Utopia Essay, Research Paper
Positives and Negatives of the Utopian Society
Sir Thomas More wrote a novel named Utopia about a country that existed only in his mind. More used the story to explore his views and feelings about politics and government. People still believe that the story holds truths that are relevant today even though More wrote Utopia during the Renaissance. Utopia contains information about More’s vision of a perfect society. The Utopian government was able to overcome or prevent all problems facing the country. The government first segregates the island by digging a canal around it so that the ocean will create and island that has hazardous straights as it’s only means into the island. It then handles the many aspects that a community faces in a manner that, for the most part, creates an enjoyable environment to live in. There are however a few points that I found a flaw in. Personal wealth, religion, and justice are three areas of the Utopian society that have positive and negative sides.
The first area of the Utopian society that I found weakness in is the lack of personal property. Every person who could get up and work did so for six hours a day. People were not allowed to be idle as it was against the law. “Actually their working hours are sufficient to provide not only an abundance, but a superabundance of all the necessities and conveniences of life” (p.35). Since every person contributes to the production of every food or material product in the commonwealth, there is no poverty and no greed. This concept looks great on paper. I feel, however, that this lack of owning anything would cause people to feel like they don’t work for themselves. There would be no reason to toil over soil that was hard to sew if you knew you were not going to starve regardless of what you produced.
The next part of Utopian culture that I disagree with is its religion and the policy it has on holidays. The people are able to worship any god they wish in anyway they wished. . The people of Utopia are able to partake in any religious ceremony they choose. Each citizen worships as he pleases and as long as he does not force his beliefs onto others he is fine (p.70). This freedom gave people a very important right. It helped to end many problems that occurred during the early years of Utopia (p. 72). This policy is a magnificent idea and it surprised me that no one who actually ran a country had thought of this. The only flaw that I found in Utopian religion was that all citizens had to the same temple at the same time for the festival of the first and last days of the month. These days, called Cynemern and Trapermern, were celebrated in a common temple in the city. The name of no specific god was used in the celebration except Mithra. Since every sect of religion used this name for their god. The government designed the services in this fashion so that they would not offend any religion (p.77). The use of no specific name of a god is a good way to avoid offending people, but it also makes the ceremony very impersonal. It seems to me that it would have been more beneficial if each group of religious Utopians was able to worship in the temple on their own day. This way they would be able to call their god anything they wanted and would feel surrounded by people with their same beliefs.
The final area with some aspects is the Utopian justice system. The government does not have many laws; they do not see a need for it. The Utopians see no need in having many laws when there is not enough time to spend to gain the understanding for a larger number. Actually, the Utopians feel that honoring good citizens as a better way to develop morals. Displaying the names of people who have done good for the commonwealth, is thought to be a good way to detour others from acting against the common good. The laws that are made are very few and are made to enforce the desired ethics. If a law is broken, the punishment is normally left to the head of the family, a male, unless the crime is so bad that a public punishment would be better for the people of the city (p.60). There are no standards for the punishment according to the wickedness of the wrongdoing, the senate decides on a case by case basis. In court, people represent themselves. The worst criminals are punished by bondage.
People in bondage do the distasteful work of the community. They do not stay in prisons and their only distinctions from citizens are a few physical and cosmetic differences. Even those punished by bondage are able to redeem themselves with hard work and patience (p. 59-61). Using bondage for severe crimes as opposed to capital punishment is a moral punishment. Bondsmen also provide service to the country whereas if they were put to death, no benefits would be received. However, the freedom they are given allows them the opportunity to endanger the public again. More laws and increased security of bondsmen would create an environment safer for all Utopians.
There are many positive aspects of the Utopian justice system. The most prevalent is the court itself. Many cases are kept out of court due to family punishment. With no lawyers, the judicial process is much quicker than today’s court system in America. The most negative part of the justice system is the lack of laws. A society should regulate their people by rules, not just positive reinforcement. There should also be regulations of punishments for each crime. Without that there is always a place for unfairness. Officials should keep convicted bondsmen under a closer watch and make them more visible. These are the most vicious criminals in the country. The citizens should treat them as such for their own safety.
The society in Utopia has positive and negative elements in religion, personal rights, and justice. With a few minor changes, I feel that the negative could be eliminated. Utopia portrays aspects of a community that is idealistic. However, the balance of good and bad portions creates a realistic, more attainable society.
More, Thomas. Utopia. Translated by H.V. S. Ogden (Arlington Heights, 1949).
Другие работы по теме:
High School Uniforms Essay Research Paper High
High School Uniforms Essay, Research Paper High School Uniforms in our Country School uniforms have been an issue in our nation for quite some time. Many of today?s teens, find that it is very uncomfortable to wear uniforms to school. The biggest question that school uniforms raise, is weather or not wearing uniforms makes the students more disciplined to do their school work.
