Biotechnology In Food Essay, Research Paper
REG MITCHELL’s defence of “Frankenfoods” — genetically engineered (GE)farm products — in his Oct. 9 article “So-called Frankenfoods have no more pathogens than are found in nature” is a repetition of the mantra we hear daily from the global corporations that dominate agricultural biotechnology.
His principal point seems to be that since life abounds with risks of various kinds (cancer-inducing elements in the environment, the risk of being hit by a truck) we shouldn’t be concerned about the possibility of adding another one to the list.
He suggests biotechnology is an unstoppable reality, with half of U.S. soybeans planted this year to GE seeds, as well as half of Canada’s canola crop. He could have added the vast acreages of genetically modified (GM) cotton, corn and potatoes growing in North America this year. Such crops are expected to triple in use worldwide in the next few years, he writes.
The projections quoted by Prof. Mitchell may not materialize. The European Union will not accept GM products, and this is causing horrendous marketing problems for North American farmers.
It is becoming obvious we cannot force Europeans to take such products, even though Canada and the U.S. are using the World Trade Organization (WTO) in an effort to do so. Most large European and British supermarket chains have removed GE products from their shelves, and the largest European food processors (Nestle and Unilever) will no longer use GM products.
All this is being reflected in the market — non-GM foods are now selling at a higher price than genetically altered crops. And there is a scramble by farmers to find non-GM seed for planting next year — there may not be enough to meet the rising demand.
Mitchell tells us GM crops will reduce the use of herbicides and insecticides. In fact, the whole point of GM soya and canola is to allow any amount of Monsanto’s weed killer “Roundup” to be sprayed on them without harming the crop.
Biotech corporations have engineered the naturally occurring Bt insecticide into every cell of crops of potatoes, corn and cotton, even though they know this guarantees Bt will be useless in a very few years as insects resistant to it rapidly multiply. Organic growers will have lost the only insecticide they are allowed to use.
And recent research has shown pollen drifting from a corn crop into which Bt has been engineered will kill non-target species such as the Monarch butterfly. “Genetic drift” or “genetic pollution” into non-GM crops or weedy relatives is turning out to be much more prevalent and its implications more serious than biotech researchers predicted.
Mitchell says genetic engineering can be expected to help feed a hungry world. This routine claim of the biotechnology industry is deeply resented in developing nations, where it’s well-known the real causes of hunger are poverty and inequitable food distribution. In any case, most GE crops produce less food than do normal seeds — about seven per cent lower in the case of the 1998 U.S. soybean crop. In a particularly noble contribution to the relief of world hunger, the biotech industry plans to offer farmers seeds that die after producing one crop, forcing them to return to the company for new, expensive seed each year.
“To satisfy government regulation, such crops are rigorously tested to determine risk,” writes Mitchell. Surely he knows that, in fact, no research has been done anywhere on the effect of GE foods on humans.
The British Medical Association has warned the U.K. government not enough is known about these foods to allow them on the market. In Canada, however, we have adopted the doctrine of “substantial equivalence” — if it looks like a potato it is a potato, and no further queries are necessary.
Prof. Mitchell advises us to seek out the Health Canada Web site in order to be assured of the safety of “novel foods,” as genetically altered products are called.
That’s a good suggestion — at the site, you will find that a corporation wishing to market a “novel food” need not seek approval from Health Canada. It has merely to notify the department of its intentions 45 days before selling the product, along with data assuring its safety. Health Canada can ask for more information if it wishes. And that’s it — there is no testing of such foods in
public laboratories.
If an independent scientist (Prof. Mitchell, for example) wished to check that data, he would have to use the freedom of information process to get it, and even then it would only be released if the corporation in question agreed.
In the scientific process, researchers normally publish their results so colleagues around the world can verify or disprove their results, or use them as a springboard from which to press the work further.
In biotech research, the watchword is secrecy. You don’t publish without corporate permission, and you certainly don’t publish anything that might reflect unfavourably on the product the company is pushing. There are studies showing corporate funding is a very effective way of ensuring research will be favourable to the sponsoring company’s products.
