, Research Paper
Oprah, Uma. Uma, Oprah. 1 Homer, Virgil. Virgil, Homer. The Aeneid, the greatest Latin
epic of the battles and wanderings of the Trojan hero, Aeneas, and his founding of the ruling line
for the Roman Empire was written by the great Latin poet Virgil. Or so it seems. When one is
reading the Aeneid and has also read both Homeric epics, one can almost instantly see many
parallels between Homer and Virgil. Not only are there parallels in the actual style of writing,
but the most prominent parallels come in the aspects of structure, events, and characterization.
The Aeneid is, in actuality, … a structural and thematic reworking of both epics of Homer. 2
The Aeneid is clearly modeled in the beginning after the Odyssey while in the end it is modeled
after the Iliad. The happenings and actions of Aeneas are very similar to both those of Odysseus
and later of Achilles. Many of the characters themselves are also modeled after Homer s
characters. There are also many little details here and there which show that Virgil certainly
modeled his epic after Homer, not to plagiarize, but for the style and the use of a model for
human insight and feeling. When reading the Aeneid, one can clearly see and hear the Homeric
echoes present in the epic.
The Aeneid is clearly divided into two parts, The Odyssean Aeneid 3 and, The
Iliadic Aeneid. 4 The first six books are based on the Odyssey while the last six books are
based on the Iliad. To clearly see that Virgil was indeed basing his working on Homer, let us
examine the Homeric echoes that are present in the first half, or the Odyssean Aeneid. The first
parallel that presents itself is the immediate situation of Aeneas and his ships. Just as Odysseus
and his crew were lost after the end of the Trojan War, so too are Aeneas and his crew. Just like
Odysseus was battered by a storm and almost killed after leaving Calypso s island5, so too are
Aeneas ships being battered by a storm set on by Juno. The general situation is the clear
parallel, however. Not only the storm, but the fact that Aeneas and his ships are wandering lost
for many years and at the mercy of a vengeful god, and the fact that they will eventually land on
a friendly shore just like Odysseus landed on the Phaeacian shore6, is almost an exact replica of
Odysseus situation in the Odyssey. When Aeneas arrives on Carthaginian soil, he, just like
Odysseus did when he arrived in Phaeacia7, tells the story of how he arrived and under what
circumstances8 both told in rousing flashbacks. Another similarity to the Odyssey are the
contests and games. While in the land of the Phaeacians, Odysseus participates in the contests
there9, while Aeneas holds similar contests to honor the death of his father Anchises10. Just as
Aeneas leaves the land of the Carthaginians, Dido places a curse on him similar to the one
Polyphemus places on Odysseus when she says, … I hope and pray that on some grinding reef/
Midway at sea you ll drink your punishment/ And call and call on Dido s name! 11 This leads to
perhaps the most obvious parallel between the Odyssey and the Aeneid, the visits to the
underworlds12. Just like in the Odyssey where Odysseus receives advice on how he should
proceed to get himself home, here too does Aeneas receive advice on how he should get to Italy
and how he will have to fight a bloody war with the inhabitants there upon his arrival. Just as
Odysseus meets the souls of people he knew, so too does Aeneas as he meets Dido, Palinurus,
and his father Anchises. The fact that he does leave Carthage raises a very subtle echo between
Homer and Virgil, the rejection of happiness or immediate luxury in exchange for the struggle
for something much better. In the Odyssey, Odysseus rejects happiness and luxury with
Nausicaa, Circe, and Calypso to struggle and perhaps even die to return home to his own wife.
So too does Aeneas reject happiness and luxury with Dido, even though he is truly in love with
her, to struggle and wage war on a foreign land to found an empire for his future descendants.
