A True Education Essay, Research Paper
A True Education
Students from impoverished neighborhoods and students from economically secure neighborhoods; who deserves the best education? Better yet who deserves an education? In the opinions of both Mike Walzer and Mike Johnson everyone who desires an education deserves one regardless of their social or economic background. This is democracy at work, yet here is where the two men have their first difference of opinion.
To Walzer, the goal of a basic education is to provide all students with the tools they need to succeed in life, while promoting social values and an understanding of democracy. This is all fine and well, but to Johnson education should prepare children for the world they live in and the world they will shape. Democracy can be taught and learned from reading ?the papers? not giving the students a say in their education. Students must be pushed into the subjects the teach feels they as a member of society will need to learn. If the school is going to prepare the student to succeed in life than the school must give its students a strong basic education. Johnson pushes his students to take the SATs in their freshman year, makes them take Regents exams regardless of their learning level, and pushes them past the limits of their abilities. Is this reform? Is this a working system of education? Yes in both instances. Why? Because right now students wanting to go to college or get a job are measured by certain standards and in order to succeed they must meet the minimum requirements. While many argue the necessity to break away from standards and judge students based on individual portfolios, Johnson views the reality of the present situation. That reality is everyone must fit a standard and until that is changed first, the goal of education is to prepare students to meet those standards. By forcing students to over-achieve and learn basic societal skills like how to act in a formal setting (a situation Johnson teaches by taking students to a formal restaurant) Johnson bestows upon his students the ability to meet any standard and achieve any goal. Why? Because he has given them the tools they need in life and the self-confidence and respect to utilize what they have learned. Education is not about promoting lofty democratic ideals, but about preparing people to face society and giving them the ability to develop principles that will shape society and themselves. These principles will come from the same source; the feeling of self-respect and confidence Johnson has bestowed upon his students.
So where is Walzer on all of this? Walzer agrees that education must prepare students not only for the future, but also the present. However, the way about doing that differs. Equality and democracy should be at the foundation of the basic education. Walzer believes that in order for students to be successful in society and in order to strengthen society the principles of democracy should be taught. Students should come out of school with an idea about the social good, which comes from understanding democracy. Equality and a sense of cooperation are necessary concepts to be taught to the students. These concepts further the development of democracy, which is key to Walzer?s basic education. However, teaching democracy is not enough. Walzer does agree with Johnson that a basic education must give students the proper tools to achieve success in life. Yet Walzer, again like Johnson, is not guaranteeing success; he is guaranteeing only that the education received by the student will, if they choose, lead them to success. Sometimes basic education is not enough and some may choose to narrow the field they wish to enter into. For these students Walzer calls for specialized education. This sort of education will prepare students for a specific career and broaden their options when entering society. Here students choose what to learn and move on when they have taken in what they felt was important. It is an education that is left up to the student and not the school or teachers.
So in comparison how do Walzer (ideals and principles) and Johnson (tools and fundamentals) match up? The two educators agree on bestowing upon their students the tools necessary to achieve both in the present and future, while also instilling self-confidence. However, Johnson is more concerned with meeting the standards of society not preparing for what may be as in Walzer?s case. To Johnson basic education is giving his students tools and abilities which net results now giving his students a better life than they had. Walzer goes beyond this to instill democratic principles and ideals, which will allow his students to shape society and participate actively in the democratic process. From here Walzer desires students to continue their education in specialized schools in order to achieve their goals and specify the role they?ll play in shaping society. Johnson on the other hand is more concerned with teaching the basics so that his students are well rounded and prepared for entering the society that exists now. Where they go from there is up to them. Yet, both men agree upon the most important issue; that all people who desire an education should receive one regardless of their background. In education, whether it is basic or specialized, this is the most important element to success as a society. To deny anyone who is willing to learn is to deny society of a valuable resource in the eyes of these educators.
So who is right? Well, both men are. Johnson has the best idea for basic education. Basic education should promote self-confidence in the learner through high standards and goals, while giving the student the proper tools to achieve whatever they choose to do in society. Virtues, principles, morals, and democratic ideals should be left up to the families and communities to teach to their children. Teachers and schools have a hard enough time preparing people for the real world as it is without having to produce philosophers! However, Walzer is correct in stressing specialized education. In order to truly achieve in an ever-changing society, students must have an understanding and expertise in a specific function important to the development of society. Basic education prepares the student for society, but specialized education gives the student the tools to adapt to societal changes. There is no perfect system, but by combining the philosophies of Johnson and Walzer one can begin to develop a well-rounded philosophy of education.
