Paper
****Writer’s note: This paper dissects Thomas More’s Utopia and Niccolo Machiavelli’s The Prince in an effort to discover their views on Human nature—This paper can easily be transformed from this topic******
Niccolo Machiavelli vs. Thomas More : Defining Human Nature
It is difficult to determine Niccolo Machiavelli’s and Thomas More’s view on human’s nature. Each took a different approach to the topic. Through Utopia, Thomas More attempted to change man’s thinking by creating an ideological society. Niccolo Machiavelli, through The Prince, attempted to teach man how to deal with human nature. With this in mind, Machiavelli’s concept is much more realistic than More’s; therefore Machiavelli better represents human nature.
Machiavelli’s view of human nature in The Prince, presents, on the surface, a view of governing a state drastically different for his time. Machaivelli believed that the ruling Prince should be the sole authority determining every aspect of the state and put into effect a policy which would serve his best interests. With this, Machiavelli uses the prince as man, and the state as the man’s life. These interests were gaining, maintaining, and expanding his political power. Though in some cases Machiavelli may seem harsh and immoral, one must remember that his views were derived from concern of Italy’s unstable political condition in the 1500s. Machiavelli seems to be teaching the common man how to live his life so that their life is good and prosperous.
Machiavelli generally distrusted citizens, stating that “…since men are a sorry lot and will not keep their promises to you, you likewise need not keep yours to them” (Machiavelli
651). Furthermore, “ a prince never lacks legitimate reasons to break his promises” when, “such an observance of faith would be to his disadvantage; and when the reasons which made him promise are removed” (651).
Machiavelli did not feel that a Prince should mistreat the citizens. This suggestion once again to serve the Prince’s best interests. If a Prince can not be both feared and loved, Machiavelli suggests, it would be better for him to be feared by the citizens within his own dogma. He makes the generalization that men are, “… ungrateful, fickle, simulators and deceivers, avoiders of danger, greedy for gain; and while you work for their good they are yours” (649). He characterizes men as being self-centered and not willing to act in the best interest of the state,” and when it (danger) comes nearer to you they turn away” (649). Machiavelli reinforces the Prince’s need to be feared by stating: “…men are less hesitant about harming someone who makes himself loved than one who makes himself feared…” (649). The bond of love is one which men, the wretched creatures they are, break when it is to their advantage to do so; “… fear is held together by a dread of punishment which will never abandon you”(649). Machiavelli suggests that the key to being a good “prince,” is deception. “It is necessary to know how to disguise this nature well and to be a great hypocrite and a liar: and men are so simple-minded and so controlled by their present necessities that one who deceives will always find another who will allow himself to be deceived” (651). Machiavelli states that men judge more, ”with their eyes than with their hands.” And with this Machiavelli claims that, “everyone sees what you seem to be, few people perceive what you are,” (652) and those who do realize what the Prince is, dare not tell, for the Prince has the power of the masses to protect him.
Machiavelli, in a sense, describes how to live, successfully and prosperously, by dealing
with the human’s nature. He details how one is to manipulate another’s thought, in order to place oneself in a more respectable position. With this, Machiavelli pronounces human nature to be very cold-blooded, deceiving, self-centered, and most of all temperamental.
Thomas More, in Utopia, tried to express that the only way for a better life was through change. More’s key complaints of human nature were greed, power, and pride. More, seemingly, imagined a society, in which these three things no longer existed, believing that they were man’s downfall.
The main thought that he attempted to instill in the minds of the English was this: Take a miserable spell of disastrous harvests, when many of thousand of men have passed on in hunger. If at the end of this famine the barns of the rich were searched, surely enough provisions would be found in them to have saved the lives of those who died from starvation and disease, if it had been rationed equally among them. Thusly, the suffering of a bad harvest was unnecessary. So easily might men get the necessities of life if that cursed money, which is supposed to provide access to them were not in fact the chief barrier to our getting what we need to live. With this, More described greed.
At first glance, Thomas More’s Utopia appears as a socialist, communist society; however, if Utopia is a truly socialist state, then one can see that oppression is inescapable. It is clear that More attempted to create an egalitarian society to better the people as a whole, and not individually. His descriptions of the institutions of Utopia (i.e., A day in Utopia, The household, Utopian Beliefs, and Treatment of the dying) was precise and so well formatted that it is difficult to see any flaws, without peering deeply into his words.