Besides the Homeric echoes to the Odyssey, the last half of the Aeneid is an echo of
Homer’s Iliad. It is indeed after Book VI that Virgil turned, “… to the Iliad and modeled his last
six books on Homer’s tragic poem of war.”13 The first obvious parallel here is the presence of a
major war. In the Iliad the war is between the Greeks and the Trojans, while in the Aeneid, the
battle is between the Trojans and the Latins led by Turnus. Both battles are reminiscent of each
other as being fought by large enemies and being especially violent and gruesome. There is even
a siege that occurs similar to the Greeks storming the city fortress of sacred Ilion when the Latins
try to storm the Trojan ramparts. One obvious similarity is the calling of a truce and the choosing
of the two champions to decide the war14. In the Iliad it is Paris and Menelaus who are to fight
and decide the war while in the Aeneid it is Aeneas and Turnus. Both truces eventually end with
a divinity causing someone to break the truce and wound one of the champions as an arrow
wounds Menelaus and a spear wounds Aeneas. Another similarity is the death of the closest
friend of the strongest hero. In the Iliad it is Patroclus’ death that finally motivates Achilles to
enter the war while in the Aeneid it is Pallas’ death that causes Aeneas, even though he is already
fighting in the war, to increase his vigor and enthusiasm for the fight. Aeneas, like Achilles,
grieves heavily over the death of his close friend. One very interesting parallel between the Iliad
and the Aeneid is the crafting of the shield for the hero15. Both shields represent various facets
of the societies from which each warrior comes. Both are also crafted by the god of the forge:
Vulcan, Hephaestus in the Greek. Another major echo from Homer in the Aeneid is the battle
between Aeneas and Turnus. This battle is almost a reproduction of the epic fight between
Achilles and Hector. Between Achilles and Hector, Achilles had to chase him around the city
three times before Hector was finally stopped by Athena to do battle while in the Aeneid Turnus,
“… Swifter than wind he fled,”16 is reminiscent of how Hector fled Achilles and he also, “… ran,
weaving circles at a loss/ This way and that…”17 just like Hector. Aeneas too is just like Achilles
who could not catch up with Hector as Aeneas, “… pressed on hotly, matching stride for stride,/
Behind his shaken foe.”18 The way Turnus dies is even reminiscent of how Achilles kills Hector
by letting him speak before he actually delivers the death blow while at his mercy.
Homer is also echoed in Virgil by the characters themselves. A close reading of the
characters and the way they act reveals that they are in fact modeled on Homer’s characters. The
first character that is modeled on Homer is Aeneas. Aeneas is a combination of both Odysseus
and Achilles. He is Odysseus in the way that he is trying to prevail against the wrath of a god
and sail to a destination while being presented with struggles along the way such as storms, the
Charybdis, and Polyphemus, all like Odysseus had to confront. Aeneas even has to go into the
underworld like Odysseus did to receive advice and hear prophecy about his immediate future.
He is like Achilles in that he is the best warrior that the Trojans have and also like Achilles he is
the son of a goddess. He also loses a close friend like Achilles does and is the one who slays the
other army’s champion after a chase and fight. The character of Turnus is based on Hector from
the Iliad. Just like Hector, he is defending his land against invaders and what he sees as a threat
to his entire way of life. Just like Hector who dies in the fight for his city, so too does Turnus.
They both die very similar deaths at the hands of the warrior heroes. Pallas is based on the
character of Patroclus. Just like Patroclus to Achilles, so too was Pallas a good friend to the
hero, in this case Aeneas. Unfortunately, also like Patroclus, he is killed in the heat of battle by
the enemy s champion, Pallas in his haste to join war at a young age, while Patroclus haste was
going too far up in the ranks of the Greeks to fight the Trojans. Even Aeneas son Ascanius or
Iulus is based upon the Telemachus that Homer based his Telemachus on, the young boy unable
as yet to go to war, but idolizing and worshipping his father as the ideal warrior. The gods are
also based on each other. While in the Odyssey it is Poseidon who causes all the trouble for
Odysseus, in the Aeneid, it is Juno who causes much the same trouble for Aeneas as well.
Clearly Virgil is imitating Homer s wrath theme from the Iliad and the Odyssey. There is also a
parallel between Dido and the women in Homer. Both women in Homer, Helen and Penelope,
are strong minded and loyal, so too is Dido. Also, the warrior princess in Book XI could also be
tribute to the strong women of Homer. Even the Trojans themselves have reversed role with the
Greeks of the Iliad as they are now seen as the invaders.
