Paper
Susan Brownmillers’s essay “Let’s Put Pornography Back in the Closet”, is an well-argued essay. However, adult material is protected by the First Amendment, which protects the freedoms of speech and press. Beginning in the first paragraph, she tries to get the reader’s sympathy by showing that she is not against the First Amendment. She begins her essay by, “Free speech is one of the great foundations on which our democracy rests.” So starting with her introduction she gets the reader’s sympathy. She introduces the First Amendment and defines what it means. “[The First Amendment's] purpose is the protection of unpopular ideas and political dissent.” Then she goes on to quote Chief Justice Warren Burger – “To equate the free and robust exchange of ideas and political debate with commercial exploitation of obscene material demeans the grand conception of the First Amendment and its high purposes in the historic struggle for freedom. It is a misuse of the great guarantees of free speech and free press.” This gives the reader the impression that what she says is a valid argument because a Judge said it in a court. However, Judges are people too, and they have their opinions, and it doesn’t mean that it’s right. After she talks about how the book industry won a battle to keep some potentially offensive books in print, she starts talking about the real issue at hand – pornography. She talks about the Miller case of 1973, who was a porn distributor that sent unsolicited stuff through the mail, and the court came up with guidelines that it hoped would strengthen obscenity laws by giving more power to the states. She believes that the courts made everything even more confusing by setting up a three part test which said, “The materials are obscene if they depict patently offensive, hard-core sexual conduct; lack serious scientific, literary, artistic, or political value; and appeal to the prurient interests of an average person – as measured by the contemporary community standards.” The above sentence is not correct. It should state “The materials are obscene if and only if ” The way Susan states it, it means that there could be other way that the material can be considered obscene, while the courts said that this was it, if it didn’t pass the three part test, then it was not obscene.Susan shows what the dictionary word prurience means, and again tries to get the reader’s sympathy by showing that she is not totally against the First Amendment. “Here we part company rather swiftly with old-line conservatives who don’t want sex education in the high schools, for example.” She defines why feminists are against pornography. “The feminist objection to pornography is based on our belief that pornography represents hatred of women, that pornography’s intent is to humiliate, degrade, and dehumanize the female body for the purpose of erotic stimulation and pleasure. We are unalterably opposed to the presentation of the female body being stripped, bound, raped, tortured, mutilated, and murdered in the commercial entertainment and free speech.” I think Susan goes a little bit too far over here. Not all, if any, pornography fits this description. A lot of pornography is just like playboy – artful pictures of the female body. Some pornography has the act of intercourse pictured, and yes some hard core pornography has rape, S&M, and other fetishes. These are taken using women who do it willingly, women who enjoy S&M, and other fetishes. And if that is not the case, then there are other laws at work here, laws that punish criminals for rape and murder.
Susan states, “Justice William O. Douglas wrote in his dissent of the Miller case that no one is compelled to look. This is hardly true. To buy a paper at the corner newsstand is to subject oneself to a forcible immersion in pornography, to be demeaned by an array of dehumanized, chopped-up parts of the female anatomy, packaged like cuts of meat at the supermarket.” Even though this is not true, I like the way Susan uses words to get the reader on her side. “Dehumanized, chopped-up parts of the female anatomy, packaged like cuts of meat at the supermarket.” This almost brought me over to her side. This is simply not true. At most supermarkets, the magazine section is away from the newspaper section, and most pornographic magazines either have their own section or are hidden behind other magazines so only the name shows. Susan tries to show that obscenity laws are nothing new. “We live quite compatibly with a host of free-speech abridgements. There are restraints against false and misleading advertising or statements – shouting ‘Fire’ without cause in a crowded movie theater, etc. – that do not threaten but strengthen, our societal values. Restrictions on the public display of pornography belong in this category.” This is simply not true. Shouting “Fire” in a crowded theater without reason can cause a panic during which people might get hurt. I do not see how people can get physically hurt from looking at adult material. She concludes again by trying to get on the reader’s side. “We are not saying ‘Smash the presses’ or ‘ban the bad ones,’ but simply ‘Get the stuff out of our sight.’ Let the legislatures decide – using realistic and humane contemporary community standards – what can be displayed and what cannot.” Isn’t it true that because standards vary from one community to another, and from time to time even in the same place her recommendation subjects the rights of a minority to the whims of a majority? The Bill of Rights, after all was supposed to safeguard constitutional right from the possible tyranny of the majority.