Epithalamion Essay Research Paper EpithalamionEpithalamion is an
Epithalamion Essay, Research Paper Epithalamion Epithalamion is an interesting mixture of negatives and positives for me. I found parts of it interesting and well written. However, I found other parts that I am less enthusiastic about. Spenser used many different devices in this poem that make it stand out from many other similar poems from the same time period.
Moor
’s Utopia Essay, Research Paper Long before communism was thought of, Thomas More derived an idea similar to it. This might have contributed to the beginnings of socialism. His idea was called “utopia”. The meaning of the word has changed significantly over the years. Today, it means an ideal perfection, especially in laws and social conditions.
Flucations In The Australian Dollar Essay Research
Paper The Australian Dollar is a “Commodity Currency”. A “Commodity Currency” means that its fortunes are heavily dependent on the prices of Gold, Copper, Nickel, Coal and Wool. All of these commodities are Australia?s main exports.
Gattaca The Movie And Discrimination Essay Research
Paper In the movie Gattaca the main character Anton was discriminated against because of his gene makeup. Anton never even had a chance in the society in Gattaca because the potential employees of companies were not tested on their skills or knowledge but on their physical and mental possibilities. The same society also used derogatory terms for people like Anton.
Utopian Society Essay Research Paper Animal Farm
Utopian Society Essay, Research Paper Animal Farm, like Brave New World, shows the idea of a Utopia . The animals yearned for their perfect farm where they could run themselves and their work would be rewarded rather than be given more work. It was their idea of a flawless society, where everyone was happy and cooperated.
Vision Of Utopia The Scarlet Letter Vs.
. Pleasentville Essay, Research Paper Visions Of Utopia: “The Scarlet Letter” vs. Pleasantville In both “The Scarlet Letter” and “Pleasantville,” there is an image of utopia, a perfect world that has been created and everyone that lives inside of it is happy with their lives and couldn’t wish for anything better.
Tale Of Two Cities And Utopia Essay
, Research Paper There are many similarities between the book A Tale of Two Cities by Charles Dickens and the writings of Thomas Mores Utopia. In both of the writings they talk about the gap between the rich and the poor in France leading up to the Revolution.
Thomas Vs Moore Essay Research Paper Plato
Thomas Vs. Moore Essay, Research Paper Plato’s Republic and Thomas More’s Utopia have a relationship in that they both share an idea. These books both have the concept of an ideal society, although they do this for distinct reasons and they attain contrasted types of perfection. More describes Utopia as “the most civilized nation in the world”.
Telecommuting Psychology Essay Research Paper TELECOMMUTINGPsychology Telecommuting
Telecommuting: Psychology Essay, Research Paper TELECOMMUTING Psychology Telecommuting has positives and negatives psychologically. Some positives include staying home with children; more free time, and making your own schedule, etc. Some say that looks very inviting. Many people, employees and managers, don’t look at the negatives (no set times, difficulty communicating, being looked upon as a slacker, no face to face contact and so on) before they volunteer for their chance at freedom.
Thomas More Essay Research Paper More
Thomas More Essay, Research Paper More’s purpose in writing utopia was quite clearly to open people’s eyes to the social and political evils of the world around them, e.g. inflation, corruption, maltreatment of the poor, wars for little or no purpose, courtly ostentation, the misuse of power by absolute monarchs, etc.
1984 Essay Research Paper The classic novel
1984 Essay, Research Paper The classic novel 1984 by George Orwell, the modern classic of “Negative Utopia”, is the novel that we are just starting. There are many things from this book that are used everyday in comic strips, comparisons in news articles, and even the television show “Big Brother” is taken from 1984.
1984 Essay Research Paper The lesson to
1984 Essay, Research Paper The lesson to be learned from George Orwell’s 1984 is that an “ideal” of having a Utopian society will never really work. George Orwell may have written 1984, in order
Illegal Immigration In The US Essay Research
Paper Illegal immigration in the U.S. is a major concern to the government to the government and it s citizens. This was not a major concern until lately in the past twenty years. There has been an alarming increase of illegal immigrants in the U.S. A debate has arisen over the amount of action that has been exerted on the behalf of the national government to control the amount of illegal immigrants in the country.
Society Of Utopia Essay Research Paper Sir
Society Of Utopia Essay, Research Paper Sir Thomas More’s Utopia has been labeled as “the first original story by a known Englishman.” This Englishman, Sir Thomas More, was a noted statesman, author, and Archbishop of Canterbury who boldly opposed the divorce and remarriage of the overbearing King Henry VIII and because of this was unjustly beheaded.
Narrative Shift Hemingway Essay Research Paper Narrative
Narrative Shift -Hemingway Essay, Research Paper Narrative Shift Hemingway s characters often turn to primitive rituals for comfort. (Donaldson, Vol. 13 in Literary Criticism) It is at this primitive point in each character when Hemingway employs a narrative shift or shifting the narrator s description through another characters point of view.
