The Song of Roland is the oldest known epic in France, dating from around the Twelfth Century AD. Telling the story of Charlemagne at Roncesvalles in 778, the events of The Song of Roland have been shifted into a modern (12th Century) setting, bringing a long history of concerns about Muslim invasion that gripped France in Charles Martel’s and Charlemagne’s time. The historical part of the battle is changed to make it more understandable, even more tragic, for the Twelfth Century audience. The threat of the Muslims had a very real meaning and a long history that the listeners knew. The Muslim invasions of Spain and even parts of France had forced Western Europeans into close contact with another culture and religion. Charlemagne’s struggle with the Saracen forces could take on a theme of good versus evil or right versus wrong, which makes great material for an epic tragedy.
In the early Twelfth Century, concrete knowledge about the customs, habits, and religion of the Muslims could be seen as little or non-existent. In a piece of Christian crusade propaganda, one would not necessarily expect the author to take great interest in truthfully revealing the tenets of Islam and the differences between this faith and Christianity (Lazzari 97). The poet says the “infidels” have numerous gods, against the monotheism that makes “There is no god but Allah” the first and foremost fundamental belief of Islam (Frankel). An example of this misunderstanding includes the unknown author’s claim that the enemy King Marsile worships three gods: Muhammad, Apollo, and Tervagent. The Roland poet was ignorant of other religions, and could not distinguish one from another, which did not keep him from hating all of them. The point of the poem is that Charlemagne overthrows the pagan religion as well as a physical army; this is a Christian victory, a Crusade. Also, when the Saracens swear an oath to do their best to kill Roland, they swear it on their holy book, saying it is written by Muhammad and Tervagant as the authors of it. Islam teaches that the Koran is literal word of God, with no man being able to claim responsibility for it. When the Saracens expect the return and vengeance of Charlemagne, they pray to their god Tervagant, who does not come to their aid. Angered by this, the Saracens destroy their own temple, cursing and tearing down the statues of Tervagant, Muhammad, and Apollo.
They rush off to Apollo in a crypt,
Rail against him and hurl abuse at him:
“O, wretched god, why do you cause us such shame?
Why did you permit our king to be destroyed?
Anyone who serves you well receives a poor reward.”
Then they grab his scepter and his crown
And hang him by his hands from a pillar;
Then they send him flying to the ground at their feet
And beat him and smash him to pieces with huge sticks.
They seize Tervagant’s carbuncle
And fling Muhammad into a ditch
Where pigs and dogs bite and trample on him. (Lines 2580-2591)
This scene reflects perhaps the ultimate sacrilege to the Christian community, which believed quite strongly in icons, but it makes no sense in Islam as images and pictorial representations were and are not permitted (Lazzari 98).
The Saracen warrior mirrors the Christian quite frequently throughout the text. Charlemagne retires to an orchard, underneath a pine tree, after his first defeat of the Saracens. Here his 15,000 soldiers gather around, as well as his Twelve Peers, with whom he discusses his plans for leaving Spain. King Marsile, also goes to an orchard after the same battle and is described as sitting in the shade. His 20,000 men surround him and he also talks with his closest advisors on how to finally crush the French. The political and governing strategies of the two groups are the same. Both leaders are greatly respected by their men, yet their best ideas come from a select group of advisors, many of whom are related to each other and to the king (Lazzari 98). As Marsile and his men seal their treachery, the similarity is complete; twelve chosen from the Saracens, led by the nephew of King Marsile, will go head to head with the twelve companions of Charlemagne, led by Roland, his nephew (Lazzari 98). The glove that the Saracen carries as representative of his ruler will be the same emblem that Ganelon, ambassador of Charlemagne, accepts from his king. The Saracen doubles the Christian in other aspects of the epic as well. During the battle, each Christian knight meets individually with a Saracen knight. Blows are exchanged and one knight emerges victorious, having killed the other. The two armies are equipped identically, though a certain exoticism dominates the description of the Saracen outfit. The armor remains essentially western, as does the basic riding techniques, on a special war-horse, in tight lines (Goldin 24). Yet, the Saracen is distinguished from the French by the origin of his weaponry. The author gives the impression that excellent, perhaps the best, armor comes from far away, from the pagan lands of Saragossa and Valencia (Lazzari 98). Admiration for the Saracen is not limited to his armor. The Saracen knight can be noble handsome, loyal, and bold. All the same characteristics admired in the Christian knight can be found in the Saracen knights as well. The author highlights the skill and beauty of the Saracen Margariz. Baligant, the Emir of Babylon is seen as a prime example of the knight who would be perfect, were he only a Christian. Even physically, this Saracen warrior shares the traits of a Christian; his skin is described as being white (Lazarri 98).