In the Aeneid, Virgil has many parallels to Homer. These echoes range from characters
to plot to the structure itself. Virgil uses the style and devices of Homer as a tool for not only
telling a rousing epic about the founding of Rome, but also as a tool for probing into the human
soul and conveying the human condition to the reader. Some of these echoes include the
wanderings of Aeneas, the massive battle between the Trojans and the Latins, and some of the
characters such as Aeneas being both Achilles and Odysseus. The Aeneid, was written as a
Roman story about the founding of Rome and its ruling line, and thus one would not suspect that
there would be any parallels to a Greek epic of fiction, but indeed in the Aeneid, there are many
parallels or echoes to Homer.
BIBLIOGRAPHY
Bloom, Harold. Homer s Iliad. Pennsylvania: Chelsea House Publishers, 1996.
. Homer s Odyssey. Pennsylvania: Chelsea House Publishers, 1996.
. Virgil s Aeneid. Pennsylvania: Chelsea House Publishers, 1996.
Gransden, K.W. Virgil, The Aeneid. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, 1990.
Virgil. The Aeneid. trans. Robert Fitzgerald. New York: Vintage Classics, 1990.
34a
Другие работы по теме:
Things Are Not What They Seem Essay
, Research Paper Things Are Not Always What They Seem William Faulkner s short story A Rose for Emily centers around Miss Emily and what the townspeople think of Miss Emily. One of the themes for A Rose for Emily is appearance versus reality. This theme of appearance versus reality can be seen through what the townspeople think of Miss Emily and by the actions taken by Miss Emily.
Homer Essay Research Paper HOMERThere is no
Homer Essay, Research Paper HOMER There is no question that the writer of the Iliad and the Odyssey was one of the greatest poets in the history of Western Europe, but aside from this, very little can be said about him. Ancient Greek tradition, as well as a study of language and the style of the poems indicates that he probably lived and wrote sometime in the eighth or ninth centuries B.C., but no more definite date can be determined.
Parataxis Of Homer Essay Research Paper Throughout
Parataxis Of Homer Essay, Research Paper Throughout the epic poem The Odyssey, Homer employs a technique called parataxis. This technique is used frequently to identify characters in the book or explaining an event.
Biography Of Homer Essay Research Paper Biography
Biography Of Homer Essay, Research Paper Biography of Homer (?-? BC) Beyond a few fragments of information, historians and classicists can only speculate about the life of the man who composed the Iliad and the Odyssey. The details are few. We do not even know the century in which he lived, and it is difficult to say with absolute certainty that the same poet composed both works.
Le Diable Et L
’homme Essay, Research Paper Il ?tait une fois l? a v?cu un homme ? c?t? du nom de Homer. Homer ?tait un homme tr?s gros, qui a appr?ci? la nourriture beaucoup, particuli?rement des beignets. Il a recherch? toute sa vie un
The Aeneid Essay Research Paper A Common
The Aeneid Essay, Research Paper A Common Thread While outwardly similar, the characters Aeneas and Odysseus are inwardly as different as the authors that brought them to life. The respective views of the authors societies on gender, race, and social conduct are seen throughout the epics in the characterization and interaction of their heroes.
HomerS Odyssey And VirgilS Aeneid Essay Research
Paper Virgil was a creative genius fromhis time, but it can be understandable that many of his works may have been influenced fromprevious works of literature. The Aeneid is not only a personal epic aboutn Aeneas, ut also exaltation and beautification of ROme and the future of the people. There is a greater emphasis placed upon the founding of ROme rather than the actual adventure of Aeneas.
The Odyssey Vs The Aeneid Essay Research
Paper Comparisons: The Odyssey The Aeneid Virgil was a creative genius from his time, but it can be understandable that many of his works may have been influenced from previous works of literacy. A comparison of Virgil?s, The Aeneid, and Homer?s, The Odyssey, will help to show the different aspects of Roman and Greek cultures.
