Utopia-Sir Thomas More Essay, Research Paper
Thomas More’s use of dialogue in “Utopia” is not only practical but masterly layed out
as well. The text itself is divided into two parts. The first , called “Book One”, describes the
English society of the fifteenth century with such perfection that it shows many complex sides
of the interpretted structure with such clarity and form that the reader is given the freedom for
interpretation as well. This flexibility clearly illustrates More’s request for discussion and
point of view from this reader. In one concise, artistic paragraph, More clearly illustrates his
proposition of the problems people possess within a capitalist society and the fault of the
structure itself; clearly showing More’s point of view for “Book One”. If More attempted to get
anything across to the people of England it was this:
Take a barren year of failed harvests, when many thousands of men have been carried off by hunger. If at the end of the famine the barns of the rich were searched. I dare say positively enough grain would be found in them to have saved the lives of all those who died from starvation and disease, if it had been divided equally among them. Nobody really need have suffered from a bad harvest at all. So easily might men get the necessities of life if that cursed money, which is supposed to provide access to them, were not in fact the chief barrier to our getting what we need to live. Even the rich, I’m sure, understand this. They must know that it’s better to have enough of what we really need than an abundance of superfluities, much better to escape from our many present troubles than to be burdened with great masses of wealth. And in fact I have no doubt that every man’s perception of where his true interest lies, along with with the authority of Christ our Saviour….. would long ago have brought the whole world to adopt Utopian laws, if it were not for one single monster, the prime plague and begetter of all others—I mean pride. (More, pg.83)
For one to fully realize the significance of this virtueous paragraph they first must remember
the time period it was written; more so now that we are in the twentieth century dominated by
capitalism.
Before More accounts for his rhetorical, socialist society of “Book Two” in detail, he
strengthens his idea of communism by pre-establishing the problems of England in “Book
One”. This measurement makes one see the strengths and weaknesses between the two; as
well as, their similarities. It is difficult to title Utopia as a socialist, communist society, in as
much, it is just as valid to argue that Utopia is as opressive as the England described in
“Book One”. If Utopia is a truely socialist state, then one can see that opression is
unescapable in either society. Either way, it just shows the absurdity to claim either of these
as an utopian commonwealth. However, it is clear that More’s attempt was to make Utopia an
egalitarian society for the better of the people as whole. His description of the institutions
Utopia is so prescise and well formatted that it is difficult to see any flaws other than the ones
that were out of his control. More, just as anyone, was a slave of the society he lived in. No
matter how hard More tried to escape it, his morals and values were still derived from the
society he lived in. This is why one must look at Utopia as a society designed only to better
the people of the capitalist England. It is absurd to look at Utopia as a perfect state, in as
much, the knowledge which was true to More would interfear with many areas within the
society of Utopia; More’s faith, his ignorance of the evolving future, and the societies outside
of Utopia described in “Book Two” would make the society of Utopia a paradox. The strength of
it all, is that More amazingly knew his socialist state was not perfect; even for the society of
England:
…though he is a man of unquestioned learning, and highly experienced in the ways of the world, I cannot agree with everything he said. Yet I confess there are many things in the Commonwealth of Utopia that I wish our own country would imitate—-though I don’t really expect it will (More, pg. 85)
In correlation to both societies described in “Utopia”, with both opressing the people
within it, controlling their knowledge and way of life, it is clear that utopia is impossible to
reach as long as human kind is confined to any institution. The difference between the two
societies is seen when one looks at where this opression stems from. England’s capitalist
society is structured in such a way that it allows the people within it to opress or be opressed
by each other. In Utopia the oppression is derived not from the people but from the structure
itself. Therefore, a capitalist societies’ structure allows more freedom for the people than the
egalitarian society; thus, ironically, it is argueable to state that capitalism is more socialist
than socialism. The problem of a capitalist society stems not from its’ structure but from the
people within it. In contrast, the people of the socialist society are all equal; yet, what makes
this possible is the structures’ control over the people. Both societies have strengths and
weaknesses. Untill humankind can be resocialized losing the terms power, greed , and pride
from our vocabulary, will there be terms like opression and freedom in it as well. The only
possibillity for this, is if humankind is confined within a similar society as described by More
called Utopia; then evolve into a society with the same structural freedoms like capitalism.
