, Research Paper
Follow Up: let’s turn to the real world. The Summit of the Americas is taking place in Quebec City. World leaders and protestors and gathering around one key factor of development – trade. Preliminary talks are underway to develop a “Free Trade Area of the Americas” from Argentina to Canada. Many people have strong opinions about trade. Some of these opinions are better informed than others. If you were hired as an advisor to either the protest groups or the government’s what useful information could you provide them about the risks and benefits of such a deal?
This issue of free trade throughout 34 countries of Americas (except Cuba) has been a matter that has been gaining more and more popularity lately. The talks of escalated electricity in the air have been augmenting as we have been approaching this long awaited conference in Quebec City. In December 1994, at the first Summit of the Americas, the 34 democratically elected Heads of State of the Western Hemisphere agreed to create a Free Trade Area of the Americas by 2005. However the U.S. are known to be pushing for an earlier completion deadline of 2003. The FTAA is suppose to eliminate trade and investment barriers on virtually all goods and services traded by member countries, reducing prices for consumers and creating new markets for producers throughout the hemisphere. [Office of NAFTA & Inter-American Affairs]. As there s three years left to seek to meet the anticipated deadline to strike an agreement, this meeting that has started this weekend might prove crucial as the draft that serves as the basis for the agreement to be complete by 2005, is shaping up persistently. Besides governments of each country, there are nine negotiating groups (NG) within the FTAA process and each NG has responsible for negotiating a portion of the overall FTAA accord. These nine negotiation groups have been meeting regularly in Miami, which is the site of these negotiations, in order to negotiate the diminution of trade barriers in their subject area. These nine NGs are:
+ Negotiating Group on Market Access (NGMA) Chair – Chile, Vice Chair – Barbados
+ Negotiating Group on Agriculture (NGAG) Chair – Brazil, Vice Chair – Ecuador
+ Negotiating Group on Investment (NGIN) Chair Trinidad & Tobago, Vice Chair – Colombia
+ Negotiating Group on Services (NGSE) Chair – U.S., Vice Chair – Peru
+ Negotiating Group on Government Procurement (NGGP) Chair – Canada, Vice Chair – Chile
+ Negotiating Group on Dispute Settlement (NGDS) Chair – Costa Rica, Vice Chair – Peru
+ Negotiating Group on Intellectual Property Rights (NGIP) Chair – Mexico, Vice Chair – Paragua
+ Negotiating Group on Subsidies, Antidumping & Countervailing Duties (NGADCV) Chair – Venezuela, Vice Chair – Uruguay
+ Negotiating Group on Competition Policy (NGCP) Chair Colombia, Vice Chair Canada
The protestations in the capital of La Bella Province are undoubtedly expected to get hostile and for what has been reported so far, the violence is increasing and the number of protestants is augmenting significantly. It makes you wonder why the need for such a serious demonstration that might prove to be one of the most imposing and most violent protestations we have seen in our country in a while. This has been the talk amongst many of us and the awareness of this campaign is at the highest. Nonetheless, in Qu bec City at the present moment, there s a more than ironic situation. The spot where the negotiations are holding place has been shielded, and the fence has been laid around, almost four kilometers away from the meeting place so that the demonstrators are extensively distanced. What is the point of demonstrating when the leaders can not be accessed by any means and they do not see the protestations anywhere but on television, even though the masses have gathered to have their say only a few kilometers away. What is it the point of protesting? All demonstrations might as well be happening in a different city since the people who will make the decisions can absolutely not feel a hostile vibe as the security is at the maximum around them. Negotiated behind closed doors, with no citizen input but plenty of suggestions from business interests, the FTAA is yet another example of the kind of free-market fundamentalism that has created a global race to the bottom that erodes environmental protection, workers’ livelihoods, and human rights. If you think NAFTA has been a disaster for working families and the environment in the US, Canada, and Mexico, this will be far worse. [Free Trade Area of the Americas]. This comes to prove that the most influential figures will agree on a pact regardless of masses who have gathered all over the place to protest the immoral and unfair side of this deal. Abundant negative effects that will affect us if this deal is to go through are alarming and the massive outcome of demonstrators is not surprising, but the current situation in Quebec is discreditable: “Thousands of police officers are coming to back up what is being called Quebec’s ‘wall of shame,’ and many Canadians are asking whether such separation is necessary, or is anti-democratic overkill” [ 4/10 New York Times ]
As outline previously these are the evident advantages that the folks in favor of global free trade will accentuate:
+ Better access to international markets for Canadian companies
+ Increased competition
+ Cheaper goods and services
+ Better mobility for workers
+ More efficient markets
+ More competitive industries
+ Less government regulation
+ Smaller bureaucracy
+ Lower taxes
Prime minister of Canada, Jean Chr tien stated that globalization is “neither heaven nor hell” but a reality to be tapped. He claimed that “We must together come up with new instruments which will give all the members of our large family a fair and equal opportunity to benefit”. Apparently many nations of Latin America and the Caribbean are now almost uniformly devoted to free trade and regionalism as a strong method of development. As Yedida weighted the situation perfectly, FTAA certainly is a risky deal more for some than other but the facts is that Poor countries have less money to begin with and are dependant upon the money from wealthier countries coming in. For poorer countries, the FTAA would mean more money coming in. For richer countries, the FTAA would mean more goods coming in, and less money staying. Before these agreements are made, countries need to weigh their priorities carefully. [Yedida]