The Saracen is not without his abominable traits, however (Lazzari 97). Roland sees the approaching enemy in a sense of black versus white, noting that they “are blacker than ink and have no white except for their teeth alone.” Just as the Emir symbolizes the almost ideal knight, the Saracen Abisme serves as the stereotypical concentration of French fears of Arabs. Not only is Abisme morally corrupt, he is also physically repulsive. His very humanness is called into question by his inability or unwillingness to laugh and play. The Archbishop Turpin, symbolizing Christianity and Good, takes it upon himself to destroy the personified evil, Abisme. The fight is nothing other than good versus evil, right versus wrong, truth versus lies (Lazzari 98). The portrait of the Saracen in The Song of Roland goes back and forth between the positive and the negative. At the same time that the audience of the 1100’s feared the Saracen, and thus pictured them in monstrous terms, they also coveted the refinements of Muslim culture, many of which were totally lacking in the West. The Saracen characters of this story show this movement between fear and envy. The Song of Roland helped shape the attitudes that made the crusades possible. Not simply by opposing Christians and Muslims, but also by constructing a Saracen who was frightening and inhuman enough to kill at the same time that he possessed objects and characteristics worthy of use (Lazzari 99). The epic battle satisfied both of these urges.
The numerous “errors” in this representation and in the figure and career of Charlemagne are frequently pointed out and sometimes rashly attributed to the poet’s ignorance. Charlemagne was in fact thirty-seven years and not yet Emperor when the rear-guard was ambushed: he was the King of the Franks, and he was not 200 years old: he wore a mustache but never a beard (Goldin 5). Islam is and was monotheistic and forbade graven images of God: no Saracen ever prayed to the idols of Muhammad, Apollo, or Tervagant. Many details in the epic have been rejected: history knew only a terrible defeat; the song reveals a glorious victory. The poem sets forth the vision of a great past, the past as it had to be, given the way things are; the past that guides the present and enjoins the future. The poet was painting a picture of an age where things were as they ought to be and all men were in their right places (Goldin 6).
Works Cited
Epics for Students. Lazzari, Marie, Editor. Gale Research. Detroit: 1997.
The Song of Roland. Burgess, Glyn, Translator. Penguin Books. London: 1990.
The Song of Roland. Goldin, Frederick, Translator. W.W. Norton & Company, Inc.
New York: 1978.
Другие работы по теме:
Cats In The Cradle
– Appreciation Essay, Research Paper This poem (song), “Cats in the Cradle” is written by Harry and Sandy Chapin. The poem teaches you that you have to pay attention to your kids and not as much to your work. This poem is about a dad who pays more attention to his work than to his son.
Stand By Me Essay Research Paper Stand
Stand By Me Essay, Research Paper Stand By Me Stand By Me, is a film written in 1986, that focuses on the two day journey of four best friends. The music in the film is one that is mostly song scoring. The music in this film was chosen very well. It was even pop song scoring. This movie has two main examples of music that I would like to point out, starting with moodsetting, it then moves to song scoring.
Chivalric Songs Essay Research Paper Micro theme
Chivalric Songs Essay, Research Paper Micro theme Topic: Courtly songs off differing views of Chivalry, especially of Chivalric love. Contrast as specifically as possible, the views on chivalry in one of these pairs: #?s 2 & 4, #?s 6 & 7.
Music Everywhere Essay Research Paper The rhythm
Music Everywhere Essay, Research Paper The rhythm flows through one s head. It can be viewed many ways, but effects everyone differently. This naturally occurring and man made miracle can t be summed up in just one short essay. Yet many have and will continue to try. It s carried across millions of airwaves everyday.
