AP US History Essay, Research Paper
March 1, 1997
Period 4
Treaty of Versailles: Who was at fault for its denial?
The Treaty of Versailles, which was a peace treaty that called for the end of World
War 1(between Germany and the Allies), was defeated in the Senate by an unknown
alliance of two forces. The two forces were President Wilson?s ?all or nothing? attitude
and the strong opponents of the Treaty in the Senate.
William Borah (Sen, Idaho), one of the ?irreconcilables?, brings out a clear
weakness in the Covenant of the League of Nations in his speech to the Senate. The
weakness is that will any country really feel comfortable, or approve of, another country?s
government dealing with their domestic affairs and concerns, especially if they have an
army to support whatever they decide. He also brings up a point that no one would
approve of a tribunal, with 41 other nations in it, to settle a problem that might arise
between members of the nation because what one nation sees a vital, another nation may
see as wasteful, which might just lead to another World War. The League as he describes
it is contradictorial in all that it is to accomplish (?force to destroy force, conflict to
prevent conflict, militarism to destroy militarism, war to prevent war?) and it can?t work
like that because it has no authority to back up its own judgment. This goes against
Wilson?s idea of the League because he helped create it and it is a very important and big
step to him in creating a worldwide government (Doc A)
The Treaty as portrayed in The New Republic is useless, which is a strong reason it
shouldn?t be passed. It wasn?t useless in the sense that it would officially end the war, but
in a sense that it would not ?moralize nationalism?. The moralization of nationalism could
be achieved by ending the separation of classes and ambitions that could only be enjoyed
by some, not all, people in the country. According to the journalist the Treaty doesn?t
make even a bland attempt to solve these problems, and that it, in fact, promotes and
heightens those differences of opinion between the nations. (Doc B)
In a general speech given by Wilson, he provides that Article X, which morally
bound the U.S. to aid any member of the League victimized by external aggression, is the
?inevitable, logical center to the whole system of the Covenant of the League of Nations?.
Although he supports it, he feels he is not at fault if the Covenant isn?t correct. On
another separate occasion, Wilson defended that Article X morally, not legally, bound the
U.S. to aiding other victimized nations, ergo the U.S. didn?t have to help who they didn?t
want to help. Article X angered Congress because they wanted to reserve their
constitutional right of declaring war to themselves. Article X also enraged the great-
grandson of George Cabot, Henry Cabot Lodge (R, Idaho). He so disliked Article X that
he made his own reservation to it, which provided that the U.S. has no obligation to get
involved with the affairs of any other country. His reservation would later be turned down
by Congress. (Doc C)
Herbert Hoover correctly advises President Wilson to, in so many words, to hurry
up and do something to approve the treaty in the Senate or it will never get passed. He
gives this advice to President Wilson because he knows that Lodge is effectively using
delay tactics, such as reading the whole 264- page treaty aloud to the Senate Foreign
Relations Committee, to divide and sway public opinion about the Treaty to his favor.
Although he is pleased with the concern the government is giving to the treaty, he feels
their could be improvements and if these improvements aren?t quick in happening, then
the very necessary public opinion of the Americans will start to go against the treaty
because of the many ?wrongs imposed in the Treaty? and Lodge?s active lobbyism. When
popular public opinion goes, in most cases, so does the bill. (Doc D)
The cartoon (Doc E) shows how the Republicans felt about not being involved in
the peace proceedings in Paris. When Wilson went to Paris, his delegation included not a
single Republican which greatly infuriated them. He did not even consult the Republican
leadership in the Senate about the peace negotiations, which was also an insult to the
Republicans. Among the leading Republicans was Henry Cabot Lodge of Massachusetts,
who was also the chairman of the Senate Committee on foreign relations.
Lodge and Wilson were the two great minds of U.S. politics at the time so they were
naturally against each other because of their different partisan roots. Wilson?s decision
would prove to be fatal to his cause because the Senate majority belonged to the
Republicans, which meant that the Treaty would not probably pass without a lot of their
support.
In his Economic Consequences of the Peace, John Maynard Keyes argues that
Germany should have to repay the United States and other Allies for the damages they
caused to them during the war. This was necessary, economically, for the U.S. and the
rest of the Allies because the Allies needed the money from Germany to pay off their
wartime debts to America and America needed the money so they wouldn?t have to use
taxpayer?s dollars to pay for the debt. This would actually go against the Wilson
supported idea of Article X because America would morally have to help Germany out
because they did damage to Germany and Germany was damaged the most by the war!
(Doc G) ( This issue would later be solved by the Dawes Plan of 1924, in which
American money was cycled around the world as loans, back to the U.S. Treasury as debt
payments)
W.E.B. DuBois, editor of Crisis magazine, blamed both Wilson and his opponents
as the main reasons that the U.S. is not in the League of Nations, in his article ?The
League of Nations?. He compares the U.S. government to the other governments of the
League and the U.S. government comes out looking very silly. He makes an interesting,
but all too true point, that one nation can?t control the world or just stay out of it, which
the twin tower forces are causing to happen. (Doc H)
Jane Addams? view of the League of Nations catastrophe is actually quite similar
to DuBois?, but in a different way. She has found that the joining of the League by signing
the Treaty is a very difficult question to answer because of the multiverse of opinion. The
members of the Women?s Peace Party knew there was a lot more effort needed to push
forth for a sufficient international organization, but what type of effort would everyone
approve? The question of the Treaty was an answerless idea among her group and among
the government also, which had answers but different ones that they couldn?t agree upon.
