Together, the Constitution and the Bill of Rights aimed to solve the problems that the Americans had encountered under British rule and the Articles of Confederation by forming a new strong central government which was to be run by the people. The British colonization of the states had failed because it did not allow the people certain rights; namely, the right to have sole legislative/taxation power, the right to bear arms, and the right to be free from the quartering of troops. On the other hand, the Articles of Confederation failed because they provided the states with too much democracy. They provided the states with the power to pass almost any measure unchecked, they did not allow for an executive branch, and they gave no power to the central government. The Constitution aimed to restore order to the new states by putting them under one strong national government, while at the same time protecting the rights of all [white males]. It was in this way that the Constitution aimed at “Limiting popular government and protecting private property and minority rights without at the same time denying the sovereign public power of the people. ”
Many of the Constitution?s writers, such as James Madison, saw that with the state governments, factions ran the assemblies, and if these factions could be eliminated, then democracy in the United States could work. Madison talked about this problem and its solution in Federalist 10. He, along with many other notable statesmen noted that the state assemblies were often quick and hasty in their judgements, which lead to many bad decisions. Madison says: “?our governments are too unstable, that the public good is disregarded in the conflicts of rival parties, and that measures are decided?by the superior force of an interested and overbearing majority. ” A notable example of these hasty judgements was debtor relief measures that many of the states passed into law after the war. Many times these measures allowed for the printing of worthless paper money for debtors to pay off their debts. Therefore, part of the solution to the dilemma of forming a new balanced government came by controlling the democracy. The best solution to this problem came from James Madison and the Federalists: they proposed that under the new constitution, the electorate should be expanded. Madison stated, “If a faction consists of less than a majority, relief is supplied by the republican principle, which enables the majority to defeat its sinister views by regular vote. ” Under this theory the government under the new Constitution would work by eliminating the popular majority, which held all the power under the Articles of Confederation. Each representative would represent a variety of people, and would be forced to sift through all of the different views and find the median. Therefore, under the constitution the popular majority would be eliminated because no faction could have sole control of government; therefore, every issue would have the support of multiple groups, and minority rights could still be protected under a democracy.
Even though the problem with popular democracy had been solved, the new Constitution added extra measures to make sure that no laws would be passed hastily. To prevent the hasty votes that occurred under the Articles of Confederation, the Constitution was designed with a built-in system of checks and balances. The most radical check came with the establishment of an executive power in the national government. Before, under the Articles of Confederation, there was no executive power in either the state or central government. Many members of the Aristocracy recognized the problem with this. Men like George Washington saw the need for there to be a power to check the assemblies; he believed “men will not adopt and carry into execution measures the best calculated for their own good, without the intervention of a coercive power. ” These opinions among the delegates at the Constitutional convention lead to the institution of an executive branch in the new government. The president was given the power to veto any law passed by both houses, in order to prevent the situation which occurred under the Articles of confederation. However, to ensure that the President could not become a tyrannical force who would always have the last word, Congress was given the power to override a presidential veto with a two-thirds majority vote. This additional clause was added to prevent the reoccurrence of British tyranny. Under British rule, there was no override; therefore, the governor had the final word, and there was no real democracy. The final check came with the power given to the Supreme Court. Judges were nominated by the President and then approved by the Senate; however, after they are put into office, they are there for life, and have no more political obligations. Therefore, they were free to rule on issues based solely on the law and nothing else. With this power, they were able to overturn a law that had been agreed upon by both the executive and legislative branches. This final check allowed the people a permanent guardian who would always look out for their rights.
While the Constitution managed to protect minority rights and private property, while preserving a government by the people, the first Congress added ten additional amendments to further protect the people?s rights. Many of these rights had been violated while under British rule, and were listed as grievances under the Declaration of Independence. These additional rights include: the right to bear arms, the right to be free from quartering troops, and the right for individual states to legislate themselves as long as they do not violate the national law.