34c
Другие работы по теме:
Lyrics Essay Research Paper Music companies should
Lyrics Essay, Research Paper Music companies should not be held liable for the effects of their material. Certain forms of music are being cited as a cause of violence in today s society. Some individuals want forms of music, such as so-called “Gangster Rap” to be censored. However, what the public needs to understand is that rap artists are only telling of incidents that actually happen.
Historical Fiction Essay Research Paper Textbooks can
Historical Fiction Essay, Research Paper Textbooks can often prove to offer only a limited amount of information. Space and time constraints place the author(s) of these textbooks in a sticky situation. They must get the general concept through without taking up to much space. However, this can sometimes push out relevant material that van help to support the general concept.
Joey Essay Research Paper Friday of the
Joey Essay, Research Paper Friday of the hump I didnt have gas mask Sgt Shin made general references in that hazing is ok in his shop and if he does it no one will say anything and if the NCOs do it that he will not say anything.
Censorship Essay Research Paper Censorship by definition
Censorship Essay, Research Paper Censorship by definition is the suppression of published or broadcast material to the public. People have fought and died for the right to hear, read, and see anything and everything that is available. But our right goes beyond that, we have the full right to publish and broadcast material, even though it is controversial.
Charles Dickens Essay Research Paper Charles censoredenscharles
Charles Dickens Essay, Research Paper Charles *censored*ens charles *censored*en’s early life was greatly influential in his most famous novels. his childhood was full of tragedies and problems. *censored*ens needed to overcome several obstacles so that he could have a chance at an education. after defeating these hurdles, *censored*ens wrote the novels that have entertained many people for many generations.
Internet Censorship Essay Research Paper Censorship of
Internet Censorship Essay, Research Paper Censorship of inappropriate material has been an issue with every form of mass media. Now the new and upcoming Internet is becoming the focus. Software makers and service providers are choosing what the public should see. Does this seem right? How can a stranger choose what another person or their family sees on the Internet? Parents and adults should choose what they and their children are exposed to on the Internet.
Motivation Speech Essay Research Paper IV BROADCAST
Motivation Speech Essay, Research Paper IV. BROADCAST PROGRAMMING: BASIC LAW AND POLICY The First Amendment and federal law generally prohibit the FCC from censoring material in broadcasting. Stations choose the material they determine as best for their community. The FCC does not advise on artistic standards, formats, grammar or the quality of their programming.
Censorship 10 Essay Research Paper CensorshipTom Cruise
Censorship 10 Essay, Research Paper Censorship Tom Cruise and Nicole Kidmen star in the film, Eyes Wide Shut, which is a artistic movie about two people having sex. What has society come to? Shouldn t this have been censored? Or is it showing their art to the world? The never ending debate over censorship boast s so many arguments.
Wangus The Sewer Beast Essay Research Paper
out of the sewer, and into the camode, he’s a green-skinned goblin with a twelve foot chode. he comes for your sisters *censored*, strange goblin fetish, he’s gonna eat it.
Corruption In Our Nations School Systems Essay
, Research Paper It all started when I was just a little tike sitting in some *censored*ed up class room in which I would get well accustomed to one day. I mean really; twelve years of ones life in an institution of which they
Richard Wright Essay Research Paper The Man
Richard Wright Essay, Research Paper The Man Who Was Almost a Man In The Man Who Was Almost a Man by Richard Wright, the main character Dave expresses his needs to be acknowledged as an adult. Yet he also exhibits his immaturity and the fact that he is not yet an adult and can not handle adult problems. His actions lead him into trouble that proves the fact that he is still an adolescent who can not handle problems of the adult world.
Doug And Me Essay Research Paper Dr
Doug And Me Essay, Research Paper Dr Dre] Ya’ll know me still the same ol’ G But I been low key Hated on by most these niggas Wit no cheese, no deals and no G’s, no wheels and no keys
Turner
’s Syndrome Essay, Research Paper Turner?s Syndrome Turner?s Syndrome is a common disease in females that affects many body systems. It affects about out of 2,000 females. This genetic
Censorship 2 Essay Research Paper CensorshipThere are
Censorship 2 Essay, Research Paper CensorshipThere are many aspects to censorship. But before I explain the many different aspects of censorship, I would like to discuss what censorship includes. Censorship is the supervision and control of the information and ideas that are circulated among the people within a society.
Censorship Essay Research Paper Music CensorshipSince the
Censorship Essay, Research Paper Music Censorship Since the being of time people have been making and listening to music. Music has been considered the best way to express ourselves. The Bible even talks about how music was used to praise God. Music has been used for all type of things ranging from to getting a girl to notice guy, trying to get over a broken heart, or maybe losing a love one.