More outlines an utopian day as “…a six-hour working day—three hours in the morning,
then lunch—then a two-hour break—then three more hours in the afternoon, followed by supper” (More 633). Each citizen in the society has an equal amount of responsibility. Each performs the same task, farming, and each has his/her own specialty (i.e., carpentry, blacksmith, etc.) With this he strips away pride. How can one man be proud if there are so many others perform the same task as he? He goes on to say, “after supper they have an hour’s recreation, either in the gardens or the communal dining halls, according to the time of year” (633). More sets the sleeping time, almost as a law, taking into account the society rather than the individual.
More, just as anyone, was a slave to the society in which he lived. His view on the English society, in which he resided, was one of oppression, being ruled by a higher authority. More attempted to create a society in which oppression did not exist; however, oppression did exist with the use of a Styward. A Styward’s only job was “…to see that nobody sits around doing nothing, but that everyone gets on with his job” (632). It is quite contradictory that More intended to erase power when he places the Styward with power. Increasingly contradictory is that More states that women are the “…weaker sex…” (632) and “…are given the lighter jobs” (632). More goes on to state that “…wives are subordinate to their husbands…” (634). Not only does this express More’s own slavery to his society but does this not instill more power in the men?
Thomas More unsuccessfully, and optimistically, describes human nature. He seems to believe that man is a creation of his governing authority; and that if the governing power is to be removed then man would be a less hostile force. He depicts that man by nature is good-willed and conforming. He forgets that man is an animal in the world, competition runs fierce. When it
comes down to it, one man will overtake the other to better himself; and with this there will
always be a governing power. Niccolo Machiavelli, on the other hand, triumphantly describes
human nature. He depicts man in a form, though pessimistic, truer to reality. Machiavelli suggests that man will never change and that one will always attempt to overcome the other. He portrays man as an untrustworthy, ungrateful, greedy, and lying lot. Machiavelli admits the unchangeable faults of man in a way that stuns the reader, unlike More.
Works Cited
Machiavelli, Niccolo. “The Prince.” Current Issues & Enduring Questions. Ed. Sylvan and Hugo
Bedau. Boston: Bedford/St.Martin’s, 1999. 646-52.
More, Thomas. “Utopia.” Current Issues & Enduring Questions. Ed. Sylvan and Hugo Bedau.
Boston: Bedford/St.Martin’s, 1999. 632-44.
Machiavelli, Niccolo. “The Prince.” Current Issues & Enduring Questions. Ed. Sylvan and Hugo
Bedau. Boston: Bedford/St.Martin’s, 1999. 646-52.
More, Thomas. “Utopia.” Current Issues & Enduring Questions. Ed. Sylvan and Hugo Bedau.
Boston: Bedford/St.Martin’s, 1999. 632-44.
Другие работы по теме:
Moor
’s Utopia Essay, Research Paper Long before communism was thought of, Thomas More derived an idea similar to it. This might have contributed to the beginnings of socialism. His idea was called “utopia”. The meaning of the word has changed significantly over the years. Today, it means an ideal perfection, especially in laws and social conditions.
Poetry Essay Research Paper Don t Give
Poetry Essay, Research Paper Don t Give In Dylan Thomas s poem “Do Not Go Gentle Into That Good Night”, is an urgent plea from Thomas to his dying father, and all men not to give in
Utopian Society Essay Research Paper Animal Farm
Utopian Society Essay, Research Paper Animal Farm, like Brave New World, shows the idea of a Utopia . The animals yearned for their perfect farm where they could run themselves and their work would be rewarded rather than be given more work. It was their idea of a flawless society, where everyone was happy and cooperated.
Vision Of Utopia The Scarlet Letter Vs.
. Pleasentville Essay, Research Paper Visions Of Utopia: “The Scarlet Letter” vs. Pleasantville In both “The Scarlet Letter” and “Pleasantville,” there is an image of utopia, a perfect world that has been created and everyone that lives inside of it is happy with their lives and couldn’t wish for anything better.