“The powers not delegated to the United States by the Constitution; nor prohibited by it to the states, are reserved to the states respectively, or to the people. ” This may have been the most important amendment included in the Bill of Rights. While still under British rule, the colonists were always fighting for the right to have sole taxation and legislation powers over themselves. They were never given this right though, and towards the end they were not even allowed to tax or legislate themselves. Under the king?s orders, they assemblies of Massachusetts and other colonies were dissolved, and if they remained intact, their governors vetoed every act that they passed into law. Therefore, it was necessary for the first Congress to include a measure that prevented this sort of interference in state government. If the states were free to make their own laws, while still abiding by the national ones, then there was no infringement on their rights as there had been under the British rule. This amendment limited the power of the central government, and gave more power to the state governments, therefore protecting the people?s rights.
Other measures the first Congress added the Bill of Rights included the right to bear arms, and the right to be free from quartering troops. These two amendments helped to further protect the rights of citizens. In the time leading up to the revolution, quartering of troops was used as a punishment for the Massachusetts colonists. This penalty was imposed to save England money and to punish the colonists. Therefore, the first Congress added this amendment to the Constitution to protect the minorities of the Country from this form of punishment. Congress had the same idea when they granted the people the right to bear arms. The second amendment was put into action to keep the government from infringing on the people?s right to protect themselves. Shortly before the revolution, the British armies had tried to take this right from the colonists. They marched, under orders, to a weapons shed in Concord, MA to take away the arms that the colonists had acquired. Because of these actions, they new Americans were guaranteed the right to own a gun for their own protection.
It is clear that both British rule and the Articles of Confederation did not provide an adequate form of government for the colonies. Therefore, the Americans united as one body to form a new government, which not only limited the effects of popular government, but also protected the rights of minorities and landowners. Together, the Constitution and the Bill of Rights solved the problems that the Americans had for over thirty years by providing structure through checks and balances, while protecting the individual rights of men with the Bill of Rights. The Constitution allowed the country?s first politicians a means to solve the great dilemma of: “Limiting popular government and protecting private property and minority rights without at the same time denying the sovereign public power of the people. ”
1. Gordon Wood, The Radicalism of the American Revolution, p189.
2. James Madison, Federalist Number 10.
3. James Madison, Federalist Number 10.
4. George Washington?s letter to John Jay, August 1, 1786.
5. Amendment X to the Constitution. Found in the Back of Morgan p184.
6. Gordon Wood, “The Radicalism of the American Revolution, p189.
Другие работы по теме:
The Star Essay Research Paper In Great
The Star Essay, Research Paper In Great Expectations, by Charles Dickens, light is used symbolically through the example of Estella. Miss Havisham brings Estella up in the darkness, consequently sheltering her from the true
Hukle Berry Finn Essay Research Paper Huckleberry
Hukle Berry Finn Essay, Research Paper Huckleberry FinnAll right, then, I’ll go to hell.” Six simple words; yet they have a very deep and complex meaning. The above quote was taken from Twain’s Huckleberry Finn, and it illustrates how modern man copes with what Twain termed the “inescapable dilemma of Democracy.” In the novel, Huck is faced with the dilemma of whether or not to return Jim, the runaway slave, back to Jim’s owner.
Great Compromises Essay Research Paper Would the
Great Compromises Essay, Research Paper Would the United States of America ever be united if it were not for compromises? I would say the chances are slim. During the early years of the new nation, there was a lot of conflict and turmoil. During the Constitutional Convention of 1786, one of the most essential compromises of the early United States was the Great Compromise.
Abortion Essay Research Paper Many have pondered
Abortion Essay, Research Paper Many have pondered upon the meaning of abortion. The argument being that every child that is born should be wanted and others who believe that every child that is conceived should be born. The choice of a woman whether or not she wants to conceive a child is called abortion. Abortion preserves a woman?s constitutional right, relieves the undesired child of future distress, and establishes a peaceful society.
Hobbit Essay Research Paper The main conflict
Hobbit Essay, Research Paper The main conflict in this novel is ultimately the acquisition of the lost treasure of the dwarves hoarded by Smaug (the great dragon under the mountain).