(Doc I)
Although Wilson and his opposing forces were clearly against each other on their
views of the whole Treaty of Versailles issue, they ended up being the main reason for the
failure of it in America. They both wanted to pass the Treaty but only with their own
certain reservations or without reservations. Either way they could never agree upon it in
America. The strong division of the public opinion and the twin towers proved to be too
much for the Treaty to be approved in the United States.
Другие работы по теме:
Nat King Cole Essay Research Paper NAT
Nat King Cole Essay, Research Paper NAT KING COLE BORN MARCH 17, 1919 DIED FEBRUARY 15, 1965 BORN NATHANIEL ADAMS COLES HE WAS THE FIRST AFRICAN- AMERICAN WHO BECAME A SUCCESS WITH THE WHITE AUDIENCE.
Italian National Soccer Essay Research Paper ITALIAN
Italian National Soccer Essay, Research Paper ITALIAN NATIONAL TEAM HISTORY With an extraordinary record which includes three World Cups the Federazione Italiana Giuoco Calcio celebrated its 100th birthday in 1998. The Italian team was founded on March 16th 1898 on Torino, Italy. The first president of this federation ever elected was Mario Vicary.
Bib On VR Essay Research Paper Books
Bib On VR Essay, Research Paper Books and Periodicals Benningfield, Damond. “The Virtues of Virtual Reality.” Star Date, July/Aug. 1991, pp. 14-15. Burrill, William. “Virtual Reality.” Toronto Star, 13 July
Art History Essay Research Paper M
Art History Essay, Research Paper ?M & M ? s? When I entered in the gym, the outside morning quiet, softly blowing breeze stopped and the screams of go Phillips was
Letter To Shareholder Essay Research Paper March
Letter To Shareholder Essay, Research Paper March 5, 1998 Ms. Mary Ruiz 321 Orange Way Green Valley, Ca 90272 Dear Shareholder: This year has been an exciting and profitable one at Nomad. As a shareholder, let us tell you about our recent successes and the challenges we expect in the coming year and beyond. This letter summarizes the high points of the year and provides valuable details about our work in individual areas of the organization, including finance, communications, quality assurance, and travel.
Inhumane Treatment Essay Research Paper When groups
Inhumane Treatment Essay, Research Paper When groups and nations come into conflict, they sometimes act in inhumane ways. They use cruel and harsh treatment toward others. Two conflicts that occurred between 1900 and 1945 that resulted in the inhumane treatment of people are the Nazi Holocaust and the Salt March.
American History X Essay Research Paper This
American History X Essay, Research Paper This movie was a very intense movie. The message that it was trying to send was very powerful and it hit me fairly hard. The message that this movie was trying to send to me was that society as a whole does not have the maturity and inteligence to deal with subjects such as racism and hate.
Women Of Today Essay Research Paper Throughout
Women Of Today Essay, Research Paper Throughout most of history women generally have had fewer legal rights and career opportunities than man. Wife hood and motherhood were regarded as women’s most significant professions. In the 20th century, however, women in most nations have gained the right to vote and have increased their educational job opportunities ( WIC, 1).
ROTC Entrence Essay Essay Research Paper entrance
ROTC Entrence Essay Essay, Research Paper entrance essay For almost as long as I cn remember, I have been interested in th military. Influenced by such movies as “Patton”, and by my dad’s interest in military history, my
Killer Angels Essay Research Paper Detailing the
Killer Angels Essay, Research Paper Detailing the events around four days in late June and early July, 1863, the story follows four men as they march into the field for what will become the bloodiest three days in American history. Robert E. Lee leads the Confederate troops on an invasion of Pennsylvania, believing it is the only way the South can still force Washington to accept peace, and a Southern victory.
Jeruselem Essay Research Paper Ariel David What
Jeruselem Essay, Research Paper Ariel, David. What do Jews Beleive. New york: Schocken Books, 1995. 8 Dec. 2000 . World history. D, G -. Torah. Egypt: G-D, 1515. 1 Jan. 1000 . The holy book.
Religions 2 Essay Research Paper Global History
Religions 2 Essay, Research Paper Global History 9 March 23rd 1999 In the world today there are three major religions, Christianity, Judaism, and Islam. Each having the same background but having different views of this religion. These religions all have originated from the same area, the Middle East, and each having branched out from there.
Minister Louis Farakan Essay Research Paper In
Minister Louis Farakan Essay, Research Paper In today’s society it does not take much to bring about a change in the way we as a people think. In the prompt, choosing a living man or woman who has influenced the way we think, Minister Louis Farakan comes to mind. In his efforts to unite the men of the African American community, there were a lot of negative and positive reactions.