Fern Hill Essay Research Paper Fern HillEveryone
Fern Hill Essay, Research Paper Fern Hill Everyone wants to be a child forever. If that were possible, there would be no worry of growing old or dying. In his poem, Fern Hill , Dylan Thomas portrays the desire for infinite youth through the use of symbolism and imagery.
Tale Of Two Cities And Utopia Essay
, Research Paper There are many similarities between the book A Tale of Two Cities by Charles Dickens and the writings of Thomas Mores Utopia. In both of the writings they talk about the gap between the rich and the poor in France leading up to the Revolution.
Thomas Vs Moore Essay Research Paper Plato
Thomas Vs. Moore Essay, Research Paper Plato’s Republic and Thomas More’s Utopia have a relationship in that they both share an idea. These books both have the concept of an ideal society, although they do this for distinct reasons and they attain contrasted types of perfection. More describes Utopia as “the most civilized nation in the world”.
Utopian Socialism Essay Research Paper Since the
Utopian Socialism Essay, Research Paper Since the beginning of the idea of money, there have been those who have wealth, and those who want it. Utopian socialism is not a new idea, and it has remained popular since its creation. Many people know what socialism is, but not that many know the principles Utopian Socialism.
Thomas More Essay Research Paper More
Thomas More Essay, Research Paper More’s purpose in writing utopia was quite clearly to open people’s eyes to the social and political evils of the world around them, e.g. inflation, corruption, maltreatment of the poor, wars for little or no purpose, courtly ostentation, the misuse of power by absolute monarchs, etc.
1984 Essay Research Paper The lesson to
1984 Essay, Research Paper The lesson to be learned from George Orwell’s 1984 is that an “ideal” of having a Utopian society will never really work. George Orwell may have written 1984, in order
Death At Canterbury Essay Research Paper Death
Death At Canterbury Essay, Research Paper Death at Canterbury Cathedral If only the Canterbury Cathedral could talk, there would be so many things to here about. It has been through two fires, the murder of Thomas Becket, a war, and numerous unknown incidences. Becket, involved deeply with Canterbury, died because of his beliefs in his church.
War Of 1812 Essay Research Paper Our
War Of 1812 Essay, Research Paper Our government has gone through many changes. Our founding fathers had different ideas of how or government should be. Alexander Hamilton wanted a strong centralized government while Thomas Jefferson wanted a Democratic form of government. Today the government is a blend of both ideas.
Society Of Utopia Essay Research Paper Sir
Society Of Utopia Essay, Research Paper Sir Thomas More’s Utopia has been labeled as “the first original story by a known Englishman.” This Englishman, Sir Thomas More, was a noted statesman, author, and Archbishop of Canterbury who boldly opposed the divorce and remarriage of the overbearing King Henry VIII and because of this was unjustly beheaded.
Utopia Essay Research Paper Webster s Dictionary
Utopia Essay, Research Paper Webster s Dictionary defines utopia as an ideally perfect place, especially in its social, political, and moral aspects. That definition leaves a certain dense mark that shows that in order for a utopian society to work, everyone must be the same in many if not most ways.
Utopia Essay Research Paper Positives and Negatives
Utopia Essay, Research Paper Positives and Negatives of the Utopian Society Sir Thomas More wrote a novel named Utopia about a country that existed only in his mind. More used the story to explore his views and feelings about politics and government. People still believe that the story holds truths that are relevant today even though More wrote Utopia during the Renaissance.
The Eye Of The Dragon Essay Research
Paper Character Sketch In The Eyes of the Dragon, the author Stephen King shows that Thomas is more than just a character to us. Thomas shows his traits as being naivete, jealously, and low self-esteem in
My Golden Age Essay Research Paper Many
My Golden Age Essay, Research Paper Many people have their own Golden Ages. It is like a dream that a person would like to live out. Many of these dreams tend to be similar to a utopia, or a perfect world. Due to the fact that their Golden Age is a perfect world, most of these dreams are a little bit on the unrealistic side.
