PRIVATE SCHOOLS Essay, Research Paper
Tax Dollars Should Not Be Used For Private schools
Should parents be allowed to choose their children?s schools? This is a question that goes much farther than simply just choosing schools. Do parents really have a choice? Some parents can afford to send their kids to a private religious school but some don?t have the funds to do this. Some say that the government should offer tuition vouchers so that the poor and minorities can have a choice. This seems to be a good idea but there are many debates in whether or not it is constitutional. In the following I will discuss why vouchers are a horrible idea.
Vouchers are plans that allow tax dollars to be used for tuition at private schools, including religious schools. The government pays for each and every citizen in America to go to school. They pay for students to go to a public school within their area but sometimes the public schools in some areas are not very good such as the inner city schools. The idea of vouchers would allow poor students to have the chance to go to a better school and rise out of poverty. Some of the questions that are being asked are will they actually help the low class or will they only help the more advantaged students? Another question is if vouchers are constitutional or not, and have there been any experiments with vouchers yet.
Right now there are two programs providing public dollars to pay tuition for low-income students to attend private schools, in Milwaukee and Cleveland. Both include religious schools. These are considered to be experimental programs. These programs have been looked at and the problem so far that seems to be the most apparent is the fact that vouchers may just benefit the more advantaged. According to the Ohio official state evaluation (Metcalf 1998): ?Scholarship students who accepted a scholarship to move from the Cleveland public schools to a private school were achieving at higher levels of achievement than their public school peers before they entered the program. Thus, it appears that the scholarship program attracted better achieving students away from Cleveland public schools.? Another study from the National Education Association says ?students in Milwaukee?s SAGE class-size reduction program out performed regular public school students and voucher students in reading, and did as well in math.?
The purpose of vouchers is to create a choice for parents. With vouchers that choice is not guaranteed. According to a study by the National Education Association throughout recent history the percentage of students attending public and private schools have remained constant (89%) public and (11%) private (Education 58). The one thing that sets private schools apart from public schools is the fact that public schools must accept any student that wishes to attend no matter what. A private school however can choose the students they want. Private schools only want the best students and they don?t have the capacity to accept large amounts of pubic school students. So where is the choice? To me it sounds like the only people that will advantage from vouchers are the elite students and the only ones that are getting a choice are the private schools.
If the voucher proposal should pass public schools are going to suffer. It is proven that that they hurt the majority of students whom stay in public schools. According to the National Education Association ?In 1998-99, public funding for some 6000 voucher students resulted in a loss of over $22 million in state education funding for the Milwaukee public schools. In the same year, Cleveland public schools lost $9 million in state funding, plus another ten million in administrative and transportation costs-taken largely from state funding earmarked for disadvantaged public school students?(Education 60). How can the public schools even come close to competing with private schools taking losses like this? This is yet another reason why vouchers are a bad idea.
Now comes the question. Are vouchers constitutional? The answer is no. According to An article called Are School Vouchers Constitutional? ?The First Amendment of the Constitution means this: Neither the state nor federal government can set up a church. Neither can aid laws, which aid on religion, aid all religions, or prefer one religion over another… No tax in any amount large or small can be levied to support any religious activities or institutions, whatever they may be called, or whatever form they may adopt to teach or practice religion?(Are School Vouchers Constitutional 2). Now what has this said? Neither the state nor federal government can pay for religion. So where is the question? If a student is sent to a private religious school on government funds, the Constitution will be broken!
With all of this said, how is there any question about there being more vouchers? There is no proof of improvement in students that are in the experimental programs, parents aren?t the ones who are getting to make the choices, public schools will suffer greatly, ?and we have to remember that that will still be the majority of students,? and vouchers are not constitutional. If we want to improve the education of students in America we are going to have to look to alternative methods. We need to quit looking at education on such a huge level. Parents need to get more involved with there children and we need to improve the schools that we have now instead of just trying to put them out of business.
ATF on the Issues. Vouchers vs. small class size. 10-3-00 http/www.aft/voucher/report/effect.ht
Battle, Susan. Are School Vouchers Constitutional? 10-3-00. members.tripod?~candst/tnppage/vouch3.htm
Education: Opposing View Points. The government should Not Offer Tuition Vouchers.