Beatrice 2
Beatrice & Benedick-Lovers Or Fighters? Essay, Research Paper When reading Shakespeare it is somewhat difficult to distinguish what this brilliant author is trying to portray in his works. This is mainly due to the use of old English text and constant hidden meanings behind much, if not all of his material.
Relationship Of Beatrice And Benedick In Act
Iv Scene I Of Much Ado About Nothing Essay, Research Paper Act IV scene i is a turning point for Beatrice and Bene*censored*. At the beginning of the play they both pronounce their desire to never marry. However, at this point in the play the two say that they are in love, when unbeknownst to them they have been tricked into loving each other.
Should The Internet Be Censored Essay Research
Paper I believe that the Internet is a good source of information on a wide variety of subjects. I have personally used the Internet for a year now and have found it very useful for helping me with my school work as well as being very entertaining. However I have been deterred by some of the information that is easily accessible and that anyone could look at such as, detailed instructions on how to make harmful or fatal explosives and illegal pornographic material.
Should The Internet Be Censored Essay Research 2
Should The Internet Be Censored? Essay, Research Paper Should the Internet be censored? Censorship on the Internet is a very controversial issue. Many agree that censoring violates the First Amendment of free
Body Shop Essay Research Paper 1 Is
Body Shop Essay, Research Paper 1) Is Anita Rod*censored* correct when she claims that it is possible to run a business in a very ethical and socially responsible manner and still “give shareholders a wondrous return on their investment”?
Censorship Essay Research Paper Censorship on Television
Censorship Essay, Research Paper Censorship on Television Television, radio, and now even computers are growing as quickly as anyone can imagine. As these media sources expand there is a continued need for censorship. In this day and age television, being the least censored of the masses, should have certain simple and specific regulations set upon it.
An Entymology Of The Word Fuck Essay
, Research Paper Fuck! Is that offensive to you? Why is the word ?*censored*? such a taboo word in the English language as opposed to its definition of ?copulation?? It would seem to make sense that if a word is offensive it?s meaning would be twice that. Strangely, sex is not an offensive word at all, and is used frequently in formal conversations and writings.
Net Censorship Essay Research Paper Most of
Net Censorship Essay, Research Paper Most of us have used it. Most of us find it useful, Some of us find it entertaining. Some of us find it offensive. ?It? is the Internet. The Internet has dramatically changed our society. It brings together people
My Thoughts On Love Essay Research Paper
My thoughts on Love What is love for? Why does it have to be just a word thrown around like a misguided sin? Why do people fall in love? Is it because they want to be hurt? If people realized that love
Censorship Essay Research Paper Why There Should
Censorship Essay, Research Paper Why There Should be Censorship Censorship is the examination of material for objectionable matter. It is used to keep material from influencing people the wrong
Censorship Essay Research Paper Censorship Censorship
Censorship Essay, Research Paper Censorship Censorship is the supervision and control of the information andideas that are circulated among the people within a society( Censorship ). I believe that music, books, and the media should not becensored. In the first amendment, it states that it is a right to have freespeech.
Lao Tzu
’S Response Essay, Research Paper I am Lao Tzu. In response to Mr. Martin’s observation: “The mind cannot find truth by itself, but it sure as hell can find falsehood. The idea of stumbling through life with my heart open and my bull*censored* detector turned off doesn’t appeal to me.”
Ode To Boys Essay Research Paper We
Ode To Boys Essay, Research Paper We like them But do they like us The ones we do never fuss They don’t stop in And we wonder why We stress, we bitch We sometimes cry
Pornography Essay Research Paper Susan JacobyA First
Pornography Essay, Research Paper Susan Jacoby ?A First Amendment Junkie? Censoring pornography is wrong. Pornography should not be censored just be cause some people find it offensive. I cannot recall the last time someone made me look at a pornographic picture, or made me buy a pornographic magazine or movie.
Compare Contrast The Love Between Claudio And
Hero Essay, Research Paper Compare/ contrast the love between Claudio and Hero with Beatrice and Bene*censored*. Whose is Stronger? The lovebetween Bene*censored* and Beatrice was much stronger than the love between Hero and Claudio. One reason Bene*censored* and Beatrice?s love was stronger because the way Hero and Claudio got together was not true love.
Miller VsCalifornia Essay Research Paper Miller v
Miller Vs.California Essay, Research Paper Miller v. California A recurring problem that we have here in the United States is how to define obscenity and to answer the question is the material containing the obscenity protected the First Amendment, stating the freedom of the press provision. Finally one day the Supreme Courts ruled that obscene works are not protect by the constitution but that ruling only caused more problems.