Therfore, for the capitalist England of the fifteenth century, More’s society in “Book Two” was
not his ideal utopian state; but a path leading towards it.
As you can see, More’s liturary dialogue called “Utopia”, as stressed through out this
essay, is not an attempt to illustrate an utopian society, and would be a parodox if done so. I
think one get’s this false interpretation through the title of the text and the name of his socialist
imaginary state with perfect political, social, conditions or constitution.”(pg.395) It also states
that “Utopia” is derived from the Greek words “no place”. If More had this definition in mind it
would clarify the a majority of the ambiguities within the context of the text, also illustrating
even more of the opression More faced in England; as well as, his fear of it. More’s “Utopia
was done in such a way to enlighten the people of England about their opressing capitalist
society. Instead of leaving the reader with a sense of hopelessness, he gives an alternative
society; not to make the reader interpret it as an ideal society to want over England’s, but
make one realize the possibility of change. It is aimed to make one contemplate on the
weaknesses and strengths of their own society and how to go about changing it to better the
common wealth of their people as a whole
Другие работы по теме:
Thomas Kennerly Wolfe Essay Research Paper Wolfe
Thomas Kennerly Wolfe Essay, Research Paper Wolfe, Tom b. March 2, 1930, Richmond, Va., U.S. in full THOMAS KENNERLY WOLFE, JR. American novelist, journalist, and social commentator who is a leading critic of contemporary life and a proponent of New Journalism (the application of fiction-writing techniques to journalism).
Poetry Essay Research Paper Don t Give
Poetry Essay, Research Paper Don t Give In Dylan Thomas s poem “Do Not Go Gentle Into That Good Night”, is an urgent plea from Thomas to his dying father, and all men not to give in
Conservation Essay Research Paper Child DevelopmentFour year
Conservation Essay, Research Paper Child Development Four year old Nicolas, six year old Thomas, and eight year old Jamie were the subjects for all the following experiments. First, the experiment will be stated and performed, the reaction will follow second, and then a conclusion. All children were uninformed of what and why this was taking place.
Fern Hill Essay Research Paper Fern HillEveryone
Fern Hill Essay, Research Paper Fern Hill Everyone wants to be a child forever. If that were possible, there would be no worry of growing old or dying. In his poem, Fern Hill , Dylan Thomas portrays the desire for infinite youth through the use of symbolism and imagery.
Smoke Signals Essay Research Paper The relationship
Smoke Signals Essay, Research Paper The relationship between Victor and Thomas in the movie Smoke Signals is what gives the stories that Sherman Alexie weave they’re meaning. Their relationship grows from acquaintances, to veritable enemies, to close friends. This shifting in association gives the movie a very heartwarming effect.
The Terrible Trins Essay Research Paper What
The Terrible Trins Essay, Research Paper What the book is about: The book is about a mother mouse named Dolly and three baby mice named Thomas, Richard and Henry. Together they try to defeat the cats in the farmhouse where they live. The mice are taught by their mother on what not to get into like mouse traps and poison.
Death At Canterbury Essay Research Paper Death
Death At Canterbury Essay, Research Paper Death at Canterbury Cathedral If only the Canterbury Cathedral could talk, there would be so many things to here about. It has been through two fires, the murder of Thomas Becket, a war, and numerous unknown incidences. Becket, involved deeply with Canterbury, died because of his beliefs in his church.
War Of 1812 Essay Research Paper Our
War Of 1812 Essay, Research Paper Our government has gone through many changes. Our founding fathers had different ideas of how or government should be. Alexander Hamilton wanted a strong centralized government while Thomas Jefferson wanted a Democratic form of government. Today the government is a blend of both ideas.
Society Of Utopia Essay Research Paper Sir
Society Of Utopia Essay, Research Paper Sir Thomas More’s Utopia has been labeled as “the first original story by a known Englishman.” This Englishman, Sir Thomas More, was a noted statesman, author, and Archbishop of Canterbury who boldly opposed the divorce and remarriage of the overbearing King Henry VIII and because of this was unjustly beheaded.