Utopia Essay Research Paper Webster s Dictionary
Utopia Essay, Research Paper Webster s Dictionary defines utopia as an ideally perfect place, especially in its social, political, and moral aspects. That definition leaves a certain dense mark that shows that in order for a utopian society to work, everyone must be the same in many if not most ways.
Information Superhighway Essay Research Paper If the
Information Superhighway Essay, Research Paper If the goal of the Information Superhighway is to unite people, why is it that so far it has only acted as a disunifying agent, creating debate wherever its name arises. The reason is, people are scared of it, and for good reasons as well as fictional. One of these “good” reasons would be personal privacy, a gap in the system sometimes not even denied by those that should be denying it.
Untitled Essay Research Paper Words 937
Untitled Essay, Research Paper Words = 937 Huxley s so called Utopia drastically suppresses the individual in society. The people in this Utopia are completely lacking in crucial emotions which the imperfect individual possesses. They have no feelings of love, care and sympathy because blind happiness is a necessity for stability.
Adoption Essay Research Paper Biracial adoptions have
Adoption Essay, Research Paper Biracial adoptions have been the topic of debate for many years but not only for it s effects on the children and their parents but also for it s effect on society and the effect it has on the child s ability to function in society. With this in mind the Federal Government has decided to step in.
Greek And Roman Arches And Architecture Essay
, Research Paper Architectural designs changed greatly since the ancient times. Most famous architectures and sculptures today originated from the Greek and Roman civilizations. Moreover,
My Golden Age Essay Research Paper Many
My Golden Age Essay, Research Paper Many people have their own Golden Ages. It is like a dream that a person would like to live out. Many of these dreams tend to be similar to a utopia, or a perfect world. Due to the fact that their Golden Age is a perfect world, most of these dreams are a little bit on the unrealistic side.
Utopia By Thomas More 14781535 Essay Research
Paper The term “Utopia” has come to mean an idyllic, visionary Shang-ri-la type of community. However, when More derived the term from the Greek, it literally meant “nowhere.” In essence, both
UtopiaSir Thomas More Essay Research Paper Thomas
Utopia-Sir Thomas More Essay, Research Paper Thomas More’s use of dialogue in “Utopia” is not only practical but masterly layed out as well. The text itself is divided into two parts. The first , called “Book One”, describes the
The Tempest Essay Research Paper Prospero
The Tempest Essay, Research Paper Prospero’s philosopher lacking Shakespeake’s Tempest is a window into his idea of a utopia. The island serves as a place much like that of Plato’s Republic and Moore’s Utopia. But, Prospero, the leader of Shakespeare’s Tempest is not the same philosopher king that both Moore and Plato wished to rule their respective societies.
Utopia Essay Research Paper Why a Utopian
Utopia Essay, Research Paper Why a Utopian World Can Exist The book Utopia, by Thomas More, explains what a perfect world would look like. Utopia is simply a word used to define what can generally be described as the consummate dream of the best level of Human existence. Every person has thought of, at least once in his life, that it would be nice if there were no disease, no crime, no poverty, and/or for some other improvement in the Human condition.
Gender Role Reversal Essay Research Paper Throughout
Gender Role Reversal Essay, Research Paper Throughout one’s life each of us face new obstacles due to the progression of the life cycle. Many of these so-called obstacles we encounter are from the many role demands that each one of us has to fulfill. As we get older our lives take on new roles, such as being a: wife, parent, school teacher, etc.
Utopia Essay Research Paper Utopia is supposed
Utopia Essay, Research Paper Utopia is supposed to be a place or state of perfection. But the word can also be used as something that is unattainable. This piece will focus on the latter idea.
Living In Utopia Essay Research Paper Living
Living In Utopia Essay, Research Paper Living in Utopia Private property is abolished in Utopia, and society is communally organized in such a way that there is no shortage and that everyone has work, food, a home and opportunities for cultural expression. Sounds great, eh? Would you like to live there, and if not, why? Your answer should take account of More’s context (why he wrote Utopia?) and should be supported by reference to the text.
Utopia V Dystopia Essay Research Paper Utopia
Utopia V. Dystopia Essay, Research Paper Utopia vs. Dystopia What is utopia? According to The Random House Dictionary, utopia is a place or state of political or social perfection based on the novel Utopia by Thomas More (Random House 976). Most people can not picture this definition because the real world is not as perfect as Thomas More describes in Utopia.
Utopia Essay Research Paper Someone said
Utopia Essay, Research Paper Someone said,”Human beings are the animals who create utopia.” If men lived in a world where circumstances were very vitiated, they would need to accept the impossibility of meaning in secular life. In the early Sixteen-century, More’s Utopia was published and struck his generation.
Total Quality Management Essay Research Paper I
Total Quality Management Essay, Research Paper I feel it’s important to learn about the subject of total quality management (TQM) when dealing with operations management. Total Quality Management and continuous improvement put tremendous emphasize on the importance of empowering employees within an organization.