Finally, there is the impact of genetic engineering on modern farming. The products of GE require high-input, high-capital operations, and are designed to facilitate large-scale, continuous-cropping monocultures. This is the antithesis of sustainable agriculture in which crop rotations, maintenance of soil
structure and fertility, and natural pest-control methods are valued.
Biotechnology in agriculture is, of course, the opposite of organic agriculture, and public concerns about it will speed the already phenomenal increase in demand for organic produce.
Другие работы по теме:
My Symbolical Snack Essay Research Paper My
My Symbolical Snack Essay, Research Paper My Symbolical Snack THE LIQUID My liquid is APPLE JUICE. The apple, once portrayed as the Forbidden fruit eaten by Adam and Eve, has a lot of nutrients that are essential to the body. Potassium, fiber, and many vitamins are things that your get from the apple.
Genetic Engineering Essay Research Paper Imagine a
Genetic Engineering Essay, Research Paper Imagine a world full of ?mini Hitlers? seeking world domination, killing millions as their solution to establish a superior race or bunch or 2 headed humans eating a pig with 6 legs. These scenarios may sound like something out a science fiction novel, but this is the kind of things that people think about when they hear the words ?genetic engineering?
Tapeworm2 Essay Research Paper Biological RelationshipIn nature
Tapeworm2 Essay, Research Paper Biological Relationship In nature you see many biological relationship in which two living aninamls have a relationship. One animal will benefits from the other aninaml that animal which lives off the other benefits from that animal or could suffers. A tapeworm and a human are example of a parasitism.
BioTechnology Essay Research Paper The shortterm future
Bio-Technology Essay, Research Paper The short-term future of biotechnology in production agriculture looks bleak. The unattractive truth is that economics, not science can play a larger role in the future of biotechnology.
Hatchet Essay Research Paper His dad and
Hatchet Essay, Research Paper His dad and mom were divored. The boy was on his way to see is dad. so he got in a plane. & on the way the ploit showed he to fly the plane . then the ploit
Vbnfg Essay Research Paper Mrs NicholsChoosing to
Vbnfg Essay, Research Paper Mrs. Nichols Choosing to Participate June 14, 2000 Saving the Children Save the Children is an organization that was created to help less fortunate children that have little money for food and clothing. It is a nonprofit association that is working in more than 35 nations to improve the living qualities of the children and their families.
Twenty And Ten Essay Research Paper The
Twenty And Ten Essay, Research Paper The name of the book: TWENTY AND TEN THE AUTHOR: CLAIRE HUCHET BISHOP THE PUBLISHER: SCHOLASTIC INC. COPYRIGHT DATE: 1980
The Digestive Track Essay Research Paper The
The Digestive Track Essay, Research Paper The Digestive Track The BIG MAC is placed in the mouth. The bread is mainly starch, the special sauce is mainly fat, lettuce, pickles, and onions are niacin. The beef patties
Technology Essay Research Paper People very often
Technology Essay, Research Paper People very often debate whether technology is good or bad. Many people believe that technology can only cause harm to their lives and society, while many others strongly defend the technologies which have made their lives much more leisurely and enriching than it could have been several hundred years ago.
Technological Pesticides Essay Research Paper Biotechnological PesticidesSome
Technological Pesticides Essay, Research Paper Biotechnological Pesticides Some bugs and insects, most don’t realize, have jobs to do. The work some bugs put in are not wanted. Some bugs are left alone to do what they want, while others are killed off for certain purposes. Most agriculture crops spray pesticides to rid the plants and vegetables of unwanted bugs.
Year 2000 Essay Research Paper Year 2000The
Year 2000 Essay, Research Paper Year 2,000 The year two thousand seems to be on the tip of every ones tongue. From what will happen to what to expect when it comes. Others believe that these few days
Rose Circle Essay Research Paper Rose oh
Rose Circle Essay, Research Paper Rose, oh how you lie there, Lifeless and withered, Deprived of water and of food, You struggle to survive, You catch the odd droplet of life,
Hunting Is Bad Essay Research Paper A
Hunting Is Bad Essay, Research Paper A hunter walks through the woods, stalking an unsuspecting deer…Bang! The deer is dead. The hunter walks away feeling good about himself, and happy that he got a deer. Some people think this is wrong. They think that you should not kill animals for sport. It is important that hunting does not become extinct.
