by, it breaks down and needs repairs. Life is like a leaf. In its youth, it
Chinese Buddhism Essay Research Paper Chinese Buddhism
Chinese Buddhism Essay, Research Paper Chinese Buddhism There is evidence of Buddhists in China as early as the 3rd century, but Buddhism was not popular in China for years. Buddhism was probably introduced after the Han emperor Ming Ti had a dream of a flying golden deity that was interpreted as a vision of the Buddha.
Confucianism And The Rise Of Industrialism In
East Asia Essay, Research Paper ? ??? ?? Many factors helped aid in the dynamic growth that occurred in Japan and the four little dragons during the post-World War 2 period. Some of these factors were situational factors unique to the time but some of the factors were cultural. The legacy of Confucianism in Japan and the four little dragons helped to further the goals of industrialization that these nations had.
Dare Essay Essay Research Paper What DARE
Dare Essay Essay, Research Paper What D.A.R.E Means To Me Dare has prepared me to say no to drugs in eight different ways. If anyone asks me to do drugs I will know what to do, such as- just ignoring the person or just
Han Dynasty Essay Research Paper The Han
Han Dynasty Essay, Research Paper The Han dynasty (202 BC – AD 220) reunited the China after the Qin dynasty fell apart. The Han ruled China for forty years, which was divided into two periods: the earlier period Western Han and the later period Easter Han. Gaozu, who was the first king of the Han dynasty, was a minor official in Qin dynasty.
The Clash Of Civilizations Essay Research Paper
There are many civilizations around the world. A civilization is the broadest level to which a person belongs and identifies with and must share something like religion, culture, language, race, etc. with the other people of its same civilization. On the past, the want for territory and power expansion was the main cause for wars.
The Islamic And Confucianism Essay Research Paper
During the post-classical period, the Islamic and Confucianist world religions?were based upon the principles of spiritual and intellectual growth. Both valued intelligence and knowledge, and strongly supported education, yet each religion viewed the world and its inhabitants from different vantage points.