Epilogue Justinian And The Reconquest Of The
Mediterranean Essay, Research Paper 532 ? Justinian tries to break loose from circle ? enormous um money to East ? beats Vandals and then contends with Ostrogoths and Persian almost simultaneously. Did he know it was
The Constitution Essay Research Paper When the
The Constitution Essay, Research Paper When the framers decided to write a constitution, they were faced with several problems, one of which was how to set up the national government. The framers had to create a government that had strong central power but still maintained civil liberties for the people.
Sonnet 29 Essay Research Paper Rob BenkovicMrs
Sonnet 29 Essay, Research Paper Rob Benkovic Mrs. Stahl Period 8 5/8/00 Explication of “Sonnet 29” The reader can find Shakespeare’s dilemma in the first two stanzas. His problem is quite clear: he is lonely and depressed. As an outcast of society, he feels unlucky and thinks that there is no hope for him. Not even God can help him.
One Place Essay Research Paper IF I
One Place Essay, Research Paper IF I COULD VISIT ONE PLACE IN THE WORLD I WOULD GO TO THE GREAT PYRAMIDS OF EGYPT. THE PYRAMIDS AMAZE ME THE WAY THEY WERE BUILT. THE WAY THE EGYPTIANS DESIGNED AND CONSTRUCTED
Emmas Dilemma Essay Research Paper EmmasDilemma In
Emma?s Dilemma Essay, Research Paper Emma?s Dilemma In my investigation I am going to investigate the number of different arrangements of letters in a word. e.g. Tim Is one arrangementMit Is another First I am going to investigate how many different
The Smuggler Essay Research Paper Mr MrDAgatas
The Smuggler Essay, Research Paper Mr. Mr.D?Agata?s Class September 20, 1999 Victor Cannig?s ?The smuggler? is a fictional story of two well respected men on Small Island. Tasso and The Great Man are very similar expect for there physical appearance and mood.
Attention Keepers In
“The Most Dangerous Game” Essay, Research Paper Attention keepers in “The Most Dangerous Game” In Richard Connell’s “The Most Dangerous Game”, he uses several literary devices to keep the reader interested. During Rainsfords journey to and through the island of General Zaroff he partakes in an adventurous journey filled with mystery, suspense, and dilemma.
Electoral College Essay Research Paper ELECTORAL COLLEGEElectoral
Electoral College Essay, Research Paper ELECTORAL COLLEGE Electoral College, the constitutional system for the ELECTION of the PRESIDENT and VICE PRESIDENT OF THE UNITED STATES. It is the collective name for a group of electors, nominated by political parties within the states and popularly elected, who meet to vote for those two offices.
Untitled Essay Research Paper Words 361
Untitled Essay, Research Paper Words = 361 At the conclusion of Barn Burning Sarty faces a major dilemma: go back to his family or just walk away. The consequences of this decision are great. For such a young boy, choosing to leave his family must be overwhelming and frightening. However, Sarty knows that in order for him to actually live, he must do this.
Unabomber Essay Research Paper In Michael Ventura
Unabomber Essay, Research Paper In Michael Ventura’s essay, “The Ties That Bind”, he explains the dilemma in which David Kaczynski (brother of Ted Kaczynski, the infamous Unabomber) faces. He can either: 1) betray his brother turning him in, 2) do nothing and let society down. Either way he is left feeling extreme guilt.
Hamlet Dilemma Essay Research Paper The Tragedy
Hamlet Dilemma Essay, Research Paper The Tragedy of Hamlet Prince of Denmark is one of William Shakespeare’s most popular works. One of the possible reasons for this play’s popularity is the way
Magna Carta Essay Research Paper Magna CartaThe
Magna Carta Essay, Research Paper Magna Carta The Magna Carta, or the Great Chapter was the first step toward constitutional liberty for English-speaking people everywhere in the world. The Magna Carta was signed in 1215. King John and his nobles had no clue that they were laying the foundations for this new kid of government.