Mann Thomas Essay Research Paper Thomas MannThomas
Mann, Thomas Essay, Research Paper Thomas Mann Thomas Mann wurde am 6. Juni 1875, in L beck, Deutschland geboren. Sein Vater war ein wohlhabender Korn-H ndler. Seine Mutter, ein Musikerin, wurde in Brasilien geboren. Er war ein von f nf Kindern. Er und sein lterer Bruder, Heinrich, schrieben, als sie jung waren.
God Essay Research Paper I think this
God Essay, Research Paper I think this is all valid because Saint Thomas Aquinas is saying that God has to exist sometime in life to make the Earth and nature and so forth. If their were to be a infinity then there would be no first or last causes to have happened. There would be no first or last causes to have happened.
The Eye Of The Dragon Essay Research
Paper Character Sketch In The Eyes of the Dragon, the author Stephen King shows that Thomas is more than just a character to us. Thomas shows his traits as being naivete, jealously, and low self-esteem in
Thomas 2
Thomas & Hobbes Essay, Research Paper Thomas Hobbes, a mathematician, and John Locke, a philosopher both had great ideas on human society. Hobbes had a more pessamistic outlook on on human nature. Locke saw men living in a state of nature which was basically reasonable an cooperative. In my opinion hobbes ideas on human nature as being competitive prove more true.
Untitled Essay Research Paper A Biographical Report
Untitled Essay, Research Paper A Biographical Report on Thomas Fitzsimons Thomas Fitzsimons, or Fitzsimmons as his last name was sometimes spelled, was born during 1741 and died on August 26, 1811. Originally from Ireland,
Metaphysis Essay Research Paper Hello I
Metaphysis Essay, Research Paper : Hello: : I need help, I have somes question would help me. 1. do the criticisms that hume makes of Design Arguments all apply to Thomas’ Teleological Argument?
Sir Thomas More Essay Research Paper Thomas
Sir Thomas More Essay, Research Paper Thomas More In life, belief can be a very powerful thing, powerful enough to affect major choices. Believing is having faith in an idea, person, thing or religion. In Robert Bolt’s A Man for All Seasons, Sir Thomas More made many important choices the were affected by a belief in the religious theory that the Pope is the “Vicar of God” (the descendant of St.
The Life Of Sir Thomas More Essay
, Research Paper The Life of Sir Thomas More Thomas More was born on February 7, 1478. His life is chronicled in historic writing. He was well schooled and very self-disciplined. His accomplishments throughout his life were, and still are, amazing. More was liked and respected by many.
Special Relativity Essay Research Paper ESPECIALLY 2
Special Relativity Essay, Research Paper ESPECIALLY … … of Hardy’s Poems as Seen through the characters” is a study concerning Hardy’s capability of presenting irony of situation in his poetry. The analysis deals …
Thomas Paine Essay Research Paper Thomas PaineThe
Thomas Paine Essay, Research Paper Thomas Paine The complex and remarkable life of Thomas Paine has greatly influenced his many writings. His style of writing also has caused him to become very popular and has helped him influence many people. Thomas Paine’s common sense and hard life had a strong influence in his writing of “Common Sense.” In his writing of the “Common Sense he demanded for a revolution.
Plato Essay Research Paper There are many
Plato Essay, Research Paper There are many ways in which the philosophy of Plato and Aristotle have reached that of that of Saint Thomas Aquinas, due to the fact that Aristotle thought the world that we live in today is the ultimate reality. While Plato thought the world that we see every day is real but is not the ultimate reality.
Edison Essay Research Paper EdisonA Biography byMatthew
Edison Essay, Research Paper Edison A Biography by Matthew Josephson Matthew Josephson does an excellent job of covering the life and works of Thomas Alva Edison. The author of the book covered every aspect of Thomas Edison?s life from the time his grandparent?s lived in the original Thirteen colonies to the point where he was born in Milan, Ohio and later up to the point where he died in 1931.