The opposition claim global free trade will lead to these facts amongst others:
+ Lower wages and fewer employee benefits
+ Higher unemployment
+ Lower health and safety standards
+ Lower environmental protection standards
+ Weaker, less effective government
+ Fewer social programs such as health care and education
+ Less protection for developing industries and countries
Besides these previously stated effects, Possible effects of the FTAA agreement on services include:
+ Removal of national licensing standards for medical, legal and other key professionals, allowing doctors licensed in one country to practice in any country, even if their level of training is different;
+ Privatization of public schools and prisons, like in the U.S. which would open the door to greater corporate control, corruption and the cutting of critical corners (such as medical care for inmates or upkeep of safe school facilities) to increase profits; and
+ Privatization of postal services by transferring U.S. Postal Service functions to a few delivery companies like FedEx, which could then send postal rates through the roof.
[ Frequently Asked Questions About the Free Trade Area of the Americas (FTAA) ]
If I were hired as an advisor to the protest groups as I believe this is the most favorable side with most valid points I would draw attention to several points that prove that free trade is most likely destined to fail and to put masses of individuals to misery. This deal would create the world’s largest free market zone, affecting 650 million people and $9 trillion in capital. This business deal is to endanger the lives of millions of people and inequality issue is incredibly enormous, as this plan would disproportionately affect women and people of color. The FTAA threatens to amend living conditions by turning over the control of schools, electricity, water, and food to corporations whose sole interest is further revenue. If this deal is to go through, we are presumably to see a massive move of industries from wealthier parts of America, such as Canada and the U.S., to developing countries. How much more profit is a company to make if instead of paying their employees in Toronto perhaps $12 an hour, they simply transfer their plants to Mexico or ever further south and pay the labor force at least ten times a smaller amount. The unemployment rate is to atomically catapult in our regions, and all potential industries that would be build in our state will rather produce their items in third world countries and with free trade the profits are be maximized. Besides the model upon which the whole free trade concept is based has already proven to be unattainable and thus a growing number of individuals and institutions have been pushing for an alternative solution with an international system of cooperation that fosters social equality, with more cultural diversity, equal human rights and above all community well being. The reluctance for free trade is plentifully increasing after Evidence of the failure of the NAFTA model of economic integration continues to mount. In the aftermath of the Mexican peso crisis, the International Monetary Fund and the U.S. Treasury insisted that Mexico maintain its commitments under NAFTA by continuing to liberalize trade and investment regimes and by maintaining high interest rates in order to shore up the peso. Higher interest rates, decreased purchasing power of consumers, and increased competition with imported goods have had a devastating impact on small and medium-scale producers and retail businesses. Additionally, some two million Mexicans have lost their jobs, and though such macroeconomic indicators as GDP growth have turned positive in the last few years, the standard of living of most Mexicans has shown little or no improvement. The number of Mexicans pushed into the informal sector and working for less than minimum wage, without benefits, or less than full time has increased dramatically, while the purchasing power of the basic minimum wage has dropped by 24% since NAFTA s inception. [Free Trade Area of the Americas]. The unsustainable, export-driven development model is also destroying ecosystems across the Mexican territory. Perhaps the health issue is more of an alarming one as each day, over 44 tons of hazardous waste from the border region are reprehensively discarded. The amount of birth defects has catapulted severely since NAFTA and has alarmed the international community as some unprecedented specimens have been observed in the regions of maquiladoras as Vik affirmed in the pervious post. With all these facts contradicting the possible success of free trade it is obvious that the corporations and wealthy business owners from the participating countries are the principal benefactors and they ll be the ones to gain financially from a scheme that puts their welfare above everyone else s. The numbers of protestants compare to the number of individuals who are eager for this deal to go through, is far superior and the strong resistance to FTAA seems to point out the right direction.
Resources:
- > foreignpolicy-infocus/briefs/vol3/v3n6trad.html
- > mac.doc.gov/ftaa2005/
- > globalexchange/ftaa/faq.html
Другие работы по теме:
Columbus Day Essay Research Paper Columbus EssayIn
Columbus Day Essay, Research Paper Columbus Essay In April, 1492, Spain received reports that the Portuguese succeeded in reaching the Indian Ocean, therefore Spanish monarchs authorized Christopher Columbus to sail to Asia and establish trade and start to convert natives to Christianity. The reasons that the monarchs let Columbus sail were mainly to search for spices and profits, spread Christianity, and to use some of their new technology like the caravel.