*All information in this paper came from the article Scores Count and the text Classic and Contemporary Readings in the Philosophy of Education (pgs. 386-411).
Bibliography
article: “Scores Count”
Другие работы по теме:
Liberal Arts Essay Research Paper An Education
Liberal Arts Essay, Research Paper An Education in Liberal Arts Liberal arts is a universal education that provides a strong foundation of knowledge in many subjects. Liberal arts can observe the capabilities as well as the limitations of each field of study. This allows students to find connections between different fields of study, to explore them, and to discover new theories and/or inventions.
Education Today Essay Research Paper Education TodayEducation
Education Today Essay, Research Paper Education Today Education today isn?t quiet what I would like it to be; although it is improving if I was in power I think I would make a few changes. In high school there are certain classes that are mandatory for an individual to graduate history, chemistry and biology are a couple.
College Admission Essay Research Paper Shakespeare once
College Admission Essay, Research Paper Shakespeare once said “We know what we are, but know not what we may be”. While I do not know what my future holds or how I will spend the bulk of my adult life, I know that only education will detect my interest and enrich my soul. I believe Kean University will provide me with the perfect atmosphere and give me the education I need to succeed in life.
Cronon On Education Essay Research Paper Cronon
Cronon On Education Essay, Research Paper Cronon on Education Having read Victor’s story not realizing until the very end that “Victor” in the story was the author made it much more confusing! I realize that the issue here is about racial and social discrimination as well as about education and following your own ideals instead of the rest of society’s.
Things They Carry Essay Research Paper THINGS
Things They Carry Essay, Research Paper THINGS THEY CARRY Through the novel we have understood what O’Brien thinks of true war stories. O’Brien statements about war stories is a true war story is never moral, you can’t tell a true war story. It’s beyond telling. In a true war story, nothing is absolutely true.
Computer Education Essay Research Paper Back to
Computer Education Essay, Research Paper Back to the 1940s, the modern electronic computer was developed at U.S. universities; however, in the year, there was no computer education yet. It needed more 10 years to have computer education. The period of the computer revolution was 1950 in the U.S.. Computer education began in the middle of the 1950s with an organized body of knowledge.
Grades Do We Really Need Them Essay
, Research Paper This essay is about the article called “We Should Cherish Our Children?s Freedom to Think.” It was written by Kie Ho, a business executive who was born and raised in Indonesia. Ho writes this article about why he thinks that American education is, in many ways better than any other in the world.
My Love Essay Research Paper You are
My Love Essay, Research Paper You are my everything My one true love My heart will sing If we can stay forever in love When I first laid eyes upon you My jaw dropped
Why Essay Research Paper A true friend
Why Essay, Research Paper A true friend is something that is hard to come by. They have many rare qualities. These qualities are not the same for every person. A true friend can not really be defined because each person has different qualities they look for in a friend.
Aids Essay Research Paper AIDS is probably
Aids Essay, Research Paper AIDS is probably the most known and most deadly disease in the nation and probably in the whole world. It is a disease that strikes anywhere, anytime, and anyone. That is why I believe sex education is a very beneficial and effective way to let people know about AIDS.
English Class 009 Essay Research Paper I
English Class 009 Essay, Research Paper I am taking English 009 to benefit me in the future. It gives me the skills I need to succeed. I would be able to write a paper; because of the writing skills I have learned in English 009. From studying hard, my grammar could be improved. I would be offered a teaching position as a substitute teacher for English because of my experience in English 009.
Education Essay Research Paper One of the
Education Essay, Research Paper One of the greatest problems in American society today is a variation in the quality of education, dependent upon the wealth, or lack thereof, in particular areas. This problem is especially notorious in areas of destitution. Lower standards for the schools in these poorer neighborhoods are another step in the cycle of poverty.
Society Is Wrong Essay Research Paper SOCIETY
Society Is Wrong Essay, Research Paper SOCIETY IS WRONG! There is a grave matter affecting all students these days. Whether you?re still in grade school or in a post-secondary institution. The brainwashing that takes place over us is undeniable! And it?s not the teachers in which I am talking about.
Philosophy Of Education Essay Research Paper Philosophy
Philosophy Of Education Essay, Research Paper Philosophy of education Being a teacher is something that I’ve thought about my entire life. Wanting to be a teacher is a different story. It took me a few years before I realized that teaching is what I wanted to do. I never thought I could be an educator. It is almost a powerful feeling knowing that I can change the lives of so many students.