Alaska Essay Research Paper In this report
Alaska Essay, Research Paper In this report I will be writing about different topics of Alaska. They are: Alaskan cities, Alaskan History, and Physical makeup of Alaska.
St Elizabeth Essay Research Paper I chose
St. Elizabeth Essay, Research Paper I chose the name Elizabeth for my confirmation name after Saint Elizabeth. I feel that she is a very important part in history.
Ides Of March Essay Research Paper Beware
Ides Of March Essay, Research Paper Beware the ides of March Your Friends Grow fearful of the They fear you have becaome to powerful And will not spare your life to fix it
Al Gore Essay Research Paper Albert Gore
Al Gore Essay, Research Paper Albert Gore, Jr., b. Washington, D.C., March. 31, 1948, a U.S. representative (1977-1985) and senator (1985-1992) from Tennessee, was elected to the vice- precidency oh the United States on a Democtratic ticket with Gov. Bill Clinton of Arkansas in 1992. he is the son of Albert Gore, Sr., who was also a congressman (1953-1971).
My Paper Essay Research Paper 895 Mae
My Paper Essay, Research Paper 895 Mae Lynn Drive Fenton, Missouri 63026 March 4, 2000 Mr. John Smith Director of Central Service St. Mary?s Hospital P.O. Box 656
Elizabeth Bathory Essay Research Paper Rachel SmithCaywoodAP
Elizabeth Bathory Essay, Research Paper Rachel Smith Caywood AP Eng. IV March 18, 2001 Throughout history vampires have been one of the most feared fictional characters. Vlad Dracul, often called “Dracula”, is the most renowned vampire. He impaled his victims on stakes in front of his castle in order to frighten away any enemies (Glut).
John Doe Essay Research Paper French Revolution
John Doe Essay, Research Paper French Revolution “Revolutions evolve in definite phases. At first they are moderate in scope, then they become radical to excess and finally they are brought to abrupt conclusions by the emerg…
Booker T Washington Essay Research Paper Fred
Booker T Washington Essay, Research Paper Fred BoucherUS History March 1, 1991 Booker Taliaferro Washington Booker Taliaferro Washington was born April 5,1856 in James County VA. He was born in a slave hut. After the emancipation proclamation, he moved with his family to Malden W. Va. He never went to school when he was young because of poverty.
Alexendra Gram Bell Essay Research Paper For
Alexendra Gram Bell Essay, Research Paper For my pocketful I chose Alexander Graham Bell. I chose him because he was a crucial inventor in world history. Bell made it possible for us to communicate as easily to our relatives or people around the world. He was born March 3, 1847 in Edinburgh, Scotland. He came from a family of speech teachers.
History Of Lacrosse Essay Research Paper What
History Of Lacrosse Essay, Research Paper What is Lacrosse? Summary: Lacrosse is the oldest sport in North America, and dates back to the 1400 s. Lacrosse did not become well know until the 1600 s.
Defintition Of History Essay Research Paper The
Defintition Of History Essay, Research Paper The statement ? History is nothing more than a collection of the static facts of the past; people who say history changes are terribly misguided? is incorrect. History is more than just static facts when ideas and concepts involved in history are understood and applied in life.
Operation Desert Storm Essay Research Paper American
Operation Desert Storm Essay, Research Paper American History Essay Desert Storm In 1979 Saddam Hussien took control of Iraq, and immediately set the tone for his rule by killing 21 of his cabinet members. He wanted to make his country whole once again so in 1990 he invaded Kuwait and in less than 4 hours he had taken Kuwait and controlled 24% of the worlds oil supplies.
Growth In Writing Essay Research Paper Emily
Growth In Writing Essay, Research Paper Emily Gillette DVWR 101.004 Professor Bull September 22,2000 Growth in Writing Writing is one of my favorite things to do. Expressing yourself is so much easier when given time to think about what needs to be said. I would like to believe that I have a very rich writing history.
History Of The Mexican Flag Essay Research
Paper History of the Mexican Flag The Mexican Flag has a rich and colorful history. Before the Spanish came, the Aztecan flag had snakes and panthers pictured on it. Following the conquest, a flag resembling that of Castille was adopted, and on August 13, 1530, the first flag parade was ordered by the Government of Don Alonso de Estrada to commemorate the fall of Tenochtitlan nine years before.
Aboriginal People Essay Research Paper Many of
Aboriginal People Essay, Research Paper Many of the Aboriginals have developed a way of life that they are satisfied with, but by these big organizations taking control over their communities they have no way of stopping them, without the support of other people in the community. Many aboriginals have lived on these reservations most of their lives, so much of their history has been from living there.
Untitled Essay Research Paper The history of
Untitled Essay, Research Paper The history of the world.The history of the world.The history of the world.The history of the world.The history of the world.The history of the world.The history of the world.The history of the world.The history of the world.The history of the world.The history of the world.The history of the world.The history of the world.The history of the world.The history of the world.The history of the world.The history of the world.The history of the world.The history of the world.The history of the world.The history of the world.The history of the world.The history of the world.The history of the world.The history of the world.The history of the world.The history of the world.The history of the world.The history of the world.The history of the world.The history of the world.The history of the world.The history of the world.The history of the world.The history of