Before The Revolution Essay Research Paper BEFORE
Before The Revolution Essay, Research Paper BEFORE THE REVOLUTION Beginning in 1763 with the Proclamation of that year, Americans began to feel that a revolution would be justified if the Crown crossed the line and violated the rights that all men should have. England showed many examples of poor judgment in their management of the colonies that resulted in the citizens of America feeling that these rights were being oppressed and even denied.
Trade In Europe In The 18Th Century
Essay, Research Paper The competition for trading advantages started with overseas expansion at the end of the sixteenth century. It started with the increase in the supply of silver in Europe. That caused for prices to change, which caused inflation. All of this caused furhter economic instabilit. The most visible evidence of the economic expansion in early modern Europe was the overseas trading posts.
State Of Nature Essay Research Paper If
State Of Nature Essay, Research Paper If human beings lived in a state of nature they would be free. Free from any form of government. Free from people telling them how to live and how to do their job. These people would have no boss or parents to deal with. Ideally this would be the kind of environment that people would like to live in.
Money Vs Morality Essay Research Paper Money
Money Vs Morality Essay, Research Paper Money vs. Morality In a time when white males believed in superiority over everything around them, Africans, not even considered people, were kidnapped and sold as slaves. How could this ever happen? Why would Africans ever stand for such a horrific thing? These are all questions asked by many people today when looking back at history.
Salvery Essay Research Paper To facilitate the
Salvery Essay, Research Paper To facilitate the slave trade, the Europeans built forts, castles and slave holding pens all along the coast of West Africa. An estimated 10,000,000 African came to America via the slave trade. A similar number died in wars produced by the slave trade or the long hard trek from African inland to the coast.
The Ftaa Essay Research Paper The FTAA
The Ftaa Essay, Research Paper The FTAA is the Free Trade Area Americas. Its main goal is to extend the North American Free Trade Agreement to the entire Hemisphere. The FTAA brings together all the leaders of North, South and Central America (except for Cuba) to Quebec for several meetings and negotiations.
The Causes And Consequences Essay Research Paper
Mr. Chairman and members of the Senate Finance Committee: Thank you for allowing me to testify on the causes and consequences of the U.S. trade deficit. The economic turmoil in East Asia has thrust America’s trade deficit back into the news. Perhaps no aspect of American trade is talked about more and understood less than the trade deficit.
French Fur Trade Essay Research Paper The
French Fur Trade Essay, Research Paper The French Fur Trade Beginning in the mid sixteenth century, French explorers were able to establish a powerful and lasting presence in what is now the Northern United States and Canada. The explorers placed much emphasis on searching and colonizing the area surrounding the St.
Free Trade Essay Research Paper In an
Free Trade? Essay, Research Paper In an economic age in which speedy transactions of imports and exports are essential, is free trade a necessity for aiding worldwide economic development? At least John F. Kennedy thought so, he being the initiator of removing tariffs and other limitations on U.S. imports.
Slave Trades Essay Research Paper African slave
Slave Trades Essay, Research Paper African slave trade to the America and the European was much worse than slavery in Africa. In this essay ,I will show you the differences. Where were the slave trade took place. Slavery was mostly happing in North America in the carribean and in Europe.The ships full of slaves mostly come to Cuba.
The Slave Trade Essay Research Paper The
The Slave Trade Essay, Research Paper The Slave Trade Slavery is the holding of a human being as property. This practice is thousands of years old. The Egyptians used slaves to build their pyramids two thousand years ago.
Foreign Trade In Chile Essay Research Paper
Chile has developed considerably over the past 50 years. Birth rates have halved and death rates have reduced from 14 per 1000 to 6 out of every thousand people in 1997. Infant Mortality has plummeted form 126 to13 deaths out of every 1000 live births under I year old. Life expectancy for males has increased by 20 years from 52 to 72 years old and for females it has increased by 22 years from 56 to 78 years old.
The Trade Development In Gotland
& Great Zimbabwe Essay, Research Paper There were many differences and similarities between the ways trade has developed in Gotland and in Great Zimbabwe. In this essay I would discuss the most important ones, that can indicate
Another Canada Essay Research Paper When people
Another Canada Essay, Research Paper When people think of Canada and then compare it to the United States of America, they always tend to think it is similar. At least I did until I started this project. I always
VOICE OF DEMOCRACY Essay Research Paper VOICE
VOICE OF DEMOCRACY Essay, Research Paper VOICE OF DEMOCRACY AMERICAS ROLE FOR THE NEXT CENTURY Americas role for the next century will be to stay economically stable. That will be no problem unless
Does America Still Exist Essay Research Paper
Does America Still Exist? Does America still exist? The author Richard Rodriguez believes that this question should be answered with urgency now. America is the country that is supposed to be the free, fun, brave and powerful. This country is so depressing to me because America is none of the following. The United States of America leads all countries in the world in death rate, teenage childbirth, drug and substance abuse, and violence.