Public Education A Right Or A Privilege
Essay, Research Paper Public Education should be a right not a privilege. In my opinion, public education should be a right. We need public education. When it comes to voting,
Education Essay Research Paper Education What
Education Essay, Research Paper Education What is necessary to be educated is dependent solely on the society in which the individual is placed. In any society, basic survival skills- the ability to find shelter, obtain food, and clothe the body- are a must. It is the methods of going about it that differ from society to society.
Education Essay Research Paper In to day
Education Essay, Research Paper In to day’s society education is becoming more and more important. The children of today need education to get good jobs and keep up with this fast paced modern society. Nobody ever explained this to my teachers through. High school was the worst. THe teachers at my school were losers and dinn’t know what they were doing.
Him Essay Research Paper I think about
Him Essay, Research Paper I think about him day and night The though won’t go away And, oh, how I would hold him tight every second of the day He is perfect, that is true, not an average me or you
Functional Education System Essay Research Paper Sam
Functional Education System Essay, Research Paper Sam Bertolami British Literature 4th Period 8-10-00 When I accepted the position of Secretary of Education I was asked to design and create an education system that is works. Unfortunately it is my belief that no one person can create a fully functional system of education.
American Education Essay Research Paper As far
American Education Essay, Research Paper As far as the world standard goes, American public education is near the top of the ladder. But, when you compare the education here to other first world countries, we fall way short. This is not to say that all public schooling institutions are of poor quality, though, because there are many public schools in America that do provide quality education.
Education In To Kill A Mokingbird Essay
, Research Paper Education Education is to instruct mentally and morally. In the novel ?To Kill A Mockingbird? by Harper Lee education is one of the problems that one of the characters encounters.
True Friendship Essay Research Paper True FriendshipBut
True Friendship Essay, Research Paper True Friendship But not us! An why? Because I got you to look after me, and you got me to look after you, and that s why. (Page 14) This quote came from Of Mice and Men, by John Steinbeck. Lennie and George can trust and depend on each other because they are true friends. George is the smart, sophisticated and reliable one of the two.
Labor Forces Essay Research Paper The Massachusetts
Labor Forces Essay, Research Paper The Massachusetts AFL-CIO has partnered with the Massachusetts Business Roundtable to examine the future role of workforce training and education programs in the Commonwealth.
Computers In Education Essay Research Paper Education
Computers In Education Essay, Research Paper Education has been changing so much in the last few years with the introduction to the computers both in the classroom and at home with the students. Students are no longer expected to write papers but type them up; Papers are no longer expected to be just writing but integrated with pictures and graphs; Projects have also changed from who can learn the most to who can make it look good.
Sex Education Essay Research Paper Despite sex
Sex Education Essay, Research Paper Despite sex education at schools, teens are still lacking information on this topic. Even as more and more discussions about sex increase on TV, movies, and even at school,
I Love You Essay Research Paper I
I Love You Essay, Research Paper I Love the way you hold me, When I have no one to turn to. I love how you always convince me Your love is so true. I love the way you make me laugh
Education Essay Research Paper The Georgia Lottery
Education Essay, Research Paper The Georgia Lottery Corporation The Georgia Lottery was created in November 1992 by the people of Georgia to enhance education funding. The Lottery for Education Act createdthe Georgia Lottery Corporation (GLC) to oversee and operate the lottery. Rebecca Paul was hired in February 1993 as president of the GLC, andfour months later, on June 29, the Georgia Lottery was launched.
Education Essay Research Paper EDUCATIONAmericans take their
Education Essay, Research Paper EDUCATION Americans take their education for granted. Education has become one of the most important aspects of a person?s. With seventeen years of formal education, a person can do almost anything he or she wants to do. Yet many in America take this for granted. Some American students today would rather not be in school.
Love Poems Essay Research Paper All That
Love Poems Essay, Research Paper All That You Are by Steven Duke Poem No. 41993 Everything that you are, Makes me wonder how it’s true, That I?ve found everything I have,
Minimum Wage Essay Research Paper Minimum WageMinimum
Minimum Wage Essay, Research Paper Minimum Wage Minimum wage is the least amount of pay that a person receives for the job that he/she performs. The minimum wage in Massachusetts is $5.50. A job that pay s minimum wage offers little or no opportunity for improvement. Majority of the people who work for minimum wage are students, people with little education, or immigrants.