Education World. An Overview of This Years Hottest Campaign Debate. School Vouchers 101 10-3-00. http:www.educationworld/a_admin./167.shtrr
Lieberman, Myron. Public Education an Autopsy. London, England, Harvard University Press, 1993
USA Today. Justice Allows Cleveland School Vouchers. 10-3-00 http:/www.usatoday/news/cout/nsco1150.htm
Другие работы по теме:
Letter Essay Research Paper When examining an
Letter Essay, Research Paper When examining an issue it is essential that you look only at the facts and not let your opinion get in the way of what is known to be truth. Such is the case in the
Turbo Or Nitrous Essay Research Paper Turbo
Turbo Or Nitrous Essay, Research Paper Turbo or Nitrous As you are driving, you see many cars going over the speed limit. Many of the drivers are into racing and modifying their cars. In most cars there are two major modifications that can be done, they are; turbo kit, or a nitrous kit. Both increase horsepower dramatically, but one is instant and the other goes into effect after a certain rpm.
Unemployment In Us Essay Research Paper This
Unemployment In Us Essay, Research Paper This article is an attempt to examine the numbers of unemployment in the United States more closely. It contends that the Bureau of Labor Statistics misrepresents the percentage rate of unemployment in the United States in its monthly surveys.
Wages Essay Research Paper How would you
Wages Essay, Research Paper How would you like to be paid twenty-three million dollars a year ? It is obvious to say that everyone would more than love it. This figure is only one of the many outrageous wages athletes are being paid today. True, not all twenty-three million dollars goes directly to the athlete because of Uncle Sam.
Amendment Seven Essay Research Paper The 7th
Amendment Seven Essay, Research Paper The 7th Amendment is very unusual. It speaks to trials at Common Law (civil trials), rather than criminal trials. It states that in trials where the value of the potential award is greater than twenty dollars, the accused has the right to demand that they be tried by a jury; and that no facts tried by a jury shall be reconsidered in any court in the United States other than by the rules of common law.
Dollarization Essay Research Paper Richard W Stevenson
Dollarization Essay, Research Paper Richard W. Stevenson s article Greenspan View on Wider Use of Dollar discusses a process he refers to as dollarization. According to Mr. Stevenson, A number of countries have been considering abandoning their national currencies and adopting the American dollar the accepted international benchmark of stability as a way of reducing interest rates, inflation, and exchange rate volatility.
How To Enter A Nineball Tournament Essay
, Research Paper How to Play Tournament Nine-ball People may think that spending eight dollars on a tournament is a waste of money. Every Sunday I go to Millertime Billiards and enter a nine-ball tournament. I never go in thinking that I?m going to win at least my entry fee back, although it would be nice. On the other hand, I always go in knowing that I will walk out understanding more about the game then the night before.
Goals Essay Research Paper Jonathan drlasEssay 4This
Goals Essay, Research Paper Jonathan drlas Essay 4 This is my first work on this paper. My goal that I?am going to incorporate in my paper is a money goal. I want to save up 3,000 dollars before I leave for school. I leave on the 15 of august so there is a little over two months that I have to achieve this goal.
Huckleberry Finn Essay Research Paper Huck and
Huckleberry Finn Essay, Research Paper Huck and Jim both have seen money differently because Huck is white and has a chance in like and can make it. Jim was a slave and really couldn?t make money. Huck had a lot of money but didn?t spend it that easily ?Oher a hundred and fifty dollars. Quite a fortune for you?(p.12). huck and Tom were in a cave and found six thousand dollars that robbers left there.
Proffessional Athletes Are Overpaid Essay Research Paper
Matt Kelley Rhetoric Speech #2 Professional Athletes are Overpaid Every young child who has ever been involved in athletics has dreamed of being a professional in that sport. Why do you think that everyone wants to be a pro athlete. Sure it is because they get to play for a living. But also they get the big bucks.
Heinz And The Chemist Essay Research Paper
Heinz and the Chemist This essay will prove why Heinz had the right to take the drug from the chemist to save his wife’s life. There are many points that are morally right and humanly right. Not only does Heinz save a life but also teaches the chemist that he can not put a price on life.
Monetary Devaluation Essay Research Paper MONETARY DEVALUATIONLike
Monetary Devaluation Essay, Research Paper MONETARY DEVALUATION Like every other product the coin of a country has a price, which is the exchange type; this represents the quantity of Mexican pesos that are needed to buy an American dollar, and like every other price this one is determined because:
Prostitution Essay Research Paper Specific Purpose To
Prostitution Essay, Research Paper Specific Purpose: To persuade the audience that prostitution should be legal. Introduction I. Open with Impact: If Ann Landers is for prostitution, then how far out can the notion be?
Hip Hop Essay Research Paper Music AppreciationHipHop
Hip Hop Essay, Research Paper Music Appreciation Hip-Hop is one of the newest forms of music. It has expanded and is now the most popular form of music for people ages 11-25. In the last 2 years, hip-hop is the most lucrative form of music. It has sold billions of records and has made record companies billions of dollars.