The Odyssey 6 Essay Research Paper The
The Odyssey 6 Essay, Research Paper The Odyssey The Odyssey is the story of Odysseus’s journey from Troy to Ithaka. During his journey Odysseus is impeded by Poseidon and assisted by Athena. The use of olive wood as a metaphor lies in the differences between Athena and her uncle Poseidon in Odysseus’s journey back to Ithaka.
The Illiad Essay Research Paper The IliadThe
The Illiad Essay, Research Paper The Iliad The way Homer wrote this text is similar to warfare today, especially the feelings. There are some differences though. At the end of the passage, Homer wrote War is men s business; and this war is the business of everyone in Ilium, myself above all. That is stating that only men fight in wars.
The Odyssey An Epic By Homer Essay
, Research Paper The Odyssey: An Epic By Homer What do you consider to be a hero? What traits should a hero have? My hero is Odysseus. In The Odyssey by Homer, Odysseus proves to be a true epic hero through his intelligence, bravery, and loyalty.
Virtues In The Aeneid Essay Research Paper
Virtues to the Romans were of the utmost importance. Their virtues were much like ours in the fact that they are a particular excellence in a person that is commendable and a standard of morality. The family, country, and gods were the most valued aspects of a Roman citizens life as stated in Religion in Virgil by Cyril Bailey The pietas, then, which is the expression of man s relation to the gods, extends itself to the other members of these groups: it is part of pietas to the gods to be in the right relation and to act aright toward the members of your own family and toward your state (Bailey p.80).
In The Heat Of The Night Essay
, Research Paper In the Heat of the Night Essay For my essay I have chosen to write about the topic about Tibbs and Gillespie understanding and respecting each other. In the beginning of this story Gillespie thought of Virgil as he would of thought of any other Negro, but soon he found out he was wrong, Virgil was a very gifted detective with lots of skills.
Stars Essay Research Paper Bright Star Would
Stars Essay, Research Paper Bright Star, Would I were Steadfast as Thou Art Endymion (excerpts) The Eve of St. Agnes Fancy The Human Seasons Hyperion If by Dull Rhymes our English must be Chain’d
Fate- Would Homer And Virgil Be The
Same With Out It Essay, Research Paper Fate – Would Homer & Virgil be the same with out it? In Virgil’s Aeneid and Homer’s Iliad, a picture of the supernatural and its workings was created. In both works, there is a concept of a fixed order of events which is called fate. Fate involves two parts. First, there are laws that govern certain parts of mens’ lives, such as human mortality and an afterlife.
Dante And Homer Essay Research Paper Dante
Dante And Homer Essay, Research Paper Dante makes many references to Homer and the Iliad throughout the Inferno. The fates of favorite characters are described during the course of Dante?s
The Significance Of Virgil In The Inferno
Essay, Research Paper Ryan Henson Mind 180 Essay #2 What is the significance of Virgil?s relationship with Dante? The Inferno is an epic poem by Dante Alighieri, one of the greatest poets in the history of western literature. In it, he uses his mastery of language to blend elements of classical literature with a more contemporary Catholic viewpoint.
Iliad By Homer Essay Research Paper ILIADThe
Iliad By Homer Essay, Research Paper ILIAD The Iliad is an epic poem written by Homer .Homer is traditionally believed to be the author both of the Iliad and the Odyssey , the two major epics of Greek antiquity. It is believed that Homer was a blind bard and dictated the epics. Nothing further is known about Homer as an individual , and in fact it is a matter of controversy whether a single person can be said to have written both the Iliad and the Odyssey .Linguistic and historical evidence , however , suggests that the poems were composed in the Greek settlements on the west coast of Asia Minor sometime in the second half of the 8th century BC
The Iliad Essay Research Paper The IliadFrom
The Iliad Essay, Research Paper The Iliad From the beginning of time and continuously through the ages there has always been the struggle between good and evil. Through the Odyssey Homer presents a clear view of both good and evil. Odysseus, the hero and main character of the Odyssey, is portrayed by Homer as the unequivocal essence of goodness and all that is right.