Utopia By Thomas More 14781535 Essay Research
Paper The term “Utopia” has come to mean an idyllic, visionary Shang-ri-la type of community. However, when More derived the term from the Greek, it literally meant “nowhere.” In essence, both
UtopiaSir Thomas More Essay Research Paper Thomas
Utopia-Sir Thomas More Essay, Research Paper Thomas More’s use of dialogue in “Utopia” is not only practical but masterly layed out as well. The text itself is divided into two parts. The first , called “Book One”, describes the
The Tempest Essay Research Paper Prospero
The Tempest Essay, Research Paper Prospero’s philosopher lacking Shakespeake’s Tempest is a window into his idea of a utopia. The island serves as a place much like that of Plato’s Republic and Moore’s Utopia. But, Prospero, the leader of Shakespeare’s Tempest is not the same philosopher king that both Moore and Plato wished to rule their respective societies.
Metaphysis Essay Research Paper Hello I
Metaphysis Essay, Research Paper : Hello: : I need help, I have somes question would help me. 1. do the criticisms that hume makes of Design Arguments all apply to Thomas’ Teleological Argument?
The Life Of Sir Thomas More Essay
, Research Paper The Life of Sir Thomas More Thomas More was born on February 7, 1478. His life is chronicled in historic writing. He was well schooled and very self-disciplined. His accomplishments throughout his life were, and still are, amazing. More was liked and respected by many.
Utopia Essay Research Paper Why a Utopian
Utopia Essay, Research Paper Why a Utopian World Can Exist The book Utopia, by Thomas More, explains what a perfect world would look like. Utopia is simply a word used to define what can generally be described as the consummate dream of the best level of Human existence. Every person has thought of, at least once in his life, that it would be nice if there were no disease, no crime, no poverty, and/or for some other improvement in the Human condition.
Utopia Essay Research Paper Utopia is supposed
Utopia Essay, Research Paper Utopia is supposed to be a place or state of perfection. But the word can also be used as something that is unattainable. This piece will focus on the latter idea.
Living In Utopia Essay Research Paper Living
Living In Utopia Essay, Research Paper Living in Utopia Private property is abolished in Utopia, and society is communally organized in such a way that there is no shortage and that everyone has work, food, a home and opportunities for cultural expression. Sounds great, eh? Would you like to live there, and if not, why? Your answer should take account of More’s context (why he wrote Utopia?) and should be supported by reference to the text.
Utopia V Dystopia Essay Research Paper Utopia
Utopia V. Dystopia Essay, Research Paper Utopia vs. Dystopia What is utopia? According to The Random House Dictionary, utopia is a place or state of political or social perfection based on the novel Utopia by Thomas More (Random House 976). Most people can not picture this definition because the real world is not as perfect as Thomas More describes in Utopia.
Oung Thomas Edison Essay Research Paper Young
Oung Thomas Edison Essay, Research Paper Young Thomas Edison I read the book Young Thomas Edison , by Sterling North. The book tells about Edison’s Young life and how he greatly succeeded through out the years. It tells about his
Essay On Mary Thomas Story The Movie
) Essay, Research Paper Essay on Mary Thomas Story Mary and Isaiah Thomas face many problems in their community and they resist the bad influence because they have inner strength.
Sir Thomas More Essay Research Paper Man
Sir Thomas More Essay, Research Paper Man For All Seasons Essay In the play, A Man For All Seasons, Sir Thomas More is faced with a number of difficult choices, namely whether to support the King’s decision to divorce Catherine of Aragon and marry Anne Boleyn and the consequences of that decision. More makes his decision to oppose the marriage early on, but even though it is something he does not waver from, he still has trouble with it, especially when he see the pain it causes to his wife and family.
Sir Thomas More Essay Research Paper Sir
Sir Thomas More Essay, Research Paper Sir Thomas More was born in London in 1478, and died on Tower Hill in 1535, along with Bishop John Fisher of Rochester. In 1935 he was canonized, along with Fisher, as a martyr for the Catholic faith. Feast Day, June 22.
Utopia Essay Research Paper Someone said
Utopia Essay, Research Paper Someone said,”Human beings are the animals who create utopia.” If men lived in a world where circumstances were very vitiated, they would need to accept the impossibility of meaning in secular life. In the early Sixteen-century, More’s Utopia was published and struck his generation.
Thomas Edison Essay Research Paper BibliographyThomas A
Thomas Edison Essay, Research Paper Bibliography Thomas A. Edison and his Kinetographic Motion Pictures. Rutgers University Press. 1995. This book gave me a lot of the information I needed on the basic history of Thomas Edison?s work in the motion picture industry. There were also pictures