Thomas Edison Essay Research Paper Thomas Alva
Thomas Edison Essay, Research Paper Thomas Alva Edison Thomas Alva Edison was one of the greatest inventors. He was a smart man. Thomas invented many things such as the light bulb and
Oung Thomas Edison Essay Research Paper Young
Oung Thomas Edison Essay, Research Paper Young Thomas Edison I read the book Young Thomas Edison , by Sterling North. The book tells about Edison’s Young life and how he greatly succeeded through out the years. It tells about his
Thomas Riley Marshall Essay Research Paper Thomas
Thomas Riley Marshall Essay, Research Paper Thomas Riley Marshall was born in North Ranchester, Indiana on March 14, 1854. He graduated from Wabash College in 1873 where he studied law. Afterwards he was admitted to the Indiana bar in 1875, practicing his profession in Columbia City. His father was a physician.
Conscience Essay Research Paper Conscience
Conscience Essay, Research Paper Conscience Webster’s Seventh New Collegiate Dictionary defines conscience as “the sense or consciousness of the moral goodness or blameworthiness of one’s own
Essay On Mary Thomas Story The Movie
) Essay, Research Paper Essay on Mary Thomas Story Mary and Isaiah Thomas face many problems in their community and they resist the bad influence because they have inner strength.
Thomas Harris Essay Research Paper Thomas Harris
Thomas Harris Essay, Research Paper Thomas Harris is a man with many tallents, an a keen intrest in writing. He earned a major in English, he has written for many newspapers and is most known for his second book which became a major motion picture earning 5 Academy Awards for Best Picture , Best Actress, Best Actor, Best Director and Best Adapted Screen Play, Silence of the Lambs.
Sir Thomas More Essay Research Paper Man
Sir Thomas More Essay, Research Paper Man For All Seasons Essay In the play, A Man For All Seasons, Sir Thomas More is faced with a number of difficult choices, namely whether to support the King’s decision to divorce Catherine of Aragon and marry Anne Boleyn and the consequences of that decision. More makes his decision to oppose the marriage early on, but even though it is something he does not waver from, he still has trouble with it, especially when he see the pain it causes to his wife and family.
T E Lawrence Essay Research Paper Colonel
T E Lawrence Essay, Research Paper Colonel T. E. Lawrence, known as Lawrence of Arabia, was a guerrilla leader in the Arab Revolt of 1916-18, which expelled the Turks from western Arabia and
Spoon River Essay Research Paper Spoon River
Spoon River Essay, Research Paper Spoon River Thomas Rhodes talks about how the people in Spoon River could have prevented their hard times. He compared people in Spoon River to navigators and sailors because they found with all their boasted wisdom how hard at the last it is to keep the soul from splitting into cellular atoms.
THE CANTERBURY TALES Essay Research Paper The
THE CANTERBURY TALES Essay, Research Paper The Canterbury Tales Chaucer uses satire in the Canterbury Tales to expose his attitude towards the Catholic Church of the Middle Ages. The first way in which he does this is by satirizing a common nun of the Middle Ages. Chaucer, in The Canterbury Tales, tells of a nun who is supposed to be married to the church.
Thomas Edison Essay Research Paper BibliographyThomas A
Thomas Edison Essay, Research Paper Bibliography Thomas A. Edison and his Kinetographic Motion Pictures. Rutgers University Press. 1995. This book gave me a lot of the information I needed on the basic history of Thomas Edison?s work in the motion picture industry. There were also pictures
Thomas Edison Essay Research Paper Thomas EdisonOn
Thomas Edison Essay, Research Paper Thomas Edison On February 11, 1847, Thomas Edison was born in Milan Ohio. As a child, Edison always wondered why things happen and how things work. He was an extremely curious child and regarding his great curiosity, his teachers became irritated with him. Because of this, he began home schooling.
Thomas Edison Essay Research Paper Thomas A
Thomas Edison Essay, Research Paper Thomas A. Edison: Fact or Fraud? Thomas Edison was born February 11, 1847 in Ohio. He moved to Michigan at age 7 and went to school there. One teacher thought he was very dumb because he asked too many questions and never understood anything. He did home school and tried other public schools but never did too well.