Genetically Engineered Food Essay Research Paper Millions
Genetically Engineered Food Essay, Research Paper Millions of people all over the planet suffer from poverty and starvation. One very interesting but experimental solution to the problem of world hunger is genetically engineered food. The process involves the crossbreeding of crops in a laboratory with species that are not plant like.
What Is Biotechnology Essay Research Paper Biotechnology
What Is Biotechnology? Essay, Research Paper Biotechnology as defined by the Merriam-Webster dictionary is the manipulation of biological organisms to make products that benefit human beings. This in essence is biotechnology but one might still be confused by this topic.
Child Care Essay Research Paper Caring for
Child Care Essay, Research Paper Caring for a pet is like caring for a child. I feel this is because you do almost the same things that you do when caring for a child, that you would do when caring for a pet. The similarities are you provide food and shelter, you provide them with entertainment, and you take them to a doctor or vettrnarin when they are sick.
Tech Essay Research Paper Imagine thirty or
Tech Essay, Research Paper Imagine thirty or forty years form now. Biotechnology has really advanced. Scientist can now clone people and also change their DNA strands making them better or perfect all around. Do you think that it is safe to tinker with Mother Nature? Is it wise to try and control Mother Nature? Better yet can she ever be controlled? Whether or not she can be controlled is a big of deal.
Biotechnology Pros And Cons Essay Research Paper
Biotechnology: Pros and Cons Throughout this past semester many important ecological dilemmas have come to my attention. The most striking environmental issue that I have noted this semester has been agricultural Biotechnology. A reputable definition of Biotechnology would be ?the means or way of manipulating life forms (organisms) to provide desirable products for man’s use?(www.biotechknowledge).
Food Stamps Essay Research Paper while others
Food Stamps Essay, Research Paper while others think that giving away food stamps is a helpful thing, i think that the gov. should stop distrubuting food stamps. the aqusition and use of food stamps is frequently abused. people can easily obtain food stamps by creating their eligibility even if it involves cheating. one thing i believe that the government should stop handing out food stamps is that most of the people who receive food stamps are capable of working.
Honey Bee Dances Essay Research Paper The
Honey Bee Dances Essay, Research Paper The honey bee does a waggle dance is the food source is MORE THAN 50 meters away. A waggle dance is when the bee does a little ditty like a figure-eight. If the food source is LESS THAN 50 meters
Ode To Boys Essay Research Paper We
Ode To Boys Essay, Research Paper We like them But do they like us The ones we do never fuss They don’t stop in And we wonder why We stress, we bitch We sometimes cry
Fast Food Essay Research Paper The fast
Fast Food Essay, Research Paper The fast food industry is one of the largest industries in the world. Fast food has been known to be a large area of investment involving food. Restaurants such as McDonald s and Burger King have been known for their popularity mostly from advertisements and are highly rated to be the trademarks for the fast food industry.
Food Of Mexico Essay Research Paper The
Food Of Mexico Essay, Research Paper The Wonderful Food of Mexico! Food is probably the most important element of Mexican culture. Much of the daily routine and tradition in Mexico revolves around the ritual of preparing and eating food. In history, women made their way to the local markets to fill their basket with vegetables, fruits, meat, and fish.
Life Is Like Essay Research Paper Life
Life Is Like Essay, Research Paper Life is like a car. When it?s new, it usually works all right. As time drives by, it breaks down and needs repairs. Life is like a leaf. In its youth, it
Analysis Of Opposition Essay Essay Research Paper
Analysis of Opposition Essay In the first paragraph of Congressman Bernard Sanders persuasive essay on genetically modified organisms uses shocking statistics to convince the reader the issue of genetic engineering effects everyone. He points out that genetically engineered organisms are already on the table, and the usage of GMO s (genetically modified organisms) is on the rise.