Slavery Beginning To End A Brief Summary
Essay, Research Paper Slavery has long been a problem in the U.S. People would say America is the land of the free, always has been, not so. Slavery first began in America with people who were usually immigrants named indentured servants. These “indentured servants” could earn their freedom, however labor was long and difficult.
Advantages Of Technology In The International Market
Essay, Research Paper Technology plays a major role in international trade. Databases, overnight delivery and faxes have opened the world market to not only larger companies but small ones too. To add to this globalization, companies and even competitors are combining and forming alliances to cut cost and increase the profit margin.
Nuclear Weapons Essay Research Paper Nuclear weapons
Nuclear Weapons Essay, Research Paper Nuclear weapons, is one of today’s most talked about issue. The United States alone has enough missiles to destroy Earth a few times over. Americans, then should not waste their money on taxes for building more weapons! There are other issues America must be concerned with.
Fate Vs Freewill Essay Research Paper The
Fate Vs. Freewill Essay, Research Paper The argument has been made by some religious people that every person’s fate is predestined, and everyone is subject to the fate God wills them. Others have argued that everything in life is based on free will where each person decides their own fate. Still others have strayed towards the middle, claiming it is a combination of both.
Cold New World Essay Research Paper Cold
Cold New World Essay, Research Paper Cold New World: Summary Just from reading the introduction I feel that “Cold New World is a perfect title for this novel. The author tells about his shift into a known, but unknown new place. I have been living in America for twenty-one years and I would have to agree with the author when he says that this country was (and is) in a strange, even an unprecedented condition.
Nafta Essay Research Paper NAFTAOn January 1st
Nafta Essay, Research Paper NAFTA On January 1st, 1994, the North American Free Trade Agreement went into effect, creating the world s largest free trade area. Among the main objectives is the liberalization of trade between Canada, Mexico and the United States, to stimulate economic growth and give the NAFTA countries equal access to each other s markets.
Colonial Society And Economy Essay Research Paper
There were numerous effects of the French and Indian War; the Peace of Paris of 1763 ended the French and Indian War, closing all French power in North America. With the Death of King George II, the new English king, King George the III, wanted to put an end to the French and Indian War, pursuing peace and agreement.
America Has Become Too Free Essay Research
Paper America is the free-land, according to everyone who lives in this nation. Also, within the society, the freedom of speech has become eminently freer, which is surveyed through the profusion of music, movies, books, and the other aspects of culture contributed in our society today. But how free is too free? The society we live in which violence is largely contributed in those numerous forms of entertainment could be influencing the uprising in crimes across the U.S.
Why Drugs Should Be Legal Essay Research
Paper America is wasting it?s money and resources. It?s trying restrict something on which restrictions don?t have any effects: drugs. People who don?t use recreational drugs don?t do so because of the health risks; people who do use drugs would whether or not they are legal. The fact that they are illegal makes little difference.
Concerns That Caused The Settlement Of British
North America Essay, Research Paper I believe that throughout the Colonial period, economic concerns had more to do with the settling of British North America than did religious reasons. First, according to my textbook, the British originally sponsored trips over to the New World only after other countries were profiting from their collections of goods and new trade ports.
World Trade Organization Essay Research Paper THE
World Trade Organization Essay, Research Paper THE U.S. ALLIANCE FOR TRADE EXPANSION The U.S. Alliance for Trade Expansion, representing $2 trillion in annual trade and over 150 million American consumers, farmers, and workers, seeks to promote economic growth, job expansion, and higher living standards in the United States by rules-based multilateral trade liberalization through the World Trade Organization (WTO).
Argentina Essay Research Paper ArgentinaBy Chris OjedaArgentina
Argentina Essay, Research Paper Argentina By: Chris Ojeda Argentina is a South American country with a population of thirty one million people. Argentina?s capital is Buenos Aires, which is one of the largest cities in South America. Buenos Aires is situated on the coast of Argentina, which makes Buenos Aires a major trade route in Argentina and in South America.
The Philippines And The World Market Essay
, Research Paper The Philippines and the World Market The Philippines is considered to be one of the most westernized countries in Asia. It has strong ties to the United States and the United
Globalization Essay Research Paper Globalization is the
Globalization Essay, Research Paper Globalization is ?the integration of states through increasing contact, communication and trade to create a holistic, single global system in which the process of change increasingly binds people together in a common fate. ? Some economists recognize globalization as being in the best interest of all states, while others believe that increasingly liberated trade and global economic interaction is detrimental in many ways.