Oil Price Increase Essay Research Paper Oil
Oil Price Increase Essay, Research Paper Oil Reaching $30 a Barrel “Can the world afford to buy oil at thirty dollars a barrel?” Ed Crook stresses the worldwide delay in satisfying heightened global demand. Consequently he predicted prices would rise to and beyond thirty dollars a barrel.
Why Not To Smoke
… Essay, Research Paper First let me start off by saying that the choice to smoke is yours and yours alone. Everyone has their own freedom of choice to start smoking or never smoke at all. I am highly against the idea
Should College Athletes Get Paid To Play
Essay, Research Paper “Should College Athletes Get Paid To Play” Forget about the game-winning touchdown, forget about the cheerleader girlfriend, and forget the pageantry. What about the hard earned money college athletes will never see and earned? In the world of college sports its win or go home, and to the winners go the spoils.
Puerto Rico Essay Research Paper PUERTO RICOPuerto
Puerto Rico Essay, Research Paper PUERTO RICO Puerto Rico, many good things come from there. Beautiful beaches, beautiful women, and a beautiful culture. However, one thing that does not come from Puerto Rico is money, tax dollars to be exact. Why is it that the United States sends millions of dollars in financial aid to Puerto Rico and nothing comes back? The Puerto Ricans are a commonwealth, not a state, that’s why.
Boston Police Essay Research Paper
”The Boston Police Were Justified in Going Out on Strike in 1919” The period after the Civil War was a time when many businesses and corporations grew to a size where power was the key to success. Different companies would have to compete with each other to stay on top of the fast enlargement of industry. Many businesses and corporation grew so large that the factory owners did not care about the laborers themselves or there concerns, but how much time and work they could out of them.
Effort Should Be Paid Essay Research Paper
Effort Should Be Paid As you sit at a stadium or in your home and watch college football, basketball, or even baseball, do you ever wonder where the money goes from all the ticket sales? Colleges make a lot of money from their athletics. I feel that what is made should partly go back to the student athlete. College athletes should be paid for their participation in sports, since sports make a lot of money for their college.
Les Millions Des Dollars Depense Dans Le
Monde De Hockey. (The Millions Of Dollars Spent On Hockey) Essay, Research Paper LES MILLIONS DES DOLLARS DEPENSE DANS LE MONDE D’HOCKEY. Bonjour aux juges, aux professeurs, et aux autres participants.
Gold Rush Essay Research Paper Gold RushGreedWelcome
Gold Rush Essay, Research Paper Gold Rush/Greed Welcome to Greed ladies and gentlemen here is today?s contests: Cleopatre, Jack and Rebecca. You all know how to play so let?s begin. Cleopatre what would you do with 2 million dollars?
Defense Spending Essay Research Paper Defense SpendingDefense
Defense Spending Essay, Research Paper Defense Spending Defense spending is how much money the government uses to for our national defense. This year President Clinton?s budget includes 267 billion dollars for defense or around 15% of the budget. The budget only includes 18 billion dollars for foreign assistance, which accounts for about 1% of the budget.
The National Debt Essay Research Paper The
The National Debt Essay, Research Paper The National Debt For the past centuries, the american people dug themselves into a big hole which is the National Debt. In this paper I will discuss the history of the national debt, effects on the debt/deficit, wais to reduce it and control the deficit. the national debt has increased every year from 1945 to 1995.
Cars In The United States Essay Research
Paper American Cars and Japanese Cars Most people have their prefrences on what kind of car they want to buy. Japenese cars and American cars are the most popular kind of cars in America. They both have their
Athletes Salaries Essay Research Paper As you
Athletes Salaries Essay, Research Paper As you sit at the stadium or in your home and watch college football, basketball, or even baseball, do you ever wonder where the money goes from all
Theme Park Wars Essay Research Paper Theme
Theme Park Wars Essay, Research Paper Theme Park Wars It is a hot, sunny day in the middle of August. School s out for the summer, and you have nothing to do. You and your friends decide to go to a theme park for a day, but which one will you go to? California has three major theme parks; Universal Studios, Six Flags Magic Mountain, and Disneyland.
Money 2 Essay Research Paper Today no
Money 2 Essay, Research Paper Today, no matter what you do, you need money to do it. Right? Right! Shop. Travel. Make a phone call. You even need to spend money in order to make money. Money is real. People seem to be under the assumption that information wants to be free and that by enabling people to learn and follow their own interests will benefit society as a whole.