Federalist Paper
#51 Essay, Research Paper Federalist Paper #51 I believe there should be a Constitutional Convention because many of us find the government structure defective. The only answer that can be given is that as all these exterior provisions are found to be inadequate the defect must be supplied, by so contriving the interior structure of the government as that its several constituent parts may, by their mutual relations, be the means of keeping each other in their proper places.”
The Pearl Essay Research Paper The ThemeThe
The Pearl Essay, Research Paper The Theme The Pearl by John Steinbeck is the story of an intrepid man named Kino and the dilemma that he goes through when he finds a pearl. For the
Constitutionalism Essay Research Paper The seventeenth century
Constitutionalism Essay, Research Paper The seventeenth century, which witnessed the development of absolute monarchy, also saw the appearance of the constitutional state. While France solved the question of sovereignty with the absolutist state, England evolved toward the constitutional state.
The BhagavadGita Subdued Essay Research Paper The
The Bhagavad-Gita Subdued Essay, Research Paper The Bhagavad-Gita most likely begins with philosophy instead of ending with it because it gives people the major message of the whole text. If you keep reading and find out the details of how you are supposed to be a good Hindu is up to you. If it were at the end, it would probably not be a holy book, but just a story with a couple morals attached to the ending.
Constitutional Convention Essay Research Paper The Constitutional
Constitutional Convention Essay, Research Paper The Constitutional Convention Our country was based upon the idea that every citizen has certain rights that can not be taken away from him/her; these inalienable rights form the backbone for our democracy. Our constitution, which secures our rights and how we are governed, was not an easy task to write.
St Augustine Essay Research Paper Augustine of
St. Augustine Essay, Research Paper Augustine of Hippo (354-430 AD) took great pains to create and project a powerful image of himself beyond the churches and towns where he wrote and taught in Roman
Great Expectations Essay Research Paper Great Expectations
Great Expectations Essay, Research Paper Great Expectations involves many characters but Joe Gargery is one of the few that has the trait of humbleness he was always giving compliment but never taking them. Maybe his compliments were not noticed but they were given, in a way that only Joe could give them, quietly.
Everglade Dilemma Essay Research Paper Everglade DilemmaThe
Everglade Dilemma Essay, Research Paper Everglade Dilemma The worlds systems of life are of such complexity that even modern man can’t fully understand and predict it. The common word for this is Mother Nature and the question is the mystery of life. Life was created by a specific set of environmental and geologic features present at the same time.
Prisoners Dilemma Essay Research Paper THE PRISONER
Prisoners Dilemma Essay, Research Paper THE PRISONER S DILEMMA (I). In the prisoner s dilemma two people have been arrested, the one inmate is called Smith. In this situation the authorities are not interested in the truth but only want to convict someone. An interrogator lays out the consequences for Smith.
John C. Calhoun
’s Stance On Southern Succession Essay, Research Paper In 1828 John C. Calhoun had begun the protracted Nullification Crisis by asserting the constitutional right of states to “nullify” national laws that were harmful to their interests. Calhoun argued , as others have since, that the states’ rights doctorine protected the legitimate rights of a minority in a democratric system governed by majoruty rule.
A Plan In The Making The Constitution
Essay, Research Paper A Plan in the Making Some people have always wondered whether the making of Constitution of the United States was, in fact, supposed to happen at the Constitutional Convention or if it was even supposed to be drawn up in the way it was. In this essay, I will summarize to different views on what went on at the Constitutional Convention and how the Constitution of the United States come about.
Great Gatsby Essay Essay Research Paper The
Great Gatsby Essay Essay, Research Paper The Great Gatsby Essay In The Great Gatsby, there are three illicit relationships: Gatsby and Daisy, Nick and Jordan, and Tom and Myrtle. In some ways they are similar, and in some ways each is unique. In this essay, I will compare and examine each of the couples, and try to give some insight as to why none of the relationships worked out.