Homer And Virgil Essay Research Paper Comparative
Homer And Virgil Essay, Research Paper Comparative Analysis of the Aeneid, Odyssey, and Iliad The Iliad and the Odyssey are two of the best Greek epics written by Homer. Despite their popularity, almost nothing is known about the author beyond the existence of his masterpieces. Surprisingly enough no concrete evidence of his existence is available; not even to confirm the same person created the two works.
The Aeneid
– Summary Essay, Research Paper The Aeneid – Summary The Aeneid begins and ends with parallels to the Iliad, inviting us to consider Virgil’s poetry in light of Homer’s. The Aeneid is both a tribute to the Homeric style–by imitating it–and an attempt to better it. And perhaps, Virgil is not quite being fair to himself when he invites that comparison; Virgil does not have the Iliad’s tragic irony, and Aeneas is not as powerful a main character as Achilles.
Virgil
’s Aeneid Essay, Research Paper Virgil’s Aeneid The story of Virgil’s Aeneid was drawn from many sources, the most influential being the work of the Greek poet Homer. Virgil based the first six
The Illiad Essay Research Paper The IlliadHomerHomer
The Illiad Essay, Research Paper The Illiad Homer Homer is one of the greatest writers; his works have action, romance, war, friendship, and much more. Since, Homers writings are not in English the Greek non-speaking majority of us rely on people to translate or interpret his works for us. The problem with that is everyone has their own interpretation of what homer is saying, and not only that but their own way of putting it into words.
The Inferno Essay Essay Research Paper The
The Inferno Essay Essay, Research Paper The Inferno Essay The Inferno, translated by John Ciardi, is a poem of Dante s immortal drama of a journey through Hell. Sensory imagery is established throughout the poem in the course of Virgil s attempt to aid Dante through the different symbolic retributions that make up the structure of Hell.
How Women Are Portrayed In Homer
’s Odyssey Essay, Research Paper Women Portrayed in Homer s The Odyssey Women were very important to the Greeks, and they showed this value in many ways. In The Odyssey Homer shows us the different ways women were looked upon through female characters, such as Penelope, Naussica, and Anticlia.
Odysseus And Aeneas Essay Research Paper Odysseus
Odysseus And Aeneas Essay, Research Paper Odysseus and Aeneas are very alike in some ways and very different. They are both epic heroes except that one is Greek and the other is a Trojan. Odysseus is from the Greek tale The Oddessy, which was written by the famous Greek poet Homer. His quest is to find his way back home after a long journey.
Achilles The Super Yuppie Essay Research Paper
Achilles: The Super Yuppie In the beginning of Homer s The Iliad, Achilles is arguing with Agamemnon over a girl. Since Achilles does not get what he wants, he decides to leave the battle that they are in. However, this is no small battle, this is the Trojan War. Achilles action shapes the outcome of the battle, for the next fifteen or so books, with the Greeks losing.
Human Comedy Essay Research Paper One Day
Human Comedy Essay, Research Paper One Day Homer Macauley signs up for a telegram delivery job and gets it. While he delivers these letters he discovers the truth about love, hope, and pain
Rose For Emily Essay Research Paper Analysis
Rose For Emily Essay, Research Paper Analysis of ?A Rose for Emily? In William Faulkner?s short story, ?A Rose for Emily,? obsession plays a key role in the developing personality of the protagonist, Emily Grierson. Because Emily was
Miss Emily
’s Male Interaction In A Rose For Emily Essay, Research Paper Miss Emily’s male interaction in A Rose for Emily The way that a person is raised has a lot to do with their
The Simpsons Essay Research Paper The SimpsonsThis
The Simpsons Essay, Research Paper The Simpsons This cartoon for grown-ups takes place in a fictional town called Springfield in the 1990?s. The main character in the show is Homer Simpsons, a father of three and a husband. Homer works at the Springfield nuclear power plant. He is portrayed as a slacker who is completely unqualified for his job.
The Human Comedy Essay Research Paper Human
The Human Comedy Essay, Research Paper Human Maturity William Saroyan s The Human Comedy, deals with ravages of life. Due to these trials, Homer is forced to mature. How he matures is a result of facing the challenges. Two very import themes that help homer mature are family and death.