Eeeeee Essay Research Paper Lift Every Voice
Eeeeee Essay, Research Paper Lift Every Voice and SingLift every voice and singTill earth and heaven ring,Ring with the harmonies of Liberty;Let our rejoicing riseHigh as the listening skies,Let it resound loud as the rolling sea.Sing a song full of the faith that the dark past has taught us,Sing a song full of the hope that the present has brought us,Facing the rising sun of our new day begunLet us march on till victory is won.
Always True To The
“Star Spangled Banner” Essay, Research Paper Always True to the “Star-Spangled Banner” The “Star-Spangled Banner” means a lot to the American people. It represents the hardships and victories that we as Americans have prevailed against. This song perfectly depicts the challenge of the American Revolution.
The Role Of Women In The Song
Of Roland Essay, Research Paper The Role of Women in the Song of Roland Women are not mentioned often in the Song of Roland. They appear in only seventeen of almost three hundred laisses. It is because they are included so rarely, however, that the
Song Of Roland Comparision Essay Research Paper
The Song of Roland was the first French epic poem to be written down. What is the Song about? Explain the story and compare it (using examples) to two other epic poems or works that are similar
The Iliad And Song Of Roland Essay
, Research Paper The Iliad and Song of Roland: Attitudes Toward War The Iliad by Homer and Song of Roland are two enjoyable novels that both deal with the basic nature of war. They are set in different eras of history, but they both manage to depict the image of war and conquest very well. With that said, they do indeed share obvious plot characteristics.
My Own Prison By Creed Essay Research
? Paper Richie Lord 10/15/2000 ENC 1101 Song Lyrics What are they saying? “My Own Prison” by the group Creed is a very moving and inspirational song. The reason it is an inspirational song is because it has an excellent meaning. The author of the song Scott Sapp, one of the members of the band, had a hard life and is expressing his feeling about his life in this song.
Wind Symphony Essay Research Paper Becky Auten
Wind Symphony Essay, Research Paper Becky Auten Professor Hammer Music Lecture 1003 14 October 1999 Wind Symphony W.Dale Warren, Conductor The Wind Symphony preformed on Monday, October 11 at 8:00 p.m. at the Walton Arts Center in Baum-Walker Hall. The performance lasted one hour and thirty minuets and consisted of six pieces.
Hanson Essay Research Paper Hanson
Hanson Essay, Research Paper Hanson’s first single came out in May of 1997, which was Mmmbop. The song swept over the nation. It quickly rose to number one within weeks. It stayed at number one for 8 weeks. Today, Hanson has a new album at called This Time Around! The songs on This Time around are: You Don’t Know, If Only, This Time Around, Runaway Run, Save Me, Dying to be Alive, Can’t Stop, Wish that I was There, Love Song, Sure About It, Hand in Hnad, In the City, A Song to Sing.
About Love Essay Research Paper About Love
About Love Essay, Research Paper About Love This is how it starts: ?I will star to write a letter, about love and peaceful moments by your side?. ?About Love? it is the name of the song I am going to write about. Why is this song so important to me? It has to do mostly with my memories and feelings. The song reminds me a period of time in my life when I was not old enough to understand its meaning.
Songs For The Pearl Essay Research Paper
The Pearl Essay #8 I think this song well describes the feeling in the Book The Pearl at the time when Kino and Juana were walking home from the hill with a rifle and their dead baby, the song shows their pain, and they, in a sense are taking their lives on the ?otherside? (title of song) because once such a life influencing change is made in your life like that you are trapped on the ?otherside? of life and society, you are now the center of attention because of the way your life has so much changed.
Maybe They
’re Magic Essay, Research Paper Maybe They’re Magic Stephen Sondheim, in my opinion, is one of the most gifted lyricist and songwriters of all time. He uses many witty comparisons, beautiful allusions, and variations of tempo to give each song a uniqueness and identity of its own. This identity is also created for each individual character through the songs, and tactfully conveys their inner feelings.
Chorus Line Essay Research Paper A chorus
Chorus Line Essay, Research Paper A chorus lineSinging- I thought the singing in a chorus line was wonderful. All of the characters were excellent. My Favorite aspect of singing in this production is when Maria (Morales) sings “Nothing.” She sings this song as She is telling her life story. It is in reference to an improvisation class she took in high school.
Medieval Music Essay Research Paper Music in
Medieval Music Essay, Research Paper Music in the middle ages is similar to the music that we listen to today in the way that there are many different types of music for different types of people. There were many types of music in the middle ages including Slavic, Jewish, Popular, middle eastern, and many other types of religious music as well as music for entertainment.
Comparison Between Gita Govinda And The Song
Of Solomon Essay, Research Paper Analysis and Comparison of Gita Govinda and Song of Solomon Gita Govinda is a religious love poem in the Indian religion. The poem consists of
The Theme Of Father Son Relationships In Beowulf
& The Song Of Roland Essay, Research Paper The Theme of Father/Son Relationships in Beowulf & The Song of Roland Thomas Lazzaro Professor Fisher Literary Patterns of European Development Paper
Rock Music Essay Research Paper ROCK
Rock Music Essay, Research Paper ROCK Rock does mean any relatively hard mass of mineral or petrified matter, or stone, but it is also a type of music. Rock is a type of music in which teens have always been associated with. Rock music has been around since the early to mid nineteen fifties and has emerged and changed throughout the years.
Country Joe Mcdonald Essay Research Paper History
Country Joe Mcdonald Essay, Research Paper History Music Project Two of the most memorable of events of the 60s were the Vietnam War and Woodstock. Joe McDonald, was a part of both. The song which I was randomly assigned was Fixin To Die Rag by Country Joe McDonald. However, this is only the song s pop-culture name.
Song Of Myself Essay Research Paper Author
Song Of Myself Essay, Research Paper Author: Walt WhitmanTitle: Song of MyselfSummary: Song of Myself is a poem by Walt Whitman that encourages the inner-self and emphasizes the unity of all nature. Near the beginning, Whitman vividly describes how free he feels and states that everyone should experience it not at second or third hand.
Robert Frost Essay Research Paper In Robert
Robert Frost Essay, Research Paper In Robert Frosts’ poem “The Road Not Taken,” Frost talks of choosing between two roads to travel. Frost has come to a split in the road and has to choose which road to pick. In Randy Travis’ song “I Told You So,” a man learns that his girlfriend is choosing between himself and another man.
Music I Like To Listen Essay Research
Paper There are many bands and different kinds of music I like to listen to. I like to listen to many different bands and songs. When I listen to music I listen for the beat as long as listen for the lyrics. Even with all the different types of music around I mainly like to listen to hard rock. I like to listen because of the hard guitars and the streaming drums.
Uncle Sams Song Essay Research Paper Uncle
Uncle Sam`s Song Essay, Research Paper Uncle Sam’s song, "I Don’t Ever Wanna See You Again" is a song about a guy who gets his heart broken by his girlfriend. In this song Uncle Sam is
White Rabbit Essay Research Paper The song
White Rabbit Essay, Research Paper The song I am reporting on is called White Rabbit . The band, Jefferson Airplane, performs the song. I selected this song because of the eerie feeling it gives you when you listen to it. Also, this song is a very good example of drug use among the youth, especially the hippies, in the 1960 s.
The Digital World Essay Research Paper Today
?The Digital World? Essay, Research Paper Today we live in ?the digital world?, the internet reins supreme it?s the future, the next frontier. The age of digital music is upon us mp3s ras wmas etc. and along with all this is a means to share it. File shareing services and software. It is now possible to go online type in the name of the song wanted and download it.
Adam
’s Song Essay, Research Paper Adam’s Song I never thought I?d die alone I laughed the loudest who?d have known? I trace the cord back to the wall No wonder it was never plugged in at all
Barbie Girl Essay Research Paper Sing it
Barbie Girl Essay, Research Paper Sing it to the Barbie song… Hi ya lang niu! Hi lang jai! Want to ride in my Honda? Sure lang jai! Jump in! * I’m a Chinese girl, in a Chinese world,